This book is a great place to start in understanding culture in general and Western culture in particular. It equips us to be faithful Christians in our culture and to start shaping it in light of the gospel. The authors make sense of the presenting cultural issues of our day in a coherent and convincing way, getting to the underlying heart issues and cultural influences.
The ocean provides a helpful analogy to culture. Like the ocean, culture has both seen and unseen elements. Cultural undercurrents are invisible, but powerfully pressure us to conform to their collective assumptions about the world. Cultural issues are like waves: seen, heard, and felt. Understanding both is critically important to successfully navigating culture, and these two headings are used to structure and organise the first two sections of the book. In the third section, we consider the Christian worldview, putting culture in the context of the gospel rather than the other way round.
We start with the undercurrents, as they tend to be presuppositions outside our critical reflection, and we need to understand them to come to grips with any specific cultural issue.
What Culture Is and What It Does to Us
Culture refers to what people do with and make of the world. Unlike animals, we do more with the world than merely trying to survive in it, having conceptions of God, truth, morality, humanity, and history that shape how we live. Underpinning this is our worldview, which, whether we are consciously aware of it or not, informs our actions in the world and our interactions with others. It consists of our deeply held beliefs about God, morality, and the nature of reality. Understanding worldview is, therefore, crucial to understanding culture.
Culture includes things that are good, bad, morally neutral, and morally complex, and is not fixed, static, or monolithic. People and culture are also distinct, as people both make and are shaped by culture, but cannot be equated with it. Two important concepts are objectification and internalisation. The former happens when people externalise their values, imaginations, innovations, and ideas on the world around them through what they do. Ideas and their consequences become part of our normal way of living together, reinforced by artefacts and institutions.
The second is the process whereby culture shapes us. We internalise culture as we settle into its routines, lifestyles, and habits, and as we consume its products, ideas, and assumptions about the world. As we live in a culture, we become committed to its vision of life unless we are intentional otherwise. Culture shapes us most deeply by what it presents as normal, as we are creatures of cultural habit, living according to the liturgies imposed by our culture but rarely thinking them through.
In short, we make our cultures, and then our cultures shape us.
The Big Story and Approaching Culture
Once we understand what culture is and what it does to us, we need to understand how to approach it by considering the function of Scripture as God's revelation of himself, his plans and his actions in the world. Scripture is objectively true and describes the big, overarching story of reality, the world, humanity and history. No matter how chaotic, grave, disturbing, broken, or troubling our cultural moment may be, the context of the larger story of which it is a part reveals its true meaning.
The question "Have we lost the culture?" implies that there was a time when we had the culture. In reality, while some cultures are morally better than others, there has never been a thoroughly Christian culture. Winning and losing are not determined in this cultural moment, as we belong to a larger story summarised as creation, fall, redemption, and restoration. The cultural moment we live in hovers between redemption and restoration, and we must live in it and allow it to shape us. A better first question with which to approach culture than "Where do we draw the line?" or "Have we lost?" is "What is our salvation for?"
A Vision of Success
As Christians, we must take responsibility for our culture and avoid the old Gnostic heresy of dividing reality into the physical, which is evil, and the spiritual, which is good. The real division is not between the physical and spiritual (both created by God and declared to be good), but between the Creator and the creation. Though fallen, God's creation still proclaims His grandeur, kindness, and goodness.
Christian faithfulness involves our habits, attitudes and affections as well as our doctrine and lifestyle. It is not enough to sprinkle Christian truth on lives shaped more by the cultural moment than the gospel, and we must not underestimate the power of culture to form our deepest allegiances and identities. In the church, we must avoid the prevailing worldview of moralistic therapeutic deism, which declares that God visits our world, not that we live in God's world. It declares that God serves our agenda and helps us feel good about ourselves, demanding nothing of us but existing to help us in whatever way we wish.
The Information Age
Ideas influence the way we think and live in the world, shaping entire societies and driving the course of human history. In a world of competing ideas and competing authorities, we need to learn how to think critically to assess them and recognise truth. In our day, we encounter more ideas than ever, many of which are difficult to understand and require intricate and sustained reasoning. Additionally, our culture no longer defines tolerance as treating others with respect, even if their views differ from ours. Rather, tolerance means embracing the views of the majority culture, and not doing so is intolerant, as we are pressured not to think, but to conform.
We need to strengthen our powers of discernment so that we can recognise the truth amidst the lies, half-truths, propaganda, and trivialities, and see all of life through the truth. This also shows the importance of developing a biblical worldview. Our worldview is "the framework of basic beliefs we have, whether we realize it or not, that shapes our view of the world and for the world," acting as a lens by which we identify and evaluate every idea we encounter. Our view of the world is our explanation of reality, including:
Origins: Where did everything come from?
Identity: What is a human being?
Meaning: What is the meaning of life? What is our purpose?
Morality: Who determines right and wrong? What is wrong with the world, and how can it be fixed?
Destiny: What happens when we die? Where is history heading?
If we do not take time to answer these questions critically in our hearts and minds, we will answer them passively by how we live, how we make decisions, and how we relate to others. Our worldview shapes our values, which shape our behaviour; our actions reflect our core beliefs about life.
It is very important to talk to our children about their worldview, so that they can critically interact with the culture around them. Some basic steps to help with this are:
1. Talk about worldview early and often.
2. Explain non-Christian worldviews.
3. Strongly encourage your kids to read good books.
4. Discuss ideas whenever possible.
5. Ask good questions.
A few simple but important questions (for kids and all of us) are:
What do you mean by that? The battle of ideas begins with the battle for definitions.
How do you know that is true? Assertions require arguments.
What if you are wrong? This question gets at the consequences of ideas.
Identity after Christianity
Another important aspect of our culture is its vision of human identity, now taken for granted as an absolute truth: self-centred and self-serving autonomy. The modern pantheon of idols includes Self, State, Sex, Science and Stuff. These all influence our culture's conception of identity, but none more so than sexuality and gender. Rather than sex consisting of morally assessable behaviour, it is now who we are. Religious belief is mere personal opinion, but sexuality is definitive, absolute, and unquestionable. In today's culture, sexuality is identity. Part of the tragedy in this is that our culture wants to retain the fruit of human dignity and worth, while rejecting its roots.
Our culture leaves us in perpetual uncertainty about life's big questions (e.g. origins, identity, meaning, morality, and destiny), constantly barraging us with new ideas and information, tempting us to seek pleasure and self-fulfillment while offering us a dizzying array of choices about what to believe, how to live, what to buy, where to go, and what to love. We are told to question everything, to explore every alternative, and to keep an open mind on everything from politics to religion to gender. Social media, porn, and affluence offer relationships and pleasure without commitment. All of this leaves our kids incredibly unstable, prone to deception, disappointment, and cynicism.
The only antidote for this confusion is discipleship, knowing what to believe, how to behave and who we are as redeemed image bearers of the Creator. Three areas that contribute to the formation of our identity in discipleship are story, questions, and community.
Being Alone Together
It is increasingly clear that when people go online, they are doing more than expressing themselves; they are exploring alternative selves: "Our social-media profiles are highly edited constructs of our lives for friends and family to browse (and perhaps to envy). We don’t struggle online. We posture."
As we live life indirectly, with our experiences, conversations, and relationships mediated to us through our various devices, we lose touch with our world, with one another, and even with ourselves:
"The tendency today is to become curators of our own online museums for our carefully selected and polished moments. In doing so, we may think our personal brand of approved images and sound bites are the real us. Because we can only truly know ourselves in community, we lose touch with ourselves when we lose touch with others. Online life also sells us the false impression that we can separate who we are into public and private realms." This is an interesting paradox, as on the one hand we overshare constructed versions of ourselves, while on the other hand we value privacy above accountability.
There are several lies communicated to us in our tech-shaped culture:
Lie #1: I am the centre of my own universe.
Lie #2: I deserve to be happy all the time, reflecting the three chief virtues of modern society: convenience, efficiency, and choice, with the best life being one that is faster, easier, and on our own terms. Patience, prudence, and perseverance are discounted.
Lie #3: I must have choices. When we mistakenly believe that choices are prerequisites to happiness, two things result. First, rather than seizing the opportunities in front of us, we will always be looking for the next better thing. Second, addiction to choice leads to ungratefulness.
Lie #4: I am my own authority. One of the illusions of the modern world is that we are in control: "Digital reality is infinitely customizable. When so much of life is lived online, it's only a small jump to thinking that's the way all of reality should be as well."
Lie #5: Information is all I need, not teachers. Information does not equal knowledge and wisdom.
Perpetual Adolescence
The final undercurrent examined is the tendency to make adolescence the goal of our culture. We have ceased to be a culture where kids aspire to be adults, and have become a culture where adults aspire to be kids, or at least adolescents, forever. Our culture has largely abandoned robust moral concepts like sin, moral responsibility, and virtue, and teaches that a successful life is not a good life but a happy one, giving us no tools or encouragement to grow up.
The best way to encourage maturity in the next generation is by the cultivation of virtue: "We’ve told a whole generation to go find themselves. What if they find themselves, but when they do, they're jerks?" Freedom cannot be sustained without virtue; we cannot trust ourselves unless we are trustworthy; we must be the right people if we are to do the right things.
In the context of these cultural undercurrents, the book goes on to examine a number of cultural waves.
Sexuality
Under this heading come chapters on pornography, the hookup culture, sexual orientation and gender identity. Our culture combines moral indifference with an insatiable desire for instant gratification. Today's sexual orthodoxy proclaims so-called sexual freedom and insists that all consensual sex acts are good. Anything that interferes with or restricts sexual expression is, therefore, inherently bad.
To resist these trends, we must give the culture a better message, starting with a robust biblical anthropology that reflects our identity as image bearers. The gift of sexuality belongs only within the context of a husband-wife marriage. The exclusivity and commitment of marriage are the best context within which to care for children, and marriage is the best environment in which to cultivate the love, safety, security, and trust needed for sexual intimacy to flourish. Marriage is about self-giving, not self-interest.
Gender is another major area of confusion for our culture and is worth considering at greater length. The assumptions that sex is "assigned" and not a biological reality, and that gender is chosen and not innate, are deeply embedded in our culture. This highlights two cultural lies:
Lie #1: Rather than being a fixed trait rooted in biology, gender is seen as a social construct that culture creates. The problem with this is that there are only arbitrary stopping points for such social construction.
Lie #2: We should validate people's thoughts and desires so they will flourish. Absolute autonomy is seen as the path to one's authentic self, and is our culture's new vision of human dignity. Unrestrained by any external limitations, one can never be defined by anyone except oneself. Human dignity is grounded in the autonomous will of an individual, and this path of unfettered choice is the path to flourishing
In light of this, our culture's response to opposition to this narrative becomes clear. Anyone who denies people their ultimate right to choose reality is labelled a bigot. Since dignity is derived from self-determination, standing in someone's way or merely disagreeing with their choices strips a person of dignity. Tolerance is no longer sufficient; we must be affirming. Dissent indicates bigotry; bigotry is animated by hatred, therefore, all bigots must be silenced.
The alternative to all of this is to affirm that human wholeness comes not by denying reality but by conforming to it: "Affirm the goodness of what transgender people are seeking: wholeness. However, help them to see that the solution isn't mutilating their bodies but transforming their hearts, minds, and souls. In every conversation, be extravagant with showing grace and kindness. Remind people that your motivation is love, not hatred."
Affluence, Consumerism and Entertainment
Idolatry lurks beneath our culture's rampant materialism and consumerism. This approach to life says that I am the centre of the universe, and everything exists to meet my needs and satisfy my desires. Seeking our identity in our stuff validates our worship of self: "Reinforced by media, entertainment and the endless stream of advertising, we devour goods, services, and even people in an attempt to satisfy our souls."
The reality is that happiness is not found in the unbridled pursuit of affluence, pleasure, and personal satisfaction, but rather in a life well lived, characterised by wisdom, virtue, and character.
Linked to this is entertainment, which is often used to cure boredom, avoid responsibility, or anesthetise the pain of our inner emptiness. Through entertainment, we divert our attention from reality and escape into triviality and voyeurism. Ironically, an entertainment-driven culture neuters the arts' true power as we are perpetually distracted. This is a worrying sign for any society: "When a population becomes distracted by trivia, when cultural life is redefined as a perpetual round of entertainments, when serious public conversation becomes a form of baby-talk, when, in short, a people become an audience and their public business a vaudeville act, then a nation finds itself at risk; culture- death is a clear possibility."
The common factor running through these cultural waves and the others considered (addiction and racial tension) is identity: who are we, and what are we for? This leads into the final section of the book, where the authors discuss how to start to build and strengthen a Christian worldview. This involves reading and trusting the Bible, fostering the right kind of pluralism, and taking the gospel to the culture.
The Bible also sets Christianity apart from all other worldviews and religions, as it is a revealed worldview. Christianity's source of authority was established by God, who has revealed Himself in creation, in the Old and New Testaments, and ultimately in Jesus Christ: "God exists, contrary to atheistic or secular worldviews. God is personal, contrary to Eastern religions and New Age pantheism. God has spoken, contrary to postmodern skepticism. God has spoken by Jesus Christ, who is revealed in the Old and New Testaments, contrary to Judaism and Islam."
The Right Kind of Pluralism
Christians can and should be pluralists in the sense that we live in a religiously diverse culture and need to be ready to make a case for the Christian worldview while recognising the inherent dignity of all people. Religious claims are not mere individual preferences, so we cannot accept the idea that no religion can claim to be true over and above another.
Taking the Gospel to the Culture
Like the exiles, we must learn to live well in this cultural moment, and there are several legitimate ways Christians can deal with the ideas, institutions, trends, fashions, and habits of our culture: celebrate (what can we protect, promote and preserve?), create (what is missing that we can contribute?), confront (what evil can we stop?), co-opt and correct (what brokenness can we restore?)
Some Christians mistakenly think that change will come only when we acquire the levers of cultural power. God has called some to high places, but He has called all of us to be faithful where we are, in our spheres of influence. This book is a thoughtful and edifying resource that helps equip us to do just that.