Hidden away underground, in a box, twelve-year-old Molly has only her older cousin and her diary to keep her company. For two years, she writes of her confinement “in a grave”: the cold, dark and stuffiness, the unbearable suffering from insufficient food, and the complicated reliance on the two farmers who are risking their own lives to save her. Buried Words is a stark confession of Molly’s fears, despair and secrets and, above all, her fervent wish to stay alive.
I have read a lot of Holocaust memoirs and historical accounts of citizens in occupied countries risking their lives to shelter Jews from the Nazis but none have left me with the creepy feeling that I got from this diary & memoir. If the diary of Melania, written at age 12-14 is an accurate account of what when on then Victor was less their “saviour” and more of a pedophile with two captive victims. The hiding of Melania and her cousin Helen seemed to be more out of fear of him and his sister being discovered than of any altruistic desire to aid the Jewish girls, not to mention the afore mentioned sexual relationships with the girls. Add to that the often long periods without food or water and it seems more like luck that they survived until the end of the war. If this is all to be believed (and the introduction states that the value of a diary over a memoir is the absence of time to ponder events or forget details) then I am astounded that Yad Vashem found Victor and his sister Eugenia worthy of being named Righteous Among the Nations even though they were offered a “sanitized” version of events. The memoir portion of this book written by Molly (formerly Melania) offers quite a different picture of the events even calling Victor and Eugenia “strong believers in God and righteousness”. And then there was whatever happened to suddenly make Melania unwelcome in her Sydney foster home. I strongly believe that the stories of Holocaust survivors need to be preserved and remembered but like I said, this book left me with a creepy feeling, not the least of which is that the descendants of Victor and Eugenia still accept money from Molly/Melania. Luckily this was a very quick read.
I liked it—or should I say I liked both. This book actually includes, first, Molly Applebaum’s diary, written from 1942 to 1945, and, second, Molly’s memoir. Both are very interesting. The diary is written very poetically and exposes in all honesty Molly’s feelings and the things that happen to her and her cousin Helen while hiding from the Nazis. The language of the translation seems spot on for the period. I was sometimes reminded of Lucy Maud Montgomery’s prose, although her Anne series only goes as far as the First World War, while Molly’s diary is written during the second. Molly’s memoir, written later in her life, is very different in tone and development, and complements the diary. It follows Molly past the days of hiding to her life in Canada. Some of the problems she faces here are universal, not being limited to Holocaust survivors. In fact, some of what happened to her has also happened to me. Her take on things is insightful.
I had to read this book more than once to really process all the information in it. It was incredibly heartbreaking and it forced me to ask a lot of questions about what is right when life and death are on the line. If you choose to read this book, be prepared. It is not a very happy story, it involves sexual abuse and difficult topics. This woman is incredible to have survived through such a horrendous time.
I read this book for my women and gender in the Holocaust class. It is a memoir and diary of Holocaust survivor Molly Applebaum. Her experiences was very powerful and her diary gave a firsthand experience of the atrocities she went through.
I should probably read the Diary of Anne Frank at this point eh ? I've read quite abit of holocaust literature and watched Shoah, you'd think I would have done that by now. Anyway this way a good, but very sad, read