I'm honestly at a loss with this book. Tamara Ireland Stone knocked my socks off with "Every Last Word," a book that dealt with mental illness, suicide, and grief with such delicacy and heart so yeah the bar was high but I had no doubt Stone could meet it then zoom past it to new heights.
Sadly that hasn't happened with "Click'd" a very odd YA book that seems to have been intended for middleschoolers given the age of its characters but then makes the odd decision to have them all talk like 35 year olds working at a start up dot.com in Silicon Valley while they confront "issues" with the knowledge and actions that would be more appropriate for seniors in high school. Consequently we're left with a book that doesn't really work for anyone.
The deeply uninteresting story centers on Allie a twelve year old who's just finished a summer at coding camp where she's created the app "Click'd." It's basically a dorky Cosmo quiz attached to a GPS that uses an algorithm to match "players" to each other. Allie's idea is that it will help people connect with people they "click" with because it will help them find common ground with people they wouldn't otherwise meet. You fill out the quiz and then the game matches you to someone and you use to a GPS locator to track them down, then you click your phones together, take a selfie, and the person gets added to your "board." The app is a huge hit at the camp and she's chosen by her computer teacher to be a part of "Games For Good," a yearly contest where top of the line student coders design games and apps to do good in the world, the winner gets $5,000, loads of attention from developers, and bragging rights forever.
Allie needs more data to show the judges so a week before the presentation she takes her teachers suggestion and "launches" the app to her friends who then convince her to launch it to the school. It becomes an instant viral hit and Allie is on top of the world. But its not long before a glitch in the code creates problems for Allie and her friends. She has to decide if her friendships are more important than her work and she only has a few days to do it.
Simple idea right? And its certainly hitting all the right notes. Girl gamers/coders, friendship, online vs. real life, all good stuff. So why then is this such a blah read? I can't put my finger on it but part of the problem may be that Stone just gets too bogged down in the tech talk. Allie spends LOADS of the narrative in her own head and the computer lab trying to fix her game. Stone tries to make her a bit more well rounded by also having her be a soccer player and she's got a solid social life but still much of her time is spent working through the code and checking her data. Its just not that interesting.
And it leaves the reader with not much to get invested in. I mean I get it Allie wants to win the contest and she's super smart and capable and that's terrific, really, but its not enough. Why is this so important to her? What does she want beyond "winning?" The entire narrative is pinned on will she or won't she have the app ready and fixed by the contest and its just too hard to care about that instead of actual people.
The conflict is by turns too much and too little for kids this age. The glitch is discovered when the app, which is only meant to pull photos from user's Instagram accounts, yanks a personal picture one of Allie's friends never wanted anyone to see. This is a pretty damn serious issue that gets into the whole "once its on the internet it's there forever" issue and should spark a much needed talk among the characters about privacy and what you put online etc. but instead becomes a conversation about keeping secrets from friends when Allie elects not to tell her friend in the hopes that she'll be able to fix the issue before anyone finds out.
Allie's other point of conflict is Nathan the guy who always beats her at any kind of coding competition. But again the book is so low energy that even their fights are boring. We're treated to exciting as hell scenes of them...sitting in the lab together giving each other the silent treatment or....sitting in the lab together working on codes together...its riveting.
Look there's nothing wrong with this book, not really, but there's nothing especially right about it either. Its just a sort of blah story with no energy or people to really care about that's pretty well written but has nothing to say or at least can't figure out how to say what it wants to.
I can totally get behind a girl power book centered on young women and science, I think that's a tremendously important and powerful story that needs to be told again and again. But it has to be just as exciting and inspiring and even emotional as the Twilightesque stuff or no one is going to pay attention. Stone is entirely capable of telling that story in a nuanced and exciting way so I'm just left scratching my head and wondering....what happened?