This was a pretty good 4th book in the Amish Misfits series. Of course, I knew everything would work out in the end. The story was pretty good, but I did think that since Jane trusted her bishop and his wife, that it would have made a lot of sense for her to turn to them for help when she was accused of murder. She didn’t even consider it. Knowing the way the Amish respect the wisdom and guidance of their Bishop, I thought that was a bit of a flaw in the story.
I also think that in this book as well as in the first book in the series that the author painted her parents (or in the other book, her grandmother) as bitter and unforgiving. In Jane’s case, with the bishop believing her story, I would think that he would have intervened in the estrangement she had from her family, and that they would have listened to him. The Amish respect their bishops and I can’t imagine that if he believed her story that he wouldn’t have tried to reconcile the family. But, just as in Book 1, when we finished the story believing Emma’s grandmother was evil, I felt the same way about Jane’s family: that they can’t possibly be good Amish folk, if they can’t accept the truth about their own daughter and want to be involved in their granddaughter’s life. I thought that kind of made the ending somewhat less than a happy one. There was a comment that Jane knew they would never change, and not too many pages later, a contradictory comment that Jane had hope of someday reconciling with them. But as she got married and had more children, we see no sign that that will be the case.
I’m reading this series on Kindle Unlimited and intend to finish the last books. But I have to say that the best series I’ve read by this author is her “Ettie Smith Cozy Mystery” series. This is the 3rd series I’ve read by her that is straight Amish romance, and I just don’t like them as much. But, as I mentioned, I will finish the series —I guess I must like them enough to finish what I started. And since I didn’t have to pay extra for them, and they read fast, there’s no reason not to read the rest of them.