I read this book as part of a book study with my church, and I will admit that I am not the target audience for this book. I think the author’s audience probably matches that of her blog which from this book I could best describe as stay-at-home Christian moms who like to read encouraging and uplifting (although not necessarily challenging) books. That said, a couple problems beyond just the target-audience issue are below.
TOPIC: The book is about grace and holiness in the Christian life and how that should propel us to missional living. (“Dance in grace. Stand on holy ground. Run on mission.”) That is the title, the subtitle, and the basic content of the book.
CONTENT: The author uses scores of pages to tell personal stories about her own life and musings on the above-mentioned topics, yet she fails to even mention traditional terms such as justification, sanctification, and glorification which one would normally expect in a book about holiness. Her lack of traditional or defined terminology actually lead to some misunderstanding and confusion at points in my study group. (Note: The glossary at the end is not at all helpful in remedying this problem.) I learned a lot about Jess Connolly in this book but not much about doctrine or the Bible.
USE OF SCRIPTURE: There wasn’t much Scripture used because The Message isn’t Scripture (it’s a paraphrase) and there were only limited passages quoted which used an actual translation of the Bible. Those which were used often had very poor exegesis. For example, Luke 1:35-56 is not about interpersonal communication between women in the church - it is prophecy, inspired directly by God and in the format of Old Testament prophecies or songs of praise - therefore, the author’s take isn’t exactly a valid interpretation of that passage and its subsequent application is ungrounded.
DOCTRINE: The author’s church is non-denominational, but her doctrines are solidly Southern Baptist.
STYLE: The book uses a conversational blogger writing style which means it 1) used a lot of expressions that just got annoying like “friend,” “messy,” and “meaty,” 2) was overly wordy and rambling with very little actual content, and 3) contained minor grammatical errors that are generally accepted in conversation/blogs but not in published works.
USE FOR A GROUP STUDY: The discussion questions are not very “expansive” - some are too personal for people to want to share, some just don’t provide opportunity to discuss beyond a short word or sentence answer. Your group is probably going to have questions or be generally confused, and you need to be prepared to figure out what the author was trying to say in the first place and then how to present it more straight-forwardly and in a manner that will be conducive to discussion.
So again, I was not the target audience for this book, but the above constitutes some serious problems that one might want to consider before using this book for an independent or group study. The author clearly thought she was teaching (James 3:1). However, the book was so devoid of Biblical content or educational terms that, at best, it is a vaguely Christian life-coaching book and, at worst, it is a Biblically inaccurate waste of time.