Four new stories from the Ninth Doctor’s era, narrated by Nicholas Briggs.
1.1 The Bleeding Heart by Cavan Scott
Galen is a place where people come to heal. The renowned ‘planet of peace’ seems the ideal venue for talks between two warring races. But when death disrupts the diplomacy, Cosmic Nine news reporter Adriana Jarsdel uncovers a different story. Luckily, someone is there to help. A battle-weary veteran from another war. The Doctor has come to Galen - but is he looking for peace or something else entirely?
1.2 The Window on the Moor by Una McCormack
Emily and her sisters once told each other fables of warring kingdoms: wicked princes, noble dukes, and their battling armies. Now she wanders the moors of her childhood alone, remembering those tales. The TARDIS arrives amid a strange civil war, with prisons made of glass and cities stalked by terrifying beasts. As windows open between worlds, stories and storyteller meet, and Rose comes face to face with Emily Brontë.
1.3 The Other Side by Scott Handcock
Rose has invited a new friend on board the TARDIS, against the Doctor’s better judgement. But when the Time Lord tries to take his unwelcome guest home, a temporal tsunami cuts the journey short. The travellers find the source of the disturbance inside an abandoned cinema. Will Adam Mitchell help or hinder when the Doctor and Rose discover what is lurking on the other side of the screen?
1.4 Retail Therapy by James Goss
Jackie Tyler is a success. Every home should have a Glubby Glub, and Jackie is star saleswoman on the Powell Estate. At last, she’s found her calling and it’s only a matter of time before she can give Rose the life she deserves. But the Doctor isn’t impressed. Jackie Tyler isn’t just filling peoples’ houses with useless clutter. He believes she’s launching an alien invasion…
is a freelance comic writer and author. He is best known for his work on a variety of spin-offs from both Doctor Who and Star Wars, as well as comics and novels for Vikings, Pacific Rim, Sherlock Holmes, and Penguins of Madagascar.
Cavan Scott, along with Justina Ireland, Claudia Gray, Daniel Jose Older, and Charles Soule are crafting a new era in the Star Wars publishing world called Star Wars: The High Republic. Cavan's contribution to the era is a comic book series released through Marvel Comics titled Star Wars: The High Republic.
1.1 The Bleeding Heart - Set before The (Ninth) Doctor meets Rose, this is an interesting story. Sadly it’s a narrated episode, rather like the Companion Chronicles, and these don’t always work very well for me. Definitely would have been better with a full-cast although Nicholas Briggs does a decent impression The (Ninth) Doctor. (2/3)
1.2 The Window on the Moor - This one is set while The (Ninth) Doctor is traveling with Rose (fairly early as they’ve not yet met Captain Jack). The pair meet up with Emily Brontë. It had potential, but I don’t feel like it was very well realized. (2/3)
1.3 The Other Side - Adam Mitchell’s first ride aboard the TARDIS with The (Ninth) Doctor isn’t very spectacular - a quick trip home - at least that’s the way it seems at first. I enjoyed this one more than the others. Maybe it was Bruno Langley’s contributions as Adam, or maybe it was the story itself. In any case, it was better than the previous two stories. (3/5)
1.4 Retail Therapy - Camille Coduri is back as Jackie Tyler, and the world better look out! She’s selling Glubby Glubs and she’s gonna help save the human race from … Glubby Glubs. There’s a lovely hysterical scene where Jackie gets going and nobody is gonna get a word in edgewise. Perfect. (3/5)
Overall these are fine, but I’d have preferred to have full-cast productions. But sometimes it just doesn’t work that way.
1. The Bleeding Heart by Cavan Scott Prima avventura in solitaria per il nono Dottore. L’interpretazione di Briggs li rende un po’ goofy, ma è da tanto che non ascolto Eccleston in originale e potrebbe, in realtà, parlare proprio così. Trama un po’ confusionaria che si risolve tappando un buco creato dal solito Rassilon. Un mero assaggio, senza infamia e senza lode.
2. The Window on the Moor by Una McCormack Emily Brontë, Rose (che incredibilmente la riconosce ancor prima che si presenti) e il Dottore a spasso per il Moor, tra lotte dinastiche e passaggi interdimensionali. Storia banalotta, personaggio famoso non sfruttato al massimo e finale da romanzo d’appendice. Nessuna indicazione su dove incastrare la storia rispetto alla serie tv
3. The Other Side by Scott Handcock Adam Mitchell, interpretato come nella serie tv da Bruno Langley, affianca Rose e il Dottore in questa avventura. La storia si posiziona subito dopo “Dalek” e parte un po’ lenta e poco interessante, forse anche per colpa del poco simpatico Adam. Non appena si entra nel vivo le cose migliorano e, con la solita citazione alla Guerra del Tempo, la soluzione del problema è brillante. Per ora il migliore della serie.
4. Retail Therapy by James Goss Jackie Tyler, interpretata sempre da Camille Coduri, è la guest star dell’episodio. La storia ricorda altre avventure vista in video, tra Adipose e invasioni lente, ma risulta la migliore delle quattro. Un po’ per l’interazione tra Jackie e il Dottore, un po’ per il senso di familiarità. Briggs sembra interpretare il nono Dottore in maniera più fluida in questo episodio… forse proprio grazie ai duetti più brillanti. Spero che Camille Coduri resti nella famiglia Big Finish anche per altri audio.
Nel complesso, come sempre, quattro storie di vario livello che migliorano con il procedere dell'ascolto.
Chris Eccleston’s well-known reluctance to reprise his role as the Ninth Doctor means that we won’t be getting any stories featuring the original actor for a long time – if ever. In the meantime, this is as close as you’re going to get (outside of a written medium, obviously). It uses Big Finish’s “Chronicle” format, meaning that it’s essentially an audiobook with added background sound effects and a second actor providing one or more voices in addition to the narrator.
In this case, the latter is Briggs, mostly doing third-person narration in his own voice, but also doing most of the other parts. Mostly, this works quite well, and his impression of Eccleston, while obviously not flawless, is pretty good in places. Unfortunately, his impression of Rose is, understandably, much less effective and is a significant drawback in the stories in which she appears. It’s a weakness, perhaps, of the hybrid format, neither a regular audiobook nor a full-cast audio play and suffering by falling between the fences.
The collection consists of four hour-long stories.
• The Bleeding Heart – Considering that all of Nine’s TV stories take place on (or at least in orbit around) Earth, it’s surprising that the collection begins with a story on a distant alien planet at some point in the future - probably during the time of the Earth Empire, from a few hints in the dialogue. This takes away from the resemblance to the relevant TV era as, arguably, does the absence of a companion, but otherwise there are plenty of themes connecting it. The story is about an alien peace conference where things suddenly start turning bloody, which allows for some reflection on the Doctor’s own recent past in the Time War. Both the nature of the threat and its ultimate resolution fit in perfectly with the era, too, although they do require some prior knowledge of this particular incarnation. 3 stars.
• The Window on the Moor – Out on the wily, windy moor, Emily Brontë opens a window to another universe. Which is less left-field than it might sound, since she wrote what might loosely be described as fantasy fiction for her own amusement as a child. Unfortunately, while a story with Brontë does sound interesting, she’s not really in it all that much. Once again, we’re off Earth for most of the story, in this case in the alternate reality (or whatever it is; it’s not very clear) on the other side of the window. The resulting setting all feels rather generic and the plot isn’t strong enough to hold up things on its own. Yes, there’s some fun with a glass prison but even some of that just feels like padding. 2 stars.
• The Other Side – Things improve a little with the third story, although it still suffers from all the female parts being played by Briggs (something that would, at least to me, feel less out-of-place in a straight audiobook reading than in a more supposedly immersive production like this one). This time, we're focussing on temporary companion Adam, in a story set between TV episodes Dalek and The Long Game. The story, which features a temporal distortion in an abandoned cinema, shares many themes with Nine's TV run but isn't able to build too much on Adam himself - played by original actor Bruno Langley. Nor does it particularly foreshadow The Long Game, presumably to make him more sympathetic, although, in fairness it's not inconsistent with that, either. It's a good enough tale, but I'm not convinced we needed another story with a character specifically set up as a 'failed companion' that we shouldn't be rooting for. 3.5 stars.
• Retail Therapy – Finally, we reach the best story of the four, bringing back Camile Coduri as Jackie Tyler. Set primarily on the Powell Estate, this has the obvious advantage of a setting familiar from the TV series, while still bringing in a new foe - albeit one that also reflects others seen on the show down the years. But the real strength is Jackie, who gets some great character moments, including a heartfelt conversation with the Doctor about their respective relationships with Rose. For once, she gets to be the hero in a story about the struggle of everyday working people against corporate greed and glamorous celebrity. 4 stars.
感想 タイムウォーで消滅したホードという種族の記憶がタイムヴォルテックスでさまよっていたことが原因で起こっていた異常現象。”Rose”でネスティーンからタイムウォーの恨み言をぶつけられたように、ホードからまたタイムウォーについて責められるドクター。こんな調子で、9thドクターはいく先々で傷をえぐられいたのかと思うと切なくなる。ローズとの20年のタイムラグを、ドクターはひたすら待つことで飛び越える。電話で話しながらローズの後ろからドクターが現れるシーンがカッコいい。ローズの出現する時を20年間待っていた。タイムロードならではとはいえ、ターディスもないわけだから文字通り20年間、ローズを待って同じ場所で過ごしていたドクターを思うと切なくもなる。S1の“Dalek”で登場したアダム・ミッチェルも旅に加わっているが、ほんのりやきもちモードのドクターが可愛らしい。少々うざったい性格ではあるが、ドクターとローズを助けるために頑張ってくれた。最後にはドクターにもう一飛び冒険に誘われるアダム。よかったね���嬉しく思う反面、”The Long Game”での彼の末路を思うと切なくなる。
I really want to give this 4 stars. It's somewhat close, but I feel like I've gotta show how this needs to be separated from The Ninth Doctor Adventures in terms of overall quality. Look. Nicholas Briggs is a great voice actor. But he does not do a great Ninth Doctor voice. Instead of Christopher Eccleston, I imagined Nicholas Briggs cosplaying as the Ninth Doctor more often than not while listening to this.
The first two stories were kinda just okay, but I found myself really enjoying the second half of this set. "The Other Side" shows that the Ninth Doctor's life was not quite as short as we thought. Wedged between "Dalek" and "The Long Game," The Doctor at one point waits 28 years to reunite with Rose again. I actually wonder whether this is a reference to Eccleston being in 28 Days Later. This story is also another adventure involving Adam Mitchell, and the ending even implies that there are more adventures with him between this and "The Long Game," though it is a bit annoying how obvious the foreshadowing of his departure is. Of course, due to the controversial actor, there are no more Adam stories coming from Big Finish. With "Retail Therapy," I really enjoyed hearing Jackie talk about the sacrifices she's made raising Rose and how she feels like she can't measure up against The Doctor because he takes her traveling. It was a very heartfelt, down to earth story that gave the mother-daughter relationship more dimensions. I do kinda wish that, in addition to playing Jackie again, Camille Coduri could have perhaps tried voicing Rose. Sometimes it took me a moment realizing Rose was talking when Briggs read her dialogue.
Again, I really feel that the second half is strong, while the first half didn't really grab me as much. I honestly would not have gotten this collection had it not been one of various items included in a Humble Bundle. Even when it was discounted at $20 on the Big Finish website, I wasn't quick to get it. Because why get this when one can get the Eccleston audios we've been blessed with these last couple years? That being said, I am glad I took the time to listen to this so I could enjoy the stories I enjoyed. I wouldn't say it's as high of a priority as the Eccleston audios, but one might find something to enjoy.
Doctor Who: The Doctor Chronicles: The Ninth Doctor - 3.125/5 stars It was such a slog to get to the last story that I knew was going to be the best considering it has Jackie Tyler in it. 1.1 The Bleeding Heart by Cavan Scott - 4/5 stars Fun little setting, a murder mystery with tragic Time War PTSD for 9. This is the only story without Rose Tyler. It’s also very different to 9’s era considering he didn't have any stories that weren’t set on or around Earth. 1.2 The Window on the Moor by Una McCormack - 1/5 stars Una McCormack has a very rare miss here. This one just sort of drags on. I feel like if this had been a short trip and was half its length without the historical figure then this one would have been a solid story but I was so bored during this that I couldn't finish it. 1.3 The Other Side by Scott Handcock - 2.5/5 stars This one, despite having Adam Mitchell in it, is decent. It's not exciting and it feels a bit like a weeping angel story without the weeping angels (so without the best part). 1.4 Retail Therapy by James Goss - 5/5 stars Jackie Tyler starts selling aliens that de-age people as an MLM scheme. Nick Briggs voicing an old lady is never not funny to me. Jackie is so iconic in this as she is trying to make her daughter proud as she’s jealous that the Doctor can show Rose the universe and all these wonders while she can’t. I just want to give her a hug she’s such a wonderful person and a great mother.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Props to the narrator for being able to capture the 9th's doctor voice almost perfectly. You felt it really was 9 come back to do this story and the narrator was even able to get his personality to come through etc. Major major props to that. My one complaint, why oh why did they not get a female to do the voice of Rose and instead had the narrator do her voice too. It didn't fit. Not when they had other people doing the voices for all the other characters. So we had a male voice for Rose..meh. With Billie coming back to do audio with Tennant HOPEFULLY she'll do the next ones in the 9th Doctor series.
As for the stories, I loved the one of him before he met Rose (though honestly it throws things off a little because when he meets Rose he's exclaiming over his new look...but we'll just look past that, maybe he likes to marvel at his features whenever he can..) then he meets up with Rose for an adventure, then we get to Rose and Adam, which was a SUPER interesting one and I'm glad we got to see that there was more to Adam than just the short time we had with him. Then the last one with Jackie was a hoot.
They really nailed this and I'm so glad they did as there is not enough love for 9 out there in the world!
Пока Экклстон старательно обходит стороной любые предложения появиться в образе 9-го Доктора, Ник Бриггс отлично справляется с этой ролью. Серьезно, он большой молодец, сумел подобраться к тональности и закавычкам Девятого максимально близко, не опустившись до простого копирования. Пожалуй, это самое приятное в данной коллекции БФ.
В остальном: для галочки втиснутые исторические личности, невзрачные злодеи, одномерные ходы и всепроникающая атмосфера пластмассовых манекенов из первого сезона ньюскула. Хороша только последняя история, где двигателем выступает Джеки Тайлер - по-моему, не растаять от Камил Кодури невозможно. Имеет место даже проникновенный диалог с Доктором.
На выходе: качественный продукт, но без искры. Девятый сам по себе чуть не самый сложный для воспроизведения Доктор, и часто выступает фоном, а не главным действующим лицом. Это просто данность. И Биг Финиш явно старался, но не хватило необходимого слоя нарратива, увлекающего за собой в другие галактики и позволяющего раствориться в сеттинге.
I was all set to rate this a one star. In all honesty, I would have given it a zero star, but that's not possible. One thing and one thing only saved the rating on this audiobook. (And yes, I called it an audiobook, because it is most certainly not an audio drama, what it is publicized as). This is just a collection of books narrated by this one guy with one or two of the other roles being performed by actual people. It is a slightly more advanced version of an audiobook. And I hate audiobooks. Maybe this realization made me like the last book more as I finally came to realize that it was an audiobook, but I like to think that the humor and the awesomeness of Camille Coduri. God, she was awesome! Plus whoever wrote it was a genius. Glubby-glubs! Stupid name! And yet so cute! If you really want to get the most out of this collection, just listen to the last one. You can skip the rest.