What do you think?
Rate this book
The Poldark Saga #3
Jeremy Poldark
Cornwall, 1790. Ross Poldark faces the darkest hour of his life. He is to stand trial for the wrecking of two ships. Despite their stormy married life, Demelza has tried to rally support for her husband. But Ross Poldark has many powerful enemies.
564 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 1950
1056 people are currently reading
8026 people want to read
About the author
Winston Graham
219 books1,148 followersWinston Graham was the author of forty novels. His books have been widely translated and the Poldark series has been developed into two television series, shown in 22 countries. Six of Winston Graham's books have been filmed for the big screen, the most notable being Marnie, directed by Alfred Hitchcock. Winston Graham was a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature (FRSL) and in 1983 was invested an Officer of the Order of the British Empire (OBE). In his death, he left behind a son and daughter.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 833 reviews
April 1, 2018
I loved being back in this world!
As always, there is struggle and strife and Ross always in trouble. But it's mostly always for the good!
Demelza is wonderful as ever and strong in her way. And dear sweet Verity. I would love them both as friends ❤️
And now we have a new edition. But what new troubles await the Poldark's!
Wonderful series so far!
Happy Reading!
Mel 🖤🐺
As always, there is struggle and strife and Ross always in trouble. But it's mostly always for the good!
Demelza is wonderful as ever and strong in her way. And dear sweet Verity. I would love them both as friends ❤️
And now we have a new edition. But what new troubles await the Poldark's!
Wonderful series so far!
Happy Reading!
Mel 🖤🐺
March 22, 2019
This novel illustrates yet again the cinematic quality of Winston Graham’s writing. The vivid descriptions, the turmoil and troubles of the characters, how their surroundings and their circumstances colour their lives and perceptions – for me, it was truly like watching a movie. Although I have not yet watched any of the specials that have been filmed based on these novels, I can only imagine how easy the film-makers’ task must have been thanks to Mr. Graham’s visual writing. The most difficult part would be trying to figure out what to leave out while the story is condensed from novel to film.
This part of the saga begins with Ross Poldark in serious trouble because at least one of the ships that floundered on his shoreline at the end of the last novel belonged to the Warleggans. There are deep and long-standing resentments between the Warleggans and the Poldarks, just as there are also deep and long-standing attractions. Will Ross’ pride find him a permanent berth in prison after his trial in the Courts? Demelza stands by him and takes steps of her own in attempts to seek his release and freedom. However, the Warleggans have even more determination – and resources – seeking to keep him confined and/or transported.
I found it interesting as this novel progressed how the rifts between a couple are deepened by their own fears. As conflicts continue between them, so a chasm opens between Ross and Demelza that appears impossible to bridge. Both make assumptions and do not communicate these for fear that their assumptions will then become facts – and neither is prepared to deal with the burden of having their worst fears realized.
Meantime, the village continues to suffer as its prosperity declines. Ross and some of his friends can see the possibility of an end, and they take small steps to turn things around. In the process and out of dire necessity, Ross and his cousin Francis are reconciled as they team up to advance their own copper mining venture.
Ross and Demelza have a baby son and name him Jeremy. Although this great event does draw them closer, it also acts as a further spur to Ross’ efforts to generate the financial security he desires for his family. As often happens in real life, Ross finds it difficult to divide his energies between home and the wider world of commerce and both he and Demelza struggle to find a balance that will enable them to thrive as a family.
This novel is well-written and the story completely engaging, and it shares one main result with the first two: I can hardly wait for Part Four next month.
This part of the saga begins with Ross Poldark in serious trouble because at least one of the ships that floundered on his shoreline at the end of the last novel belonged to the Warleggans. There are deep and long-standing resentments between the Warleggans and the Poldarks, just as there are also deep and long-standing attractions. Will Ross’ pride find him a permanent berth in prison after his trial in the Courts? Demelza stands by him and takes steps of her own in attempts to seek his release and freedom. However, the Warleggans have even more determination – and resources – seeking to keep him confined and/or transported.
I found it interesting as this novel progressed how the rifts between a couple are deepened by their own fears. As conflicts continue between them, so a chasm opens between Ross and Demelza that appears impossible to bridge. Both make assumptions and do not communicate these for fear that their assumptions will then become facts – and neither is prepared to deal with the burden of having their worst fears realized.
Meantime, the village continues to suffer as its prosperity declines. Ross and some of his friends can see the possibility of an end, and they take small steps to turn things around. In the process and out of dire necessity, Ross and his cousin Francis are reconciled as they team up to advance their own copper mining venture.
Ross and Demelza have a baby son and name him Jeremy. Although this great event does draw them closer, it also acts as a further spur to Ross’ efforts to generate the financial security he desires for his family. As often happens in real life, Ross finds it difficult to divide his energies between home and the wider world of commerce and both he and Demelza struggle to find a balance that will enable them to thrive as a family.
This novel is well-written and the story completely engaging, and it shares one main result with the first two: I can hardly wait for Part Four next month.
February 8, 2022
I found the third book in the Poldark series as enthralling as ever and I highly recommend this series. Can't wait for the PBS miniseries "Poldark" to begin at the end of June either.
Ross and Demelza are experiencing tough financial times thanks to George Warleggan and cousin Francis. Will Ross lose everything he owns to the rapacious George Warleggan? Can't wait to read the next book "Warleggan" to find out.
I'm beginning to strongly dislike Elizabeth who doesn't seem to be able to appreciate the sacrifice Demelza made while D. nursed her in-laws back to health. At least cousin Francis is appreciative of Demelza and is ashamed of his previous behavior towards her. Hardship seemed to have helped him mature at least if nothing else and there's hope yet for the former rotter.
Very satisfying to see cousin Verity happy at last after so many years of sacrifice for her family.
I feel quite at home with these characters and have become emotionally invested in them. Hope the next book brings happier times to the Poldark family.
Ross and Demelza are experiencing tough financial times thanks to George Warleggan and cousin Francis. Will Ross lose everything he owns to the rapacious George Warleggan? Can't wait to read the next book "Warleggan" to find out.
I'm beginning to strongly dislike Elizabeth who doesn't seem to be able to appreciate the sacrifice Demelza made while D. nursed her in-laws back to health. At least cousin Francis is appreciative of Demelza and is ashamed of his previous behavior towards her. Hardship seemed to have helped him mature at least if nothing else and there's hope yet for the former rotter.
Very satisfying to see cousin Verity happy at last after so many years of sacrifice for her family.
I feel quite at home with these characters and have become emotionally invested in them. Hope the next book brings happier times to the Poldark family.
September 8, 2017
"It isn’t where you’re born in this world, it’s what you do."
If you’ve read my reviews of both Ross Poldark and Demelza, then you might be thinking here we go again… Candi’s set to get all fangirlish on us! Yep, you’re probably right! Jeremy Poldark is the third in this splendid series and just as riveting as the first two. In this one, the futures of some of my beloved characters are threatened, and I was worried indeed. Ross is faced with a dilemma and his thought process in determining the right path is fraught with tension. His emotions are complex, and he can’t seem to evade the shadow that hovers over him. A more pessimistic side of this strong-willed man appears to get the best of him. He reflects "there are no permanent things, only fleeting moments of warmth and companionship, precious stationary seconds in a flicker of troubled days."
Demelza is resilient, yet harbors some of her own doubts about herself. Nevertheless, she once more fights for those she loves with all she has. I love watching her in action. She is not a ‘manipulator’ in the ugly sense of the word, but somehow she still manages to hold the reins in some sticky situations! "It was one of the few comforting factors in Demelza’s excursions into society, this faculty she had of pleasing men. She did not see it yet as power, only as a buttress to faltering courage." She never schemes to her own advantage, but uses whatever gifts she has to work towards the benefit and happiness of others. If you don’t already know this woman, you are missing out on one of the finest characters. She ranks right up there with my favorite literary figures of all time.
Aside from the leading man and lady, we also see more of Dr. Dwight Enys, who is quickly becoming another favorite. He is truly concerned for the welfare of the people for whom he provides medical service, mostly miners’ families and other impoverished folk. He does not look down his nose at those less fortunate than himself, unlike the other pompous physician in town. We are introduced to Caroline Penvenen and her little canine companion – I can sense she will be a delightful addition to the series as well. She inserted a brand of subtle humor into the storyline that I for one rather eagerly gobbled down. "I stay with my uncle, Mr. Ray Penvenen, whom you may know. I have no parents and he reluctantly takes the responsibility of an orphan niece, as monks take a hair shirt. So at times I remove the penance by removing myself; and others wear the shirt for him." I look forward to seeing more of her sharp wit in future installments. And, naturally, George Warleggan and his schemes are once more not to be ignored. He continues to insert himself into every situation, using his power to attempt to turn the tables against Ross and in his own favor. He’s the bad guy you love to hate!
Once again, I can’t emphasize more that if you really love engaging historical fiction with memorable and well-drawn characters, you need to give this series a try. You will celebrate the victories and bewail the misfortunes. You might even become a fangirl (or fanboy) yourself! I can’t wait to read book 4, which is on my reading plan for this month. I feel a sense of doom going into the next, but I pray all will be well for my cherished friends! A genuine 5 star book.
"As always fog made the land secretive and strange; it was not the familiar friendly countryside they knew and owned; it reverted to an earlier and less personal allegiance."
If you’ve read my reviews of both Ross Poldark and Demelza, then you might be thinking here we go again… Candi’s set to get all fangirlish on us! Yep, you’re probably right! Jeremy Poldark is the third in this splendid series and just as riveting as the first two. In this one, the futures of some of my beloved characters are threatened, and I was worried indeed. Ross is faced with a dilemma and his thought process in determining the right path is fraught with tension. His emotions are complex, and he can’t seem to evade the shadow that hovers over him. A more pessimistic side of this strong-willed man appears to get the best of him. He reflects "there are no permanent things, only fleeting moments of warmth and companionship, precious stationary seconds in a flicker of troubled days."
Demelza is resilient, yet harbors some of her own doubts about herself. Nevertheless, she once more fights for those she loves with all she has. I love watching her in action. She is not a ‘manipulator’ in the ugly sense of the word, but somehow she still manages to hold the reins in some sticky situations! "It was one of the few comforting factors in Demelza’s excursions into society, this faculty she had of pleasing men. She did not see it yet as power, only as a buttress to faltering courage." She never schemes to her own advantage, but uses whatever gifts she has to work towards the benefit and happiness of others. If you don’t already know this woman, you are missing out on one of the finest characters. She ranks right up there with my favorite literary figures of all time.
Aside from the leading man and lady, we also see more of Dr. Dwight Enys, who is quickly becoming another favorite. He is truly concerned for the welfare of the people for whom he provides medical service, mostly miners’ families and other impoverished folk. He does not look down his nose at those less fortunate than himself, unlike the other pompous physician in town. We are introduced to Caroline Penvenen and her little canine companion – I can sense she will be a delightful addition to the series as well. She inserted a brand of subtle humor into the storyline that I for one rather eagerly gobbled down. "I stay with my uncle, Mr. Ray Penvenen, whom you may know. I have no parents and he reluctantly takes the responsibility of an orphan niece, as monks take a hair shirt. So at times I remove the penance by removing myself; and others wear the shirt for him." I look forward to seeing more of her sharp wit in future installments. And, naturally, George Warleggan and his schemes are once more not to be ignored. He continues to insert himself into every situation, using his power to attempt to turn the tables against Ross and in his own favor. He’s the bad guy you love to hate!
Once again, I can’t emphasize more that if you really love engaging historical fiction with memorable and well-drawn characters, you need to give this series a try. You will celebrate the victories and bewail the misfortunes. You might even become a fangirl (or fanboy) yourself! I can’t wait to read book 4, which is on my reading plan for this month. I feel a sense of doom going into the next, but I pray all will be well for my cherished friends! A genuine 5 star book.
"As always fog made the land secretive and strange; it was not the familiar friendly countryside they knew and owned; it reverted to an earlier and less personal allegiance."
October 7, 2016
"He realized that all the struggle and anxiety of the next few months would not be his alone. She would bear her share of the burden. She was bearing it now."
Within the pages of Winston Graham's Book 3 of the Poldark Series, we come to see the strength and determination of the slight waif who won the heart of Ross Poldark......Demelza. An unlikely young girl who would become his wife. An unlikely frail figure who would cast a giant shadow on things to come.
Ross Poldark, who returned to his familial land after fighting for the British in the American Revolutionary War, has quite the present battle on his hands. He has been accused of inciting the destitute locals into conviscating the contents of a ship that ran aground on the shores of Nampara Bay. Ross has an enemy in the likes of George Warleggan who wants nothing more than to see Ross hang for this. Warleggan sets out to build a solid case against Ross. Perhaps with the dastardly assistance of Ross' own cousin and his servant.
We'll see Demelza step front and center using her sharpened wits to free Ross if she can. We'll also see the games that men play in the name of greed and in the darkened corners of backroom deals. Graham presents the spotlight on class distinctions as well as the role of women in this 18th century setting. Some things just never seem to change.
If you follow the PBS Poldark Series, then this one is a must for you. If you haven't, then grab Book 1 and get a wiggle on. Such a satisfying journey into historical fiction brought to life through the stellar efforts of PBS.
Within the pages of Winston Graham's Book 3 of the Poldark Series, we come to see the strength and determination of the slight waif who won the heart of Ross Poldark......Demelza. An unlikely young girl who would become his wife. An unlikely frail figure who would cast a giant shadow on things to come.
Ross Poldark, who returned to his familial land after fighting for the British in the American Revolutionary War, has quite the present battle on his hands. He has been accused of inciting the destitute locals into conviscating the contents of a ship that ran aground on the shores of Nampara Bay. Ross has an enemy in the likes of George Warleggan who wants nothing more than to see Ross hang for this. Warleggan sets out to build a solid case against Ross. Perhaps with the dastardly assistance of Ross' own cousin and his servant.
We'll see Demelza step front and center using her sharpened wits to free Ross if she can. We'll also see the games that men play in the name of greed and in the darkened corners of backroom deals. Graham presents the spotlight on class distinctions as well as the role of women in this 18th century setting. Some things just never seem to change.
If you follow the PBS Poldark Series, then this one is a must for you. If you haven't, then grab Book 1 and get a wiggle on. Such a satisfying journey into historical fiction brought to life through the stellar efforts of PBS.
July 21, 2024
I absolutely adore this series!
March 18, 2022
"Do you think that Ross is settled down after all his trouble?"
"I always feel," Dwight said, "That Ross is like a volcano. He may be quiet forever - or erupt tomorrow."
A very good summary of Ross's character!
This is the third book in a row in this series, & once again it is a 5★ read for me. Once again the book is a mixture of romance, adventure, humour (in the most unexpected places) & Ross's prickly, difficult character.
& the good doctor (Dwight Enys) looks to be once again heading for an unsuitable romance. I can't wait to start Vol 4.
One thing that baffles me. This book was originally titled Venture Once More - a far better title than Jeremy Poldark, given that
Mysterious are the ways of the publishing world!
https://wordpress.com/view/carolshess...
August 7, 2013
I've just finished the first three of the Poldark novels.
I'd never have considered reading them if I'd not had the opportunity to read the first one for free on kindle, mainly because I shy away from romance-novels-made-into-a-long-running-TV-series.
Pity that.
Winston Graham wrote the first four novels as a series in the 1950's, and then returned to them in the 1970's and wrote another five.
I've read the first three only, because the fourth is not available on Kindle. I will seek it out at the library, though.
At the core, these novels are considered historical romance, but meticulously researched so that the period of the late 1700's in Cornwall is brought to life very vividly without any prettying up.
Graham explores the social divisions of the society with a certain brutality, dwelling on the lack of rights among the poor classes, the child labour, the ignorance, the fear of the upper classes of losing their privilege.
While Graham does not skim over the deplorable, inhumane living conditions of the poorest, neither does he revel in it for the sake of shock. It is merely there, a fact of life, ordinary.
The lives of women are exposed with a keen eye, and he does not shy away from exposing their utter dependence on the men in their lives - fathers, brothers, husbands, sons, nephews - yet he does not dramatise. They have no rights, and while they chafe privately, even this is self-curtailed because in their very bones they have accepted their place.
In the three books I read, there were three particularly important women through whom Graham was able to explore the socio-cultural boundaries in which their lives were contained. He did this marvellously - frustrating me at times, for he does not give a nod to modern sensibilities of feminism. He tells it like it was.
I think this is why I enjoyed the books so much. They are not 'romantic' at all, other than they depict relationships; but they are very real relationships, exploring power, loyalty, dependency, toxicity. Of course, life for human beings is all about relationships - between friends, family, neighbours, enemies, the relationships between those who must depend on each other for sheer mutual survival.
His characters are wonderfully complex - and by this I don't mean that he's created complex backstories for them for the sake of sensationalism, but that not a one of them is wholly good, or bad, or right, or moral, or admirable. They are all very alive with their individual flaws, strengths and characteristics, and so one can hate them, admire them, pity them, despise them in turn.
Cornwall of the late 1700's is brought to life most vividly; beautiful, yes, but also grey, and damp, and cold, the landscape wild but also ailing due to the mines and the smelters and the commencement of industrialisation. It's a harsh land.
The books are an analysis of human rights, in my view, a disclosure of how people lived that is not a dispassionate historian's highlighting of the facts, but a very human, humane, passionate, life-and-death reliving of those times through the lives of his protagonists.
I think Graham has been done a disservice by not being taken more seriously for his historical exactitude, and the dismissal of his books as romances.
I've enjoyed the first three very much, and I will seek out the remainder.
I'd never have considered reading them if I'd not had the opportunity to read the first one for free on kindle, mainly because I shy away from romance-novels-made-into-a-long-running-TV-series.
Pity that.
Winston Graham wrote the first four novels as a series in the 1950's, and then returned to them in the 1970's and wrote another five.
I've read the first three only, because the fourth is not available on Kindle. I will seek it out at the library, though.
At the core, these novels are considered historical romance, but meticulously researched so that the period of the late 1700's in Cornwall is brought to life very vividly without any prettying up.
Graham explores the social divisions of the society with a certain brutality, dwelling on the lack of rights among the poor classes, the child labour, the ignorance, the fear of the upper classes of losing their privilege.
While Graham does not skim over the deplorable, inhumane living conditions of the poorest, neither does he revel in it for the sake of shock. It is merely there, a fact of life, ordinary.
The lives of women are exposed with a keen eye, and he does not shy away from exposing their utter dependence on the men in their lives - fathers, brothers, husbands, sons, nephews - yet he does not dramatise. They have no rights, and while they chafe privately, even this is self-curtailed because in their very bones they have accepted their place.
In the three books I read, there were three particularly important women through whom Graham was able to explore the socio-cultural boundaries in which their lives were contained. He did this marvellously - frustrating me at times, for he does not give a nod to modern sensibilities of feminism. He tells it like it was.
I think this is why I enjoyed the books so much. They are not 'romantic' at all, other than they depict relationships; but they are very real relationships, exploring power, loyalty, dependency, toxicity. Of course, life for human beings is all about relationships - between friends, family, neighbours, enemies, the relationships between those who must depend on each other for sheer mutual survival.
His characters are wonderfully complex - and by this I don't mean that he's created complex backstories for them for the sake of sensationalism, but that not a one of them is wholly good, or bad, or right, or moral, or admirable. They are all very alive with their individual flaws, strengths and characteristics, and so one can hate them, admire them, pity them, despise them in turn.
Cornwall of the late 1700's is brought to life most vividly; beautiful, yes, but also grey, and damp, and cold, the landscape wild but also ailing due to the mines and the smelters and the commencement of industrialisation. It's a harsh land.
The books are an analysis of human rights, in my view, a disclosure of how people lived that is not a dispassionate historian's highlighting of the facts, but a very human, humane, passionate, life-and-death reliving of those times through the lives of his protagonists.
I think Graham has been done a disservice by not being taken more seriously for his historical exactitude, and the dismissal of his books as romances.
I've enjoyed the first three very much, and I will seek out the remainder.
February 5, 2017
The third book in the Poldark series. The farther into the series I go the deeper my feelings become for these marvelous characters. Demelza Poldark is one of the most finely drawn, enthralling women ever put to paper. She has become the heart of the books for me, and I feel that Winston Graham must have felt the same. She is open and honest and leads with her heart, and she puts the gentry to shame.
In this book we become better acquainted with Dwight Enys, a doctor ahead of his time, who feels for his patients and despairs when he cannot provide for them the basic services they so sorely need. And, there is, of course, the villain, George Warleggan, whose villainy springs from all to recognizable human traits: greed, jealousy, and feelings of his own insecurity. I love his repartee with Caroline Penvenen that is charged with both humor and an undercurrent of sexual tension.
Ross Poldark walks the tightrope that is life, and he does it without a net. He faces risks with bravado but without arrogance. He knows he might lose at any moment and that what he bets on is precious and irreplaceable, but he is unwilling to let someone else pulls his strings. You cannot help admiring him, even when he is so headstrong and wrong-headed that you want to shake him.
I cannot imagine what more one would want from a story of this nature than that it holds you, involves you, and pleases you. Winston Graham does all three. I am anxious to begin Book Four.
”Human beings were blind, crazy creatures, he thought, forever walking the tightrope of the present condemned to ever changing shifts and expedients to maintain the balance of existence, not knowing even as far ahead as tomorrow what the actions of today would bring. How could one plan a year ahead, how influence the imponderables?”
In this book we become better acquainted with Dwight Enys, a doctor ahead of his time, who feels for his patients and despairs when he cannot provide for them the basic services they so sorely need. And, there is, of course, the villain, George Warleggan, whose villainy springs from all to recognizable human traits: greed, jealousy, and feelings of his own insecurity. I love his repartee with Caroline Penvenen that is charged with both humor and an undercurrent of sexual tension.
Ross Poldark walks the tightrope that is life, and he does it without a net. He faces risks with bravado but without arrogance. He knows he might lose at any moment and that what he bets on is precious and irreplaceable, but he is unwilling to let someone else pulls his strings. You cannot help admiring him, even when he is so headstrong and wrong-headed that you want to shake him.
I cannot imagine what more one would want from a story of this nature than that it holds you, involves you, and pleases you. Winston Graham does all three. I am anxious to begin Book Four.
”Human beings were blind, crazy creatures, he thought, forever walking the tightrope of the present condemned to ever changing shifts and expedients to maintain the balance of existence, not knowing even as far ahead as tomorrow what the actions of today would bring. How could one plan a year ahead, how influence the imponderables?”
April 29, 2022
The continuing saga of the Poldarks of Cornwall just got even more complex and involved in the 3rd installment of Jeremy Poldark and I loved it! Picking up right where book 2 left off, Ross and Demelza are suffering a great loss and Ross finds himself in the midst of a trial being accused of inciting a riot when two ships ran aground and the local folks rush to salvage the wrecks. He is near bankruptcy and his future looks very bleak with the mine closure and his rival, George Warleggan breathing down his back constantly looking for ways to bring Ross down. On top of all of this, the Poldarks - Ross & Demelza, Francis & Elizabeth, Verity - are still struggling to work through various issues and personal slights and snubs from the past. Our power couple goes through a rough patch as most couples who are in love do and find themselves not able to communicate properly causing much unnecessary anguish and anxiety.
Resentment and bitterness and old grudges were dead things that rotted the hands that grasped them.
Dwight Enys, the eligible bachelor doctor demonstrates his heart for helping the poor and destitute folks of the community. We get a look at the struggles with medicine at this time and just how difficult it was to help those who were sick due to lack of supplies or poor sanitary conditions. Dwight meets one of my favorite characters, the alluring and tantalizing Caroline Penvenen and her little pug, Horace. She add lots of spice to the mix as she makes an impression on Dwight.
After supper he sat for a while in his bedroom reading a medical book, but the willful Miss Penvenen and her doings kept intervening. She existed at the corner of his eye, in the depths of his ear, in the back of his mind.
As I get deeper and deeper into the story, I am growing so much more attached to these people that I have to keep reading. These books have been so much fun to read and I know it’s really an 18th century soap opera at its finest, but I don’t care. I will keep rooting for my favorites and keep hoping the villains get their due. I already know how it ends, as I’ve seen the PBS series, but I’m really happy that I’ve taken the time to go back and enjoy the lives of my favorite Cornish family in written form.
Some of my favorite quotations:
It was one of the few comforting factors in Demelza’s excursions into society, this faculty she had of pleasing men. She did not see it yet as power, only as a buttress to faltering courage.
About Ross - He was a man of moods, yet he was her constant, something unchanging, infinitely reliable, the pivot of her life. There could never be anyone else. Without him she would not be more than half alive.
There are no permanent things, only fleeting moments of warmth and companionship, precious stationary seconds in a flicker of troubled days.
About Demelza Maybe it’s because I’m from common stock, but I want the home about me: candles burning, curtains drawn, warmth, tea, friendship, love. Those are what matter to me.
Resentment and bitterness and old grudges were dead things that rotted the hands that grasped them.
Dwight Enys, the eligible bachelor doctor demonstrates his heart for helping the poor and destitute folks of the community. We get a look at the struggles with medicine at this time and just how difficult it was to help those who were sick due to lack of supplies or poor sanitary conditions. Dwight meets one of my favorite characters, the alluring and tantalizing Caroline Penvenen and her little pug, Horace. She add lots of spice to the mix as she makes an impression on Dwight.
After supper he sat for a while in his bedroom reading a medical book, but the willful Miss Penvenen and her doings kept intervening. She existed at the corner of his eye, in the depths of his ear, in the back of his mind.
As I get deeper and deeper into the story, I am growing so much more attached to these people that I have to keep reading. These books have been so much fun to read and I know it’s really an 18th century soap opera at its finest, but I don’t care. I will keep rooting for my favorites and keep hoping the villains get their due. I already know how it ends, as I’ve seen the PBS series, but I’m really happy that I’ve taken the time to go back and enjoy the lives of my favorite Cornish family in written form.
Some of my favorite quotations:
It was one of the few comforting factors in Demelza’s excursions into society, this faculty she had of pleasing men. She did not see it yet as power, only as a buttress to faltering courage.
About Ross - He was a man of moods, yet he was her constant, something unchanging, infinitely reliable, the pivot of her life. There could never be anyone else. Without him she would not be more than half alive.
There are no permanent things, only fleeting moments of warmth and companionship, precious stationary seconds in a flicker of troubled days.
About Demelza Maybe it’s because I’m from common stock, but I want the home about me: candles burning, curtains drawn, warmth, tea, friendship, love. Those are what matter to me.
April 17, 2017
In this riveting third book, Ross must face trial for the actions he took following the death of his infant daughter. The feud with the Warleggans threatens the entire community and the relationship with his cousin Francis remains strained. It is then that his wife Demelza makes an announcement that changes their lives in unexpected ways and offers a glimmer of hope for the family's future.
June 30, 2019
I’m not sure if my introduction to the Poldark saga through the recent BBC adaptation means that these novels feel very episodic, but I found that I was quite content to read just a couple of chapters a day.
I’m used to these books being slow with this volume only just covering the next two years (1790-91) after the previous book.
As this is a continuation I won’t mention any plot points for spoilers, but I liked how Demelza handles the current situation.
She is becoming my favourite character of the saga.
This third volume covers the first half of Series Two of the show and I think that’s the best way to summarise this entry.
Some good moments that help move the story along, I always enjoying spending time with these characters.
I’m used to these books being slow with this volume only just covering the next two years (1790-91) after the previous book.
As this is a continuation I won’t mention any plot points for spoilers, but I liked how Demelza handles the current situation.
She is becoming my favourite character of the saga.
This third volume covers the first half of Series Two of the show and I think that’s the best way to summarise this entry.
Some good moments that help move the story along, I always enjoying spending time with these characters.
March 10, 2018
The title of this book is a little misleading, given that Jeremy Poldark isn't even born until the last few pages, but that's a minor quibble. I enjoyed the third installment of this series just as much as one and two, and look forward to the next nine books. It's a source of comfort to know I can return to this corner of the world and these people I have come to love and appreciate. Good historical fiction always impresses upon me the fact that no matter how long ago or how far away, people really haven't changed that much at all. Good deeds and bad, rich and poor, modesty and ambition: these things are here to stay.
December 19, 2016
Me la he bebido. Ágil, entretenida. Un lujo. Este autor sabe narrar sin resultar pesado. Olé por él.
April 8, 2023
Изобщо не бях подозирала колко много са ми липсвали Полдаркови и Корнуол от края на XVIII век. Както и финесът, наблюдателността и остроумието на Уинстън Греъм. Дано следващите части на Полдарк (заедно с тези за Шарп) да излязат по-бързо на български!
4,5⭐️
4,5⭐️
February 1, 2021
It took me some time to gather my thoughts and write a review.
I loved the novel, and I strongly recommend the series to everyone who likes historical fiction, especially 18th century Cornwall.
What puzzled me for a while was how to describe the feeling the entire novel gave off.
Turmoil might be the best word for it. Turmoil, not just in most of the characters and their lives, but turmoil in the entire Cornwall, even Europe. Poverty and hunger, mines closing, sickness, talk of war, altogether dismal circumstances that Graham manages to describe so vividly. Once again, fantastic writing!
Of course, turmoil within the characters themselves interested me the most.
He strips the characters bare in front of the reader, giving us insight into their souls. Yet, the characters rarely communicate their feelings, fears, or assumptions to each other, leading to so much misunderstanding and rifts between them.
That, of course, only contributes more to the gloomy but very realistic feel of the novel.
I loved the novel, and I strongly recommend the series to everyone who likes historical fiction, especially 18th century Cornwall.
What puzzled me for a while was how to describe the feeling the entire novel gave off.
Turmoil might be the best word for it. Turmoil, not just in most of the characters and their lives, but turmoil in the entire Cornwall, even Europe. Poverty and hunger, mines closing, sickness, talk of war, altogether dismal circumstances that Graham manages to describe so vividly. Once again, fantastic writing!
Of course, turmoil within the characters themselves interested me the most.
He strips the characters bare in front of the reader, giving us insight into their souls. Yet, the characters rarely communicate their feelings, fears, or assumptions to each other, leading to so much misunderstanding and rifts between them.
That, of course, only contributes more to the gloomy but very realistic feel of the novel.
December 19, 2022
Thank you Lori! Your review persuaded me to continue with the series and I was so delighted that the third instalment was just as strong as the previous two. This is not relevant but I wanted to add that I read the first two books in June whilst in Cornwall. Along with my parents and dogs, we decamped to the countryside of Poldark for a whole month and stayed just along from the filming site of the village scenes. I adored the television series, but i was not sure how I would feel reading a series I was already familiar with. However I enjoyed it just as much if not more and it’s the first book for a while that I felt totally absorbed in. I will be returning very soon to book 4 as they are such well written adventures.
July 28, 2025
4.5/5
It was SO good to be back in this world... I love these characters so much! Flew through this one and can't wait to continue with the series. Aaaaaand now to start the tv series again for the fourth time! 😅
It was SO good to be back in this world... I love these characters so much! Flew through this one and can't wait to continue with the series. Aaaaaand now to start the tv series again for the fourth time! 😅
March 30, 2017
This series is simply amazing! This is the third book in the Poldark series. After a horrific tragedy in book 2, Ross is angry and fragmented. In his pain he does something that will bring him to trial later on. Demelza by his side - loving, supportive, unselfish...stands up for him at all costs.
These are some of the best written characters out there. A highly enjoyable read. I am reading this series as part of a buddy read. Most of my "buddies" are ahead of me, as I joined late. But, oh the discussions we are having over in our group. I feel all sorts of emotions when reading this. Aren't we supposed to??? It's great to have pals in the Reading for Pleasure Book Club to discuss with.
If you haven't begun this series yet, I highly recommend it. No way to go wrong. It's one of the best out there.
These are some of the best written characters out there. A highly enjoyable read. I am reading this series as part of a buddy read. Most of my "buddies" are ahead of me, as I joined late. But, oh the discussions we are having over in our group. I feel all sorts of emotions when reading this. Aren't we supposed to??? It's great to have pals in the Reading for Pleasure Book Club to discuss with.
If you haven't begun this series yet, I highly recommend it. No way to go wrong. It's one of the best out there.
September 5, 2016
Loved this even more for re-reading.
I would encourage others to read as there is far more in the book.
Loved the original series and had Robin and Angharad my mind as I read.
Had a walk around the coastal path yesterday with the dramatic music from that series also.
Very atmospheric!
I would encourage others to read as there is far more in the book.
Loved the original series and had Robin and Angharad my mind as I read.
Had a walk around the coastal path yesterday with the dramatic music from that series also.
Very atmospheric!
February 4, 2017
Ross and Demelza are reeling from the tragedy of losing little Julia. Ross is brooding over his cousin's betrayal and the end of the Carnmore Copper Company. He's also about to face trial at the Assizes for his role in the shipwrecks of last winter. Should he play conciliatory like his lawyer wants him to? Then what? Debtors' prison? Should he borrow money from friends the way Demelza wants him to or should he stick to his principles? Being Ross, the answer is fairly obvious. George Warleggan's hatred of the Poldarks increases as Francis struggles with his own role in Ross's struggles. Demelza has a secret she can't share and Verity is looking forward to meeting her husband's children. Will they like her? Dwight Enys is a little older and wiser after his affair with Keren but when he meets the beautiful, headstrong Caroline Penvenen, he's smitten. He tries to remind himself she's engaged to Unwin Trevaunance but Caroline isn't so sure she wants to marry him. The villagers are ill and Dwight spends most of his time caring for them and not dancing attendance on Caroline-how dare he?! The French are in revolt and the British nobility are worried. By the time 1791 rolls around, Ross and Demelza face new challenges but with a bit more hope.
The story is really picking up in this slim third volume (with a handsome interpretation of Ross on the cover). I'm impressed the screenwriter managed to take the plot exactly as written, condense the timeline and still manage to get it accurate. The one difference here is that the story doesn't enter into George's head until after the trial and he moves a little more slowly than he does in the series, probably because of the condensed timeframe for TV. It was an interesting leap into his head, finding out more about why he hates the Poldarks and what exactly he wants. His father seems like a fair man-tough- but fair. Uncle Cary is the ruthless one and influences George. I liked the little bits of humor interjected into the story-especially the affair of poor Jud! Jud and Prudie provide drama and comic relief at the same time.
What really annoyed me about this book is being inside Ross's head. Sadly he is still conflicted in his feelings about Elizabeth. He is content with Demelza- even loves her and recognizes she makes him an excellent partner but he is unable to tell Demelza or even show her. He blocked off his feelings when his mother died and claims not to be used to women, but I was hoping Demelza would help him open up. He's lived with her for years so he should be used to her by now but he continually ignores her feelings which makes me mad. Is this the difference between a male writer and female screenwriter? It's more realistic in the book but I want some romance with my realism, especially knowing there are more dark days ahead.
I love Demelza. She doesn't deserve Ross's brooding anger. She's intelligent in her own right and witty. She manages to figure out solutions to her problems practically and occasionally gets Ross to see reason. I felt so bad for her in this book. She worries so much and I wish Ross would just talk to her and tell her what's in his heart. I like how she always knows what he's feeling even if she doesn't know what he's thinking. I also really like Verity. She isn't in the story too much but she's as sweet and good as ever.Captain Blamey seems like a man given to nearly as much brooding as Ross and he isn't home too often. Verity deserves happiness and I hope the stepchildren are kind to her. The women shine in this book because I also like Caroline. When she first appears she is spoiled, young and seems to make a game of the serious situations she finds herself in. Then as the story progresses and the reader gets to know her better, she's lively, fun and probably more intelligent than she lets on. She's open-minded and of course she loves her Pug, Horace, so any dog lover becomes an automatic hit with me. The one woman who doesn't appear in good light here is Elizabeth. She is cold, selfish and just so seriously annoying. She is likened to Galatea, and she is a lot like a marble statue wanting to be admired. I found her seriously annoying.
The men do not fare as well as the women in this book. Francis is on a bad path but yet I have sympathy for him. He's growing and becoming more of a sympathetic character. I really liked Dwight. He's a little older, a little wiser and more cautious, but no less dedicated to helping the poor.Dwight is a little shy, sweet and very kind. I admire his principles more than Ross's. Ross's hot temper would wear me thin.
I'm both looking forward to and dreading reading the next volume. I'm going to stop there!
This edition of the book is full of typos. I hope they were fixed in the latest edition.
The story is really picking up in this slim third volume (with a handsome interpretation of Ross on the cover). I'm impressed the screenwriter managed to take the plot exactly as written, condense the timeline and still manage to get it accurate. The one difference here is that the story doesn't enter into George's head until after the trial and he moves a little more slowly than he does in the series, probably because of the condensed timeframe for TV. It was an interesting leap into his head, finding out more about why he hates the Poldarks and what exactly he wants. His father seems like a fair man-tough- but fair. Uncle Cary is the ruthless one and influences George. I liked the little bits of humor interjected into the story-especially the affair of poor Jud! Jud and Prudie provide drama and comic relief at the same time.
What really annoyed me about this book is being inside Ross's head. Sadly he is still conflicted in his feelings about Elizabeth. He is content with Demelza- even loves her and recognizes she makes him an excellent partner but he is unable to tell Demelza or even show her. He blocked off his feelings when his mother died and claims not to be used to women, but I was hoping Demelza would help him open up. He's lived with her for years so he should be used to her by now but he continually ignores her feelings which makes me mad. Is this the difference between a male writer and female screenwriter? It's more realistic in the book but I want some romance with my realism, especially knowing there are more dark days ahead.
I love Demelza. She doesn't deserve Ross's brooding anger. She's intelligent in her own right and witty. She manages to figure out solutions to her problems practically and occasionally gets Ross to see reason. I felt so bad for her in this book. She worries so much and I wish Ross would just talk to her and tell her what's in his heart. I like how she always knows what he's feeling even if she doesn't know what he's thinking. I also really like Verity. She isn't in the story too much but she's as sweet and good as ever.Captain Blamey seems like a man given to nearly as much brooding as Ross and he isn't home too often. Verity deserves happiness and I hope the stepchildren are kind to her. The women shine in this book because I also like Caroline. When she first appears she is spoiled, young and seems to make a game of the serious situations she finds herself in. Then as the story progresses and the reader gets to know her better, she's lively, fun and probably more intelligent than she lets on. She's open-minded and of course she loves her Pug, Horace, so any dog lover becomes an automatic hit with me. The one woman who doesn't appear in good light here is Elizabeth. She is cold, selfish and just so seriously annoying. She is likened to Galatea, and she is a lot like a marble statue wanting to be admired. I found her seriously annoying.
The men do not fare as well as the women in this book. Francis is on a bad path but yet I have sympathy for him. He's growing and becoming more of a sympathetic character. I really liked Dwight. He's a little older, a little wiser and more cautious, but no less dedicated to helping the poor.Dwight is a little shy, sweet and very kind. I admire his principles more than Ross's. Ross's hot temper would wear me thin.
I'm both looking forward to and dreading reading the next volume. I'm going to stop there!
This edition of the book is full of typos. I hope they were fixed in the latest edition.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 20, 2022
I enjoyed this. It definitely felt like a “filler” book in the Poldark series, but I did love the character development of Demelza and how she just took charge throughout. She’s my favorite character hands down in this series, but I also like that there’s not one character that is purely good or purely evil. Winston Graham’s writing continues to impress as well. Can’t wait to pick up the next one, a thicker book (yay!).
August 29, 2016
It has been a long while since I've read a novel which has both excited and dazzled me in the way that this one has. As a writer, Winston Graham paints pictures with prose the way Michelangelo did with his palette. Not a word is wasted, evoking images of the windswept landscape of Southwest England abutting the ocean sea that is Cornwall, dotted here and there with a smattering of landed estates, villages, inns, mines, coves, and houses of varying kinds.
It is August 1790 and Ross Poldark finds himself on trial at the Bodmin Assizes for his life, accused of formenting a riot and encouraging the theft of the King's properties from the wrecks of 2 ships that ran aground near his property the previous January. George Warleggan, a business rival and enemy, in the process of building and consolidating a growing wealth and influence based on interests in banking, mining, and land, feels certain that, at long last, he will soon be rid of the "Poldark presence", which goes back several generations in Cornwall. By contrast, the Warleggans are sly and cunning up-and-comers anxious to place their humble origins fall behind them.
Ross, over the previous year, has found himself mired in tragedy and mixed fortunes, due to the death of his first-born Julia and the failure of a mining venture in which he had invested a great deal of money. This causes strains in his relationship with Demelza, his wife. Demelza is one of the most unique characters I've ever come across in any novel I've read. A woman of humble status who through marriage earned the right to be regarded as a proper lady, Demelza is loving, generous of heart, resilient, and one of her husband's biggest defenders. To that end, she travels to Bodmin to visit one of the area's influential propertied men (Sir John Trevaunance) for help in providing good character references for her husband in court. Not an easy task. France is convulsed in revolution and any act or gesture in England that suggests common cause with the revolutionaries in Paris is regarded as threats to national security. So, it looks that Ross's life may soon be forfeit upon resolution of his case.
The following extract conveys with a deep poignancy the state of the Poldarks feelings for one another ---
[Ross] "... thought: Were beauty under twenty locks kept fast... If she went to London or Bath she'd have half the aristocracy at her feet. Instead she's immured here, in an ancient house and with a bankrupt husband, doing half her own work. It must be galling to her to feel her life's slipping away. She was twenty-six last birthday. Perhaps that's the reason for the change. But it's a change towards me.
'What are you thinking of, Ross?'
'Um? Oh, about the rain. The Mellingey will be in flood very soon.'
What would have happened, he thought, if she'd married me ?[Ross is thinking of Elizabeth Chynoweth, the great love of his life, who married his cousin Francis while Ross was in America, where it had been presumed he had died fighting for King and Country] Would events have been very different? We're the slaves of our characters: would I have been happier, or she? Perhaps there are elements in her nature and mine which would have made our life together difficult.
And what of this young woman [Demelza] beside him, whom he had loved devotedly for four years and still did love? She had given him more than perhaps Elizabeth ever could: months of unflawed relationship, unquestioning trust (which he was now betraying in thought). Oh, nonsense. What man did not at some time or another glance elsewhere; and who could complain if it remained at a glance? (Chance was a fine thing.) And if there had been a cooling between him and Demelza, hers had been the first move, not his."
All in all, this is a richly layered novel --- full of surprises ---which I invite the reader of this review to peruse at his/her leisure. You'll be glad that you did.
It is August 1790 and Ross Poldark finds himself on trial at the Bodmin Assizes for his life, accused of formenting a riot and encouraging the theft of the King's properties from the wrecks of 2 ships that ran aground near his property the previous January. George Warleggan, a business rival and enemy, in the process of building and consolidating a growing wealth and influence based on interests in banking, mining, and land, feels certain that, at long last, he will soon be rid of the "Poldark presence", which goes back several generations in Cornwall. By contrast, the Warleggans are sly and cunning up-and-comers anxious to place their humble origins fall behind them.
Ross, over the previous year, has found himself mired in tragedy and mixed fortunes, due to the death of his first-born Julia and the failure of a mining venture in which he had invested a great deal of money. This causes strains in his relationship with Demelza, his wife. Demelza is one of the most unique characters I've ever come across in any novel I've read. A woman of humble status who through marriage earned the right to be regarded as a proper lady, Demelza is loving, generous of heart, resilient, and one of her husband's biggest defenders. To that end, she travels to Bodmin to visit one of the area's influential propertied men (Sir John Trevaunance) for help in providing good character references for her husband in court. Not an easy task. France is convulsed in revolution and any act or gesture in England that suggests common cause with the revolutionaries in Paris is regarded as threats to national security. So, it looks that Ross's life may soon be forfeit upon resolution of his case.
The following extract conveys with a deep poignancy the state of the Poldarks feelings for one another ---
[Ross] "... thought: Were beauty under twenty locks kept fast... If she went to London or Bath she'd have half the aristocracy at her feet. Instead she's immured here, in an ancient house and with a bankrupt husband, doing half her own work. It must be galling to her to feel her life's slipping away. She was twenty-six last birthday. Perhaps that's the reason for the change. But it's a change towards me.
'What are you thinking of, Ross?'
'Um? Oh, about the rain. The Mellingey will be in flood very soon.'
What would have happened, he thought, if she'd married me ?[Ross is thinking of Elizabeth Chynoweth, the great love of his life, who married his cousin Francis while Ross was in America, where it had been presumed he had died fighting for King and Country] Would events have been very different? We're the slaves of our characters: would I have been happier, or she? Perhaps there are elements in her nature and mine which would have made our life together difficult.
And what of this young woman [Demelza] beside him, whom he had loved devotedly for four years and still did love? She had given him more than perhaps Elizabeth ever could: months of unflawed relationship, unquestioning trust (which he was now betraying in thought). Oh, nonsense. What man did not at some time or another glance elsewhere; and who could complain if it remained at a glance? (Chance was a fine thing.) And if there had been a cooling between him and Demelza, hers had been the first move, not his."
All in all, this is a richly layered novel --- full of surprises ---which I invite the reader of this review to peruse at his/her leisure. You'll be glad that you did.
February 29, 2016
Another fabulous installment in this Poldark saga that I am LOVING!!! On to book number four!!
June 2, 2023
Oh, ROSS. You absolute drama llama!
Once again, Demelza holds it all together while Ross runs around, getting into trouble, punching George Warleggen in the head (although let's face it: we all would if given the chance!), etc.
This one features the arrival of the titular Jeremy Poldark, as well as Ross' trial for inciting a riot, and the reunification of the family. As well as one of my favorite scenes: Verity meeting her DARLING stepson!
Once again, Demelza holds it all together while Ross runs around, getting into trouble, punching George Warleggen in the head (although let's face it: we all would if given the chance!), etc.
This one features the arrival of the titular Jeremy Poldark, as well as Ross' trial for inciting a riot, and the reunification of the family. As well as one of my favorite scenes: Verity meeting her DARLING stepson!
August 17, 2017
Jeremy Poldark was very similar to the seaside town of Cornwall where it takes place: turbulent, complex infrastructures, and it was breathtaking. Considering the first half of the novel presides over a court case, I was surprisingly intrigued by the whole ordeal. I thought I would have been bored, but a small town filled with my favorite Poldark characters holds plenty of charm for me. Everyone was scattered around the village and it could have been a party despite the dire circumstances.
There was a surprising scene that featured Francis Poldark and Dr. Dwight that I was not expecting, but it certainly heightened the drama and emotion of the story. Speaking of Dr. Dwight, we encountered Caroline Peneven for the first time. I knew she was involved because she's on the sixth cover. I thought she was spoiled at first because she called the physician for her dumb dog, but her character was gradually revealed to be a compassionate little miss. Her encounters with Dwight were so sweet and I would have paired them together had I not already known the outcome. Come on, how romantic is it that she orders cases of oranges for the whole village in order to prevent scurvy? Doctors + romantic disease prevention= melted heart.
Demelza Poldark is a champion and that's all I have to say. She needs to work on her communication with her husband and being too cheeky, but she's otherwise a darling. I'm sorry her husband is such a grump but that's what you should expect when you marry a handsome brooding hero.
Verity Poldark is still a doll baby and I will defend her forever. I just want to her to be happy and I need her on a book cover ASAP.
Ross Poldark is a smoldering scarred hero but, like his wife, needs to work on communication. He's a fiery Poldark, but you don't need to brood at every opportunity. You're a babe, but lighten up. Please continue to thrash your wheat shirtless...His speech in the courtroom and his final altercation with George Warleggan were divine. I just live for English drama like this.
Finally:
Jud Paynter is a gift to this series. That's all
I'm so happy that I discovered this show on a whim with a spectacular source material to match. I have to buy Warleggan (ironic) but I don't think I want the BBC tie in. I don't want his weasel face staring at others while I read. Until my next visit to Cornwall...
There was a surprising scene that featured Francis Poldark and Dr. Dwight that I was not expecting, but it certainly heightened the drama and emotion of the story. Speaking of Dr. Dwight, we encountered Caroline Peneven for the first time. I knew she was involved because she's on the sixth cover. I thought she was spoiled at first because she called the physician for her dumb dog, but her character was gradually revealed to be a compassionate little miss. Her encounters with Dwight were so sweet and I would have paired them together had I not already known the outcome. Come on, how romantic is it that she orders cases of oranges for the whole village in order to prevent scurvy? Doctors + romantic disease prevention= melted heart.
Demelza Poldark is a champion and that's all I have to say. She needs to work on her communication with her husband and being too cheeky, but she's otherwise a darling. I'm sorry her husband is such a grump but that's what you should expect when you marry a handsome brooding hero.
Verity Poldark is still a doll baby and I will defend her forever. I just want to her to be happy and I need her on a book cover ASAP.
Ross Poldark is a smoldering scarred hero but, like his wife, needs to work on communication. He's a fiery Poldark, but you don't need to brood at every opportunity. You're a babe, but lighten up. Please continue to thrash your wheat shirtless...His speech in the courtroom and his final altercation with George Warleggan were divine. I just live for English drama like this.
Finally:
Jud Paynter is a gift to this series. That's all
I'm so happy that I discovered this show on a whim with a spectacular source material to match. I have to buy Warleggan (ironic) but I don't think I want the BBC tie in. I don't want his weasel face staring at others while I read. Until my next visit to Cornwall...
December 14, 2013
Third in the Poldark saga, this is one that resolves the final twist that occurs at the end of the novel Demelza. The first half of the novel is taken up with Ross' impending trial for disturbing the peace, striking an officer, and other assorted bits of mayhem. Ross for his part has turned dark and sullen, especially as if he is found guilty, he could quite well be executed. Demelza, his wife, is mourning the death of their daughter Julia, and is trying hard to keep Ross in line, and find a way to save him. As with the rest of the series (so far) this is wonderfully written and full of life, and it is great to see the return of characters that we care about. This is clearly a bridging novel, resolving some issues, and continuing the overall story a bit, and I suspect, setting up the plot for the next novel, Warleggan. Four stars overall and a hearty recommendation.
For the longer review, please go here:
http://www.epinions.com/review/jeremy...
For the longer review, please go here:
http://www.epinions.com/review/jeremy...
October 24, 2019
In the third book in the series, Ross has problems with justice and is called upon to solve them in the midst of parliamentary elections, which of course makes things more complicated or, at least, too complicated to be able to do anything about them his beloved wife. This development gives the writer an opportunity to comment on these rather problematic institutions at that time. The end of this adventure marks for our protagonists the beginning of a long process of reconciliation with the past and of transition to a new era, which requires retreats, sacrifices, and even more economic and emotional risks, as developments in France show that things are going to change. Of course, for good and for bad, some remain very hardheaded so they can change, and so they continue to do the same things.
A book in which there may not be as many developments as in the previous one, but that doesn't mean it's not particularly interesting. In the first half the commentary on the functioning of justice and on the processes in the not so noble sport of politics is very intense and particularly enlightening, in the second half developments on more personal issues such as dealing with past wounds are moving and particularly interesting as make our heroes go a step further, while throughout the book, the difficult passage of our beloved couple in the phase of maturity offers us conflicting feelings of joy and melancholy. So this third part is completely satisfying and adds something to this beautiful and moving story that this series offers.
Στο τρίτο βιβλίο της σειράς ο Ross έχει προβλήματα με τη δικαιοσύνη και καλείται να τα λύσει εν μέσω των εκλογών για το κοινοβούλιο, κάτι που φυσικά κάνει τα πράγματα να είναι περισσότερο περίπλοκα ή, τουλάχιστον, πολύ περίπλοκα για να μπορέσει να κάνει κάτι για αυτά με την παρέμβασή της η αγαπητή σύζυγός του. Αυτή η εξέλιξη δίνει την ευκαιρία στον συγγραφέα να κάνει έναν σχολιασμό σε αυτούς τους μάλλον προβληματικούς θεσμούς εκείνη την εποχή. Το τέλος αυτής της περιπέτειας σηματοδοτεί για τους πρωταγωνιστές της ιστορίας μας την αρχή μιας μακράς διαδικασίας για την συμφιλίωση με το παρελθόν και το πέρασμα σε μία νέα εποχή, κάτι που απαιτεί υποχωρήσεις, θυσίες και ακόμα περισσότερα οικονομικά και συναισθηματικά ρίσκα, τη στιγμή που οι εξελίξεις στη Γαλλία δείχνουν ότι τα πράγματα πρόκειται να αλλάξουν. Βέβαια, για καλό και για κακό, κάποιοι παραμένουν πολύ χοντροκέφαλοι για να μπορέσουν να αλλάξουν και έτσι συνεχίζουν να κάνουν τα ίδια πράγματα.
Ένα βιβλίο στο οποίο μπορεί να μην υπάρχουν τόσες πολλές εξελίξεις όσο στο προηγούμενο αλλά αυτό δεν σημαίνει ότι δεν είναι εξαιρετικά ενδιαφέρον. Στο πρώτο μισό ο σχολιασμός για την λειτουργία της δικαιοσύνης και για τις διαδικασίες στο όχι και τόσο ευγενές άθλημα της πολιτικής είναι πολύ έντονος και ιδιαίτερα διαφωτιστικός, στο δεύτερο οι εξελίξεις σε πιο προσωπικά ζητήματα όπως η αντιμετώπιση των πληγών του παρελθόντος είναι συγκινητικές και ιδιαίτερα ενδιαφέρουσες καθώς κάνουν τους ήρωες μας να προχωρήσουν ένα βήμα παρακάτω, την ώρα που σε ολόκληρο το βιβλίο το δύσκολο πέρασμα του αγαπημένου μας ζευγαριού στη φάση της ωριμότητας μας προσφέρει αντικρουόμενα συναισθήματα χαράς και μελαγχολίας. Έτσι και αυτό το τρίτο μέρος είναι απόλυτα ικανοποιητικό και προσθέτει κάτι ακόμα σε αυτήν την όμορφη και συγκινητική ιστορία που μας προσφέρει αυτή η σειρά.
A book in which there may not be as many developments as in the previous one, but that doesn't mean it's not particularly interesting. In the first half the commentary on the functioning of justice and on the processes in the not so noble sport of politics is very intense and particularly enlightening, in the second half developments on more personal issues such as dealing with past wounds are moving and particularly interesting as make our heroes go a step further, while throughout the book, the difficult passage of our beloved couple in the phase of maturity offers us conflicting feelings of joy and melancholy. So this third part is completely satisfying and adds something to this beautiful and moving story that this series offers.
Στο τρίτο βιβλίο της σειράς ο Ross έχει προβλήματα με τη δικαιοσύνη και καλείται να τα λύσει εν μέσω των εκλογών για το κοινοβούλιο, κάτι που φυσικά κάνει τα πράγματα να είναι περισσότερο περίπλοκα ή, τουλάχιστον, πολύ περίπλοκα για να μπορέσει να κάνει κάτι για αυτά με την παρέμβασή της η αγαπητή σύζυγός του. Αυτή η εξέλιξη δίνει την ευκαιρία στον συγγραφέα να κάνει έναν σχολιασμό σε αυτούς τους μάλλον προβληματικούς θεσμούς εκείνη την εποχή. Το τέλος αυτής της περιπέτειας σηματοδοτεί για τους πρωταγωνιστές της ιστορίας μας την αρχή μιας μακράς διαδικασίας για την συμφιλίωση με το παρελθόν και το πέρασμα σε μία νέα εποχή, κάτι που απαιτεί υποχωρήσεις, θυσίες και ακόμα περισσότερα οικονομικά και συναισθηματικά ρίσκα, τη στιγμή που οι εξελίξεις στη Γαλλία δείχνουν ότι τα πράγματα πρόκειται να αλλάξουν. Βέβαια, για καλό και για κακό, κάποιοι παραμένουν πολύ χοντροκέφαλοι για να μπορέσουν να αλλάξουν και έτσι συνεχίζουν να κάνουν τα ίδια πράγματα.
Ένα βιβλίο στο οποίο μπορεί να μην υπάρχουν τόσες πολλές εξελίξεις όσο στο προηγούμενο αλλά αυτό δεν σημαίνει ότι δεν είναι εξαιρετικά ενδιαφέρον. Στο πρώτο μισό ο σχολιασμός για την λειτουργία της δικαιοσύνης και για τις διαδικασίες στο όχι και τόσο ευγενές άθλημα της πολιτικής είναι πολύ έντονος και ιδιαίτερα διαφωτιστικός, στο δεύτερο οι εξελίξεις σε πιο προσωπικά ζητήματα όπως η αντιμετώπιση των πληγών του παρελθόντος είναι συγκινητικές και ιδιαίτερα ενδιαφέρουσες καθώς κάνουν τους ήρωες μας να προχωρήσουν ένα βήμα παρακάτω, την ώρα που σε ολόκληρο το βιβλίο το δύσκολο πέρασμα του αγαπημένου μας ζευγαριού στη φάση της ωριμότητας μας προσφέρει αντικρουόμενα συναισθήματα χαράς και μελαγχολίας. Έτσι και αυτό το τρίτο μέρος είναι απόλυτα ικανοποιητικό και προσθέτει κάτι ακόμα σε αυτήν την όμορφη και συγκινητική ιστορία που μας προσφέρει αυτή η σειρά.
August 27, 2016
5 FABULOUS SECOND TIME AROUND STARS!!
Not by a hairbreadth would a single external circumstance move to accommodate him and his schemes—he knew that. As well ask, on the butterfly's behalf, for the postponement of sunset or tomorrow's gale.
Her face was preoccupied, thoughtful, intent, but not on what she was doing. He realized that all the struggle and anxiety of the next few months would not be his alone. She would bear her share of the burden. She was bearing it already.
He went to join her.
Once again— and I know I am repeating myself— this was a fabulous story written by a brilliant author. Next in line for a re-read is the fourth installment— Warleggan.
Not by a hairbreadth would a single external circumstance move to accommodate him and his schemes—he knew that. As well ask, on the butterfly's behalf, for the postponement of sunset or tomorrow's gale.
Her face was preoccupied, thoughtful, intent, but not on what she was doing. He realized that all the struggle and anxiety of the next few months would not be his alone. She would bear her share of the burden. She was bearing it already.
He went to join her.
Once again— and I know I am repeating myself— this was a fabulous story written by a brilliant author. Next in line for a re-read is the fourth installment— Warleggan.
August 14, 2017
I'm giving this 3.5-4 stars. I thought there were some really good scenes and descriptions in this one but I am not head over heals for this series. I am looking forward though to seeing where this story goes and meeting up again with the characters.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 833 reviews