I was hoping to start 2018 on a high point, books-wise, but unfortunately The Digital Matrix didn't quite do it for me. I'd just finished Brian Kernighan's brilliant Understanding the Digital World, which breaks down for the layman how computers, digital infrastructure and services work. I'd hoped that The Digital Matrix would help me understand what being a digital organisation would entail and how incumbents (including governments) whose roots were pre-digital could make the necessary shifts.
To be fair, the Digital Matrix does cover the latter point (it starts off assuming everyone understands what being "digital" means and entails; so if you're hoping for a grounding in Digital 101, you'll have to look elsewhere and content yourself with sweeping and somewhat fluffy statements in the opening chapters of The Digital Matrix such as "Digital is eating the physical, industrial world", "digital technology is critical to every industry and every company", "digital...mean[s] embracing the new business infrastructure that's at the intersection of...'powerful computing, pervasive connectivity and potent cloud'", and "digitisation is critical for every business".)
The Digital Matrix was a two star book for me because whatever substance it had was buried underneath its sledgehammer style. (Are all business books written in this style?)
#1: The confident assertions bordering on bombast - "I will show you three winning moves..."; "this book shows you ways to structure and nurture ecosystems that cut across industry boundaries"; "this book shows you ways to...position yourself for relevance in the digital future"; "this book shows you how to use metrics that are subtle and directionally right" (directionally right??); "now that you've been schooled on theories of disruption from the periphery". And so on.
#2: The unnecessary padding. I get that repeating points, summarising key points at the end of the chapter, drawing connections between content by referring to earlier points made are all techniques to help consolidate learning. But these points can be succinct or verbose. Laying out for the reader what they can expect in the next few chapters/sections can be done factually or in a self-congratulatory tone.
But there is substance to be found if you're patient enough to wade through the fluffy filler material. The examples Venkatraman cites, though fairly well known (Uber, AirBnB, Netflix, Google, Apple, IBM, GE, Honeywell, Ford, etc) nonetheless make for good reading and illustrate how business models and assumptions have shifted dramatically. Venkatraman does offer some useful tips on how incumbents might go about formulating an initial response to digital shifts around them - establishing a "sense-making unit" in centres of digital innovation, designing "frame-storming" workshops to dig into problems and challenge assumptions, ask fundamental questions and through this, spark creativity, designing tactical experiments to examine the business impacts of technologies. And I found chapter 8 on thinking about how digital technologies like AI could augment processes (e.g. Narrative Science's Quill, IBM Watson and Wipro's Holmes) and amplify jobs, not just automate existing tasks, thought provoking.
Chapt 10, which lays out the "Rules Matrix" for going about the digital transformation journey, also provides some food for thought (though it requires you to sift for the gems buried in the 33 pages). The 9 rules are basically issues to analyse when assessing your current position and where you might want to be (to guide your thinking on what you need to do next). (a) select one or more ecosystems that can help you learn to craft your digital transformation journey, like how GE focussed on FB because "it wanted to become a 'platform and applications company' or industrial machines and systems", or how IBM focussed on the blockchain and its role in enhancing security, building trust whilst protecting privacy. (b) explore capability co-creation options. (c) examine the intersection of human talent and power. (d) engage (other players in) ecosystems as transformational triggers. (e) navigate your preferential partnerships. (f) augment smart humans with powerful machines. (g) design your new digital ecosystems. (h) co-create new business capabilities with preferred partners. (i) differentiate with computer capital and human capital working together.