What do you think?
Rate this book
Gilded Age Mystery #2
Lies That Comfort and Betray
For fans of HBO’s The Gilded Age, explore the dark side of the alluring world of America’s 19th century elite in this gripping series of riveting mysteries…
Heiress Prudence MacKenzie is a valuable partner to attorney Geoffrey Hunter, despite the fact that women are not admitted to the bar in New York’s Gilded Age. And though their office is a comfortable distance from the violence that haunts the city’s slums, the firm of Hunter and MacKenzie is about to come dangerously close to an unstoppable killer . . .
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY
The murders in Whitechapel are shocking enough to make news worldwide, and in the autumn of 1888, Geoffrey and Prudence find the stories in the New York Herald quite unsettling. But London is not the only city to be terrorized by a mad butcher.
Nora Kenny makes the occasional journey on the Staten Island ferry to work in Prudence’s Fifth Avenue house, just as her mother once served Prudence’s mother. As little girls, they played freely together, before retreating into their respective social classes. Still, they remain fond of each other. But when Nora slips away to Saint Anselm’s one chilly Saturday to confess her sins and never returns, Prudence is alarmed. And when Nora’s body is discovered in a local park, Prudence is devastated.
Nora will not be the only young woman to fall victim, but the police are uncertain what they are dealing with. Has the Ripper sailed across the Atlantic to find a new hunting ground? Is some disturbed soul copying his crimes? A former Pinkerton agent, Geoffrey intends to step in where the New York Metropolitan Police seem to be failing, and Prudence is just as determined to protect the poor, vulnerable females being targeted. But a killer with a disordered mind and an incomprehensible motive may prove too elusive for even this experienced pair to outwit.
From the author of What the Dead Leave Behind, this is a suspenseful and richly atmospheric mystery that captures both the elegance and sophistication of nineteenth-century New York, and the secrets and bloody terrors that lurked behind its gilded facades.
Heiress Prudence MacKenzie is a valuable partner to attorney Geoffrey Hunter, despite the fact that women are not admitted to the bar in New York’s Gilded Age. And though their office is a comfortable distance from the violence that haunts the city’s slums, the firm of Hunter and MacKenzie is about to come dangerously close to an unstoppable killer . . .
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY
The murders in Whitechapel are shocking enough to make news worldwide, and in the autumn of 1888, Geoffrey and Prudence find the stories in the New York Herald quite unsettling. But London is not the only city to be terrorized by a mad butcher.
Nora Kenny makes the occasional journey on the Staten Island ferry to work in Prudence’s Fifth Avenue house, just as her mother once served Prudence’s mother. As little girls, they played freely together, before retreating into their respective social classes. Still, they remain fond of each other. But when Nora slips away to Saint Anselm’s one chilly Saturday to confess her sins and never returns, Prudence is alarmed. And when Nora’s body is discovered in a local park, Prudence is devastated.
Nora will not be the only young woman to fall victim, but the police are uncertain what they are dealing with. Has the Ripper sailed across the Atlantic to find a new hunting ground? Is some disturbed soul copying his crimes? A former Pinkerton agent, Geoffrey intends to step in where the New York Metropolitan Police seem to be failing, and Prudence is just as determined to protect the poor, vulnerable females being targeted. But a killer with a disordered mind and an incomprehensible motive may prove too elusive for even this experienced pair to outwit.
From the author of What the Dead Leave Behind, this is a suspenseful and richly atmospheric mystery that captures both the elegance and sophistication of nineteenth-century New York, and the secrets and bloody terrors that lurked behind its gilded facades.
401 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 30, 2018
232 people are currently reading
875 people want to read
About the author
Rosemary Simpson
17 books385 followersRosemary Simpson's What the Dead Leave Behind is set in Gilded Age New York where the Great Blizzard of 1888 brings both disaster and independence to her wealthy and unconventional heroine. Lies that Comfort and Betray is the second in the Gilded Age Mystery series, to be followed by Let the Dead Keep Their Secrets
Rosemary is also the author of two stand-alone historical novels, The Seven Hills of Paradise and Dreams and Shadows.
She is a member of Sisters in Crime, International Thriller Writers, and the Historical Novel Society. Educated in France and the United States, she now lives near Tucson, Arizona.
Rosemary is also the author of two stand-alone historical novels, The Seven Hills of Paradise and Dreams and Shadows.
She is a member of Sisters in Crime, International Thriller Writers, and the Historical Novel Society. Educated in France and the United States, she now lives near Tucson, Arizona.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 187 reviews
May 7, 2018
Lies That Comfort and Betray by Rosemary Simpson is a 2018 Kensington publication.
The first book in this new series set a solid foundation to be built upon. But, did the second book take advantage of that momentum?
Yes! Yes, it did-
This is an excellent follow up to ‘What the Dead Leave Behind’. With Jack the Ripper terrorizing London, New York finds it is not immune to the same depravity. When Nora Kenny, a young woman who works for Prudence, is brutally murdered, the prospect of JTR having crossed the pond is not a pleasant one, nor is the idea that New York is dealing with a copycat killer. But, the police immediately arrest Nora’s fiancé, a man Prudence is sure is innocent. With the help of Geoffrey, the law firm of Hunter and MacKenzie begin a harrowing murder investigation, hoping to discover the real killer before he strikes again.
This installment deals with a host of feminine related double standards prevalent in the gilded age. The dangers of back alley abortions, the stigma of premarital sex, and pregnancy out of wedlock are all explored, as well as a little tippy toeing around religion and a few blatant hypocrisies. Prudence still battles her own demons, but they do not take center stage, this time around. Instead, Prudence channels her energy and thoughts into her work.
Prudence and Geoffrey make a terrific team and I was happy to see the way their characters are developing. But, at the end of the day, the real test is how challenging the mystery was for me and if it kept my attention, if it was suspenseful, atmospheric, and if it kept me guessing. I’m happy to report that this novel passed the test in all categories!
While this is a part of a series, it can still be read as a stand alone- however, to get Prudence’s full background, and how she came to be partnered with Geoffrey, reading the first installment will certainly enhance your enjoyment of this second one.
Overall, I am a very happy customer and am eagerly awaiting the third book in this promising series.
The first book in this new series set a solid foundation to be built upon. But, did the second book take advantage of that momentum?
Yes! Yes, it did-
This is an excellent follow up to ‘What the Dead Leave Behind’. With Jack the Ripper terrorizing London, New York finds it is not immune to the same depravity. When Nora Kenny, a young woman who works for Prudence, is brutally murdered, the prospect of JTR having crossed the pond is not a pleasant one, nor is the idea that New York is dealing with a copycat killer. But, the police immediately arrest Nora’s fiancé, a man Prudence is sure is innocent. With the help of Geoffrey, the law firm of Hunter and MacKenzie begin a harrowing murder investigation, hoping to discover the real killer before he strikes again.
This installment deals with a host of feminine related double standards prevalent in the gilded age. The dangers of back alley abortions, the stigma of premarital sex, and pregnancy out of wedlock are all explored, as well as a little tippy toeing around religion and a few blatant hypocrisies. Prudence still battles her own demons, but they do not take center stage, this time around. Instead, Prudence channels her energy and thoughts into her work.
Prudence and Geoffrey make a terrific team and I was happy to see the way their characters are developing. But, at the end of the day, the real test is how challenging the mystery was for me and if it kept my attention, if it was suspenseful, atmospheric, and if it kept me guessing. I’m happy to report that this novel passed the test in all categories!
While this is a part of a series, it can still be read as a stand alone- however, to get Prudence’s full background, and how she came to be partnered with Geoffrey, reading the first installment will certainly enhance your enjoyment of this second one.
Overall, I am a very happy customer and am eagerly awaiting the third book in this promising series.
December 31, 2017
Human wreakage.
Individuals who bear the scars of life so evident on the outside, and more's the pity, those who keep the wounds buried in personal tombs of the soul.
November of 1888 brings with it unstable times on the streets of New York City. London's Whitechapel murders seem to have gained a foothold here amongst the tall buildings and stately mansions. Has Jack the Ripper ventured on a cruise across the Atlantic? So it seems......
Nora Kenny's body has been found in Colonial Park wrapped in a tarp. The young maid's dark curls and flawless face resemble that of an angel, but the rest of her has been ravaged by someone unworldly. Her family is devastated. The police, wishing to close the case quickly amidst public outcry, arrest Nora's fiance, Tim Fahey. Tim is locked in The Tombs notorious for its torturous tactics. Many a man has confessed to crimes under extremely excruciating duress.
The Kenny family contact Prudence MacKenzie who has recently set up an investigative firm with her partner, Geoffrey Hunter. Hunter is an ex-Pinkerton investigator with a law degree and Southern roots. Prudence studied law under the fine guidance of her now deceased father, Judge MacKenzie. Highly intelligent with fine-tuned analytical skills, Prudence faces the reality that no woman has been admitted to the Bar in New York City. Time and patience may serve her well.
When another body is found in almost the same circumstances as Nora Kenny's, Hunter and Prudence sift through what little clues and evidence they have. Both girls were Irish immigrants, maids, unmarried, and frequented St. Anselm's church in the neighborhood. Who could have preyed upon them, intentionally or not? And why? But when the third victim is a prostitute, both investigators are perplexed.
This is the second book in the Gilded Age Mystery series. It certainly can be read as a standalone with the author injecting just enough backstory so as to not give away the key pinpoints of the first. Rosemary Simpson creates a strong, self-sufficient female character in Prudence. With an unusual twist, our Prudence must overcome a dependence upon the addictive tincture of laudanum given to her in her daily tea by a nefarious individual in the first book. She functions well, but the little brown bottle is like a plague in her life.
Simpson has quite the talent in her character development as you'll find out throughout this entertaining read. The plot threads will criss-cross towards the end with surely the wonderment of who, exactly, is guilty and who is not? I'm looking forward to the third installment from the very talented Rosemary Simpson.
I received a copy of this book through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Kensington Publishers and to Rosemary Simpson for the opportunity.
Individuals who bear the scars of life so evident on the outside, and more's the pity, those who keep the wounds buried in personal tombs of the soul.
November of 1888 brings with it unstable times on the streets of New York City. London's Whitechapel murders seem to have gained a foothold here amongst the tall buildings and stately mansions. Has Jack the Ripper ventured on a cruise across the Atlantic? So it seems......
Nora Kenny's body has been found in Colonial Park wrapped in a tarp. The young maid's dark curls and flawless face resemble that of an angel, but the rest of her has been ravaged by someone unworldly. Her family is devastated. The police, wishing to close the case quickly amidst public outcry, arrest Nora's fiance, Tim Fahey. Tim is locked in The Tombs notorious for its torturous tactics. Many a man has confessed to crimes under extremely excruciating duress.
The Kenny family contact Prudence MacKenzie who has recently set up an investigative firm with her partner, Geoffrey Hunter. Hunter is an ex-Pinkerton investigator with a law degree and Southern roots. Prudence studied law under the fine guidance of her now deceased father, Judge MacKenzie. Highly intelligent with fine-tuned analytical skills, Prudence faces the reality that no woman has been admitted to the Bar in New York City. Time and patience may serve her well.
When another body is found in almost the same circumstances as Nora Kenny's, Hunter and Prudence sift through what little clues and evidence they have. Both girls were Irish immigrants, maids, unmarried, and frequented St. Anselm's church in the neighborhood. Who could have preyed upon them, intentionally or not? And why? But when the third victim is a prostitute, both investigators are perplexed.
This is the second book in the Gilded Age Mystery series. It certainly can be read as a standalone with the author injecting just enough backstory so as to not give away the key pinpoints of the first. Rosemary Simpson creates a strong, self-sufficient female character in Prudence. With an unusual twist, our Prudence must overcome a dependence upon the addictive tincture of laudanum given to her in her daily tea by a nefarious individual in the first book. She functions well, but the little brown bottle is like a plague in her life.
Simpson has quite the talent in her character development as you'll find out throughout this entertaining read. The plot threads will criss-cross towards the end with surely the wonderment of who, exactly, is guilty and who is not? I'm looking forward to the third installment from the very talented Rosemary Simpson.
I received a copy of this book through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Kensington Publishers and to Rosemary Simpson for the opportunity.
April 8, 2024
Second book in the series— will admit I’ve read two in less than six weeks. Book two didn’t disappoint, and the darkness and depravity of poverty and evil is more evident in this installment.
Our regular heroes and heroine are joined by a few new cast members including the unforgettable Kevin and his oversized mangy dog, Blossom. She single-handedly earned this book the 4th star. (Simpson has a knack for populating her series with some really interesting characters who the world may overlook.)
If you love a “Jack the Ripper” style murder mystery, then you’ll definitely enjoy this one. Fairly gruesome but thankfully the murders aren’t described in real time. Descriptions are mild and are often more clinical.
As with her first book, there are many red herrings. I probably changed my mind about the villain several times. (Actually, I will admit there were so many sharp turns that I felt dizzy with all the literary fake outs.)
But with Blossom on your side, there is no escape… and several characters meet interesting ends… but if I say more, I’ll break my cardinal rule about spoilers.
I wasn’t keen on the ending, yet it didn’t stop me from rushing to borrow book 3 in the series. I’m looking forward to see what the author has in store for Prudence and company next.
Our regular heroes and heroine are joined by a few new cast members including the unforgettable Kevin and his oversized mangy dog, Blossom. She single-handedly earned this book the 4th star. (Simpson has a knack for populating her series with some really interesting characters who the world may overlook.)
If you love a “Jack the Ripper” style murder mystery, then you’ll definitely enjoy this one. Fairly gruesome but thankfully the murders aren’t described in real time. Descriptions are mild and are often more clinical.
As with her first book, there are many red herrings. I probably changed my mind about the villain several times. (Actually, I will admit there were so many sharp turns that I felt dizzy with all the literary fake outs.)
But with Blossom on your side, there is no escape… and several characters meet interesting ends… but if I say more, I’ll break my cardinal rule about spoilers.
I wasn’t keen on the ending, yet it didn’t stop me from rushing to borrow book 3 in the series. I’m looking forward to see what the author has in store for Prudence and company next.
October 23, 2023
This is a very dark and gritty series about a Jack the Ripper style killer. I really enjoy the authors style of writing. The side characters (including and maybe especially Blossom the dog) add a lot to the story. What I don't enjoy is that I feel there are a lot of loose ends. The ending does not satisfy the many questions I have. Reading books about this time in history where women are demanding opportunities be opened to them but are very limited in choices makes me grateful to be alive now. The book deals with murder, abortion, church and police misconduct. Due to the loose ends, I rate it 3.5*
January 26, 2018
Lies that Comfort and Betray by Rosemary Simpson is the second book in A Gilded Age Mystery series. It is November of 1888 and Jack the Ripper is terrorizing London with his savage butchery. Prudence MacKenzie is a partner in the private inquiry firm of Hunter and MacKenzie with Geoffrey Hunter in New York. Prudence is distressed when her childhood friend, Nora Kenny is ruthlessly murdered and left dead in Colonial Park. The manner in which Nora was killed mimics the Ripper’s. She had been expected at the MacKenzie home on Fifth Avenue to help prepare for the holidays. Where did she go after getting off the ferry from Staten Island? Then Nora’s fiancé is arrested for the crime and the police make him disappear. Prudence, Geoffrey and their well-connected assistant, Josiah Gregory start investigating by looking into Nora’s movements the day she died. They soon discover that Nora had secrets she was keeping from her family and friends. Then Ellen Tierney turns up dead in the same manner as Nora. Soon another woman is dead. There is a murderer loose in New York and the police just want to sweep the deaths under the rug. What connects the victims? Prudence and her associates intend to find out and put the killer behind bars.
I thought that Lies that Comfort and Betray would be a historical cozy mystery. I quickly found out that Lies that Comfort and Betray is a dark and graphic novel. Readers are given detailed descriptions of the mutilation done to the bodies as well as graphic sex scenes (one person has a strange religious fetish described in detail). There is also foul language in the story. At the beginning, my attention was captured. After a while, though, my mind started to wander (I was bored). I thought the author was wordy and overly detailed (do we need to know what the church smells like for example). We are given the minutest of details. This led to a slow pace that lasted throughout the whole book. We are also given details on what every character is thinking and feeling (including the dog). I liked Prudence MacKenzie. I thought she was well-crafted and developed. She is a strong, intelligent female doing an unusual occupation (studied law with her father). She is also struggling to overcome her addiction to laudanum. It is a shame that women were not admitted to the New York State Bar at that time. I also liked the character of Josiah Gregory. The mystery is one, for the most part, that plays out (which I find frustrating). The killer is not introduced until the halfway mark and we are given one miniscule clue. Otherwise, we are not given the details needed until right before the reveal (which is drawn out). The ending does wrap up all the storylines. I did appreciate the mention of Jo’s Boys in the story (Prudence was reading it). While Lies that Comfort and Betray is the second book in A Gilded Age Mystery series, it can be read alone. The author includes a summary of what occurred in the first book as well as background on the main characters. With a different writing style this could have been an interesting novel (had potential).
I thought that Lies that Comfort and Betray would be a historical cozy mystery. I quickly found out that Lies that Comfort and Betray is a dark and graphic novel. Readers are given detailed descriptions of the mutilation done to the bodies as well as graphic sex scenes (one person has a strange religious fetish described in detail). There is also foul language in the story. At the beginning, my attention was captured. After a while, though, my mind started to wander (I was bored). I thought the author was wordy and overly detailed (do we need to know what the church smells like for example). We are given the minutest of details. This led to a slow pace that lasted throughout the whole book. We are also given details on what every character is thinking and feeling (including the dog). I liked Prudence MacKenzie. I thought she was well-crafted and developed. She is a strong, intelligent female doing an unusual occupation (studied law with her father). She is also struggling to overcome her addiction to laudanum. It is a shame that women were not admitted to the New York State Bar at that time. I also liked the character of Josiah Gregory. The mystery is one, for the most part, that plays out (which I find frustrating). The killer is not introduced until the halfway mark and we are given one miniscule clue. Otherwise, we are not given the details needed until right before the reveal (which is drawn out). The ending does wrap up all the storylines. I did appreciate the mention of Jo’s Boys in the story (Prudence was reading it). While Lies that Comfort and Betray is the second book in A Gilded Age Mystery series, it can be read alone. The author includes a summary of what occurred in the first book as well as background on the main characters. With a different writing style this could have been an interesting novel (had potential).
August 1, 2020
Lies That Comfort and Betray by Rosemary Simpson is a gritty historical thriller that clearly shows the disparity in New York City in 1888 as the city is wrapped in political and police corruption and the extreme living conditions between the wealthy and the poor. Has Jack the Ripper crossed the Atlantic or is it another depraved mind? Prudence and Geoffrey are on the hunt for answers when one victim strikes too close to home for Prudence.
January 19, 2024
If you like your mysteries to be complicated, this series is for you. If you enjoy large casts and seemingly disparate threads slowly coming together, this is for you. If you don’t mind some grit to your gilded age mystery, it’s also for you. Lastly, if you delight in animal POVs, you will love this, especially Blossom, the fierce and loyal dog.
I had no idea where we were going and I loved it. I also enjoyed the brutally honest portrayal of the Church, Irish-Americans, and the NYC police.
I had no idea where we were going and I loved it. I also enjoyed the brutally honest portrayal of the Church, Irish-Americans, and the NYC police.
May 29, 2018
I am confused. I have lots of questions re: this book which involve LOTS of spoilers, so you have been warned.
1) So what exactly did Joseph Nolan do to deserve to die? (besides that he was a twisted human being) Did he play any part in the murders at all?
2) Did Father Brennan play any part in the murders at all? What exactly was he involved in (since it wasn't the murders)? Why did the housekeeper see Father Brennan in the cellar when he shouldn't have been there? Why didn't she see Slattery if Slattery was the killer?
3) How did Neil Slattery get involved in the murders? Was there any relationship b/t him and St Anselm's besides geographic proximity? Did he have a key? (how did he get into the locked church, crypt, cellar, etc)
4) How did Slattery know his way around Sally Lynn's room? How did he get in/out of the house? How was he familiar with the properties for the other dead girls?
5) What was the point of the momentous decision of bringing in the reporter if nothing ever came of it? Why was the reporter on the cusp of the biggest case of his career but didn't follow up on anything? That feels like a pointless lost thread.
What I didn't care for:
1) Speaking of loose threads - Tim Fahey and Mick McGuire are suspected of murder and subject to baseless arrest and extreme torture, but they become no more than a brief footnote at the end. Literally one sentence and then they're done,
2) The ending felt super rushed. No explanation/wrap-up of how everything happened. If it had always been Neil, how did he track down his victims? How did he know where they lived/when they were coming to St Anselms/how to plan out the murder? (see #3 above)
3) There were too many red herrings that panned out to nothing. Yes, red herrings are essential to mysteries, but in this case, it was like, it was HIM! No, it was HIM! No, it was HIM! Actually, it was none of them, it was this other guy who you didn't see in the book at all until it was time to pick a murderer.
4) There were too many spoilers from book 1. I didn't read book 1 but even if I wanted to, I wouldn't now.
5) I didn't care for the setup of the mystery. For each victim, we learn her backstory, get to know her and her hopes and dreams, then see her get to die a horrible death. It was sad and, I thought, unnecessary. We could have gotten to know them through the investigation after the murder. I would have preferred not to have them be personalized and be inside their minds before they get murdered, though I guess that's a matter of personal preference.
6) The book was quite dark and gory - it contained a lot of graphic violence, descriptions of abortions, etc. I thought the synopsis that led me to want to read this book didn't give enough warning of its graphic nature. I would never have read it if I thought it was going to be a twisted American Jack the Ripper story.
7) I liked and disliked the Blossom POV. I liked it because Blossom was awesome and crucial to the story. I didn't like it though because it was so unrealistic to make Blossom the narrator. In the end, it didn't work for me.
Ultimately - maybe I just didn't get this book, but for me, it was super dark and left too many unanswered questions.
Thanks to the publisher for providing an ARC via netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
1) So what exactly did Joseph Nolan do to deserve to die? (besides that he was a twisted human being) Did he play any part in the murders at all?
2) Did Father Brennan play any part in the murders at all? What exactly was he involved in (since it wasn't the murders)? Why did the housekeeper see Father Brennan in the cellar when he shouldn't have been there? Why didn't she see Slattery if Slattery was the killer?
3) How did Neil Slattery get involved in the murders? Was there any relationship b/t him and St Anselm's besides geographic proximity? Did he have a key? (how did he get into the locked church, crypt, cellar, etc)
4) How did Slattery know his way around Sally Lynn's room? How did he get in/out of the house? How was he familiar with the properties for the other dead girls?
5) What was the point of the momentous decision of bringing in the reporter if nothing ever came of it? Why was the reporter on the cusp of the biggest case of his career but didn't follow up on anything? That feels like a pointless lost thread.
What I didn't care for:
1) Speaking of loose threads - Tim Fahey and Mick McGuire are suspected of murder and subject to baseless arrest and extreme torture, but they become no more than a brief footnote at the end. Literally one sentence and then they're done,
2) The ending felt super rushed. No explanation/wrap-up of how everything happened. If it had always been Neil, how did he track down his victims? How did he know where they lived/when they were coming to St Anselms/how to plan out the murder? (see #3 above)
3) There were too many red herrings that panned out to nothing. Yes, red herrings are essential to mysteries, but in this case, it was like, it was HIM! No, it was HIM! No, it was HIM! Actually, it was none of them, it was this other guy who you didn't see in the book at all until it was time to pick a murderer.
4) There were too many spoilers from book 1. I didn't read book 1 but even if I wanted to, I wouldn't now.
5) I didn't care for the setup of the mystery. For each victim, we learn her backstory, get to know her and her hopes and dreams, then see her get to die a horrible death. It was sad and, I thought, unnecessary. We could have gotten to know them through the investigation after the murder. I would have preferred not to have them be personalized and be inside their minds before they get murdered, though I guess that's a matter of personal preference.
6) The book was quite dark and gory - it contained a lot of graphic violence, descriptions of abortions, etc. I thought the synopsis that led me to want to read this book didn't give enough warning of its graphic nature. I would never have read it if I thought it was going to be a twisted American Jack the Ripper story.
7) I liked and disliked the Blossom POV. I liked it because Blossom was awesome and crucial to the story. I didn't like it though because it was so unrealistic to make Blossom the narrator. In the end, it didn't work for me.
Ultimately - maybe I just didn't get this book, but for me, it was super dark and left too many unanswered questions.
Thanks to the publisher for providing an ARC via netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
January 15, 2018
In 1888 Jack Ripper's activities London, England are making headlines in New York City. In the second book of the Gilded Age Mysteries, Heiress Prudence MacKenzie is now a partner in a new investigative agency. Geoffrey Hunter, her partner is an attorney and ex-Pinkerton detective. One of Prudence's maids whose family has worked for the MacKenzie family is found murder in a grizzly death that copies the Ripper's work. In the effort to prevent headlines in the newspapers, the police arrest her fiancee and he disappears in the tombs. The case becomes a priority for the firm. More similar murders occur and The police continue to hide The evidence of The deaths. The enter the dark underbelly of New York to investigate. The story will twist throughout this dark area in order to find an answer to the murders and prove the men arrested for the murders are innocent. The ending will surprise you. There are sex and violence that may not be suitable for everyone. I recommend this as a good view of New York City in that time.
Disclosure: I received a free copy from Kennington Books through NetGalley for an honest review. I would like to thank them for this opportunity to read and review the book. The opinions expressed are my own.
Disclosure: I received a free copy from Kennington Books through NetGalley for an honest review. I would like to thank them for this opportunity to read and review the book. The opinions expressed are my own.
March 4, 2018
This is a suspenseful and richly atmospheric mystery taking place in nineteenth-century New York. A Jack The Ripper style book. The women that are murdered are done savagely. In November 1888 has Jack The Ripper sailed from England and now has a new killing spot, is there a copy cat killer, or simply someone deranged ? Prudence MacKenzie is a valuable partner to attorney Geoffrey Hunter despite this being the Golden Age. Devastated when her childhood friend Nora is murdered after an early Saturday morning confession at Saint Anselm’s she knows something must be done. When police move too slowly on this case former Pinkerton agent, Geoffrey intends to step in and Prudence is right beside him all the way. Fast paced mystery and action that kept me reading late into the night!
Pub Date 30 Jan 2018
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for a review copy. I was not required to write a positive review.
Pub Date 30 Jan 2018
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for a review copy. I was not required to write a positive review.
January 29, 2018
The Ripper murders in Whitechapel are shocking enough to make news worldwide, and in the autumn of 1888, Geoffrey and Prudence find the stories in the New York Herald quite unsettling. But London is not the only city to be terrorized by a mad butcher.
3.5 stars. What the Dead Leave Behind was the mystery I enjoyed reading the most last year, so needless to say, I was really looking forward to reading this sequel. I'll start by saying that I liked this one a lot, but not as much as I liked What the Dead Leave Behind. In that book the murder happened during the Great Blizzard of 1888 and I really found the setting interesting. This time around we have the murder happening at around the same time as the Jack the Ripper murders are taking place over in London. I was a bit disappointed in this because I feel like the Jack the Ripper thing has been done to death. This seems to be very loosely based on events that occurred in New York at a later date and features a police detective who was actually a real person.
For most of the book I thought I knew who the killer probably was, but also thought that the solution was too easy. The book did end up keeping me guessing for a while as eventually there ended up being three different good suspects. Besides the ripper part, this book dealt with some some heavy issues including abortionists, sexual deviancy, and prostitution. This resulted in the book feeling quite a bit darker than the first book in the series.
I enjoyed revisiting the characters Prudence and Geoffrey, and also liked the addition of the new character Kevin and his dog Blossom, although I did feel like they stole the show a little. I had a big problem with the way Blossom was portrayed. The dog came off as way too human and it wasn't realistic in a book like this that is set in the real world. I also would have liked for a little more development in the personal lives of Prudence and Geoffrey, but I can see that that is being set up as a slow burn with the focus mainly on the mystery, which is fine since this is a mystery series. I just kind of missed them a little here because we didn't spend as much time with their perspectives.
Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington Books for giving me a copy of this book for review.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
3.5 stars. What the Dead Leave Behind was the mystery I enjoyed reading the most last year, so needless to say, I was really looking forward to reading this sequel. I'll start by saying that I liked this one a lot, but not as much as I liked What the Dead Leave Behind. In that book the murder happened during the Great Blizzard of 1888 and I really found the setting interesting. This time around we have the murder happening at around the same time as the Jack the Ripper murders are taking place over in London. I was a bit disappointed in this because I feel like the Jack the Ripper thing has been done to death. This seems to be very loosely based on events that occurred in New York at a later date and features a police detective who was actually a real person.
For most of the book I thought I knew who the killer probably was, but also thought that the solution was too easy. The book did end up keeping me guessing for a while as eventually there ended up being three different good suspects. Besides the ripper part, this book dealt with some some heavy issues including abortionists, sexual deviancy, and prostitution. This resulted in the book feeling quite a bit darker than the first book in the series.
I enjoyed revisiting the characters Prudence and Geoffrey, and also liked the addition of the new character Kevin and his dog Blossom, although I did feel like they stole the show a little. I had a big problem with the way Blossom was portrayed. The dog came off as way too human and it wasn't realistic in a book like this that is set in the real world. I also would have liked for a little more development in the personal lives of Prudence and Geoffrey, but I can see that that is being set up as a slow burn with the focus mainly on the mystery, which is fine since this is a mystery series. I just kind of missed them a little here because we didn't spend as much time with their perspectives.
Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington Books for giving me a copy of this book for review.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
July 11, 2018
"Even so, I've learned to prefer the starkest of truths to the most comforting of lies.
I really felt this had the potential to be a amazing series and the second installment did not disappoint! The societal struggles and the political/police police corruption of the time period is excellently portrayed. While it is gruesome at times, it keeps true to the storyline and time period. I adored Prudence and the potential slow burning relationship between Geoffrey was the best torture.
I cannot wait for the next installment. This is one I'd highly recommend to my historical/mystery buddies.
I really felt this had the potential to be a amazing series and the second installment did not disappoint! The societal struggles and the political/police police corruption of the time period is excellently portrayed. While it is gruesome at times, it keeps true to the storyline and time period. I adored Prudence and the potential slow burning relationship between Geoffrey was the best torture.
I cannot wait for the next installment. This is one I'd highly recommend to my historical/mystery buddies.
February 9, 2023
This is the 2nd book in A Gilded Age Mystery series. A Jack the Ripper copycat is loose in New York and New York's finest are looking to solve each crime quickly, arresting boyfriends of the victims while trying to keep the crimes out of the papers. Our intrepid sleuths, Prudence and Geoffrey are on the case due to a connection to the first victim. The perpetrator could be any one of several people, the priest, the tailor, the butcher's son, the custodian. Helping to solve the mystery are some old friends as well as a few new ones, notably a homeless man and his amazing dog (really, the dog is terrific). Good read and I'm looking forward to the next in the series, hopefully with the wonderful Blossom.
August 17, 2020
Not awful but certainly not up to the quality of the debut story of this series. Perhaps my expectations were too high after the excellent introduction to the world of Prudence MacKenzie and Geoffrey Hunter but Lies that Comfort and Betray disappointedly did not showcase these two interesting and intelligent protagonists to the degree they deserved even in the midst of a clearly compelling, horrifying and intriguing set of crimes. I felt throughout that both Geoffrey and Prudence took backseats in this mystery as others took the driver’s seat in unearthing the murderer and solving his horrific crimes. I struggled with the heavy focus on Kevin (a homeless informant of the gangster McGlory) and his dog Blossom and struggled even more with the author placing themselves in Blossom’ Point of View for so many important aspects of the investigation. For all her newfound independence, Prudence only succeeds in getting herself in trouble time and requiring she be rescued by someone and Geoffrey seems to spend all his time chatting about who committed the crime with ex-cop Ned Hayes rather than taking any role in actively solving it. I will still read Book3 of the series as I’m not that turned off and hope that it will be more up to the.standard of the first.
January 22, 2020
This second installment in Rosemary Simpson's, "A Gilded Age Mystery" series is a wonderful continuation of the story set up in book one, "What the Dead Leave Behind". Ms. Simpson spins a wonderful yarn of mystery around three murders. She beautifully captures the atmosphere of a bustling New York City of 1888 as the colder weather sets in in early November. Her descriptive prose draws upon all of the reader's senses - whether it's the reek of spoiling fish or of a grubby homeless boy and his flea-infested dog; the greasy feel of fried potatoes served in a discarded page from a newspaper; the sounds of horse hooves clip-clopping on the cobblestone streets as handsome cabs drift by; the striking visuals of beautifully clad women or the horribly disfigured pummeled faces of men. The historic references are rich and well researched. The red herrings are many and the tension holds throughout the story which ultimately comes to a satisfying conclusion. I look forward to reading more books in this series.
June 1, 2024
This one was much darker than the first
April 13, 2020
A page turning riveting read!
December 17, 2017
I received an ARC copy from netgalley for my honest review, so thank you netgalley and publishers for offering me this book! ♡
This is a story is about Heiress Prudence MacKenzie is a valuable partner to attorney Geoffrey Hunter, despite the fact that women are not admitted to the bar in New York’s Gilded Age. And though their office is a comfortable distance from the violence that haunts the city’s slums, the firm of Hunter and MacKenzie is about to come dangerously close to an unstoppable killer . . .
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY
The murders in Whitechapel are shocking enough to make news worldwide, and in the autumn of 1888, Geoffrey and Prudence find the stories in the New York Herald quite unsettling. But London is not the only city to be terrorized by a mad butcher.
Nora Kenny makes the occasional journey on the Staten Island ferry to work in Prudence’s Fifth Avenue house, just as her mother once served Prudence’s mother. As little girls, they played freely together, before retreating into their respective social classes. Still, they remain fond of each other. But when Nora slips away to Saint Anselm’s one chilly Saturday to confess her sins and never returns, Prudence is alarmed. And when Nora’s body is discovered in a local park, Prudence is devastated.
Nora will not be the only young woman to fall victim, but the police are uncertain what they are dealing with. Has the Ripper sailed across the Atlantic to find a new hunting ground? Is some disturbed soul copying his crimes? A former Pinkerton agent, Geoffrey intends to step in where the New York Metropolitan Police seem to be failing, and Prudence is just as determined to protect the poor, vulnerable females being targeted. But a killer with a disordered mind and an incomprehensible motive may prove too elusive for even this experienced pair to outwit.
From the author of What the Dead Leave Behind, this is a suspenseful and richly atmospheric mystery that captures both the elegance and sophistication of nineteenth-century New York, and the secrets and bloody terrors that lurked behind its gilded facades.
“Simpson's debut, first in a planned series, features complex characters, a vivid look at old New York in the late 1800s, and a mystery with a twist.” —Kirkus Reviews
“Launching an atmospheric new series set in Gilded Age New York, Simpson incorporates historical events and figures to add verisimilitude to this tension-filled story. For mystery readers who appreciate period detail, including fans of Anne Perry’s Thomas and Charlotte Pitt mysteries.” —Library Journal
This was my first book by this author, and I absolutely enjoyed every second of it. It was fast paced and just alltogether an easy read. I give this book a 4 star rating!
This is a story is about Heiress Prudence MacKenzie is a valuable partner to attorney Geoffrey Hunter, despite the fact that women are not admitted to the bar in New York’s Gilded Age. And though their office is a comfortable distance from the violence that haunts the city’s slums, the firm of Hunter and MacKenzie is about to come dangerously close to an unstoppable killer . . .
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY
The murders in Whitechapel are shocking enough to make news worldwide, and in the autumn of 1888, Geoffrey and Prudence find the stories in the New York Herald quite unsettling. But London is not the only city to be terrorized by a mad butcher.
Nora Kenny makes the occasional journey on the Staten Island ferry to work in Prudence’s Fifth Avenue house, just as her mother once served Prudence’s mother. As little girls, they played freely together, before retreating into their respective social classes. Still, they remain fond of each other. But when Nora slips away to Saint Anselm’s one chilly Saturday to confess her sins and never returns, Prudence is alarmed. And when Nora’s body is discovered in a local park, Prudence is devastated.
Nora will not be the only young woman to fall victim, but the police are uncertain what they are dealing with. Has the Ripper sailed across the Atlantic to find a new hunting ground? Is some disturbed soul copying his crimes? A former Pinkerton agent, Geoffrey intends to step in where the New York Metropolitan Police seem to be failing, and Prudence is just as determined to protect the poor, vulnerable females being targeted. But a killer with a disordered mind and an incomprehensible motive may prove too elusive for even this experienced pair to outwit.
From the author of What the Dead Leave Behind, this is a suspenseful and richly atmospheric mystery that captures both the elegance and sophistication of nineteenth-century New York, and the secrets and bloody terrors that lurked behind its gilded facades.
“Simpson's debut, first in a planned series, features complex characters, a vivid look at old New York in the late 1800s, and a mystery with a twist.” —Kirkus Reviews
“Launching an atmospheric new series set in Gilded Age New York, Simpson incorporates historical events and figures to add verisimilitude to this tension-filled story. For mystery readers who appreciate period detail, including fans of Anne Perry’s Thomas and Charlotte Pitt mysteries.” —Library Journal
This was my first book by this author, and I absolutely enjoyed every second of it. It was fast paced and just alltogether an easy read. I give this book a 4 star rating!
January 14, 2018
Lies That Comfort And Betray is the second book in the A Gilded Age Mystery series.
This is another historical mystery series that I really enjoy reading and this is a fantastic follow-up to the first book, What The Dead Leave Behind.
Prudence MacKenzie, whose late father was a famed jurist in New York City, and Geoffrey Hunter, an ex-Pinkerton agent, have formed a private investigation office.
It’s November 1988 and Jack the Ripper has just killed his seventh victim in London and New York City is desperately hoping that a violent killer will not strike here. Nora Kenny, whose mother once served Prudence’s mother, has come to help at Prudence’s home, but when no one answers the door she decides to head to St. Anselm Church for confession. When she sees someone she doesn’t want talk with she hides in the church and falls asleep. A few hours later her mutilated body is found wrapped in a tarp near the carousel in Colonial Park When the police Detective Phelan finds out that she had decided to not marry Tim Fahey, Phelan immediately arrests Fahey and takes him to The Tomb where he undergoes a horrific third-degree interrogation. Then a second body of another Irish maid is found, also mutilated and wrapped in a tarp. But this body was found near the stables on the Nolan’s property where she worked. When a third body is found, Prudence and Geoffrey are completely confused as this victim was not an Irish maid, but was a prostitute. So they need to rethink their clues and that brings them back to St Anselm Church.
Gefforey contacts his friend, Ned Hayes for help and he calls in some favors from saloon owner, Billy McGlory, who provides one of his informers on the street, homeless Kevin, and his dog Blossom provides some valuable information that will put Prudence and Gefforey on right track.
Ms. Simpson’s books are well written and have an interesting cast of characters. She provides the reader with an exciting story and an insightful look at New York City in the late 1880’s
I will definitely be watching for the next book in this very enjoyable series.
This is another historical mystery series that I really enjoy reading and this is a fantastic follow-up to the first book, What The Dead Leave Behind.
Prudence MacKenzie, whose late father was a famed jurist in New York City, and Geoffrey Hunter, an ex-Pinkerton agent, have formed a private investigation office.
It’s November 1988 and Jack the Ripper has just killed his seventh victim in London and New York City is desperately hoping that a violent killer will not strike here. Nora Kenny, whose mother once served Prudence’s mother, has come to help at Prudence’s home, but when no one answers the door she decides to head to St. Anselm Church for confession. When she sees someone she doesn’t want talk with she hides in the church and falls asleep. A few hours later her mutilated body is found wrapped in a tarp near the carousel in Colonial Park When the police Detective Phelan finds out that she had decided to not marry Tim Fahey, Phelan immediately arrests Fahey and takes him to The Tomb where he undergoes a horrific third-degree interrogation. Then a second body of another Irish maid is found, also mutilated and wrapped in a tarp. But this body was found near the stables on the Nolan’s property where she worked. When a third body is found, Prudence and Geoffrey are completely confused as this victim was not an Irish maid, but was a prostitute. So they need to rethink their clues and that brings them back to St Anselm Church.
Gefforey contacts his friend, Ned Hayes for help and he calls in some favors from saloon owner, Billy McGlory, who provides one of his informers on the street, homeless Kevin, and his dog Blossom provides some valuable information that will put Prudence and Gefforey on right track.
Ms. Simpson’s books are well written and have an interesting cast of characters. She provides the reader with an exciting story and an insightful look at New York City in the late 1880’s
I will definitely be watching for the next book in this very enjoyable series.
May 26, 2018
Despite the four star rating, I have mixed feelings about this book. The description of New York in this era is strong and encompassing, and the mystery wasn't bad, but I still have a feeling that I don't know the main couple -- detectives -- very well. There is a hint that they will become a couple, but there is absolutely no chemistry between them, as if the author really didn't care about them. And the details about the soon to be murdered victims goes on and on, especially since that victim is about to be eliminated from the story. Four times we go through unending life stories of the victims and then those lives are cut off, and what is the point? I would really rather hear about the two main characters. And one of the most effective detectives is, of all things, a dog who is smarter than Lassie and whose brain we also travel around in.
But I'll keep reading because the sense of history is so good.
But I'll keep reading because the sense of history is so good.
July 22, 2022
I am enjoying this series. I really like the characters, especially Prudence, and the author comes up with interesting plots.
I will say the content of the story was particularly intense and a bit depressing, but certainly plausible in the time and place. I won't say more to avoid spoilers.
I loved the setting of New York at the time. There was so much going on then (really, probably still is today) that it offers lots of potential plots.
As I said, I like Prudence as a main character. She has demons to fight and she is strong and determined to best them even when she struggles. For me that makes her a character I can relate to and root for. Her insistence on being an equal partner in the investigative firm she has started with Hunter also makes me like her.
I'm looking forward to reading more books in this series and going on future adventures with Prudence, Geoffrey and Josiah.
I will say the content of the story was particularly intense and a bit depressing, but certainly plausible in the time and place. I won't say more to avoid spoilers.
I loved the setting of New York at the time. There was so much going on then (really, probably still is today) that it offers lots of potential plots.
As I said, I like Prudence as a main character. She has demons to fight and she is strong and determined to best them even when she struggles. For me that makes her a character I can relate to and root for. Her insistence on being an equal partner in the investigative firm she has started with Hunter also makes me like her.
I'm looking forward to reading more books in this series and going on future adventures with Prudence, Geoffrey and Josiah.
August 29, 2022
Page turning! Never read this author before. She is coming out with a book in November that takes place in Niagara Falls and I wanted to read one of her books. This story takes place in 1880's NYC. A serial killer is on the loose. Is he a copycat or is he the actual JTR? So many twists and turns. Every time you think you know who the murderer is, new possibilities come along.
Many references to JTR. Prudence, Geoffrey, Josiah, Kevin and Blossom (the wonder dog) go to any lengths to find their killer. And when you think the story is over, IT IS NOT!. I look forward to reading the author's other books. This had me reading late at night and early in the morning! The descriptions of the victims are graphic. Well written storyline and fantastic characters! I do not give 5 stars often, but this one deserved it! If you like reading abt Jack the Ripper, you will like this one. If more thrillers and murder mysteries were written like this one, I would read them more often!
Many references to JTR. Prudence, Geoffrey, Josiah, Kevin and Blossom (the wonder dog) go to any lengths to find their killer. And when you think the story is over, IT IS NOT!. I look forward to reading the author's other books. This had me reading late at night and early in the morning! The descriptions of the victims are graphic. Well written storyline and fantastic characters! I do not give 5 stars often, but this one deserved it! If you like reading abt Jack the Ripper, you will like this one. If more thrillers and murder mysteries were written like this one, I would read them more often!
January 19, 2018
An engrossing read with characters that jump right off the page and into your living room. A well written mystery with a great mix of suspense. When Prudence decides to solve the mystery of who murdered her long time friend and family maid, she finds herself plunged into the heart of the Church and the working classes of New York City. With Geoffrey by her side and the assistance of some additional delightful characters, Prudence solves the crime after nearly becoming a victim herself. A great read!
April 22, 2019
Not What I hoped it Would be!
After finishing the first novel in the series, I read the first chapter of the second novel, as offered. I thought I would love this story as well as I did the first. In the beginning, I really liked it. Somewhere around the middle of the book, the story took a drastic turn: it became about gangsters, prostitution, a street urchin and a ridiculously intuitive dog. I really didn't enjoy the book. But, kept reading it after paying ten dollars for it. I will remove this author from my "follow" list.
After finishing the first novel in the series, I read the first chapter of the second novel, as offered. I thought I would love this story as well as I did the first. In the beginning, I really liked it. Somewhere around the middle of the book, the story took a drastic turn: it became about gangsters, prostitution, a street urchin and a ridiculously intuitive dog. I really didn't enjoy the book. But, kept reading it after paying ten dollars for it. I will remove this author from my "follow" list.
April 23, 2018
I mostly liked the first book in this series, but this book just mostly annoyed me. :-). I think it became too silly for me when a dog’s perspective was featured nearly as much as “her human’s”. I also thought the “who dunnit” conclusion was very unsatisfactory.
December 1, 2024
A well written book that is unfortunately riddled with problems. 2/5 stars.
I read the first book in this series quite a while ago, and I remember enjoying it. It had an atmospheric feel with well written characters. I don't think I went into this with high expectations, but regardless this ended up being a major letdown. This novel is still well written, that hasn't changed. The time, people, and environment are so well described you feel like you're there. But outside of that, there's not much else praise I can give. Some of the characters are good, basically the main ones. However, there's so many inconsistencies, bone headed characters decisions, and a mind boggling ending that I had to give this one 2 stars. Keep reading if you want to find out why.
This is primarily an atmospheric read. There is a lot of description, sometimes in ways that take you away from the plot. While that becomes distracting at points, it's never overly so. This immersed you in the period and made you feel like you were right along with Geoffrey and Prudence as they investigated. The writing is the strongest part of this novel by far, and is consistent with the first book. As a warning to others though, this novel is very graphic, and has content and trigger warnings for general violence, as well as abortion.
The characters are a bit mixed. The main set are pretty good, especially Geoffrey. Prudence makes some absolutely ridiculous decisions in this book though, and it's the unfortunate part about when female characters are written as illogical for "plot reasons" instead of them just using their brain. She is absolutely smarter than how she acts in this book and I'm sad to see it went this direction. The side characters however are unique, and helped flesh out the world. The main problems is some of the decision making and inconsistencies. You have characters trusting people they blatantly shouldn't. You have characters that talk passionately about justice to then make a decision in the completely opposite direction. And probably one of the worst parts is having characters seemingly do everything in their power to evade bringing a killer to justice (don't even get me started on the wannabe corrupt police). Not enjoyable.
The mystery itself was an almost carbon copy of the Jack the Ripper murders. That didn't make it bad by any means. There was rising tension in the book, and the setup made it believable that I never felt like it was contrived. The main problems here are some of the resolutions and lack there of. As many other reviewers have pointed out, there's a ton of unanswered questions. Some of them are fine, but there's major plot involving questions completely left open. Add on top of that the almost random plot resolutions that conclude the story on one hand and not on the other, very weird. The ending was so stupid in my opinion. What an absolute letdown to close the book. It's so opposite from the characters and their backstories that I audibly said WTF out loud.
As you can see, a lot to complain about. I enjoyed the first book, but this was such a let down. I'm honestly unsure if I'll continue, it really was that unenjoyable. I would recommend the first book, and maybe you'll enjoy this one more than me. But I can't in good conscious recommend it.
Quick hits:
+ The writing is well done.
+ The characters are mostly good, some let downs but mostly good. Especially Geoffrey.
- Characters making decisions that make no sense.
- Inconsistent character moments.
- Mind boggling ending.
- A few contrived moments that didn't feel real or earned.
I read the first book in this series quite a while ago, and I remember enjoying it. It had an atmospheric feel with well written characters. I don't think I went into this with high expectations, but regardless this ended up being a major letdown. This novel is still well written, that hasn't changed. The time, people, and environment are so well described you feel like you're there. But outside of that, there's not much else praise I can give. Some of the characters are good, basically the main ones. However, there's so many inconsistencies, bone headed characters decisions, and a mind boggling ending that I had to give this one 2 stars. Keep reading if you want to find out why.
This is primarily an atmospheric read. There is a lot of description, sometimes in ways that take you away from the plot. While that becomes distracting at points, it's never overly so. This immersed you in the period and made you feel like you were right along with Geoffrey and Prudence as they investigated. The writing is the strongest part of this novel by far, and is consistent with the first book. As a warning to others though, this novel is very graphic, and has content and trigger warnings for general violence, as well as abortion.
The characters are a bit mixed. The main set are pretty good, especially Geoffrey. Prudence makes some absolutely ridiculous decisions in this book though, and it's the unfortunate part about when female characters are written as illogical for "plot reasons" instead of them just using their brain. She is absolutely smarter than how she acts in this book and I'm sad to see it went this direction. The side characters however are unique, and helped flesh out the world. The main problems is some of the decision making and inconsistencies. You have characters trusting people they blatantly shouldn't. You have characters that talk passionately about justice to then make a decision in the completely opposite direction. And probably one of the worst parts is having characters seemingly do everything in their power to evade bringing a killer to justice (don't even get me started on the wannabe corrupt police). Not enjoyable.
The mystery itself was an almost carbon copy of the Jack the Ripper murders. That didn't make it bad by any means. There was rising tension in the book, and the setup made it believable that I never felt like it was contrived. The main problems here are some of the resolutions and lack there of. As many other reviewers have pointed out, there's a ton of unanswered questions. Some of them are fine, but there's major plot involving questions completely left open. Add on top of that the almost random plot resolutions that conclude the story on one hand and not on the other, very weird. The ending was so stupid in my opinion. What an absolute letdown to close the book. It's so opposite from the characters and their backstories that I audibly said WTF out loud.
As you can see, a lot to complain about. I enjoyed the first book, but this was such a let down. I'm honestly unsure if I'll continue, it really was that unenjoyable. I would recommend the first book, and maybe you'll enjoy this one more than me. But I can't in good conscious recommend it.
Quick hits:
+ The writing is well done.
+ The characters are mostly good, some let downs but mostly good. Especially Geoffrey.
- Characters making decisions that make no sense.
- Inconsistent character moments.
- Mind boggling ending.
- A few contrived moments that didn't feel real or earned.
February 2, 2018
Thanks to the publisher for providing me with an ARC.
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY is the second novel in the Gilded Age Mystery series by Rosemary Simpson. In the first novel, WHAT THE DEAD LEAVE BEHIND, the reader is introduced to wealthy heiress Prudence MacKenzie and ex-Pinkerton detective Geoffrey Hunter. Prudence's father has recently passed away and then her fiancé, Charles, perishes in the Great Blizzard that struck New York City in 1888. Prudence teams together with Charles' friend, Geoffrey, to prove that Charles' death was no accident, and that her step-mother is attempting to do away with her in an nefarious plot to get her hands on Prudence's inheritance.
In the second installment in the Gilded Age Mystery series, Prudence and Geoffrey are now operating their own private investigative company. Despite the restrictions placed upon women of the era, Prudence is determined to break the mold and be an equal part of the company - even if that means placing herself in physical danger.
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY begins the day after Jack the Ripper brutally murders and butchers his final victim in the Whitechapel area of London. When the butchered body of an Irish woman (who just happens to be Prudence's childhood playmate and current maid) turns up in New York City, Prudence and Geoffrey believe that there is a Jack the Ripper copycat at work. The police believe it as well, and they are determined to cover it up by placing the blame on the victim's innocent fiancé. Two more Irish women (one a maid and the other a prostitute) are also murdered and their bodies are butchered. The police are more concerned with covering up the details of the murders to prevent a panic among the citizens of the city than they are with finding the serial killer who is stalking the city. Meanwhile, Prudence and Geoffrey set their sights on connecting the three women and finding the one commonality between the victims that will lead them to finding the killer.
This novel is a captivating follow-up to WHAT THE DEAD LEAVE BEHIND. As a character, Prudence MacKenzie really comes into her own in this novel. She continues to grow as a person and take charge of her life as she breaks the mold of what everyone expects of a woman during her era. What makes LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY intriguing is that Rosemary Simpson tells the story from so many different perspectives - including a rather articulate dog. The characters are all well-developed and interesting. The various perspectives help give the readers a full picture of what is going on. I thoroughly enjoyed the novel. My only complaints are that there were times when the story seemed to drag a bit. Also, the murderer never makes an appearance (aside from a couple brief but insignificant mentions) until late in the novel and that makes it difficult and frustrating for those of us who are playing along at home and trying to figure out the killer before he's caught.
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY is the second novel in the Gilded Age Mystery series by Rosemary Simpson. In the first novel, WHAT THE DEAD LEAVE BEHIND, the reader is introduced to wealthy heiress Prudence MacKenzie and ex-Pinkerton detective Geoffrey Hunter. Prudence's father has recently passed away and then her fiancé, Charles, perishes in the Great Blizzard that struck New York City in 1888. Prudence teams together with Charles' friend, Geoffrey, to prove that Charles' death was no accident, and that her step-mother is attempting to do away with her in an nefarious plot to get her hands on Prudence's inheritance.
In the second installment in the Gilded Age Mystery series, Prudence and Geoffrey are now operating their own private investigative company. Despite the restrictions placed upon women of the era, Prudence is determined to break the mold and be an equal part of the company - even if that means placing herself in physical danger.
LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY begins the day after Jack the Ripper brutally murders and butchers his final victim in the Whitechapel area of London. When the butchered body of an Irish woman (who just happens to be Prudence's childhood playmate and current maid) turns up in New York City, Prudence and Geoffrey believe that there is a Jack the Ripper copycat at work. The police believe it as well, and they are determined to cover it up by placing the blame on the victim's innocent fiancé. Two more Irish women (one a maid and the other a prostitute) are also murdered and their bodies are butchered. The police are more concerned with covering up the details of the murders to prevent a panic among the citizens of the city than they are with finding the serial killer who is stalking the city. Meanwhile, Prudence and Geoffrey set their sights on connecting the three women and finding the one commonality between the victims that will lead them to finding the killer.
This novel is a captivating follow-up to WHAT THE DEAD LEAVE BEHIND. As a character, Prudence MacKenzie really comes into her own in this novel. She continues to grow as a person and take charge of her life as she breaks the mold of what everyone expects of a woman during her era. What makes LIES THAT COMFORT AND BETRAY intriguing is that Rosemary Simpson tells the story from so many different perspectives - including a rather articulate dog. The characters are all well-developed and interesting. The various perspectives help give the readers a full picture of what is going on. I thoroughly enjoyed the novel. My only complaints are that there were times when the story seemed to drag a bit. Also, the murderer never makes an appearance (aside from a couple brief but insignificant mentions) until late in the novel and that makes it difficult and frustrating for those of us who are playing along at home and trying to figure out the killer before he's caught.
June 30, 2022
This is the 2nd book in a series. In 1888, Prudence is working as a private detective along with lawyer friend, Geoffrey. When Prudence’s sometimes-maid (and friend from when they were kids) turns up not only murdered, but “gutted” (similar to Jack the Ripper over in London), people wonder if the Ripper has moved to New York or if this is a copycat. The police want to solve the case quickly, so they arrest the fiancee, but Prudence and Geoffrey don’t think he did it. Then another, then another young woman turn up with a similar MO.
I am really enjoying these mysteries. Prudence is much more assertive than most women of her time and “station”, but I like her. Realistic? I don’t know, but the entire atmostphere/setting of the book is done really well, I think. With how these murders are happening, there is some gore, but that doesn’t bother me. There was more going on than the murders in this book, so even when things appeared to be drawing to a close, there was more to come.
I am really enjoying these mysteries. Prudence is much more assertive than most women of her time and “station”, but I like her. Realistic? I don’t know, but the entire atmostphere/setting of the book is done really well, I think. With how these murders are happening, there is some gore, but that doesn’t bother me. There was more going on than the murders in this book, so even when things appeared to be drawing to a close, there was more to come.
September 14, 2018
This is the second book of a series but the first one I have read. Simpson is a great storyteller, bringing New York. The horrific murder of an Irish maid known to Prudence Mackenzie shocks New York, the privileged and the underbelly alike. Prudence and her partner Geoffrey embark want to solve the murder for personal reasons and to ensure that New York doesn't have it's very own Jack The Ripper.
The Police have their own agenda so Prudence and her team bring in some unlikely helpers. My favourite of these is a dog called Blossom, who really is a wonderful character.
It's a fast-paced, unpredictable historical mystery with great dialogue and interesting, well-rounded characters. I am looking forward to reading the next one.
The Police have their own agenda so Prudence and her team bring in some unlikely helpers. My favourite of these is a dog called Blossom, who really is a wonderful character.
It's a fast-paced, unpredictable historical mystery with great dialogue and interesting, well-rounded characters. I am looking forward to reading the next one.
November 15, 2018
4.5/5 ⭐️
I really LOVE this series! This is the second of three so far, and they’ve all been top-notch! Here, a Ripper-like murderer strikes in New York. There are twists and turns and murder scenes not for the squeamish. 🤭 Great writing and character development, dark and macabre scenes and even a flea-ridden mangy street mutt named Blossom to save the day...what’s not to ❤️?! Hope there’s more of these to come!
I really LOVE this series! This is the second of three so far, and they’ve all been top-notch! Here, a Ripper-like murderer strikes in New York. There are twists and turns and murder scenes not for the squeamish. 🤭 Great writing and character development, dark and macabre scenes and even a flea-ridden mangy street mutt named Blossom to save the day...what’s not to ❤️?! Hope there’s more of these to come!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 187 reviews