Evans-Wentz built his reputation as the translator of the Tibetan Book of the Dead. The cover of The Fairy Faith in Celtic Countries proclaims the latter to be his first love, however. While he was likely an able translator, and in 1910 when The Fairy Faith was published, may have been considered an expert researcher, the Scientific Method has come a long way since Dr. Evans-Wentz' time.
He devotes over 260 pages to the "collecting of evidence" in Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Brittany, the Isle of Man, Cornwall and other Celtic countries. What he actually collects are folk-lore, family traditions, legends over 1000 years old, and a few personal experiences. Most of the stories are of the "My mother told me, and she had it from her neighbor on good authority" type. Perhaps that is why Dr. Evans-Wentz goes to such great length to assure the reader that the persons he interviewed are of the highest moral integrity and soundest mind. Rather than collecting information about a creed or faith or set of beliefs, however, Dr. Evans-Wentz' purpose seems to have been to prove (or at least convince his readers)the existence of faeries, the tricks they often play on mortals, and their connection to ancient gods or the ancestors of those who believe in them.
He compares such Celtic structures as Stonehenge and New Grange to the Pyramids of Egypt and tries to establish a connection in the belief systems of the builders of such monuments. He quotes Hebrew and Christian scripture, Buddhist and "Hindoo" wisdom. Occasionally he even refers to the "North American Red Man" as having similar beliefs and traditions as the Celtic peoples. All mankind, he avers, originally belonged to some form of "Sun Cult"--some retaining the belief far longer than others. He points to the Eastward orientation of Stonehenge, New Grange, the Great Pyramid, the temples of the "Florida Red Man," Inca temples in Cuzco, the Parthenon in Greece and even the majority of major Catholic and Anglican cathedrals in Europe and Britain as proof of the universality of sun worship, even pointing out that the "Mohammedan" and the "Hindoo" face the east for their prayers (apparently unaware that Muslims who live east of Mecca would face the west). The exception which he may have thought would prove his rule is the Thug cult in India. This cruel, evil group revered the West.
He incorporates the tenets of both Darwin and Freud, quotes dozens of scientists and scholars. Yet, in the end, his conclusion is that in addition to worshiping a sun god, mankind universally believes in some sort of rebirth after death. Whether resurrection or reincarnation, Evans-Wentz believes that he has scientifically proven the universality of belief in and the actuality of re-birth. He claims that belief in a post-life existence presupposes belief in a pre-existence. That pre-existence, he says, is a life-force into which we all return at death only to be reborn later. For him it explains why children often have completely different personalities, attitudes, and beliefs than do their known relatives; why we experience feelings of deja-vu; why things that we have never seen, heard or experienced are somehow familiar to us. It even explains evolution more clearly, he insists.
I learned nothing about the belief system, creed, rites, or rituals of the Celtic people who believe in the world of Faerie. I did learn how the standardization of English spelling, the Scientific Method, and the condensation and clarity of English sentences have changed during the last century. I couldn't help thinking, on numerous occasions that if Lucy Van Pelt had used Evans-Wentz' writing style, her 100 word essay on Peter Rabbit would have comprised only two sentences!