~3.5~
The Sweetest Star isn't quite as sexy or full of feels as the first book in the series, but it's still an enjoyable read with the, um, sweetest ending.
What I loved about Leo and Jamie, the MCs from book 1, is that they were willing to be vulnerable together. I didn't get the same vibe from Eric and Dash. Even though Eric, like Leo, is a former member of 90s boy band 5*Star, this book does not have a broken dreams kind of vibe.
Eric has carved a niche for himself in the food business and is about to get his own TV show on Eat Network (I'm so glad the real network went with Food instead of Eat; it's much more appetizing).
Dash is a food blogger and is offered a spot as Eric's co-host after Eric's former boyfriend bails on the deal. Dash just broke up with his boyfriend of ten years and is insecure and unapproachable.
There's a lot of back and forth between the men. I don't mind some relationship angst, but the running hot and cold got really irritating after a while.
Dash, especially, made me want to bang my head on a hard surface. He acted like a 15-year-old emo kid, pushing Eric away and refusing to make the fake boyfriend thing real, even after Eric essentially begs him.
It all worked out, of course, and the epilogue made me happy, but I'm hoping for a stronger emotional connection in the next book in the series.
And, yes, this book can absolutely be read as a standalone; the MCs from book 1 are mentioned only in passing. Honestly, though, I wouldn't skip book 1; it's pretty awesome.