Picked this up in NYC with Collin, I'm interested in issues of migration and slavery. The strength of the book was the voices of the immigrants, the smugglers and the state officials, which the author allowed to come out unfiltered. The great weakness of the book was the writing style and the simplistic level of analysis. If this were turned into me by a student, I'd give it a low C in both areas. These are important current issues which require much deeper reflection than this writer seemed capable of providing.