What do you think?
Rate this book


200 pages, Hardcover
First published October 26, 2017
If there is a naïveté in too blind a faith in the essential decency of human nature, there is also a naïveté of a more dangerous kind in denying any idealistic motives to one’s opponents. To do this is not only to make a psychological mistake; it is greatly to under-rate the strength of one’s enemy.
I am now staying with the Sennis – an old-fashioned “black” Roman family. An American mother and four grown-up sons, two of whom fought in Abyssinia (one still in the regular army, the other in the Breda works in Milan). Their grandfather belonged to the guardia nobile and their uncle, who is also here, in the diplomatic service, has been for five years Mussolini’s capo del cerimoniale. The Sennis are all Fascists, but they are Catholics first; where there is a clash between the two Catholicism wins. Moreover they pride themselves on not being cut off from news from abroad. They read assiduously not only the Italian papers and the Osservatore Romano, but The Times, Le Temps and the Journal de Genève; they listen every day to the news from the BBC and Paris PTT. They are intensely anti-German, mildly anti-French and inclined, even now, to like England (Chamberlain’s England). Two of them went to Oxford; all have many English friends. They deplore the “necessity” of the Axis, feel a mild aversion to anti-Semitism and wholeheartedly deplore and condemn (on moral and religious grounds) the Anglo-Franco approach to Russia. Their Catholicism and their aristocratic traditions combine and blind them to the fundamental ungenerosity of their attitude; but they would be profoundly shocked if this was suggested to them. Affectionate and high-principled in their private lives, they one and all totally drop these principles and sentiments as soon as any political issue is discussed – and the word “realistic” is seldom off their lips.
I agreed with his sentiments and yet felt uncomfortable- there was something wrong. Then, as he went on, I realized that everything he was deploring in the present world was the good side: the revolutionary, vital, idealistic element. Everything he wished to preserve (and admired...) was based on the rule of money- and the power money brings. Peace and war, the Jewish question, the social question, the situation in China, every question under the sun, was seen only in its relation to vested interests. So complete, so whole-hearted was his preoccupation that after an hour's conversation I began to wonder whether I had not been incredibly naive in believing there was any other governing motive in human life.Mussolini sounds disturbingly familiar:
[Count Carlo Senni] emphasizes one trait which strikes everyone who has ever worked with Mussolini: his unbounded, almost undisguised, utterly cynical contempt for his own human instruments. Except for his brother Arnaldo (now dead) and perhaps, to a lesser extent, his daughter, there is no human being in the world whom he loves and trusts. He believes in the ability of his son-in-law; he does not trust him. A sentimentalist about "the people" en masse, he is completely cynical about all individuals, and measures them only by the use he can put them to...And let's close with Origo's description of meeting the head of the Polish colony in Rome, a man she calls K.
For those in Poland nothing could be done. --"But the International Red Cross?"--He shook his head. He had heard only yesterday that the Mission which was about to start from Geneva had been refused admission. We all gasped. "But even in Spain..." He nodded. "You don't understand; the Germans prefer us to die." K's face hardened. "I was at the head of the little deputation of Poles who visited his Holiness last month", he said. "Perhaps you read in the papers what he said? He spoke coldly, prudently. That is not the way to speak to men who..." He broke off. "In any case...there was an ecclesiastic who talking to me, the other day, about the terrible effects of war upon the human soul. The worst, he said, is destruction of respect for the Will of God. No, I said, the worst is this: that if today, I had a chance of shooting down a German woman or child, I would do so without an instant's scruple or pity. That whole race- I no longer feel that they are human beings." There was such complete conviction, such immeasurable bitterness, in his voice that no one answered."