What do you think?
Rate this book
Harp on the Willow
Love is patient and kind... 1 Corinthians 13:4 West Virginia, 1869
Three years ago, Dr. Daniel Kavanagh settled down in the quaint town of Mount Laurel and established a medical practice there. The single doctor has been nursing an unrequited crush on Serena Norman, the local schoolteacher.
Just down the road lies the coal mining town of Owenduffy, considered by most in Mount Laurel to be a backwoods hamlet. When the mine company's doctor abandons his post, Daniel agrees to visit one day a week, much to the consternation of his fellow residents, including his secret love, Serena.
Addie Rose, the daughter of an Owenduffy coal miner, has a gift for caring for others. When a receptionist position in Daniel's office suddenly becomes available, what windows of opportunity will God open for Addie Rose—just a job, a possible career as a nurse, or maybe something more?
Harp on the Willow is a touching tale of true love, the kind that can only come from a Savior who first loved us.
Three years ago, Dr. Daniel Kavanagh settled down in the quaint town of Mount Laurel and established a medical practice there. The single doctor has been nursing an unrequited crush on Serena Norman, the local schoolteacher.
Just down the road lies the coal mining town of Owenduffy, considered by most in Mount Laurel to be a backwoods hamlet. When the mine company's doctor abandons his post, Daniel agrees to visit one day a week, much to the consternation of his fellow residents, including his secret love, Serena.
Addie Rose, the daughter of an Owenduffy coal miner, has a gift for caring for others. When a receptionist position in Daniel's office suddenly becomes available, what windows of opportunity will God open for Addie Rose—just a job, a possible career as a nurse, or maybe something more?
Harp on the Willow is a touching tale of true love, the kind that can only come from a Savior who first loved us.
304 pages, Paperback
First published February 1, 2018
17 people are currently reading
130 people want to read
About the author
B.J. Hoff
51 books147 followersBJ Hoff’s writing is known for her historical settings, her unforgettable characters, and her lyrical prose. She is the bestselling author of numerous historical fiction series, including the Riverhaven Years, the Mountain Song Legacy, the Song of Erin saga, the American Anthem series, An Emerald Ballad series, and her newest book Harp on the Willow.
Her five-volume Emerald Ballad series was the first major work of fiction to bring the Irish immigration experience to the CBA marketplace, and the work that first brought BJ an international reading audience.
Her readers know they can expect to meet some memorable people in her novels and also know that many of those people will be immigrants; Irish immigrants particularly but not exclusively.
BJ admits to a passion for building worlds. Whether her characters move about in small country towns or metropolitan areas, reside in Amish settlements, secluded mansions, or coal company houses, she creates communities where people can form relationships, raise families, pursue their faith, and experience the mountains and valleys of life.
She’s intent on making her historical novels relevant to the present by developing characters and settings that, while staying true to the history and culture of their times, reflect many of the spiritual trials and social problems faced by contemporary readers. Her novels are meant to be stories that build a bridge from the past to the present.
Her literary awards include the Christianity Today’s Critics Choice Book Award for fiction; a Gold Medallion Award finalist; and a number of Excellence in Media Silver Angel awards. Her books have been translated into many foreign languages, and she frequently hears from her international readers in countries such as Ireland, England, Norway, and Germany.
A former church music director and music teacher, BJ writes from her home in a small town in east central Ohio. She and her husband share a love of music, books, and time spent with their family: two daughters and three lively young grandsons.
Her five-volume Emerald Ballad series was the first major work of fiction to bring the Irish immigration experience to the CBA marketplace, and the work that first brought BJ an international reading audience.
Her readers know they can expect to meet some memorable people in her novels and also know that many of those people will be immigrants; Irish immigrants particularly but not exclusively.
BJ admits to a passion for building worlds. Whether her characters move about in small country towns or metropolitan areas, reside in Amish settlements, secluded mansions, or coal company houses, she creates communities where people can form relationships, raise families, pursue their faith, and experience the mountains and valleys of life.
She’s intent on making her historical novels relevant to the present by developing characters and settings that, while staying true to the history and culture of their times, reflect many of the spiritual trials and social problems faced by contemporary readers. Her novels are meant to be stories that build a bridge from the past to the present.
Her literary awards include the Christianity Today’s Critics Choice Book Award for fiction; a Gold Medallion Award finalist; and a number of Excellence in Media Silver Angel awards. Her books have been translated into many foreign languages, and she frequently hears from her international readers in countries such as Ireland, England, Norway, and Germany.
A former church music director and music teacher, BJ writes from her home in a small town in east central Ohio. She and her husband share a love of music, books, and time spent with their family: two daughters and three lively young grandsons.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews
January 11, 2022
This wasn't a remarkable story but it was enjoyable. As you can see in the blurb, the premise isn't complex. There's no need for a critical analysis of this, not that I could give you one anyway :)
This is a nice, slow story that, to me, read like "a day in the life of..." In this case it is more like "a time in the life of a country doctor". A doctor who cares so much for his community and his fellow man that he consistently puts their needs above his own. A man willing to do what is right rather than what is comfortable or expected when he agrees to treat a patient from "the wrong side of the tracks". The 'tracks' in this story is actually a river that divides Mt Laurel and Owenduffy, a coal mining town.
While treating a patient, the doc meets Addie Murphy who tends to the sick in her community. Oh Addie... the doc finds her interesting and soon she has him questioning his feelings for one Serena, a not-so-secret love interest.
Treating the patients from Owenduffy is not well-received in Mt Laurel and causes some drama. "Why are you treating those people?"
The characters are well drawn and the ones I liked, I liked and the ones I didn't, ooh, I really didn't like them :) The doctor's original receptionist Audrey, Serena and Brad Nolan all fall into the latter category. This takes place in 1869 so maybe I'm being unfair to Serena, but I didn't care for her attitude.
I enjoyed this and I found myself at times wishing it were longer. It didn't need to be, my sinful self just wanted more - more doctor, more Addie and more Murphy, her dad.
I'd like to thank Netgalley, the publishers and the author for an electronic version of this story in exchange for an honest review.
This is a nice, slow story that, to me, read like "a day in the life of..." In this case it is more like "a time in the life of a country doctor". A doctor who cares so much for his community and his fellow man that he consistently puts their needs above his own. A man willing to do what is right rather than what is comfortable or expected when he agrees to treat a patient from "the wrong side of the tracks". The 'tracks' in this story is actually a river that divides Mt Laurel and Owenduffy, a coal mining town.
While treating a patient, the doc meets Addie Murphy who tends to the sick in her community. Oh Addie... the doc finds her interesting and soon she has him questioning his feelings for one Serena, a not-so-secret love interest.
Treating the patients from Owenduffy is not well-received in Mt Laurel and causes some drama. "Why are you treating those people?"
The characters are well drawn and the ones I liked, I liked and the ones I didn't, ooh, I really didn't like them :) The doctor's original receptionist Audrey, Serena and Brad Nolan all fall into the latter category. This takes place in 1869 so maybe I'm being unfair to Serena, but I didn't care for her attitude.
I enjoyed this and I found myself at times wishing it were longer. It didn't need to be, my sinful self just wanted more - more doctor, more Addie and more Murphy, her dad.
I'd like to thank Netgalley, the publishers and the author for an electronic version of this story in exchange for an honest review.
March 9, 2018
Hoff was a new author for me, but this pretty cover was irresistible. I loved escaping into the doctor's world, and within a few pages I was anticipating a doctor-version of a Jan Karon novel. The atmosphere was intriguing and absorbing. I really loved David and Addie Rose as characters and Sarge was a dear.
But as I read along it felt as though all the detail had been poured into the early chapters of the book. The tone slowly changed to a more modern one (the town would have fit better between 1920-1950, rather than in 1869, with the modern sensibilities of the characters and with their speech patterns) and I kept feeling a jar each time I was reminded of the date. Here are some things that pulled down my enjoyment and subsequently my rating:
-David is not described until page 35
-POV switches without warning to several different random people. Most of them don't re-occur.
-SO MUCH TELLING. Weeks would pass over in a leap and be summarized in three pages of "xyz happened."
-Serena is not believable. She's chasing David one minute, thinking to snatch him up and marry him, then not even contacting him for two weeks? The kisses were super awkward. She has a job despite being an heiress and tells her parents what to do...really unlikely in the time period.
-The mine owner's first name changes halfway through the book
-David's younger brother is said to be almost twenty, but was born after David's family immigrated to America, which in one spot was sixteen years ago and in another was eighteen years ago. A timeline chart would have easily prevented this.
-Abrupt ending. Whew, really? All those pages wasted in telling rather than showing, and now I'm told "they had been engaged for two weeks" and I'm supposed to be happy about the ending that skipped all that?
-The married-guy-hits-on-heroine trope. So cheap, so overdone. Eye roll.
If it had kept the tone of the early chapters and had been free of annoying errors and telling, it would have been an easy four star and maybe even a five. But the weak storytelling ended up overshadowing the beautiful setting too much.
Thanks for NetGalley and the publisher for a free review copy.
But as I read along it felt as though all the detail had been poured into the early chapters of the book. The tone slowly changed to a more modern one (the town would have fit better between 1920-1950, rather than in 1869, with the modern sensibilities of the characters and with their speech patterns) and I kept feeling a jar each time I was reminded of the date. Here are some things that pulled down my enjoyment and subsequently my rating:
-David is not described until page 35
-POV switches without warning to several different random people. Most of them don't re-occur.
-SO MUCH TELLING. Weeks would pass over in a leap and be summarized in three pages of "xyz happened."
-Serena is not believable. She's chasing David one minute, thinking to snatch him up and marry him, then not even contacting him for two weeks? The kisses were super awkward. She has a job despite being an heiress and tells her parents what to do...really unlikely in the time period.
-The mine owner's first name changes halfway through the book
-David's younger brother is said to be almost twenty, but was born after David's family immigrated to America, which in one spot was sixteen years ago and in another was eighteen years ago. A timeline chart would have easily prevented this.
-Abrupt ending. Whew, really? All those pages wasted in telling rather than showing, and now I'm told "they had been engaged for two weeks" and I'm supposed to be happy about the ending that skipped all that?
-The married-guy-hits-on-heroine trope. So cheap, so overdone. Eye roll.
If it had kept the tone of the early chapters and had been free of annoying errors and telling, it would have been an easy four star and maybe even a five. But the weak storytelling ended up overshadowing the beautiful setting too much.
Thanks for NetGalley and the publisher for a free review copy.
March 15, 2018
I greatly appreciate the cover of this book and that it actually made it to publishing without a beautiful women grinning back at me. I've read BJ Hoff before and do not remember her flutters of romance between the characters. I enjoyed Daniel and the town and his connection to his patients but was always removed from the story when Addie Rose came on the scene; I just didn't think she was necessary for this to be a successful read. I'm just not the reader to appreciate "the unusual grace and unexpected elegance of her hand; long slender fingers with perfectly shaped nails, yet with a visible strength and grace to each movement" I just don't think I've ever had that impression of someone's hands before. Moments like that took me from the otherwise enjoyable story.
February 18, 2018
I loved the feel of this story. It had the slow feel of West Virginia rural mountains in the late 1860's after the civil war. It focuses on Dr. Daniel Kavanagh MD, an Irish boy made good who has come to practice in the small town of Mt. Laurel Virginia. He soon finds himself helping the mining families across the river in Owenduffy which does not endear him to some of the people in Mt. Laurel. When his receptionist quits, Daniel finds himself asking the daughter of one of the miners who has some healing knowledge to be his receptionist and assistant nurse.
This is a wonderful start to a new series by B.J. Hoff. It is the first book I have read by this author, but I have read many wonderful reviews of his books. The characters especially Daniel and Addie Rose were so endearing. The respect they had for one another and what they learned from each other made them both stronger people. Their caring and concern for their patients was wonderful, and I felt like I was watching over their shoulder as they helped the people of both towns. Daniel learned that what he thought he needed might not be what he really needed to complete his life. While Addie Rose learned that what she never thought she would have in life might be right there after all.
This book reminded me a lot of another book about a doctor's life: Bryson City Tales: Stories of a Doctor's First Year of Practice in the Smoky Mountains
This book was just released in January. There was a formatting problem with the Kindle edition, and it was occasionally distracting. But I would still highly recommend this historical fiction read and look forward to reading more books in this series.
FAVORITE QUOTATIONS: "If one does not question, nothing will change."
"God protect me from anything that wasn't sent by You."
This is a wonderful start to a new series by B.J. Hoff. It is the first book I have read by this author, but I have read many wonderful reviews of his books. The characters especially Daniel and Addie Rose were so endearing. The respect they had for one another and what they learned from each other made them both stronger people. Their caring and concern for their patients was wonderful, and I felt like I was watching over their shoulder as they helped the people of both towns. Daniel learned that what he thought he needed might not be what he really needed to complete his life. While Addie Rose learned that what she never thought she would have in life might be right there after all.
This book reminded me a lot of another book about a doctor's life: Bryson City Tales: Stories of a Doctor's First Year of Practice in the Smoky Mountains
This book was just released in January. There was a formatting problem with the Kindle edition, and it was occasionally distracting. But I would still highly recommend this historical fiction read and look forward to reading more books in this series.
FAVORITE QUOTATIONS: "If one does not question, nothing will change."
"God protect me from anything that wasn't sent by You."
December 15, 2017
A good start to a new historical series by one of my favorite Christian fiction authors! Set in West Virginia, 1869, book one introduces the town of Mount Laurel, and Dr. Daniel Kavanagh, whose practice includes a wide variety of people--from babies to the elderly--giving the story a bit of a Mitford feel set back in time. The story takes a turn from the sunny side of town, to the darker, dusty side, when the good doctor is called to help out across the river in the coal mining town of Owenduffy. Not everyone is happy about his choice to serve both communities.
"We are not here to play, to dream, to drift; We have hard work to do, and loads to lift; Shun not the struggle, face it, ’tis God’s gift. " (Maltbie Babcock)
This quote especially fits the character of Dr. Daniel who is a solid character, hardworking to a fault, focused on serving his community well. His past in the Civil War and growing up as an Irish immigrant gave him an extra amount of compassion. I got the feeling there was a connection to another book with the mention of Hull House and his family.
This is a good start to a new series, with a tender romance included. The theme of prejudice stands out, mainly against the Irish immigrant mine workers and impoverished in the mining 'camp', and the choice to follow conscience over matters of the heart. I look forward to reading more of his story and getting to know other characters in the next books. Wished the ending had been stretched out more, with more details of his relationship to the woman who chooses to pursue. It seemed to skip over some interesting details.
Recommend to readers who enjoy clean historical romances.
(An e-book was provided by NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions are my own.)
"We are not here to play, to dream, to drift; We have hard work to do, and loads to lift; Shun not the struggle, face it, ’tis God’s gift. " (Maltbie Babcock)
This quote especially fits the character of Dr. Daniel who is a solid character, hardworking to a fault, focused on serving his community well. His past in the Civil War and growing up as an Irish immigrant gave him an extra amount of compassion. I got the feeling there was a connection to another book with the mention of Hull House and his family.
This is a good start to a new series, with a tender romance included. The theme of prejudice stands out, mainly against the Irish immigrant mine workers and impoverished in the mining 'camp', and the choice to follow conscience over matters of the heart. I look forward to reading more of his story and getting to know other characters in the next books. Wished the ending had been stretched out more, with more details of his relationship to the woman who chooses to pursue. It seemed to skip over some interesting details.
Recommend to readers who enjoy clean historical romances.
(An e-book was provided by NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions are my own.)
October 9, 2023
This plot involves a doctor serving in a town adjacent to a poor mining region and the prejudice he endures while attempting to help the mine workers and their families. Many people in the town feel he should help only the wealthier residents of the town and ignore the mining community. Throw in a tragic mine collapse and sweet romance and you will find yourself turning pages.
March 11, 2021
3.5 out of 5 stars
November 28, 2017
Another great book written by BJ Hoff. The story of Dr. Daniel Kavanagh a medical doctor in a small town of Mount Laurel. He has a crush on the school teacher of the town Serena. There is a small coal mining town of Owenduffy near Mount Laurel.They have a doctor in the small coal mining town but he is always drunk or not available. One night when a child from Owenduffy knocks on his door for help for his sick sister he runs to help the child. He meets Addie Rose a coal miners daughter there. Serena does not like him helping people from the coal mining town . The story is about finding romance and also a story about caring for people no matter how much they have. It is a great inspiring storyline. I read the book in a day I could not put it down. Can not wait to read more in the series.
March 20, 2018
**FTC DISCLAIMER: I RECEIVED AN E-ARC FROM NETGALLEY IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW. RECEIPT OF THIS BOOK IN THIS MANNER DOES NOT AFFECT MY OPINION OF THE BOOK OR THE CONTENT OF MY REVIEW.**
It’s been three years since Dr. Daniel Kavanagh settled down in the quaint town of Mount Laurel, West Virginia. The single doctor has a somewhat complicated relationship with the local schoolteacher, Serena Norman. He’s just not sure if she feels the same way as he feels about her or not as she seems to give mixed signals. Just down the road from Mount Laurel lies the coal mining town of Owenduffy, which is considered by most of the town to be a backwoods hamlet, nowhere near as good as their own town. When the mining company finds themselves without a doctor, Daniel reluctantly agrees to visit once a week to take care of the people who live in Owenduffy. Some of residents of Mount Laurel, including Serena, aren’t happy about what they see as Daniel dividing his time among people who are less deserving than they are. So, Daniel finds himself being pulled from both directions as he tries to do what’s best for all of his patients. Addie Rose, the daughter of one of Owenduffy’s coalminers, has a real gift for taking care of the sick and dreams of becoming a nurse. When a receptionist position suddenly opens up in Daniel’s office, what windows of opportunity will God open through the simple decision to offer the job to Addie Rose? Will she find just a receptionist job, a chance to realize her dream of becoming a nurse, or even more?
I really enjoyed this sweet story and it could have easily gotten more than the 3.5 stars that I’m rating it. There were just a couple of areas that kind of hung me up and kept me from being able to rate it higher. But, before I get to that, I really feel like the storyline was well planned and worked really well. Like I said, I truly enjoyed reading the story. I also loved the characters. They were all so well written. Daniel, Addie Rose and her father, Miss Gladys, and the Holliday family are among my favorites. I absolutely adored Sarge! Now, I loved to hate Brad Nolan!! And the mine owner, I can see where he has so much room for growth. Just when I would start to hate him, he’d do something that made me wonder if he might possibly care about his workers, at least a little. Like I said, there’s room for growth. Now, for what kept me from being able to rate it higher, the dialogue just didn’t seem to fit with the time period. In many places, the way people talked seemed too modern to be 1869. It was to the point that any time the year or time period was pointed out, it would surprise me enough to actually jolt me from the story. I’m not trying to be a stickler or anything but it really affected my enjoyment of the story. Really, that’s the only negative I can think of. Otherwise, I loved the book and can’t wait for the sequel so I can find out what happens next. Oh, and I also need to compliment the author on choosing an amazing cover!! It’s gorgeous and was part of the reason I wanted to review it.
It’s been three years since Dr. Daniel Kavanagh settled down in the quaint town of Mount Laurel, West Virginia. The single doctor has a somewhat complicated relationship with the local schoolteacher, Serena Norman. He’s just not sure if she feels the same way as he feels about her or not as she seems to give mixed signals. Just down the road from Mount Laurel lies the coal mining town of Owenduffy, which is considered by most of the town to be a backwoods hamlet, nowhere near as good as their own town. When the mining company finds themselves without a doctor, Daniel reluctantly agrees to visit once a week to take care of the people who live in Owenduffy. Some of residents of Mount Laurel, including Serena, aren’t happy about what they see as Daniel dividing his time among people who are less deserving than they are. So, Daniel finds himself being pulled from both directions as he tries to do what’s best for all of his patients. Addie Rose, the daughter of one of Owenduffy’s coalminers, has a real gift for taking care of the sick and dreams of becoming a nurse. When a receptionist position suddenly opens up in Daniel’s office, what windows of opportunity will God open through the simple decision to offer the job to Addie Rose? Will she find just a receptionist job, a chance to realize her dream of becoming a nurse, or even more?
I really enjoyed this sweet story and it could have easily gotten more than the 3.5 stars that I’m rating it. There were just a couple of areas that kind of hung me up and kept me from being able to rate it higher. But, before I get to that, I really feel like the storyline was well planned and worked really well. Like I said, I truly enjoyed reading the story. I also loved the characters. They were all so well written. Daniel, Addie Rose and her father, Miss Gladys, and the Holliday family are among my favorites. I absolutely adored Sarge! Now, I loved to hate Brad Nolan!! And the mine owner, I can see where he has so much room for growth. Just when I would start to hate him, he’d do something that made me wonder if he might possibly care about his workers, at least a little. Like I said, there’s room for growth. Now, for what kept me from being able to rate it higher, the dialogue just didn’t seem to fit with the time period. In many places, the way people talked seemed too modern to be 1869. It was to the point that any time the year or time period was pointed out, it would surprise me enough to actually jolt me from the story. I’m not trying to be a stickler or anything but it really affected my enjoyment of the story. Really, that’s the only negative I can think of. Otherwise, I loved the book and can’t wait for the sequel so I can find out what happens next. Oh, and I also need to compliment the author on choosing an amazing cover!! It’s gorgeous and was part of the reason I wanted to review it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 26, 2018
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I'm not sure if I liked this book or didn't like it.
First off let me start off my saying that I'm not very fond of books that talk mainly in the first person. I don't know why but I've just never liked it. As far as the storyline went, I felt like it was too slow. We don't even meet the main love interest until chapters in. The romance was very limited almost as if it was nonexistent.
This is book is appropriate for ages 13 and up for some adult material.
I'm not sure if I liked this book or didn't like it.
First off let me start off my saying that I'm not very fond of books that talk mainly in the first person. I don't know why but I've just never liked it. As far as the storyline went, I felt like it was too slow. We don't even meet the main love interest until chapters in. The romance was very limited almost as if it was nonexistent.
This is book is appropriate for ages 13 and up for some adult material.
February 18, 2020
This was the first book I've read by BJ Hoff, and I am definitely looking forward to reading more!
Without knowing anything about this author, I was intrigued by her books at the library. Musical titles, medical themes, history . . . yes, yes, and yes. So I chose this one stand-alone book as my introduction to her.
I enjoyed her writing style. I enjoyed the descriptiveness. I enjoyed the tone and the people and the characters as they came to life. The romance was sweet, subtle, and barely there, for the most part. There were two kisses in this book, not detailed, and it left me saying "aww!" and not closing the book in a hurry.
The romance, though, is also why I gave this one only three stars. This guy in the book is obsessed with a girl. He uses the term "crush", and it got a bit annoying. I mean, he's making his decisions based on the whims and fancies of this girl who seems to be playing on him, and who, by the way, seemed to be EXTREMELY selfish. I was VERY surprised, later in the book, when I read that she thought it was going somewhere. I mean . . . ?? I felt it was a case of only-single-guy-knows-only-one-single-girl -- and there was nothing but relief when she finally decided to move to a different town.
The *real* romance was sweet -- it grew, not of obsession, but through working together. Through hard work, long nights, and praying and worrying together. And that, my friends, is what love should be based on. Getting to know the real person, when all guards are down and we can see each other for who we really are.
The religious aspect comes across cleanly, if a bit weak. it wasn't just thrown in there, as I've seen in other books, but it definitely wasn't the strongest part of the book. I mean, the doctor attends church every Sunday, and he prays for his patients, but I'd like to see a bit more of his Christianity lived out in his life. I mean, he was a morally good person and made good decisions, by all means, and I can't say he acted in a sinful way. But maybe he should have prayed about Serena instead of obsessing over her? I don't know if that even makes sense, at all -- and it might just have been me, personally.
One other issue I had was the more modern attitudes and actions and speech of the characters. It's 1869. Just a few years after the War between the States. But it felt more like the early 1900's, and every time he'd mention the war, I was surprised to find it had happened such a short time ago. Historical fiction should stay as historically accurate as possible! Another reason for the three star rating. There were a few inconsistencies with a few of the characters, as well. The time line kept changing -- did Daniel leave Ireland sixteen years ago, or eighteen years ago? And what is the mine owners name, after all? And I felt that everyone warning Daniel about treating the young girl in Owenduffy was leading up to something much bigger and worse than simply becoming the doctor for over there. I kinda feel like there should have been a conflict of some kind, and there wasn't any.
Anyways, it was a delightful book to wile away time in between a few heavier reads I'm attempting to finish. And I met a new author . . . whose books will quickly be read, I am sure.
Without knowing anything about this author, I was intrigued by her books at the library. Musical titles, medical themes, history . . . yes, yes, and yes. So I chose this one stand-alone book as my introduction to her.
I enjoyed her writing style. I enjoyed the descriptiveness. I enjoyed the tone and the people and the characters as they came to life. The romance was sweet, subtle, and barely there, for the most part. There were two kisses in this book, not detailed, and it left me saying "aww!" and not closing the book in a hurry.
The romance, though, is also why I gave this one only three stars. This guy in the book is obsessed with a girl. He uses the term "crush", and it got a bit annoying. I mean, he's making his decisions based on the whims and fancies of this girl who seems to be playing on him, and who, by the way, seemed to be EXTREMELY selfish. I was VERY surprised, later in the book, when I read that she thought it was going somewhere. I mean . . . ?? I felt it was a case of only-single-guy-knows-only-one-single-girl -- and there was nothing but relief when she finally decided to move to a different town.
The *real* romance was sweet -- it grew, not of obsession, but through working together. Through hard work, long nights, and praying and worrying together. And that, my friends, is what love should be based on. Getting to know the real person, when all guards are down and we can see each other for who we really are.
The religious aspect comes across cleanly, if a bit weak. it wasn't just thrown in there, as I've seen in other books, but it definitely wasn't the strongest part of the book. I mean, the doctor attends church every Sunday, and he prays for his patients, but I'd like to see a bit more of his Christianity lived out in his life. I mean, he was a morally good person and made good decisions, by all means, and I can't say he acted in a sinful way. But maybe he should have prayed about Serena instead of obsessing over her? I don't know if that even makes sense, at all -- and it might just have been me, personally.
One other issue I had was the more modern attitudes and actions and speech of the characters. It's 1869. Just a few years after the War between the States. But it felt more like the early 1900's, and every time he'd mention the war, I was surprised to find it had happened such a short time ago. Historical fiction should stay as historically accurate as possible! Another reason for the three star rating. There were a few inconsistencies with a few of the characters, as well. The time line kept changing -- did Daniel leave Ireland sixteen years ago, or eighteen years ago? And what is the mine owners name, after all? And I felt that everyone warning Daniel about treating the young girl in Owenduffy was leading up to something much bigger and worse than simply becoming the doctor for over there. I kinda feel like there should have been a conflict of some kind, and there wasn't any.
Anyways, it was a delightful book to wile away time in between a few heavier reads I'm attempting to finish. And I met a new author . . . whose books will quickly be read, I am sure.
October 4, 2018
Last year I read a series by B.J. Hoff with the hero in this story as a child. It was so nice to read about him as an adult. Daniel Kavanagh moved to Mount Laurel after the Civil War and opened up his medical practice. There he met Addie Rose, a local miners daughter. He was infatuated with the local school teacher, but things were a little iffy with Miss Serena Norman. After the doctor for the nearby mining company was fired for being drunk all the time, Daniel agreed to help doctor the miners and families of Owenduffy one day a week until another doctor could be found.
This is were he met Addie Rose and found she was a wiz with patients and when Daniel's receptionist retired suddenly, he hired Addie Rose, who accepted the job readily. Daniel and Addie Rose got along well together and soon Daniel started thinking more about Addie Rose than Serena. This was confusing to Daniel and he decided to keep his feelings to himself.
If you want to find out more about Daniel, Serena, Addie Rose and the town folk of Mount Laurel and Owenduffy, pick up a copy and read it for yourself. There are several more memorable characters in this book. Some mystery and intrigue and lots of love. This is a clean and well written book and I believe you will like it as much as I have. Enjoy!
I borrowed this book from my local library and have given this review voluntarily.
This is were he met Addie Rose and found she was a wiz with patients and when Daniel's receptionist retired suddenly, he hired Addie Rose, who accepted the job readily. Daniel and Addie Rose got along well together and soon Daniel started thinking more about Addie Rose than Serena. This was confusing to Daniel and he decided to keep his feelings to himself.
If you want to find out more about Daniel, Serena, Addie Rose and the town folk of Mount Laurel and Owenduffy, pick up a copy and read it for yourself. There are several more memorable characters in this book. Some mystery and intrigue and lots of love. This is a clean and well written book and I believe you will like it as much as I have. Enjoy!
I borrowed this book from my local library and have given this review voluntarily.
February 20, 2018
What can be better than curling up on a cold winter’s day with a sweet, gentle, Christian Historical Fiction novel entitled “Harp on the Willow”? I know, not much could beat that, right!? Written by BJ Hoff and published by Harvest House in January of 2018, this sweet book takes readers on a pleasant visit to a small town named Mount Laurel, and reveals some of the stories held within the hearts of its residents - in particular of Dr. Daniel Kavanagh and his many patients.
I enjoyed “Harp on the Willow” largely in part due to the unique, quirky, personable characters who inhabited its pages with typical small-town-everybody-knows-everybody’s-business. The romance of the story was also sweet, but did feel unexplainably rushed at the end, leaving me asking, “How did that happen?”. Several thought-provoking themes, such as cultural prejudice, abuse, and the heartache of dementia add depth and help round out the storyline.
Overall, while “Harp on the Willow” did not make my top favorite list of Historical Fiction, it was a sweet and rather endearing story. BJ Hoff has crafted a pleasant novel that is perfect to enjoy while sipping tea or munching popcorn on a snowy afternoon.
This book was provided courtesy of Harvest House Publishers, in exchange for my honest review.
I enjoyed “Harp on the Willow” largely in part due to the unique, quirky, personable characters who inhabited its pages with typical small-town-everybody-knows-everybody’s-business. The romance of the story was also sweet, but did feel unexplainably rushed at the end, leaving me asking, “How did that happen?”. Several thought-provoking themes, such as cultural prejudice, abuse, and the heartache of dementia add depth and help round out the storyline.
Overall, while “Harp on the Willow” did not make my top favorite list of Historical Fiction, it was a sweet and rather endearing story. BJ Hoff has crafted a pleasant novel that is perfect to enjoy while sipping tea or munching popcorn on a snowy afternoon.
This book was provided courtesy of Harvest House Publishers, in exchange for my honest review.
June 14, 2018
I liked this story about a small-town doctor, his medical practice and the two women he's interested in who couldn't be more different. It was interesting to see what the medical practices were like during the 1860s in America. It was also sad to see what the justice system was like then, too, as men who beat their wives weren't usually punished. I felt for him as it would have been hard to treat women who you couldn't really help. I liked how much he cared about others and put them first, even to the detriment of himself. He had a strong relationship with the Lord and prayed often. One thing I thought was odd was that he prayed for two deceased people and he wasn't Catholic. I also liked the moments of humor as Daniel could be pretty amusing when he wanted to be. There were a few romantic moments but the scene I was really waiting for took place off page, so I was disappointed at the seeming build-up. I would recommend this story if you like historical fiction.
I received a copy of this book from Harvest House Publishers. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. This is my honest opinion.
I received a copy of this book from Harvest House Publishers. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. This is my honest opinion.
January 17, 2018
"Daniel Kavanagh, MD, was given to defining a good day as one when the elderly and somewhat eccentric Miss Gladys Piper had no more than one imaginary disease that required treatment during her office visit."
Set in the Potomac Highlands of West Virginia 1869, this is the story of hard work, loss, love, heartbreak and fear. Dr. Daniel is back from the Civil War, determined to make a difference in the lives of the people of Mountain Laurel. He succeeds for the whole town loves their local doctor. But when the nearby mining town of Owenduffy needs medical care, Daniel is encouraged not to attend 'those people'. He soon finds a capable assistant in Miss Addie Rose, resident of the mining town, and plows ahead, tending to whomever needs medical care.
Rich in descriptions of the land thereabout and full of interesting characters, this one is sure to please many readers who love a long saga by Hoff.
*My thanks to the publishers for this preview copy. All opinions are my own.
Set in the Potomac Highlands of West Virginia 1869, this is the story of hard work, loss, love, heartbreak and fear. Dr. Daniel is back from the Civil War, determined to make a difference in the lives of the people of Mountain Laurel. He succeeds for the whole town loves their local doctor. But when the nearby mining town of Owenduffy needs medical care, Daniel is encouraged not to attend 'those people'. He soon finds a capable assistant in Miss Addie Rose, resident of the mining town, and plows ahead, tending to whomever needs medical care.
Rich in descriptions of the land thereabout and full of interesting characters, this one is sure to please many readers who love a long saga by Hoff.
*My thanks to the publishers for this preview copy. All opinions are my own.
February 8, 2018
Harp on the Willow
by BJ Hoff
Harvest House Publishers
Christian , Historical Fiction
Pub Date 06 Feb 2018
I am reviewing a copy of Harp on the Willow through Harvest House Publishers and Netgalley:
1869 West Virginia three years prior Dr Daniel Kavanagh settled in the quaint town of Mount Laurel where he established a medical practice. Daniel Kavanagh is a single doctor with a crush on the local school teacher Serena Norman.
Just down the road from Mount Laurel is the mining town of Owenduffy, when the company doctor abandons his post. Daniel agrees to visit one day a week, much to the consternation of the fellow residents including his secret love Serena.
Addie Rose the daughter of a Coal Miner has a gift for caring for others. When a receptionist position in Daniel's office suddenly becomes available, what the windows of opportunity will open for Addie Rose just a job or something more.
I give Harp on the Willow five out of five stars!
Happy Reading
1869 West Virginia three years prior Dr Daniel Kavanagh settled in the quaint town of Mount Laurel where he established a medical practice. Daniel Kavanagh is a single doctor with a crush on the local school teacher Serena Norman.
Just down the road from Mount Laurel is the mining town of Owenduffy, when the company doctor abandons his post. Daniel agrees to visit one day a week, much to the consternation of the fellow residents including his secret love Serena.
Addie Rose the daughter of a Coal Miner has a gift for caring for others. When a receptionist position in Daniel's office suddenly becomes available, what the windows of opportunity will open for Addie Rose just a job or something more.
I give Harp on the Willow five out of five stars!
Happy Reading
February 8, 2018
I've always loved B.J. Hoff's writing. Poignant and down to earth come to mind. Also, faith is embedded in the whole story that naturally seeps to the surface rather than in-your-face. Wholesome reading!
Dr. Daniel, a bachelor doctor in a small town in the late 1800s, is a wonderful character fully developed. I would have thought, though, that more mommas would have been pushing their daughters at him, except for a certain dainty woman who has captured his attention. There's a scruffy mining town across the bridge that needs Dr. Daniel's attention, where he meets Addie Rose. So there you've got a good mix for a really good story--don't forget the dog :)
Well-developed story line, great premise, well-developed characters, and an explosion. Can't beat it for a great, rainy day read.
Five of five stars.
Dr. Daniel, a bachelor doctor in a small town in the late 1800s, is a wonderful character fully developed. I would have thought, though, that more mommas would have been pushing their daughters at him, except for a certain dainty woman who has captured his attention. There's a scruffy mining town across the bridge that needs Dr. Daniel's attention, where he meets Addie Rose. So there you've got a good mix for a really good story--don't forget the dog :)
Well-developed story line, great premise, well-developed characters, and an explosion. Can't beat it for a great, rainy day read.
Five of five stars.
March 11, 2018
Harp On The Willow is one of my favor authors that I have been reading for a very long time. The author tends to leave a piece of themselves on the pages they write. This book is one of deep love 0 love for their work, love for others, love for that very special one and love for the LORD 0 Amen? how could you beat all that love you have Daniel who is a Doctor on the right side of town per se and the miners and Addie Rose on the wrong side per se . Will Daniel choose the right or wrong woman for him? Is the right girl from the wrong side? This is a special book - so enjoyable, tender yet exciting. I received a copy of this book from the Publisher and Netgalley; all the opinions expressed in this review are all my own.
If you would like to read more of my Christian book reviews go to christianlybookreviewers.blogspot.com
If you would like to read more of my Christian book reviews go to christianlybookreviewers.blogspot.com
July 7, 2018
The story was good, but...the ending drove me crazy! And so did the title and cover. I don't know what the quote, the book, and the locket had to do with the story.
Back to the ending. SPOILER ALERT: Daniel had to recover from exhaustion. But he went back to work without changing! Didn't he learn anything?! Then he and Addie Rose had all this tension: What is he thinking? What is she thinking? Should I let the other him/her know? The ending glossed over everything! It skipped the DTR conversation and jumped to their getting engaged days later. Really?! Did he ask the father for permission? Daniel and Dom had a challenging relationship--how did that conversation go? It felt like this lovely story unfolding and the author was allowed only two pages to wrap things up.
Back to the ending. SPOILER ALERT: Daniel had to recover from exhaustion. But he went back to work without changing! Didn't he learn anything?! Then he and Addie Rose had all this tension: What is he thinking? What is she thinking? Should I let the other him/her know? The ending glossed over everything! It skipped the DTR conversation and jumped to their getting engaged days later. Really?! Did he ask the father for permission? Daniel and Dom had a challenging relationship--how did that conversation go? It felt like this lovely story unfolding and the author was allowed only two pages to wrap things up.
February 16, 2018
I had never read any of B.J. Hoff's books before, but I was pleasantly pleased with this one. I admit the cover drew me as the first thing, and then I steadily fell into the life of Dr. Daniel Kavanagh. I enjoyed being an observer of his life, and watching as he defines his feelings for the local school teacher. I really did enjoy this book. Though some say that this book seemed to end too quickly, I felt more like it was everything happening all at once to Daniel, much like we sometimes may encounter in our own life. And I think that through that he realized that he needed to come to truth with his self and his feelings that have came to light in his life.
July 27, 2019
Not much happens in this novel, but sometimes that's alright. This is a well-written, easygoing piece of fiction. I wish 1860s Mount Laurel, West Virginia, were a real place, and that I could somehow get there and meet these warm characters. Some subplots were unnecessarily stretched out, and I would have liked more chapters from Addie Rose's perspective (to get to know her character better), but I can't complain beyond that. A nice piece of biblical historical fiction to satisfy that particular tooth.
August 19, 2019
I've enjoyed prior books by this author, and wanted to give this one a try.
It's a homey, rather cozy, historical fiction novel.
You will meet Dr. Daniel Kavanaugh, an eligible bachelor in the small town of Mountain Laurel.
This is the story of how he lives in that small town, doctors his neighbors, tries to keep the peace with the people across the river in a mining town. And about his love life.
Not too much action, but an intriguing story line.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
It's a homey, rather cozy, historical fiction novel.
You will meet Dr. Daniel Kavanaugh, an eligible bachelor in the small town of Mountain Laurel.
This is the story of how he lives in that small town, doctors his neighbors, tries to keep the peace with the people across the river in a mining town. And about his love life.
Not too much action, but an intriguing story line.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
August 11, 2020
I thoroughly enjoyed this read by B.J. Hoff set just after the Civil War in West Virginia. The principal characters are Dr. Daniel Kavanagh, an army veteran of the war who has settled in Mount Laurel just across the valley from the coal mining town of Owenduffy. He has a romantic interest, Serena who is a school teacher.
The story revolves around Daniel, the town and his patients on both sides of the valley. With all the interest in equality, acceptance and the like these days, this story will engage you and cause you to consider "those" people that may be in your life.
The story revolves around Daniel, the town and his patients on both sides of the valley. With all the interest in equality, acceptance and the like these days, this story will engage you and cause you to consider "those" people that may be in your life.
July 7, 2024
Setting: West Virginia I read this book as part of my challenge to read clean fiction books with settings in all 50 states. This story follows the life of a Doctor around the time period of 1869 in both a regular town and a poor coal mining town. It was really well written, but I found some of the subject matter to drag until I had read about 75% of the book. Then it got much more interesting.
April 6, 2022
I absolutely loved this book!! It was set in the mountains of West Virginia. It is about a young doctor who came there under sad circumstances but feels at home and decides to stay. There are many colorful characters and of course a romance. Life in the mountains is often hard but it's rewarding. Read this book!! You won't be sorry!!
March 17, 2019
A Heart Warming Story
I just fell in love with all the characters in this book and the town of Mt Laurel. Can’t wait to read the rest of the series to find out what happens to Daniel & Abbie Rose. Prejudices were as common back then as they are today but love always wins the day.
I just fell in love with all the characters in this book and the town of Mt Laurel. Can’t wait to read the rest of the series to find out what happens to Daniel & Abbie Rose. Prejudices were as common back then as they are today but love always wins the day.
December 14, 2017
I enjoyed this book very much.
From the coal town to the more affluent "normal" town, the characters and relationships were beautifully woven together.
I would love to visit Mt. Laurel!
From the coal town to the more affluent "normal" town, the characters and relationships were beautifully woven together.
I would love to visit Mt. Laurel!
January 4, 2018
Harp on the Willow is the first book from Mt. Laurel Memories series. I loved this story and can not wait for the second installment of the series. 5+ stars.
February 2, 2018
Dr. Daniel Kavanagh is a caring busy doctor in Mt Laurel. He finally hires a capable nurse assistant who soon becomes much more.
March 16, 2018
This was such a great read!! It was hard for me to put the book down & do the things I was s'posed to be doing! If you enjoy historical Christian fiction, this is a definite "must read" for you!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews