2.4
This book started out like something I was really up for: a simple and fun fantasy novel full of magic and adventure. Rina seemed like a good protagonist too as she’s competent, but a little naïve, leaving room for success while still learning from her adventures. Then there was what seemed like a pretty fun and straight-forward plot structure involving traveling to different ink mages to gain powers with hopes of preparing to fight back against those who have wronged her family, a structure almost like a RPG with the sense of progress checked off by each power-up along the way with the added cool factor of new abilities.
Unfortunately, these aspects were bogged down significantly by a couple factors: (1) forced grimdark and "gritty" fantasy clichés; and (2) the serial structure of the story that was later compiled into a book without modification (at least as I understand it), which causes the plotting and pacing to feel very all over the place.
There is lots of sex throughout the book, to the point it feels like a TV show looking for ratings by throwing in some gratuitous nudity at least once per episode. The fact this was initially a serial makes me think this explanation might be more accurate than I might’ve otherwise thought. There are also plenty of soldier characters whose whole life (and existence in the novel) seems to revolve around raping and whoring (and assumedly fighting on occasion I guess). A lot of the sex is fairly gross and not much of it seems 100% consensual. The worst part is that none of it felt like it fit the rest of the story at all. It’s totally okay if a story isn’t some representation of every harsh reality imaginable in the setting. This is especially true when other aspects of the story feel romanticized with little real explanation (ie, how loyal and committed the common people are to their former duke when the invaders haven’t treated them all that poorly and the duke wasn’t especially benevolent. I’m not sure why these common people cared as if they were some loyal knights carrying out their oaths). It would’ve been one thing if the sexual detours were just every now and then, but there are a lot in this book, especially with the villain whose chapters are mostly just sex scenes. His POV could’ve been cut entirely and the book would’ve been much stronger. None of the sex scenes comported with Rina’s narrative and generally came in through other POVs that were barely relevant, if at all. This also led to the book having way more POVs than it needed. It’s as if after starting the story, the author decided to go in a totally different direction but wasn’t able to make the rest of it consistent with those goals.
The main plot follows a somewhat sheltered girl whose ability to solve problems mostly comes from her fighting skills and her status as a duchess. And I liked that setup with a strong and competent young woman who is generally respected instead of the typical cliché of her being looked down upon as a noble woman picking up a sword. Those stories are important, but there are so many of them already. Instead, I was looking forward to a story about a chick who just kicks some ass without dealing with a bunch of criticism for existing. In my opinion, the book delivers on this, but only very occasionally. In part, this is because despite escaping some of those clichés, basically every man Rina meets wants to get with her, even when they’re decades older than her. That makes some sense given her status, but at parts like these, I often forgot she’s even vaguely competent as much of her character tends to fall by the wayside for this middle segment of the book.
Some plot points didn’t make much sense, especially in the character motivation department. I didn’t mind too much at first as those motivations weren’t essential to the real force of the story, but it didn’t help a book that was already struggling in a lot of other areas. There were some questionable decisions as well that seemed based more on plot convenience than logic, for instance, trying to become an ink mage to single-handedly fight back against an invasion instead of going to your king for help against the invading force that’s taken over an entire duchy under his protection.
I see a lot of praise in other reviews for the magic system, but while it had some cool factor to it, it’s barely much of a “system” as there are few rules beyond the basic metaphysical explanations and the fact Rina’s powers depend on getting magical tattoos. They just sort of let her “do stuff.” Cool stuff here and there, but there’s not much discussion of costs, limitations, or resources that might make the magic more interesting. It was functional and still enjoyable given the aesthetic and I think it works well for the style of the book, but a “magic system” isn’t something I’d specifically praise the book for.
Overall, I thought this book was pretty flawed. It does have some really cool ideas and I find aspects of the overarching plot inspiring, but ultimately I have a hard time bumping my rating up too much. Simply because of that inspiration, I might continue onto the next book with hopes that it has less repetitive erotica, but I’ll be going in with pretty low expectations and looking at it as a book I’ll just zone out to. Plus, it's on Kindle Unlimited, so it won't cost me anything. Otherwise I might not bother.