Compared to the first two books in the series, The Pool is (so far) my favorite.
Nightmare Inn set the tone and Room 13 carried on with it, but the third entry pulled off what you expect from YA Horror. If your expectations are gory deaths and grisly fates and downer endings, that macabre trifecta, this is it.
There are also now characters to actually care about.
Still continuity between the books as the latest part of the New Arcadia's older history is shared.
Kelly Schneider is the head lifeguard of the New Arcadia Inn for the summer, a job to help pay for college tuition. She didn't remember applying for this certain hotel but assumes that one of the many other places she applied to recommended her.
She arrives late at night in the middle of nowhere and is guided there by Martin, teen activities director. Kelly will be in charge of four other lifeguards: Chip, Eric, Claire and Tiffany. Chip develops quite the crush on Kelly, but her eyes are set on Nick, a non-lifeguard who has made friends with the others in the four days before Kelly's arrival.
Tiffany seems to be really into Nick as well and not very enthusiastic that he seems to be interested in Kelly. Eric and Chip state that Nick is a man of mystery as he won't open up a lot of information about himself.
When a pipe to the filtration system bursts near the outdoor pool, Kelly and Nick rush out to shut the system off. Crossing the soggy ground, Kelly's foot seems to be stuck and when she goes to free herself...it feels as if a skeletal hand is wrapped about her ankle.
The next morning, Kelly goes with Nick to try and find if there is a skeleton buried underground before the crew comes to repair the pipeline. Kelly finds a bracelet with the name Laura spelled out with white beads. Nick begins to snoop around in the files and Kelly learns he is here to discover the answer to a dark family secret.
Soon, the pool is refilled and open to the public, yet the water is cloudy and murky.
Some guests in their late forties or early fifties are talking at their table one morning while Kelly and Nick are having breakfast. Mention is made that there was a drowning accident where a girl drowned but they never...found her body. This is when the horror really begins, and it goes after the lifeguards one...by one.
The only reason I didn't give The Pool five stars is because the climax starts high and then dips low into an ending which is tragic yet...hollow somehow. Probably because I actually liked most of the characters and the previous books had characters who were awful people.
Kelly was serious about her lifeguard job and keeping the guests safe while poor Nick was there for a good reason. Eric and Tiffany were kind of annoying yet not awful and Claire and Chip didn't really get any definition that was enough to make you hate them. The employees of the New Arcadia Inn and what is behind it...are still the main reasons to read the Nightmare Inn series.
So, the question is...will it rate five-star service or fail miserably?