McScotch himself describes his book and pays tribute to a colleague in this note, which appears at the front of the volume:
“This book consists of the reminiscences of an ordinary fighter pilot of the R.F.C. who had the privilege of serving in one of the leading Fighter Squadrons and who had the honor of being the friend of the supreme fighter of all the Air Forces, that indomitable and lovable patriot, ‘MICK’ MANNOCK, V.C., D.S.O., M.C.”
Available records and publications show “McScotch” himself as a fighter pilot with 40 Squadron, holding the rank of lieutenant and then captain. He is credited with 12 kills of German opponents.
This is a detailed and exciting account of squadron life and shows the bravery and true comradeship of these flyers.
Originally published in 1936, "FIGHTER PILOT" is McScotch's recounting the highlights of his service on the Western Front between May and December 1917 as a fighter pilot with 40 Squadron of the Royal Flying Corps (RFC).
This is a book that reveals much of the stresses, thrills, and perils of being a combat pilot, in addition to the relationships among squadron mates and ground crews who kept the planes flying. McScotch (his real name is William MacLanachan, a Scot) sheds considerable light on the relationship he had with Edward 'Mick' Mannock, who would go on to become Britain's top fighter ace of the First World War.
One of the most revealing missions McScotch describes took place deep inside the German lines. He was part of a flight of Nieuport fighters (later 40 Squadron would be equipped with the faster and better armed S.E.5A fighter, which did require some 'breaking in' owing to defective engines and armament - problems that were eventually remedied) that attacked a flight of German planes above an airfield. The attack was skillfully carried out, so much so that the entire enemy flight was shot down. What became clear to the pilots in McScotch's flight (including Mannock) was that the German planes were unarmed! Indeed, the German crews were trainee aviators. The realization only hit home after the attack had been carried out. So it was that upon returning to base, McScotch and his fellow pilots made an agreement among themselves that none of them would put in a claim for a kill because each pilot felt that what they had done --- even though perfectly legitimate under wartime conditions --- had amounted to murder.
McScotch was fortunate to have survived at the Front for as long as he had. Most RFC pilots that were sent to France at that stage of the war were lucky to last 3 weeks before being wounded, killed, or becoming a POW. The RFC had a policy of aggressively pursuing the enemy on his side of the lines. That explains why a lot of the air combat on the Western Front often took place above the trenches and deep behind the German lines.
Mannock would later return to France (this time in command of his own squadron) and would be killed in action in July 1918. As for McScotch (who was credited with shooting down 7 German planes), he states that "events happened which prevented my returning to France." I wish he would have gone on to describe what those events were.
"FIGHTER PILOT" is one of the best First World War pilot memoirs I've read. It gives the reader a palpable and poignant feel for what life at the Front was really like for a combat pilot.
Without doubt the best book I've ever read on aerial warfare over the Western Front.
Penned by someone who experienced it, it excudes a credibility that's almost visceral. It refutes so much of the 'armchair' historians' opinions by injecting a lived truth.
Excellent read,thoroughly enjoyed. Recommend all budding service personnel should read this. A factual proof of how Britain constantly sends people to war poorly equipped,under supported yet expects miracles...usually delivered but at what personal cost....
I enjoyed this book very much. The writer, 'McScotch' reminisces about the day to day life of British pilots in World War I, flying behind the German lines in France. He details the extraordinary exploits of Irishman 'Mick' Mannock, the supreme fighter of all the Air Forces, describing him as 'an indominable and lovable patriot'. The heartfelt character studies of the men were interesting and saddening, especially when they did not make it back. The reader also feels a similar sadness for the German boys, who went down in flames. The author tells of the pilot's superstitions. It was bad luck to play the piano in the mess. It seemed that those who did, were not likely to live through the week. It was bad luck to fly with a 'leave slip' in your back pocket and similarly to have your photo taken with your best friends.
This book is a well-written description of the Air War over France. The perspective from a British pilot and his observations is unique. The action sequences are descriptive and the pilots relations to one another are revealing
Five stars because this book ( biographical I assume), is an eye opener as well as an excellent read. Telling the history of the early years of the fighter pilots and the sometimes inferior machines they used & still proved superior t o the enemy.
Although a Google search suggests that the author wasn't as much in Mannock's circle as he claims, it is still interesting to read a historical account of WW1 fighter pilots.