Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Double Life of a Serial Murderer: The Life of Serial Killer Herb Baumeister

Rate this book
Westfield, Indiana is a quiet suburb of Indianapolis, among other equally quiet Indy suburbs with names such as Carmel, Zionsville, and Fishers. The gay nightclubs of the suburb were the kind of places where members of Indy’s LGBT community would come to unwind, relax, and feel at ease.

But it was these same havens of acceptance and community that became the disturbed man’s favorite hunting grounds. He would lure young men into his car and then on to his million dollar estate where he would wine and dine the unsuspecting victims before strangling them to death. However, Herb Baumeister would ultimately commit suicide before answering for his crimes or even explaining to the larger world why he did what he did.

Many psychoanalysts have poured over the behavior of this twisted man to create quite a startling portrait. According to them, Herb Baumeister appeared to be a man who felt himself better than most. It has been presumed that it was this feeling of omniscience that led Baumeister to believe that he could do things that others could not.

Only he was cunning enough to live a double life, with both components safely compartmentalized and separate, without a soul knowing. Only he could navigate through the complex worlds of business, society, and family, while simultaneously hunting other human beings like animals. Baumeister believed that while most others were caught for their misdeeds, only he could get away with murder.

Read on your favorite devices such as Kindle, IPhone, IPad, Android cellular phone, tablet, laptop, or computer with Amazon's free reading Kindle App.

86 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 5, 2017

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jack Smith

48 books28 followers
Biographer and recorder of the history of serial killers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
28 (35%)
4 stars
24 (30%)
3 stars
16 (20%)
2 stars
9 (11%)
1 star
3 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews
Profile Image for Dan.
4,259 reviews796 followers
September 8, 2023
“His name was Herb Baumeister, a man who would never admit to being gay himself, yet who spent the better part of ten years secretly collecting scores of young gay men for his own selfish, sexual fetishes.”


In the early 1990s, terror strikes the gay community of Indianapolis, Indiana.

Herb Baumeister hid behind a seemingly-successful façade of family life in the Indianapolis suburbs burb by day. But by night, he stalked vulnerable gay men. He would eventually strangle them to death.

Herb worked at a middle management position at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles. Shortly after marriage, Herb was institutionalized for several months; diagnosed with a compulsive disorder.

The catalyst to breaking open the case was Virgil Vandagriff, a private investigator hired by the family of victim Roger Allan Goodlet.

Mark Goodyear also survived Herb’s attack—and was invaluable to the investigation that led to Herb’s capture.

The homophobia in Indiana caused many delays and mistakes. Mark Goodyear was not taken seriously for way too long; the cops were more interested in his recreational drug use than his being a victim of attempted murder.

It still remains questionable that Julie Baumeister was impervious to Herb’s…extracurricular activities. While the two were hardly a romantic couple, her children literally dug up multiple sets of human remains on their sprawling property.

As the walls closed in on Herb, he committed suicide. In a letter, he apologized for many things in his life—except for the murders of all of the young gay men.

The property of Fox Hollow Run, Herb and Julie’s enormous estate, remains haunted to this day—literally. There have been countless sightings and experiences with the apparitions of the young men slain there. The Sci-Fi channel even did a documentary on the haunted property, in 2012.
Profile Image for Carlton Phelps.
603 reviews10 followers
May 30, 2025
Mr. Smith researches his subjects.
The details about Mr. Baumeister are so thorough that I could feel my skin crawl when he would go out looking for his next victim.
The victims were young homosexual men whom he would pick up at local gay hangouts. It was thought that Baumeister was a closeted homosexual.
He was harmless-looking and unassuming.
He and his family lived in an exclusive neighborhood that he could hardly afford. He owned a string of thrift stores and made good money, but not enough to afford the estate in which he and his family lived.
The police were slow to respond to the missing men because they were over 21 and homosexual.
Things started to unravel when a person lived after he was attacked and could give the police a description of Baumeister and a vague description of the house.
Baumeister buried his victims on his property. One day, his son, playing in the woods, found a skull and gave it to his mother. And his home life started to unravel.
Great read for those who like true crime.
Profile Image for Bettye McKee.
2,201 reviews157 followers
August 22, 2017
An intriguing case study

Not much information is available concerning Herb Baumeister and his crimes, and now will never be known. Therefore, much of this book is about the investigation, the search for the serial killer responsible for the disappearance of of young gay men.

Baumeister was never arrested for the murders, never tried, never convicted, never sent to prison for his crimes. In fact, no one knows how many victims there were. Baumeister apparently saw the writing on the wall and took his own life, leaving his victims' loved ones with no hope of justice.

40
Profile Image for Allen.
53 reviews
December 26, 2019
This book reads more like a short overview of the case. I was hoping to be drawn in with some character development of at least a few of the victims. This is a quick read of mostly case facts, and not much "story" to scare, terrify or endear you to someone that would ultimately fall victim to this man. I guess I should stop holding every true crime book to the standards of In Cold Blood.
Profile Image for Sandra Burns.
1,837 reviews46 followers
June 17, 2019
Good, short read plus a bonus book

Man who is married, and owned a chain of thrift stores, hid his secret life. A closet homosexual, he went to bars to pick up men. He killed them.
15 reviews1 follower
June 14, 2021
Amazing life of a businessman

Good true story about a man no one would suspect as a serial killer.He had a family and business to hide his murderous life
28 reviews
January 3, 2023
Good Read

This made my second time reading about this person from another author, just wanted to compare. This was written differently. I enjoyed it very much.
Profile Image for Shannyn Martin.
159 reviews7 followers
January 26, 2023
I recommend this over the other Baumeister book, "You Think You Know Me," as it contains a lot more lesser known, factual details about Baumeister, his family and his victims.
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews