Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

What Should've Been

Rate this book
He was her best friend growing up and she grew to love him, but never said a word, not wanting to lose his friendship.

When Ronnie moved into town and he fell in love, she relegated herself to the permanent friend zone, choosing to be the third wheel in the relationship.

Her love was so strong for them both that when they found out Ronnie couldn't have children, she became their surrogate.

Then tragedy struck and she was left alone, pregnant and grieving. When Jude, Ronnie's older brother, steps in, she finds something she never thought she would have - her own forever love.

This book is rated for 18 years of age and older. There is some sexual content.
This is an HEA with no cliffhanger.

253 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 9, 2017

72 people are currently reading
73 people want to read

About the author

Liberty Parker

159 books613 followers
I have been an avid reader for most of my life. When I was younger I used to sit and fill spiral notebooks full of stories. As I got older, I took the jobs needed for raising my boys as a single mom, until I met my now amazing husband. I have stopped working in the last three years and started promoting authors, then I blogged and reviewed for authors, which lead me down the path to writing and creating characters and stories. I love creating behind the scenes with my writing getting to use my imagination and write the story as it comes to me. My youngest is now a senior in High School leaving me with some spare time on my hands to be filled. I am loving the people I am meeting and the support system I have found. You can find me at my home Facebook page here: https://www.facebook.com/authorlibert... or you can like my Author page at: https://www.facebook.com/authorlibert... or join my Lady Outlaws at:https://www.facebook.com/groups/Liber...

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
64 (56%)
4 stars
24 (21%)
3 stars
18 (15%)
2 stars
5 (4%)
1 star
2 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews
114 reviews1 follower
October 27, 2019
Sweet love story

Felicity Holden and Ronnie had been best friends forever, but Holden and Ronnie fell in love. Felicity agreed to be their surrogate when Ronnie could not have a baby. Ronnie does in a tragic accident and Holden falls apart, leaving Felicity to lean and fall for Jude. Jude is sweet, strong, and knows he wants to take care of Felicity and the baby. Great stand alone romance.
Profile Image for Shannon .
475 reviews3 followers
December 22, 2017
Amazing emotional journey through grief,feelings of betrayal, survival and love..when everything that was planned falls apart AND blame is thrown what do you do? Jude is one of the best characters I've ever read about!! Dont want to spoil anything but well just do yourself a favor and get this book!!?
Profile Image for Jamie Ellis.
1,131 reviews15 followers
July 10, 2017
Devoured it!!!!

This book was an awesome read. The storyline was fast paced, hot sex scenes, angsty and full of love. I am not going to go into detail on this review because I think you need to go in with no misconceptions or ideas on what to expect. I think you as a reader need to experience the beauty of which this book was written. I am in love with Jude a little bout myself, and I think you all will be too after reading this book. I actually had to contact Liberty before reading this book because I was kind of scared at first the circumstance and premise of the synopsis. She explained it to me a little without giving to much away and I am so glad that I read this beautiful book.
So thank you Liberty for writing this book.
Thanks Jamie Nibarger Ellis
Profile Image for Sue.
1,945 reviews25 followers
September 8, 2018
OMG such a sad and yet uplifting story. I laughed, I cried and kept trying to figure out what would happen next. The characters in this book were just like anyone you might encounter in your everyday life...except there was some deep, darkness inside some of them that made them more than just what we see on the surface.
I loved Jude...he was almost too good to be true...but every story needs that good guy who will do anything to protect his family and love.
I haven't read too much by this author (except for some biker books which are my fave) and this is a contemporary romance which is different but take a chance if you like angsty family drama with a bit of suspense and danger as well.

**** 4 **** "he was all in" stars
2,617 reviews25 followers
October 9, 2017
this book was awesome! it had me in tears in parts of it. its about two best friends that grow up together . only she has feelings beyond friendship for him. a new girl comes into the picture that has captured his heart. they marry and decide to have a family . only she finds out she cant have kids. so the best friend carries the baby for her. a accident happens that leaves this poor woman alone until the brother comes along to help her raise the child.
Profile Image for Kim Richards.
1,338 reviews7 followers
November 18, 2017
Brilliant

I absolutely loved this book.
I was really into it by the end of the first chapter. I laughed, I got frustrated and yes I cried, then repeated all again not necessarily in that order.
There are twists, turns and surprises throughout the story, I got a shock with one of the surprises I never saw it coming.
This is the first Liberty Parker book I have read, but I will be reading more of her books. So worth the 5 stars I have given it and I highly recommend this book.
Profile Image for Victoria Bolin.
31 reviews
May 28, 2019
Good plot but...

I really liked the plot of this story. It’s a new one to me. I feel like the book wasn’t very well written. There are several errors in grammar and spelling that the author should look back over. And I feel like it lacked detail. Details that make me feel drawn into the book, like I’m part of the story. It was a very good plot and would be a wonderful book with some revisions.
222 reviews4 followers
July 13, 2019
It was a ROLLERCOASTER of epic proportions, sad, funny, suspense, all in one. Had to keep rising just to see what was gonna happen next, and the twists it would take made you want to read more and quicker. Great standalone read with love, grief, and an alpha Male that will make you fall in love 100 times over.
Profile Image for Rose Helg.
2,899 reviews27 followers
September 2, 2019
Good Book.

First, I want to say, " This is the first time I read her book. " I Love this book. It was Good. The ending was Great. I just had to read just one more chapter, before I went to bed. As it turns out, I finish this book, then I went to bed. I will definitely read more of her books. Good Book.
Profile Image for Cynthia Carpenter.
1,674 reviews15 followers
October 29, 2019
This book is a journey of Felicity and Jude and their heartbreakingly, painfull, romantic, hot and steamy read of two people who lose what they love the most and figuring out how to live and be what they need to be for each other and a baby. I laughed, cried, and fell for these two characters truly an amazing read. Can't wait to read more.
Profile Image for Teresa Lara.
3,482 reviews53 followers
October 25, 2019
What an amazing beautiful innocent sweet heartstopping love story of Felicity and Jude
So emotional grabbed my heart
1,531 reviews14 followers
September 2, 2020
Fantastic story😂😁

This story was so moving and touching!!!!. It has an interesting, incredibly sad but great storyline. Liberty is an amazing storyteller and PHENOMENAL writer!!!.
Profile Image for Lisa Rittel.
9 reviews
Read
October 28, 2020
A wonderful, heartrending and heartwarming story of unrequited love, friendship and sacrifice.
Keep your tissues handy. You will need them.
Profile Image for Jennifer.
805 reviews19 followers
May 17, 2020
This book starts with Felicity, who has agreed to be surrogate for her two best friends, Ronnie and Holden. When the unthinkable happens, she is consoled by Ronnie's brother, Jude.
Felicity is a sweet, loving woman, who proves to be loyal and giving to her friends, even when it might not be in her best interest. Jude is just as amazing as Felicity, and they totally deserve each other. The two decide to raise the child together, and soon become close friends.
This book had me in tears within the first few chapters, and had me laughing throughout. There were times that my heart started racing, and times when I couldn't believe what had just happened. I was kept guessing from beginning to end (and even after the end!) To me, these are all of the signs of a five star book, that I would definitely recommend to all my friends!

Merged review:

This book starts with Felicity, who has agreed to be surrogate for her two best friends, Ronnie and Holden.  When the unthinkable happens, she is consoled by Ronnie's brother, Jude.  

Felicity is a sweet, loving woman, who proves to be loyal and giving to her friends, even when it might not be in her best interest.  Jude is just as amazing as Felicity, and they totally deserve each other.  The two decide to raise the child together, and soon become close friends. 
This book had me in tears within the first few chapters, and had me laughing throughout.  There were times that my heart started racing, and times when I couldn't believe what had just happened.  I was kept guessing from beginning to end (and even after the end!)  To me, these are all of the signs of a five star book, that I would definitely recommend to all my friends!
Profile Image for Ebony.
672 reviews24 followers
September 27, 2017
I have a new book boyfriend...His name is Jude!!!

OMG!!! This is the first book by Liberty Parker that I have read from start to finish...I am BLOWN AWAY!!! This book was an AMAZING read!!! My heart was broken and put back together right along with Felicity!!! This book started off so sad and by the last sentence, I was smiling!!!

I loved reading the alternating point of views of these amazing and endearing characters!!! I was able to walk away with a more rounded story and feel connections to both of the main characters. This story was well written and hit almost every emotion that I had!!

Liberty Parker has written a book that will stick with me for a really long time!!! It is a perfect read and I really hope that she continues with this series!!! I HIGHLY recommend this book to anyone looking for a great love story!!! You will not be disappointed!!!
Profile Image for Shannon McFadden.
Author 5 books42 followers
September 14, 2017
Such a great book. I couldn't put it down.

Merged review:

Great read

I would recommend this book to anyone, who wants a sweet, sexy, read. It is an emotional rollercoaster, that has a happy ending. This is different than Liberty's normal books, but it is so good!!!
461 reviews3 followers
December 20, 2017
This was different from the normal Liberty Parker books I have read. This was a put the phone in the refrigerator type of cry book to prepare yourself for what was to come. Really enjoyed this book
101 reviews
September 14, 2017
Totally amazing ... I loved this book from beginning to end Liberty outdid herself on this on

Merged review:

Awesome read

I truly loved the story of finding happiness through sadness. I would love to see more stories like this. I would recommend having some tissues around for the happy and sad tears... Liberty you hit this one out of the park.
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.