Okay this volume gets four stars for the epic sword duel during Persia's birthday (epic in terms of shoujo manga, not shounen obviously). I was thrilled to see the stakes meet the seriousness of the situation. I was wondering when the shoe was going to drop when they started dating, and while we have gotten small instances up until this point, this is the first instance where the severity of their relationship came in. I'm glad that Kaneda balanced the serious scenes with funny ones (Cait Sidhe's intro was hilarious) and was willing to take their duel so far considering how early readers are into the series. I also enjoyed seeing Romio take his oath to become a prefect seriously and decide to become a prefect yeoman, despite how boring or possibly degrading it can be. Romio and Juliet's relationship once again shines in this volume and is the brightest part of the series. On that note, I have been holding off doing this, but it is finally time that I address some of the issues I have with the series:
1. The amount of fanservice has been ratcheting up as the series goes on, and while it is not enough to make me stop reading, it is starting to get distracting. I'm starting to wonder whether this is a shoujo manga or a harem series. Again, not enough to make me stop reading, but it got on my nerves sometimes.
2. I mentioned this in my review for the second volume, but way too many of the side characters are boring and one-dimensional. Scott is obsessed with Persia, Somali is obsessed with Aby and is stupid, Maru is a jerk who has become a softy, etc. I'm not exaggerating when I say that most of the side characters never deviate from their chosen personality quirks. The only exceptions I have found so far are Char and Hasuki, and Hasuki is pushing it to be honest.
All my gripes aside, I do still thoroughly enjoy this series. It's fun, the romance is still great, and our heroes have a solid goal to reach now. I'm curious to see how this plot will proceed from here on out, but as long as the romance stays strong, I'm good with anything.