Erynn Mangum is a wonderful storyteller, and she's become one of my all time favorites over the past year. I'd really enjoyed the way she wrapped up the original three books in the Lauren Holbrook series, and I was hopeful that I'd end up feeling the same about this one.
Annie actually ended up surprising me by becoming probably my favorite protagonist of all the books I've read by Erynn. She has such a wonderful heart for Jesus, and I loved how the reader gets to witness her journey from being a loner keeping everything to herself to learning how to let others in, and grow so much in the process.
This book was probably one of the best illustrations of the biblical fact that we are all new creations in Christ; despite what we may be boggled down with from our past. I felt like I was learning this right along with Annie, and it was a heartwarming plot point to watch her trying to come to terms with it.
Annie and Zach's romance was spot on, and is probably also my favorite romance from any of the books. It felt authentic and heartfelt, and definitely gave off all the swoony vibes.
It's no secret that I obviously loved the majority of this story, but two factors kept it from being the five star read I was hoping for.
First, I honestly wish this one had been better edited before it was published. So many discrepancies existed throughout the bulk of the story, and it did get a little irritating after awhile. There were also numerous grammatical and spelling mistakes that grated on my nerves, and it did hinder my enjoyment a bit.
However, that being said, those issues wouldn't have been enough to drop the rating down to four stars. My main issue with this entire story was a conversation that happens between Annie and Lauren's oldest sister Laney about Lauren's other sister Lexi. From the first book about Annie, the reader discovered that Lexi and her husband Nate were having fertility struggles. The way that particular issue was handled in this story didn't bother me, but this particular conversation did.
Without giving away spoilers, the conversation includes a lovely statement from Laney to Annie about how "Jesus saved Lexi from experiencing traditional parenting" for another opportunity, and wow did that rub me the wrong way. I'm pretty sure that no one who has ever actually experienced infertility would appreciate it being described that way, and it felt like the author was just glossing over all the hard bits that would go into all these decisions.
That being said, I did honestly still love this story, I just wish the author had tackled certain sensitive issues a bit better than she did.
Final Rating: 4/5.