What do you think?
Rate this book
The Vangie Vale Mysteries #1
Vangie Vale and the Murdered Macaron
Small towns and gossip go together like flaky crust and sweet pastry cream. Between the police scanners, the coffee ladies, and the senior center, no secret is safe for long. But Vangie Vale wants nothing more than to stay under the radar...especially the police radar.
So when her new bakery is linked to a murder investigation, nothing will stop the gossip mill from connecting her to the dead body. Can't have that.
In order to clear her good name and keep her face off the front page, this bakery owner becomes extra nosy...with a little side of breaking-and-entering... But when she comes face-to-face with the Sheriff, Vangie can't ignore the fact that one of her macarons was involved in a murder. She has to find the real murderer.
Book One in The Matchbaker Mysteries, a new cozy culinary mystery series with a surprise bi-vocational amateur sleuth, from USA Today Bestselling Author, R.L. Syme.
RECIPE INSIDE: The Murdered Macaron!
So when her new bakery is linked to a murder investigation, nothing will stop the gossip mill from connecting her to the dead body. Can't have that.
In order to clear her good name and keep her face off the front page, this bakery owner becomes extra nosy...with a little side of breaking-and-entering... But when she comes face-to-face with the Sheriff, Vangie can't ignore the fact that one of her macarons was involved in a murder. She has to find the real murderer.
Book One in The Matchbaker Mysteries, a new cozy culinary mystery series with a surprise bi-vocational amateur sleuth, from USA Today Bestselling Author, R.L. Syme.
RECIPE INSIDE: The Murdered Macaron!
364 pages, ebook
First published July 20, 2017
872 people are currently reading
1452 people want to read
About the author
R.L. Syme
26 books395 followersR.L. Syme is a USA Today best-selling author. She writes mysteries and cozy mysteries, as well as nonfiction. R.L. grew up reading Nancy Drew mysteries passed on by her grandmother.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews
April 17, 2019
Vangie Vale was already becoming known for her macarons which she baked, along with other culinary delights, to have with the coffee she served in her café. The day the handsome man and his grumpy wife called in was the beginning of the strangest set of circumstances that had happened in the small town for some time. Vangie was immediately connected to a murder – something she could ill afford as her reputation in her other job was threatened – and she knew she had to investigate to find a murderer and protect her name.
With the Sheriff convinced he had the murderer behind bars, and Vangie equally convinced he was wrong, she knew she had to dig deeper. But there was a risk – could she afford it? She only wanted to bake and keep her customers happy after all…
Vangie Vale and the Murdered Macarons by R.L. Syme is the first in the Matchbaker Mystery series and quite an enjoyable cosy. The mystery was intriguing; the characters both likeable and not so much. The Sheriff was an angry man, especially around Vangie. Overall, it’s a cosy mystery which I would recommend, and I’ll look at #2 soon.
With the Sheriff convinced he had the murderer behind bars, and Vangie equally convinced he was wrong, she knew she had to dig deeper. But there was a risk – could she afford it? She only wanted to bake and keep her customers happy after all…
Vangie Vale and the Murdered Macarons by R.L. Syme is the first in the Matchbaker Mystery series and quite an enjoyable cosy. The mystery was intriguing; the characters both likeable and not so much. The Sheriff was an angry man, especially around Vangie. Overall, it’s a cosy mystery which I would recommend, and I’ll look at #2 soon.
August 13, 2017
A brand new small town cozy mystery series begins. I love getting in on the ground floor with these books.
Vangie Vale is an interesting character. She leaves scandal behind in North Carolina and heads to Saint Agnes, Montana. Not only does she open a new bakery, but she also is a part time Pastor. She must remain on her best behavior in Saint Agnes or she will not be allowed to be a Pastor any longer. So, what happens? She immediately gets tossed in a murder mystery.
The local gossips are convinced she’s part of the murder investigation which is making Vangie’s boss anxious and ready to fire her. She is desperate to prove her innocence and gets right to investigating for herself. The local Sheriff warns her to stay away, but Vangie’s livelihood is on the line and she’s not about to walk away.
R.L. Syme creates the perfect setting for a cozy mystery - a small town with many gossipy neighbors. I had some ideas who the murderer was, but I didn’t guess correctly and I didn’t put all the pieces together. I was quite surprised at all the various twists, turns, and red herrings there were in this book.
The author hooks you in right from the start. I couldn’t put it down until I knew who and what was behind the murder. Great start to a new series. I’ll definitely be looking for the next one.
FTC Disclosure: I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book from the author and publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Vangie Vale is an interesting character. She leaves scandal behind in North Carolina and heads to Saint Agnes, Montana. Not only does she open a new bakery, but she also is a part time Pastor. She must remain on her best behavior in Saint Agnes or she will not be allowed to be a Pastor any longer. So, what happens? She immediately gets tossed in a murder mystery.
The local gossips are convinced she’s part of the murder investigation which is making Vangie’s boss anxious and ready to fire her. She is desperate to prove her innocence and gets right to investigating for herself. The local Sheriff warns her to stay away, but Vangie’s livelihood is on the line and she’s not about to walk away.
R.L. Syme creates the perfect setting for a cozy mystery - a small town with many gossipy neighbors. I had some ideas who the murderer was, but I didn’t guess correctly and I didn’t put all the pieces together. I was quite surprised at all the various twists, turns, and red herrings there were in this book.
The author hooks you in right from the start. I couldn’t put it down until I knew who and what was behind the murder. Great start to a new series. I’ll definitely be looking for the next one.
FTC Disclosure: I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book from the author and publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 18, 2022
Kindle freebie at time of download
Part-time pastor and full-time baker, Vangie Vale is stuck in the small town of Saint Agnes, Montana to do penance for something that happened back in her urban parish in Durham, North Carolina. Vangie is new to baking and likes to try out her macaron flavors on the locals, collecting feedback on which flavors she should make for the tourists. She never expected the next tourists that walk through the door would be so famous- or so much trouble. When a flirtatious, well-dressed tourist with a faux British accent walks through the door, Vangie feels flattered by his attention and is happy to match him with a box of macarons. Unfortunately the woman he is with fat-shames Vangie's friend Emma and Vangie sees red. She provides them with wrong directions into town never dreaming that her prank would have deadly consequences. With the sheriff already on her case about using her phone on his property, he's now looking at her as a person of interest for murder! The estranged aunt of one of her best customers, high schooler Austin Krantz, has been brutally murdered and the sheriff sets his sights firmly on Vangie's new friend, Henry, a famous Hollywood celebrity. The sheriff feels Vangie is colluding with Henry to cover up murder, and if Vangie is accused, she'll lose her ordination status! She'll do anything to fulfill the calling she knows is hers and to help a friend. How can she prove Henry is innocent when he's already been judged by the whole town?
I just could not get into this mystery. It is very meandering and repetitive in the first half. It picks up a bit in the second half but I had to skim to get through it. I found the mystery was just too dark for me and I was apalled by the whole thing. The second death is especially tough to take. The small town setting got on my nerves and the pastor/baker heroine didn't appeal to me enough to want to read about her adventures.
There are too many characters and confusing situations in this book. When we meet Vangie, she has been banished to Saint Agnes for some as yet unnamed scandal back in Durham. A scandal which is never fully explained but enough is revealed in the end to know it wasn't Vangie's fault. Vangie sees herself as being called to the ministry. She liked her urban parish because she could do a lot of good there. Her new parish is tiny, multi-denominatinal and in a small town. The people of the parish sound just as judgmental and pig headed as the ones in Durham though. Vangie is a good person. She LOATHES bullies and especially men who take advantage of women. She should team up with Daisy from Magic, Lies, and Deadly Pies.
Vangie can't seem to catch a break and most of the ignorant townspeople don't seem to like her much, except the teenagers and her neighbor, Emma. Emma is a sweetheart. She's creative and artistic and Vangie doesn't appreciate Emma's art windows. Emma is a true friend to Vangie when she needs it and I don't think we see the same level of friendship from Vangie yet. Leo Van Andel, Vangie's baking assistant, loves working for her. He's eager to get into pastry school and become a pastry chef himself. Unfortunately, his parents seem to be prejudiced against Vangie and men baking in general. I hate that because if you look at the best pastry chefs from history to today, the majority of them are MALE - and they make a lot of money. Poor Leo doesn't deserve such horrible, narrow-minded people. It's unclear why they dislike Vangie so much and fear their son being around her.
Henry Savage, a major Hollywood movie star, comes across as a little too Hollywood for me. He loves to flirt and enjoys his new friendship with Vangie. They just met and he asks her out. I don't know why she agreed. She's too innocent and naive to be a pastor if she thinks he wanted spiritual counselling. Henry is clearly amusing himself with his flirtations and his phony English accent. Method acting or trying to charm his way into Vangie's bed? He's a convenient suspect for murder, having been seen in the right place but the sheriff seems not to have truly investigated the case.
Henry's agent, Scarlet, is a witch. She's tough, mean and rude. She hates small towns and has nothing nice to say about anyone or any place. I don't blame Vangie for being mean and giving them wrong directions. She shouldn't have risen to Scarlet's bait though. Scarlet is the only character to exhibit any growth. I ended up feeling some empathy for her by the end.
The victim, Claire, was known around town. The nasty, judgmental townspeople slut shame her and her own family sent her away because she was a troubled teen. I read nothing about getting her help, trying to support her or anything else kind. They said nothing about mental health, substance abuse or anything else- just that she was BAD. It sure sounds like no one liked her, not even her sister. The family was estranged and never saw Claire but Henry knew her! There's a mystery there full of secrets. Like Vangie, I don't think he did it based on his reaction to the news and the way he acts in jail. I wouldn't put it past Scarlet though to do the dirty deed for him. Claire's husband, Derek, is a bad boy type but he seems to be trying hard to be clean and on the right side of the law. He sounds like he loved Claire very much and is the only one, besides Vangie, who wants to see justice done. I actually kind of like him. I don't trust him but I don't think he's a murderer.
Leo's best friend, Austin Krantz, hangs out in the bakery after school. He has big dreams that will take him out of their small town and onto a career in the Navy, following in the family military tradition. His mom works at the bank and has been a single mother his whole life since his father was killed serving the country. Nikki works hard to support Austin. He's a good kid and maybe he should get a job and help out with his college expenses? He seems to have a level head on his shoulders and I think he could do both. I do fear he might be the murderer though or know the murderer. His grandma is super creepy and was a terrible mother. I think she did it, sad to say. I think she's mentally unsound.
Leo's dad, Michael Van Andel, sounds like he could be a suspect as well. A former high school football player, he's big and a tough guy. He hates Vangie having more influence over his son than he does. Michael knew Claire very well and the two families have always been close. He knew all her secrets so maybe he silenced her so she couldn't share those secrets with anyone else.
Malcolm Dean, the sheriff and Vangie's neighbor, has some kind of bug up his butt about Vangie. He does.not.like her or anything she does. He doesn't trust her and instead of being neighborly and inviting her over when she needs to make an important call, he threatens her just for standing under a bush on the edge of his property. Malcolm Dean doesn't do much to investigate the murder either. He seems to hate outsiders because he's quick to judge Henry and proclaim Henry guilty- without evidence, I might add. Irma, the police department administrator, seems kind. She's compassionate and enjoys Vangie's cookies. At least someone in this town has a heart!
Peter, the former pastor of Vangie's church and president of the church board, is also judgmental and unforgiving like everyone else in town. He listens to gossip and doesn't even ask Vangie for her side of the story. He's so quick to make assumptions and go to her bishop which will get her fired!
I really, really disliked this town and the people. Maybe if Vangie goes back to Durham I'd read more but Saint Agnes is not for me. I also do not like macarons so not even the baking saved this one for me.
Part-time pastor and full-time baker, Vangie Vale is stuck in the small town of Saint Agnes, Montana to do penance for something that happened back in her urban parish in Durham, North Carolina. Vangie is new to baking and likes to try out her macaron flavors on the locals, collecting feedback on which flavors she should make for the tourists. She never expected the next tourists that walk through the door would be so famous- or so much trouble. When a flirtatious, well-dressed tourist with a faux British accent walks through the door, Vangie feels flattered by his attention and is happy to match him with a box of macarons. Unfortunately the woman he is with fat-shames Vangie's friend Emma and Vangie sees red. She provides them with wrong directions into town never dreaming that her prank would have deadly consequences. With the sheriff already on her case about using her phone on his property, he's now looking at her as a person of interest for murder! The estranged aunt of one of her best customers, high schooler Austin Krantz, has been brutally murdered and the sheriff sets his sights firmly on Vangie's new friend, Henry, a famous Hollywood celebrity. The sheriff feels Vangie is colluding with Henry to cover up murder, and if Vangie is accused, she'll lose her ordination status! She'll do anything to fulfill the calling she knows is hers and to help a friend. How can she prove Henry is innocent when he's already been judged by the whole town?
I just could not get into this mystery. It is very meandering and repetitive in the first half. It picks up a bit in the second half but I had to skim to get through it. I found the mystery was just too dark for me and I was apalled by the whole thing. The second death is especially tough to take. The small town setting got on my nerves and the pastor/baker heroine didn't appeal to me enough to want to read about her adventures.
There are too many characters and confusing situations in this book. When we meet Vangie, she has been banished to Saint Agnes for some as yet unnamed scandal back in Durham. A scandal which is never fully explained but enough is revealed in the end to know it wasn't Vangie's fault. Vangie sees herself as being called to the ministry. She liked her urban parish because she could do a lot of good there. Her new parish is tiny, multi-denominatinal and in a small town. The people of the parish sound just as judgmental and pig headed as the ones in Durham though. Vangie is a good person. She LOATHES bullies and especially men who take advantage of women. She should team up with Daisy from Magic, Lies, and Deadly Pies.
Vangie can't seem to catch a break and most of the ignorant townspeople don't seem to like her much, except the teenagers and her neighbor, Emma. Emma is a sweetheart. She's creative and artistic and Vangie doesn't appreciate Emma's art windows. Emma is a true friend to Vangie when she needs it and I don't think we see the same level of friendship from Vangie yet. Leo Van Andel, Vangie's baking assistant, loves working for her. He's eager to get into pastry school and become a pastry chef himself. Unfortunately, his parents seem to be prejudiced against Vangie and men baking in general. I hate that because if you look at the best pastry chefs from history to today, the majority of them are MALE - and they make a lot of money. Poor Leo doesn't deserve such horrible, narrow-minded people. It's unclear why they dislike Vangie so much and fear their son being around her.
Henry Savage, a major Hollywood movie star, comes across as a little too Hollywood for me. He loves to flirt and enjoys his new friendship with Vangie. They just met and he asks her out. I don't know why she agreed. She's too innocent and naive to be a pastor if she thinks he wanted spiritual counselling. Henry is clearly amusing himself with his flirtations and his phony English accent. Method acting or trying to charm his way into Vangie's bed? He's a convenient suspect for murder, having been seen in the right place but the sheriff seems not to have truly investigated the case.
Henry's agent, Scarlet, is a witch. She's tough, mean and rude. She hates small towns and has nothing nice to say about anyone or any place. I don't blame Vangie for being mean and giving them wrong directions. She shouldn't have risen to Scarlet's bait though. Scarlet is the only character to exhibit any growth. I ended up feeling some empathy for her by the end.
The victim, Claire, was known around town. The nasty, judgmental townspeople slut shame her and her own family sent her away because she was a troubled teen. I read nothing about getting her help, trying to support her or anything else kind. They said nothing about mental health, substance abuse or anything else- just that she was BAD. It sure sounds like no one liked her, not even her sister. The family was estranged and never saw Claire but Henry knew her! There's a mystery there full of secrets. Like Vangie, I don't think he did it based on his reaction to the news and the way he acts in jail. I wouldn't put it past Scarlet though to do the dirty deed for him. Claire's husband, Derek, is a bad boy type but he seems to be trying hard to be clean and on the right side of the law. He sounds like he loved Claire very much and is the only one, besides Vangie, who wants to see justice done. I actually kind of like him. I don't trust him but I don't think he's a murderer.
Leo's best friend, Austin Krantz, hangs out in the bakery after school. He has big dreams that will take him out of their small town and onto a career in the Navy, following in the family military tradition. His mom works at the bank and has been a single mother his whole life since his father was killed serving the country. Nikki works hard to support Austin. He's a good kid and maybe he should get a job and help out with his college expenses? He seems to have a level head on his shoulders and I think he could do both. I do fear he might be the murderer though or know the murderer. His grandma is super creepy and was a terrible mother. I think she did it, sad to say. I think she's mentally unsound.
Leo's dad, Michael Van Andel, sounds like he could be a suspect as well. A former high school football player, he's big and a tough guy. He hates Vangie having more influence over his son than he does. Michael knew Claire very well and the two families have always been close. He knew all her secrets so maybe he silenced her so she couldn't share those secrets with anyone else.
Malcolm Dean, the sheriff and Vangie's neighbor, has some kind of bug up his butt about Vangie. He does.not.like her or anything she does. He doesn't trust her and instead of being neighborly and inviting her over when she needs to make an important call, he threatens her just for standing under a bush on the edge of his property. Malcolm Dean doesn't do much to investigate the murder either. He seems to hate outsiders because he's quick to judge Henry and proclaim Henry guilty- without evidence, I might add. Irma, the police department administrator, seems kind. She's compassionate and enjoys Vangie's cookies. At least someone in this town has a heart!
Peter, the former pastor of Vangie's church and president of the church board, is also judgmental and unforgiving like everyone else in town. He listens to gossip and doesn't even ask Vangie for her side of the story. He's so quick to make assumptions and go to her bishop which will get her fired!
I really, really disliked this town and the people. Maybe if Vangie goes back to Durham I'd read more but Saint Agnes is not for me. I also do not like macarons so not even the baking saved this one for me.
August 18, 2017
The book was a delightful read and I enjoyed it. I like our main character, Vangie. Sometimes she drove me a little nuts because she had a tendency to put herself into situations that held the possibility of danger without really thinking too much, but she didn't do that often, so I didn't get too annoyed by it.
I had mixed feelings about most of the supporting characters throughout the book. As we got more into the back story of the town and its people, I understood the characters motivations better and started to like some of them more, but there were enough red herrings in this book that I was suspicious of most of the townspeople and characters until the villain was actually revealed.
The plot line moved along at a steady and somewhat quick pace, though it wasn't so quick that you couldn't keep up. This was a fun read and I recommend it to anyone looking for a good whodunit.
I had mixed feelings about most of the supporting characters throughout the book. As we got more into the back story of the town and its people, I understood the characters motivations better and started to like some of them more, but there were enough red herrings in this book that I was suspicious of most of the townspeople and characters until the villain was actually revealed.
The plot line moved along at a steady and somewhat quick pace, though it wasn't so quick that you couldn't keep up. This was a fun read and I recommend it to anyone looking for a good whodunit.
August 11, 2017
Dollycas’s Thoughts
This series is off to a tasty start.
Evangeline (Vangie) Vail is a part time pastor and a full time baker. The issue that brought her to Montana is a little foggy yet but she is settling in nicely. Her Matchmaker Bakery is a really cute idea. She matches you to the perfect pastry and beverage not the man or the woman of your dreams. She’s an upbeat person and a good listener and she truly wants to help wherever she can. When one her pastry boxes is found at a crime scene she becomes one of the Sheriff’s top suspects. She and the Sheriff have a very rocky relationship. They are neighbors and he just didn’t like her from the first time they met. The only place near her home that she can get cell phone service is at the corner of his property near a big bush and it just drives him crazy. He reports her trespassing to the parish and she is on thin ice already with them. He has even threatened to arrest her. Let’s just say all this trespassing and murder has not made Vangie’s life easy but she doesn’t give up. I really like her and want to get to know her much better.
The murder mystery is very well plotted out. It all comes down to a very small timeline, alibis for all of the suspects and motive. Vangie takes us down a prickly path until we finally get to the real killer. Vangie can now add sleuth to her resume. Some of the story goes a little off a cozy path, at the end of one chapter my breath was just taken away. The author quickly get us back on track in the cozy realm. It was simply a page turner that kept my attention from the beginning to the end.
I am excited about this series. This first escape to Montana just gave us a taste of what to expect from this author and these characters. I am very happy to learn there are two more books in the series to be released soon.
**My review was of an Advance Review Copy and was informed that there were some adjustments made to the final edition.
I received this book free from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
February 20, 2020
I read a lot of books in a lot of genres, and I have to say this cozy stands out. It's light, funny, warm, suspenseful, insightful and spiritually uplifting. All in one book! I'm amazed.
R.L Syme is a masterful writer. Her characters are unique, wonderfully flawed and totally lovable. Her plot is so tight I had a hard time putting the book down. Her prose is luscious. I've marked several lines on Goodreads, they are that good.
And full disclosure: I happen to love macrons.
I can't wait to start the next book.
I highly recommend this book for anyone who loves cozy mysteries or good genre fiction.
R.L Syme is a masterful writer. Her characters are unique, wonderfully flawed and totally lovable. Her plot is so tight I had a hard time putting the book down. Her prose is luscious. I've marked several lines on Goodreads, they are that good.
And full disclosure: I happen to love macrons.
I can't wait to start the next book.
I highly recommend this book for anyone who loves cozy mysteries or good genre fiction.
June 13, 2020
After reading the non-fiction books by the other pen name of this author I knew I had to give her cozy mysteries a try too and I am so glad I did. This book was fabulous. This is one of the best cozies I've read. The mystery was so well done with plenty of twists reveals, secrets and lies as well as plenty of hints. The characters all felt so realistic and well done and I really liked following Vangie Vale around as she tried to solve this mystery. I also liked how this one had a clear cozie vibe, but at the same time also felt unique and fresh in the way it was handled, although I can't quite put my finger on how the author managed that.
Let's start with the mystery. I really liked the mystery in this book. The set-up was a little bit different, with the main character not being the one to discover the body, but she is sort of connected as a box of macarons from her bakery were found on the body and two possible suspects were in the town the murdered person was found because she send them there. She also got to know one of the suspects and believes he's innocent. She wants justice served and so she gets involved. It made sense and I liked how a lot of the investigating was her asking questions and it didn't feel forced even thought she was totally trying to solve the mystery.
This mystery had so many twists and turns. There are so many secrets and slowly they come to light one by one. So many lies as well and it was hard weeding through everything and figuring out what really happened. I like how the author kept the mystery going forward, with plenty of clues along the way that helped form a better picture, but at the same time you really don't get the full picture until the end. It was a very satisfying way of progressing through the mystery. I also liked how the mystery went in some directions I hadn't expected, there were some great twists. The mystery kept me guessing and I spent some time trying to figure out what was going on and who the murderer was. I managed to guess the killer right and was pretty pleased about that, but there was one person who was involved and I just couldn't figure out how that person tied into it until the end. It was great when everything came to light.
Vangie Vale was such a great main character. I like how realistic and multi faceted she felt. She was a good person, but she also does things she isn't proud of. She is a bakery owner, but also a pastor, which actually was quite interesting to read about. I felt like we really got a good feel for her personality. With how she could read people, but also how she could be wrong. How she felt when things happened and her fear when she was in a dangerous situation. There is a bit of what happened in her past that we don't get all the details about, but that worked well here and I assume we get more information about that as the series progresses. I also would like to see both more about her job as a pastor and bakery owner, as while both were definitely a part of the book she wasn't workign as much as I had expected.
There is a great group of side characters as well and they all feel realistic and have multiple sides just like Vangie. There are quite some characters involved into the mystery, but it didn't feel like too much and I never had trouble remembering who was who, except for a few times a character we hadn't seen a lot of suddenly popped up again. The only one who I didn't get as good of a feel for as I would've liked is Emma, who is a good friend of Vangie, but I never really felt their friendship. I liked how Leo felt like a younger brother to Vangie and how she interacted with him. I also liked seeing how Vangie interacts with Henry who she finds attractive, the Sheriff with whom she keeps butting heads constantly and Derek who turns out to be more than he seems at first. I feel like there might be a hint of a possible romance with a few of those, but I am not quite sure yet how and if that will develop. I also liked how some characters start out one way, but when you learn more about them it paints a fuller picture and they seem different than what I expected at first.
The small town setting in a fictional town in Montana also was well done. It had that small town vibe and I liked getting to see a bit of the town and the inhabitants in this book.
To summarize: This was an amazing start to this cozy mystery series. The mystery was a really good one. It kept me guessing and there were some many twists and turns. I liked how there were plenty of clues and hints along the way, so it felt like the mystery kept progressing while you still don't get the full picture till the end. I managed to guess who the murderer was correctly, but wasn't sure about some other details. I liked main character Vangie Vale, she felt so realistic and multi faceted. She's a good person, but also makes mistakes. She wants justice to be served and gets herself involved in this mystery. I really liked her and feel like we got a good feel for her personality. I also liked the side characters, many of whom feel just as real and have multiple sides just like Vangie does. I like how some characters turned out to be different than what they seemed at first. I really look forward to reading the next book in this series!
Let's start with the mystery. I really liked the mystery in this book. The set-up was a little bit different, with the main character not being the one to discover the body, but she is sort of connected as a box of macarons from her bakery were found on the body and two possible suspects were in the town the murdered person was found because she send them there. She also got to know one of the suspects and believes he's innocent. She wants justice served and so she gets involved. It made sense and I liked how a lot of the investigating was her asking questions and it didn't feel forced even thought she was totally trying to solve the mystery.
This mystery had so many twists and turns. There are so many secrets and slowly they come to light one by one. So many lies as well and it was hard weeding through everything and figuring out what really happened. I like how the author kept the mystery going forward, with plenty of clues along the way that helped form a better picture, but at the same time you really don't get the full picture until the end. It was a very satisfying way of progressing through the mystery. I also liked how the mystery went in some directions I hadn't expected, there were some great twists. The mystery kept me guessing and I spent some time trying to figure out what was going on and who the murderer was. I managed to guess the killer right and was pretty pleased about that, but there was one person who was involved and I just couldn't figure out how that person tied into it until the end. It was great when everything came to light.
Vangie Vale was such a great main character. I like how realistic and multi faceted she felt. She was a good person, but she also does things she isn't proud of. She is a bakery owner, but also a pastor, which actually was quite interesting to read about. I felt like we really got a good feel for her personality. With how she could read people, but also how she could be wrong. How she felt when things happened and her fear when she was in a dangerous situation. There is a bit of what happened in her past that we don't get all the details about, but that worked well here and I assume we get more information about that as the series progresses. I also would like to see both more about her job as a pastor and bakery owner, as while both were definitely a part of the book she wasn't workign as much as I had expected.
There is a great group of side characters as well and they all feel realistic and have multiple sides just like Vangie. There are quite some characters involved into the mystery, but it didn't feel like too much and I never had trouble remembering who was who, except for a few times a character we hadn't seen a lot of suddenly popped up again. The only one who I didn't get as good of a feel for as I would've liked is Emma, who is a good friend of Vangie, but I never really felt their friendship. I liked how Leo felt like a younger brother to Vangie and how she interacted with him. I also liked seeing how Vangie interacts with Henry who she finds attractive, the Sheriff with whom she keeps butting heads constantly and Derek who turns out to be more than he seems at first. I feel like there might be a hint of a possible romance with a few of those, but I am not quite sure yet how and if that will develop. I also liked how some characters start out one way, but when you learn more about them it paints a fuller picture and they seem different than what I expected at first.
The small town setting in a fictional town in Montana also was well done. It had that small town vibe and I liked getting to see a bit of the town and the inhabitants in this book.
To summarize: This was an amazing start to this cozy mystery series. The mystery was a really good one. It kept me guessing and there were some many twists and turns. I liked how there were plenty of clues and hints along the way, so it felt like the mystery kept progressing while you still don't get the full picture till the end. I managed to guess who the murderer was correctly, but wasn't sure about some other details. I liked main character Vangie Vale, she felt so realistic and multi faceted. She's a good person, but also makes mistakes. She wants justice to be served and gets herself involved in this mystery. I really liked her and feel like we got a good feel for her personality. I also liked the side characters, many of whom feel just as real and have multiple sides just like Vangie does. I like how some characters turned out to be different than what they seemed at first. I really look forward to reading the next book in this series!
January 12, 2018
Vangie is a part time minister who has a bakery cafe...and a secret so she needs to keep her nose clean and stay out of the news. She also lives next door to the sheriff who can't seem to stand her because she uses one tiny little part of his property for making cell phone calls since she can't get any coverage inside her house.
When a local murder is somehow linked to her bakery, Vangie sets out to investigate what turns out to be a fairly complicated case with lots of suspects and twists. I know I never saw it coming when I found out who the killer was.
It never came out and said what infraction Vangie had against her from her old assignment but whatever it was, she is in Saint Agnes parish in Montana on a sort of probationary period. It was imperative that this murder and any link to her bakery be kept out of the media and press.
This was a well written mystery although in some parts I was getting a little lost in details. There were a lot of interesting characters and the one that hits me as most interesting was biker Derek because it just seemed such a comical mismatch in a way to have a minister and a biker sidekick who was totally comfortable with the whole breaking and entering part of investigating. But just because he's got a record, doesn't mean Derek is a totally bad person. I ended up liking him quite a bit and I hope he appears in the next book.
The main murder and mysteries were solved but there was one thing left hanging so I hope it gets wrapped up in the next book. I won't spoil it by saying what it is.
When a local murder is somehow linked to her bakery, Vangie sets out to investigate what turns out to be a fairly complicated case with lots of suspects and twists. I know I never saw it coming when I found out who the killer was.
It never came out and said what infraction Vangie had against her from her old assignment but whatever it was, she is in Saint Agnes parish in Montana on a sort of probationary period. It was imperative that this murder and any link to her bakery be kept out of the media and press.
This was a well written mystery although in some parts I was getting a little lost in details. There were a lot of interesting characters and the one that hits me as most interesting was biker Derek because it just seemed such a comical mismatch in a way to have a minister and a biker sidekick who was totally comfortable with the whole breaking and entering part of investigating. But just because he's got a record, doesn't mean Derek is a totally bad person. I ended up liking him quite a bit and I hope he appears in the next book.
The main murder and mysteries were solved but there was one thing left hanging so I hope it gets wrapped up in the next book. I won't spoil it by saying what it is.
June 14, 2018
Someone had painted a mural on the big front window of my bakery, blocking my view of the parking lot.
Evangeline "Vangie" Vale is a part time pastor and full time baker in St. Agnes, Montana. She has be banished to the small town from her parish in North Carolina following an embarrassing incident. She has a knack for matching patrons with their perfect pastry. Vangie matches two newcomers with her newest cookie, French macarons. The woman, Scarlet disrespects Vangie as she is leaving the bakery and she gives her the wrong directions to the bank that the two are looking for. Vangie is the number one suspect after her box of macarons are discovered with a murder victim.
Scarlet and Henry are in St. Agnes to take care of a business transaction. Vangie is drawn to Henry and is surprised to learn that he is a popular Hollywood star. Henry is also a former resident of St. Agnes and knew the murder victim. Now we have additional suspects.
Sheriff Malcom Dean is an enigma. He is Vangie's next door neighbor and constantly complains about her coming onto his property to use her cell phone. The service in her home is spotty and she stands at the edge of his driveway to make phone calls. I never quite understood why this was such a problem. He is presented in such a negative manner and I'm not sure if it was to keep him from being a love interest.
The mystery was so complicated and twisted that I felt I needed a chart to keep up with who hated who and who was keeping what secret. It eventually worked out but it was quite a ride.
There is a lovely recipe for macarons (not to be confused with macaroons) in the book. I'm not sure if I am ready to tackle the meringue delights just yet. I'll stick with the coconut chewy macaroons.
I will read the next book just to see where certain relationships are headed.
Evangeline "Vangie" Vale is a part time pastor and full time baker in St. Agnes, Montana. She has be banished to the small town from her parish in North Carolina following an embarrassing incident. She has a knack for matching patrons with their perfect pastry. Vangie matches two newcomers with her newest cookie, French macarons. The woman, Scarlet disrespects Vangie as she is leaving the bakery and she gives her the wrong directions to the bank that the two are looking for. Vangie is the number one suspect after her box of macarons are discovered with a murder victim.
Scarlet and Henry are in St. Agnes to take care of a business transaction. Vangie is drawn to Henry and is surprised to learn that he is a popular Hollywood star. Henry is also a former resident of St. Agnes and knew the murder victim. Now we have additional suspects.
Sheriff Malcom Dean is an enigma. He is Vangie's next door neighbor and constantly complains about her coming onto his property to use her cell phone. The service in her home is spotty and she stands at the edge of his driveway to make phone calls. I never quite understood why this was such a problem. He is presented in such a negative manner and I'm not sure if it was to keep him from being a love interest.
The mystery was so complicated and twisted that I felt I needed a chart to keep up with who hated who and who was keeping what secret. It eventually worked out but it was quite a ride.
There is a lovely recipe for macarons (not to be confused with macaroons) in the book. I'm not sure if I am ready to tackle the meringue delights just yet. I'll stick with the coconut chewy macaroons.
I will read the next book just to see where certain relationships are headed.
January 16, 2018
If that name doesn't pull ya in right off ... u are just plain silly. I love the cover, love the name, I totally want a macaroon (what she is spelling it MACARON? right?) now. any who. a fun quick read for me ... Loved it all. Love these character, I enjoy R.L. writing style. Found it on Amazon for free, totally why I was drawn in right away, had to see what this read was all about. Loved it!! I think this book needs 2 include a package of macarons ... please? That seems fair, right? I have never had any that were that great, do they insist?
June 12, 2021
Vangie is a part-time Reverend and full-time baker. When her cookies are a clue in a murder, she can't help but get involved. Interesting characters with a good mystery.
April 22, 2018
This a review of an advanced reader copy of this novel which I received free of charge in exchange for a honest review. I gave this book 4.5 stars only because it has let out an important part of the lead characters backstory, presumably until another volume.
Evangeline Vale is a pastor at a community church in a small town in Montana. She is part time at the this small church simply because there isn't much work in this tiny town so she also has a bakery to make ends meet. She has a talent for reading people and is able to match them up with the sweet treats they will like so her barkers is named the MatchBakery. One day a man and woman stop in the bakery to get directions and she sells them some "matched" treats, macarons in this case. the woman is incredibly rude to Vangie and her friend so when she gives the requested directions she states turn left instead of the correct right. As this is a small town it won't take them too far out of their way to discover the incorrect direction. Unfortunately this leads to a chain of events that involves murder and her cookie buyers and she are prime suspects when her cookies are found in a murdered woman's hands. Thus begins the story of old wrongs, blackmail and more murdered to cover the truth. Including a near miss for Evangeline. The characters in this book are interesting in their histories and motivations and for the most part likeable. The scene and scenery are described beautifully and make one want to revisit Montana. But the plot, the story is very well done. The clues are mostly there but not quite enough to give you a glimpse of the surprise ending. I really enjoyed this book and look forward to the next in the series. I'm hoping all of Evangeline's back story will be provided.
Evangeline Vale is a pastor at a community church in a small town in Montana. She is part time at the this small church simply because there isn't much work in this tiny town so she also has a bakery to make ends meet. She has a talent for reading people and is able to match them up with the sweet treats they will like so her barkers is named the MatchBakery. One day a man and woman stop in the bakery to get directions and she sells them some "matched" treats, macarons in this case. the woman is incredibly rude to Vangie and her friend so when she gives the requested directions she states turn left instead of the correct right. As this is a small town it won't take them too far out of their way to discover the incorrect direction. Unfortunately this leads to a chain of events that involves murder and her cookie buyers and she are prime suspects when her cookies are found in a murdered woman's hands. Thus begins the story of old wrongs, blackmail and more murdered to cover the truth. Including a near miss for Evangeline. The characters in this book are interesting in their histories and motivations and for the most part likeable. The scene and scenery are described beautifully and make one want to revisit Montana. But the plot, the story is very well done. The clues are mostly there but not quite enough to give you a glimpse of the surprise ending. I really enjoyed this book and look forward to the next in the series. I'm hoping all of Evangeline's back story will be provided.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 13, 2017
Honestly the author, R.L. Syme, had me at the mention of macaron and her cover made me eager to dive into the book and try her cookie recipe! Aside from finding a delectable macaron cookie recipe that I couldn’t stop eating (more about that later) I found a story that left me salivating for more! Ms. Syme creates a refreshing, unique protagonist in Vangie Vale and sets up situations that allows both the character and the plot to shine. I love that not only is Vangie a part-time baker, she is a matchbaker AND the part-time pastor of the town’s community church. The matchbaking business was dreamt up by her sister as a marketing tool, but Vangie has a knack for matching up a patron to a drink, pastry, or a sandwich. She claims she’s not psychic but some might disagree. Being the pastor gives Vangie the inside track on the residents and because of her compassionate nature, people open up to her which helps in her investigation when brutal murders rocks her town.
As the reader delves into the book, the layers of complexity in both Vangie’s personal life and the plot are slowly revealed with intricate twists and turns that kept me turning pages. In addition to a suspenseful plot, I found the dialog and interaction between Vangie and the characters highly entertaining. Ms. Syme comes up with some delightful sentences that are spot on, such as “So much L.A. in one little package,” to describe an actress. And her perfectly delectable descriptions of the shop’s macarons are drool worthy and made me want to visit the town of St. Agnes, Montana for a taste testing!
The recipe at the back of the book, The Murdered Macaron Recipe is a Matcha green tea macaron with ginger buttercream filling. Yes, it is a unique flavor combination but I loved the earthy, delicate green tea flavor that melded with the spiciness of both fresh and crystallized ginger. Ms. Syme's detailed instructions were easy to follow and the results well worth the labor involved in making macaron cookies.
I received an advance copy with the hopes I would review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
As the reader delves into the book, the layers of complexity in both Vangie’s personal life and the plot are slowly revealed with intricate twists and turns that kept me turning pages. In addition to a suspenseful plot, I found the dialog and interaction between Vangie and the characters highly entertaining. Ms. Syme comes up with some delightful sentences that are spot on, such as “So much L.A. in one little package,” to describe an actress. And her perfectly delectable descriptions of the shop’s macarons are drool worthy and made me want to visit the town of St. Agnes, Montana for a taste testing!
The recipe at the back of the book, The Murdered Macaron Recipe is a Matcha green tea macaron with ginger buttercream filling. Yes, it is a unique flavor combination but I loved the earthy, delicate green tea flavor that melded with the spiciness of both fresh and crystallized ginger. Ms. Syme's detailed instructions were easy to follow and the results well worth the labor involved in making macaron cookies.
I received an advance copy with the hopes I would review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
August 12, 2017
VANGIE VALE AND THE MURDERED MACARON by R.L. Syme
The First Matchbaker Mystery
Vangie Vale has been relocated to Saint Agnes, Montana. A part time pastor and more time baker, Vangie is doing penance, biding her time, and creating delicious baked goods in her bakery. When a stuck up southern belle named Scarlet gives a parting dig to Vangie and her friend, Vangie decides to assist karma and gives the woman and her blond James Bond type partner incorrect directions. Yet by giving in to her baser instincts, Vangie unwittingly sets a disastrous chain of events in motion. A woman is found murdered with a box of Matchbaker cookies by her side and the misdirected couple is detained by the police. Now Vangie is going out of her way to put things right. But who's telling the truth?
There's a lot going on in VANGIE VALE AND THE MURDERED MACARON. Everybody lies. And most of those lies are accepted as truth. Readers too, are unaware and accept the lies as truths, just like Vangie. As the truth changes, everyone must revisit all they've learned and readjust. There are a lot of characters as well, each important, and each with his or her own issues and agendas. There's also a lot of important backstory of which readers and most characters are unaware. Important information is hinted at and will hopefully be slowly revealed in future books.
This first book in the Matchbaker Mystery series looks at human nature, and the motivations within us all. A complicated story, VANGIE VALE AND THE MURDERED MACARON, introduces us to a unique protagonist with a hidden background. Vangie Vale is an intriguing character. She's a pastor with issues. She makes mistakes, acts out in anger, and then does all she can to make peace and rectify what she's done.
FTC Disclosure – The publisher sent me a digital ARC in the hopes I would review it.
The First Matchbaker Mystery
Vangie Vale has been relocated to Saint Agnes, Montana. A part time pastor and more time baker, Vangie is doing penance, biding her time, and creating delicious baked goods in her bakery. When a stuck up southern belle named Scarlet gives a parting dig to Vangie and her friend, Vangie decides to assist karma and gives the woman and her blond James Bond type partner incorrect directions. Yet by giving in to her baser instincts, Vangie unwittingly sets a disastrous chain of events in motion. A woman is found murdered with a box of Matchbaker cookies by her side and the misdirected couple is detained by the police. Now Vangie is going out of her way to put things right. But who's telling the truth?
There's a lot going on in VANGIE VALE AND THE MURDERED MACARON. Everybody lies. And most of those lies are accepted as truth. Readers too, are unaware and accept the lies as truths, just like Vangie. As the truth changes, everyone must revisit all they've learned and readjust. There are a lot of characters as well, each important, and each with his or her own issues and agendas. There's also a lot of important backstory of which readers and most characters are unaware. Important information is hinted at and will hopefully be slowly revealed in future books.
This first book in the Matchbaker Mystery series looks at human nature, and the motivations within us all. A complicated story, VANGIE VALE AND THE MURDERED MACARON, introduces us to a unique protagonist with a hidden background. Vangie Vale is an intriguing character. She's a pastor with issues. She makes mistakes, acts out in anger, and then does all she can to make peace and rectify what she's done.
FTC Disclosure – The publisher sent me a digital ARC in the hopes I would review it.
September 4, 2017
First of all I love the name Vangie Vale. When I first heard the name I chuckled. I thought is was the perfect name for a cozy.
Evangaline "Vangie" Vale ended up in Montana after leaving her North Carolina ministry due to a scandal. Her sister talked her into opening a bakery since she is only a part time pastor & will need other work. If she can just keep her nose clean for 2 years then she can go back to North Carolina, but that's hard to do when a box of cookies from your shop end up at a murder scene. Vangie decides to figure out who the killer, but it will be hard since the sheriff already has it out for her.
Seems like to me cozies are the latest fad right now & this one fits right in. You got an amateur sleuth taking matters into her own hand to prove that she is innocent. She teams up with the mostly unlikely possible suspect to figure out the truth behind the mystery. It has mystery, funny, food. And even a recipe.
This little small town has a lot of secrets. It kept me reading wanting to find out about all the secretness going on. I usually guess the killers but boy this one had me fooled. Two thumbs up for Ms. Syme. This seems like its going to be a pretty interesting series.
I received this Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for an honest review. This review is my own opinion.
Evangaline "Vangie" Vale ended up in Montana after leaving her North Carolina ministry due to a scandal. Her sister talked her into opening a bakery since she is only a part time pastor & will need other work. If she can just keep her nose clean for 2 years then she can go back to North Carolina, but that's hard to do when a box of cookies from your shop end up at a murder scene. Vangie decides to figure out who the killer, but it will be hard since the sheriff already has it out for her.
Seems like to me cozies are the latest fad right now & this one fits right in. You got an amateur sleuth taking matters into her own hand to prove that she is innocent. She teams up with the mostly unlikely possible suspect to figure out the truth behind the mystery. It has mystery, funny, food. And even a recipe.
This little small town has a lot of secrets. It kept me reading wanting to find out about all the secretness going on. I usually guess the killers but boy this one had me fooled. Two thumbs up for Ms. Syme. This seems like its going to be a pretty interesting series.
I received this Advanced Reader Copy in exchange for an honest review. This review is my own opinion.
July 30, 2021
4.5 Stars
Banished from her home parish, Evangeline "Vangie" Vale is sent to a small Montana town to minister as a part-time pastor. Since her pastoral work will not be enough alone to finance her livelihood, she invests in a bakery. A chance encounter with Hollywood types thrusts her into the mystery of a local woman whose dead body is decorated with a box of macarons from Vangie's business.
I almost feel as though I should recuse myself from writing a review as I immediately became friends with Vangie. The character is so real and so likeable that it's almost impossible not to want her company. Moreover, the cast of characters who make up the book is no less realistic. Each one, from the major players to the most minor, is well fleshed out and relatable.
The road on this mystery was long, arduous, and twisty. At one point, I told myself "it's not the destination; it's the journey". But that's not true, because both were equally important and the journey was the destination and the destination was the journey. If you are accustomed to shorter, quickly-solved cosies then this will not be for you. If, on the other hand, you are willing to put in the time, you will be rewarded with a very satisfying story rich with authentic characters and a well-crafted plot.
I look forward to travelling further along this journey with Vangie - so much so that I've already broken my rule (of not consecutively reading a series) and started the next book.
Recommended with the above warning that these stories take time and commitment to unfold.
Banished from her home parish, Evangeline "Vangie" Vale is sent to a small Montana town to minister as a part-time pastor. Since her pastoral work will not be enough alone to finance her livelihood, she invests in a bakery. A chance encounter with Hollywood types thrusts her into the mystery of a local woman whose dead body is decorated with a box of macarons from Vangie's business.
I almost feel as though I should recuse myself from writing a review as I immediately became friends with Vangie. The character is so real and so likeable that it's almost impossible not to want her company. Moreover, the cast of characters who make up the book is no less realistic. Each one, from the major players to the most minor, is well fleshed out and relatable.
The road on this mystery was long, arduous, and twisty. At one point, I told myself "it's not the destination; it's the journey". But that's not true, because both were equally important and the journey was the destination and the destination was the journey. If you are accustomed to shorter, quickly-solved cosies then this will not be for you. If, on the other hand, you are willing to put in the time, you will be rewarded with a very satisfying story rich with authentic characters and a well-crafted plot.
I look forward to travelling further along this journey with Vangie - so much so that I've already broken my rule (of not consecutively reading a series) and started the next book.
Recommended with the above warning that these stories take time and commitment to unfold.
October 24, 2017
I finished this late last night and couldn't stay away to write the review! I read the second book in this series first (given by the author for a review) and enjoyed it so much I bought the first in the series.
I really like Vangie Vale! She is caring and concerned about those around her and their needs. Splitting her time between her bakery and part time pastoral duty you get to see her in the different settings and how she interacts with the community. Her caring just takes things a bit further than most as, in this story, she tries to help a man she just met prove he is innocent of murder. This story had lots of twists and a slew of characters but you get to know the vital one's from Vangie's perspective as she pieces the clues together to finally solve the case. And wow, I did not see that ending coming!
Having already read the second book it was nice to get some background on her relationships with some of the other characters. I'm really looking forward to the third book which comes out next month to see what Vangie gets up to next!
I really like Vangie Vale! She is caring and concerned about those around her and their needs. Splitting her time between her bakery and part time pastoral duty you get to see her in the different settings and how she interacts with the community. Her caring just takes things a bit further than most as, in this story, she tries to help a man she just met prove he is innocent of murder. This story had lots of twists and a slew of characters but you get to know the vital one's from Vangie's perspective as she pieces the clues together to finally solve the case. And wow, I did not see that ending coming!
Having already read the second book it was nice to get some background on her relationships with some of the other characters. I'm really looking forward to the third book which comes out next month to see what Vangie gets up to next!
April 21, 2020
Saint Agnes, Montana is a small town where
Evangeline Vale better known as Vangie has
been placed a part time pastor.
Vangie has opened a bakery named the
Matchmaker Bakery. This is her full time job.
Vangie is able to match you to the perfect
pantry and beverage.
When one of the Matchmaker Bakery boxes
is found at the scene of a murder, Vangie
becomes a person of interest. Vangie decides
to begin her own investigation to find the
murderer. She opens more than one can of
worms.
Small town gossipy neighbors, a Sheriff with
an unknown dislike of Vangie, a colorful, cast
of quirky, well defined characters with a lot
of secrets underlying their behavior making
one wonder who can be trusted.
A fast paced, well plotted murder mystery
with many twists and turns.
A delicious murdered macaron recipe at
the end of the story.
Evangeline Vale better known as Vangie has
been placed a part time pastor.
Vangie has opened a bakery named the
Matchmaker Bakery. This is her full time job.
Vangie is able to match you to the perfect
pantry and beverage.
When one of the Matchmaker Bakery boxes
is found at the scene of a murder, Vangie
becomes a person of interest. Vangie decides
to begin her own investigation to find the
murderer. She opens more than one can of
worms.
Small town gossipy neighbors, a Sheriff with
an unknown dislike of Vangie, a colorful, cast
of quirky, well defined characters with a lot
of secrets underlying their behavior making
one wonder who can be trusted.
A fast paced, well plotted murder mystery
with many twists and turns.
A delicious murdered macaron recipe at
the end of the story.
July 27, 2017
A new to me author and a book that will keep you turning the pages as fast as you can to see what happens.
I love the small town feel and what was great, Vangie is a baker, part time pastor and now investigator. New and fresh in the cozy world that makes you want to read more. What happens when a customer gets some macaroons? Vangie in trouble. She tries to stay under the radar of the police but that is about to change.
Blackmail, lies, secrets that is something that will get your interest and hold it. A fun read for everyone.
I love the small town feel and what was great, Vangie is a baker, part time pastor and now investigator. New and fresh in the cozy world that makes you want to read more. What happens when a customer gets some macaroons? Vangie in trouble. She tries to stay under the radar of the police but that is about to change.
Blackmail, lies, secrets that is something that will get your interest and hold it. A fun read for everyone.
July 21, 2017
This was one of the best murder mysteries I've read. I couldn't put it down. The author kept you guessing right from the start till nearly the end of the book who was doing the murders, lots of twists and turns, extremely well written. A must to read.
August 11, 2017
This is the first offering in a new series, and I found it fascinating. Our main character, Vangie, is a bit of a Jill of all trades--baker, pastor, and investigator. She has just recently arrived in Saint Agnes, Montana and opened her bakery, specializing in macarons, strudels, and cookies.
When a murder victim is found with a box of her macarons in hand, and she becomes a suspect, her investigative skills kick in. From there, she and the reader will discover lies, secrets, and blackmail, leading to a surprising reveal of the killer.
Vangie's past seems to be somewhat complicated, although we don't know everything about it yet. She appears to have had some trouble in North Carolina which resulted in the church sending her to Montana. Because of that, apparently, a member of the local church council has it out for her and reports every little thing she does to the bishop. He is not a very likable character, but he fits into the scheme of things very well.
The sheriff also doesn't seem to like Vangie very much, even though she helps him find the killer. Hopefully, we'll get a little more insight into that relationship as the series progresses.
As for the "matchbaker" in the series title....you'll just have to read the book to see what that's about! It adds another layer to the book, and to Vangie's personality, making her a most unique cozy heroine.
I'm already looking forward to Vangie Vale and the Strangled Strudel.
When a murder victim is found with a box of her macarons in hand, and she becomes a suspect, her investigative skills kick in. From there, she and the reader will discover lies, secrets, and blackmail, leading to a surprising reveal of the killer.
Vangie's past seems to be somewhat complicated, although we don't know everything about it yet. She appears to have had some trouble in North Carolina which resulted in the church sending her to Montana. Because of that, apparently, a member of the local church council has it out for her and reports every little thing she does to the bishop. He is not a very likable character, but he fits into the scheme of things very well.
The sheriff also doesn't seem to like Vangie very much, even though she helps him find the killer. Hopefully, we'll get a little more insight into that relationship as the series progresses.
As for the "matchbaker" in the series title....you'll just have to read the book to see what that's about! It adds another layer to the book, and to Vangie's personality, making her a most unique cozy heroine.
I'm already looking forward to Vangie Vale and the Strangled Strudel.
December 4, 2017
This book was way too long for the story. It felt like too many twists were added. By the time I got to the end there were characters in play that I couldn't remember how they related to the story. At the 50% mark I took a break and realized I was only half way through but it felt like we had reached the reveal point. The motives didn't make sense at all, and keeping the main characters scandal a secret was more annoying than suspenseful.
June 14, 2018
This was an easy, light read for me. Vangie is a part-time pastor and bakery owner who is unexpectedly involved in solving a murder investigation despite repeated warnings to stay out of it. The characters are introduced, but since this is the beginning of a series, the author has held back some information for future books. Though there were some distracting grammatical mistakes, the mystery kept me guessing until the end.
October 4, 2017
"Vangie Vale & the Murdered Macaron” is a complex mystery, and a welcome beginning to the “The Matchbaker Mysteries” series.
Read full review in the 2017 October issue of InD'tale Magazine.
Read full review in the 2017 October issue of InD'tale Magazine.
December 31, 2023
Overall, the book was exciting in the second half, which is why I gave it 3 stars, but still a bit clunky at times with the writing. There were some great ideas but too many of them and missed opportunities to fully flesh out those ideas. In addition, there were too many characters and not enough depth to the characters.
The characters were not described enough to the reader or given a description of their appearance too late in the book, after already forming a picture in my head of what I thought the character looked like. For example, the main character, Vangie, had a specific haircut and color, which was not revealed until the middle of the book, after already pictured her looking differently for the whole first half of the book. I also thought Austin and Leo were more interesting characters and would have enjoyed more depth into their thoughts and feelings.
This book became more interesting in the second half. I also liked the setting, but it wasn't described enough. I enjoyed the fact that it was hard to guess what was happening until the very end. However, even when things were revealed that I didn't know before, I had to stop and think about it before it made sense because of three reasons:
1) There were so many characters introduced fleetingly that it took a minute to remember who they were
2) The way things were worded, at times, caused confusion. I feel like more editing would have been helpful. The syntax and semantics of the writing, at times, was not always the greatest. This caused me to have to re-read sentences to understand the meaning, which was annoying.
3) Details I didn't need or want were provided while other information was left out. For example, I still do not know exactly why Vangie was on probation. Are pastors not allowed to have romantic relationships? It didn't seem like that was the case earlier in the book. So that unresolved major mystery about the book was unsatisfying and disappointing in the end.
Other things about the book:
1) I felt Vangie was a bit dumb and confusing, although I enjoyed her compassionate and open nature. I feel like Vangie would have been more interesting if she were smarter and compassionate and caring at the same time. It's also a bit unbelievable that everyone else in the town is even dumber than than the main character, causing her to have to solve the mystery of the crimes. The characters only appeared to be somewhat smart because so much info was withheld from the reader. However, the choices Vangie makes do not often make sense. For example, Vangie decides to break into a house while Derrick was already seen breaking into the house because she feels she needs to stop Derrick from getting into further trouble. That was pretty dumb of her and did not really make sense, particularly in the context of her own character. Previously, she gets revenge on a customer who calls her fat by giving her the wrong directions. Now, she is willing to commit a crime to " help" someone else. Why did she think she would be helping Derrick by breaking and entering? Why would that help anyone if she was also caught breaking and entering? It just comes across like she's dumb but yet she solves all the crimes. And even though she's new to town and people do not appear to trust her, the people suddenly open up to her when they are confessing things.
2) In addition, the way things were introduced or revealed in the book often read like technical writing, rather than showing the reader what needed to be known. This made a lot of parts, particularly in the beginning, very boring, and I almost stopped reading the book entirely. Many details were repeated that were not important or meaningful.
3) When momentum was built behind solving a mystery, such as the murder weapon and the traditions of passing along the veterans' knives between homes, it was dropped and never spoken of again. The reader can deduce the murder weapon was Nikki's in the end, but after so much build up about the knife, the way that was revealed felt disappointing. In addition, there was so much emphasis placed on removing fingerprints and fingerprints that were still on the weapons, etc, but that plot twist just dropped later.
The characters were not described enough to the reader or given a description of their appearance too late in the book, after already forming a picture in my head of what I thought the character looked like. For example, the main character, Vangie, had a specific haircut and color, which was not revealed until the middle of the book, after already pictured her looking differently for the whole first half of the book. I also thought Austin and Leo were more interesting characters and would have enjoyed more depth into their thoughts and feelings.
This book became more interesting in the second half. I also liked the setting, but it wasn't described enough. I enjoyed the fact that it was hard to guess what was happening until the very end. However, even when things were revealed that I didn't know before, I had to stop and think about it before it made sense because of three reasons:
1) There were so many characters introduced fleetingly that it took a minute to remember who they were
2) The way things were worded, at times, caused confusion. I feel like more editing would have been helpful. The syntax and semantics of the writing, at times, was not always the greatest. This caused me to have to re-read sentences to understand the meaning, which was annoying.
3) Details I didn't need or want were provided while other information was left out. For example, I still do not know exactly why Vangie was on probation. Are pastors not allowed to have romantic relationships? It didn't seem like that was the case earlier in the book. So that unresolved major mystery about the book was unsatisfying and disappointing in the end.
Other things about the book:
1) I felt Vangie was a bit dumb and confusing, although I enjoyed her compassionate and open nature. I feel like Vangie would have been more interesting if she were smarter and compassionate and caring at the same time. It's also a bit unbelievable that everyone else in the town is even dumber than than the main character, causing her to have to solve the mystery of the crimes. The characters only appeared to be somewhat smart because so much info was withheld from the reader. However, the choices Vangie makes do not often make sense. For example, Vangie decides to break into a house while Derrick was already seen breaking into the house because she feels she needs to stop Derrick from getting into further trouble. That was pretty dumb of her and did not really make sense, particularly in the context of her own character. Previously, she gets revenge on a customer who calls her fat by giving her the wrong directions. Now, she is willing to commit a crime to " help" someone else. Why did she think she would be helping Derrick by breaking and entering? Why would that help anyone if she was also caught breaking and entering? It just comes across like she's dumb but yet she solves all the crimes. And even though she's new to town and people do not appear to trust her, the people suddenly open up to her when they are confessing things.
2) In addition, the way things were introduced or revealed in the book often read like technical writing, rather than showing the reader what needed to be known. This made a lot of parts, particularly in the beginning, very boring, and I almost stopped reading the book entirely. Many details were repeated that were not important or meaningful.
3) When momentum was built behind solving a mystery, such as the murder weapon and the traditions of passing along the veterans' knives between homes, it was dropped and never spoken of again. The reader can deduce the murder weapon was Nikki's in the end, but after so much build up about the knife, the way that was revealed felt disappointing. In addition, there was so much emphasis placed on removing fingerprints and fingerprints that were still on the weapons, etc, but that plot twist just dropped later.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 28, 2018
A (Most welcome) better than I expected mystery
While coming out of a terrible book slump, I've found myself reading (by chance) a string of unsatisfying books. So much so that I couldn't finish them. (Hence why there are several salty DNF reviews on my Goodreads account 😂) but I couldn't be more pleased that this book exceeded my expectations and that I am definitely interested enough to look for the next books in the series.
I don't usually care for e-books, but I had the chance to purchase it while it was free, through either BookBub or Booksy, and I thought I'd try anything if the price was right. Haha.
But a cozy-style mystery set in Montana that features a bakery? One of the places near and dear to me (I got my B.A. at the University of Montana in Missoula) and baking is a particular hobby of mine, how could I refuse? So I didn't.
I really loved the mystery itself, I felt it had depth and layers to really feel like a mystery, not just a side problem that the MC just happens upon. I will admit that on occasion certain things seemed a tad forced, but that could just be my perception since this (felt like it) was a very dialogue and internal thought heavy book as opposed to actions showing the reader the story.
I was a bit iffy on Vangie, the MC, for most of the book. I can't quite put my finger on why, but I obviously like the book enough that I'm looking forward to reading the next one and seeing if my opinion changes.
The side characters were interesting and varied, even if there were plenty of occasions where I felt interactions were somewhat forced, not least of which was the stereotypical/trope-y instant dislike of the MC because she wasn't a local, but that's also perhaps and unfair judgement on my part, having never actually lived in a small town.
(Not my full thoughts, but perhaps I'll write a longer review when I'm not typing on my Kindle)
Overall, 3.5 stars, rounded up because of all the books I've read/DNF-ed/or picked up and put back down, I actually wanted to come back to this one, something that hasn't happened in a while. And for that I'm grateful.
While coming out of a terrible book slump, I've found myself reading (by chance) a string of unsatisfying books. So much so that I couldn't finish them. (Hence why there are several salty DNF reviews on my Goodreads account 😂) but I couldn't be more pleased that this book exceeded my expectations and that I am definitely interested enough to look for the next books in the series.
I don't usually care for e-books, but I had the chance to purchase it while it was free, through either BookBub or Booksy, and I thought I'd try anything if the price was right. Haha.
But a cozy-style mystery set in Montana that features a bakery? One of the places near and dear to me (I got my B.A. at the University of Montana in Missoula) and baking is a particular hobby of mine, how could I refuse? So I didn't.
I really loved the mystery itself, I felt it had depth and layers to really feel like a mystery, not just a side problem that the MC just happens upon. I will admit that on occasion certain things seemed a tad forced, but that could just be my perception since this (felt like it) was a very dialogue and internal thought heavy book as opposed to actions showing the reader the story.
I was a bit iffy on Vangie, the MC, for most of the book. I can't quite put my finger on why, but I obviously like the book enough that I'm looking forward to reading the next one and seeing if my opinion changes.
The side characters were interesting and varied, even if there were plenty of occasions where I felt interactions were somewhat forced, not least of which was the stereotypical/trope-y instant dislike of the MC because she wasn't a local, but that's also perhaps and unfair judgement on my part, having never actually lived in a small town.
(Not my full thoughts, but perhaps I'll write a longer review when I'm not typing on my Kindle)
Overall, 3.5 stars, rounded up because of all the books I've read/DNF-ed/or picked up and put back down, I actually wanted to come back to this one, something that hasn't happened in a while. And for that I'm grateful.
July 30, 2017
I think this was the first time I read a cozy set in Montana and after reading this book (and the author's notes), I want to visit! It sounds like a calm and peaceful place to visit - assuming you don't stumble across a murder!
Vangie is a minister that has been sent to Montana as part of a reconciliation. We really don't know what happened in NC to get her sent to Montana or what the church council has been told. We find a little bit out at the end, but for me that just left me wanting to know more! It is hard to like Pete Mayhew from the church council because he seems to have it in for Vangie and reports her to the bishop for all these minor things - like standing on the corner of her property next to the Sheriff's land to be able to use her cell phone. Granted the Sheriff is complaining but we don't know why because she isn't technically on his property. And then when her store window gets broken, Pete seems to think it is her fault some how. Like I said, not very likable and has way to much time on his hands!
Then there is the Sheriff who doesn't like her for some reason and we never really find out why. He does seem to soften his attitude towards her in the end when she helps him solve the mystery of who killed Claire, but he doesn't seem very happy about it! Perhaps because his beliefs were challenged especially when he was wrong.
Then there is the mystery - who killed Claire and why? The author does a great job in leading us down various paths and hinting at suspects...I was very surprised when it was all revealed because it was not a character i was suspecting...I was close but no cigar. And as with most cozies, Vangie finds herself in the middle of the investigation whether she wanted to be there or not!
I read a copy of the book that to my understanding was changed a bit - nothing too substantial but I am waiting to find out how this one incident changes the book. Either way the book was enjoyable and I liked reading the Macaron receipe at the end. I don't know that I'll try making any but they sure do sound yummy!
Vangie is a minister that has been sent to Montana as part of a reconciliation. We really don't know what happened in NC to get her sent to Montana or what the church council has been told. We find a little bit out at the end, but for me that just left me wanting to know more! It is hard to like Pete Mayhew from the church council because he seems to have it in for Vangie and reports her to the bishop for all these minor things - like standing on the corner of her property next to the Sheriff's land to be able to use her cell phone. Granted the Sheriff is complaining but we don't know why because she isn't technically on his property. And then when her store window gets broken, Pete seems to think it is her fault some how. Like I said, not very likable and has way to much time on his hands!
Then there is the Sheriff who doesn't like her for some reason and we never really find out why. He does seem to soften his attitude towards her in the end when she helps him solve the mystery of who killed Claire, but he doesn't seem very happy about it! Perhaps because his beliefs were challenged especially when he was wrong.
Then there is the mystery - who killed Claire and why? The author does a great job in leading us down various paths and hinting at suspects...I was very surprised when it was all revealed because it was not a character i was suspecting...I was close but no cigar. And as with most cozies, Vangie finds herself in the middle of the investigation whether she wanted to be there or not!
I read a copy of the book that to my understanding was changed a bit - nothing too substantial but I am waiting to find out how this one incident changes the book. Either way the book was enjoyable and I liked reading the Macaron receipe at the end. I don't know that I'll try making any but they sure do sound yummy!
August 6, 2017
I am so glad I got the chance to read this book. It is a refreshing book with wonderful characters that make the story so good. Vangie Vale is not your typical character in a cozy book. She is one complex woman in a small town in the beautiful setting of Montana. I have been to Montana before and it is easy to fall in love with the state. The landscape alone takes your breath away. The people are friendly and always helpful. It's the perfect place for Vangie to start over. She owns a bakery that has a quirky gimmick. I did have to laugh at how clever it was . Tourists couldn't resist stopping in at the bakery for fresh baked goods matched up especially for them. What I really liked about Angie was her other job as pastor of the small town. As you get further into the story, you will discover some background on her that will explain why she landed in Saint Agnes, Montana.
Vangie has several goals in mind. She wants to help people and stay out of the limelight. Oh if only that could happen her life would be carefree. But it is not to be when a famous actor shows up in her bakery. I liked how Vangie wasn't that impressed about who he was which I'm sure must have hurt his ego. The mystery is subtle, and leaves behind secrets, blackmail and bodies. The best part of the entire book is that I couldn't figure out who the killer was. I had in my head who I thought it was, but with the twists the author delivers I quickly went to another suspect. The book is well written and I liked how the author touched on religion in a way that was not preachy. Along the way I found myself so engrossed in the book I forgot about everything going on around me.
I loved the ending and how the author left us with questions as to where Vangie finds herself next. This is sure to be a series to follow and don't forgot to try the recipe at the end of the book. Thank you for a clean mystery that deals with forgiveness, redemption and family.
I received a copy of this book from The Great Escapes Virtual Book Tours. The review is my own opinion.
Vangie has several goals in mind. She wants to help people and stay out of the limelight. Oh if only that could happen her life would be carefree. But it is not to be when a famous actor shows up in her bakery. I liked how Vangie wasn't that impressed about who he was which I'm sure must have hurt his ego. The mystery is subtle, and leaves behind secrets, blackmail and bodies. The best part of the entire book is that I couldn't figure out who the killer was. I had in my head who I thought it was, but with the twists the author delivers I quickly went to another suspect. The book is well written and I liked how the author touched on religion in a way that was not preachy. Along the way I found myself so engrossed in the book I forgot about everything going on around me.
I loved the ending and how the author left us with questions as to where Vangie finds herself next. This is sure to be a series to follow and don't forgot to try the recipe at the end of the book. Thank you for a clean mystery that deals with forgiveness, redemption and family.
I received a copy of this book from The Great Escapes Virtual Book Tours. The review is my own opinion.
August 17, 2017
Vangie Vale quickly became one of my favorite cozy mystery heroines. Vangie is a pastor and a baker and just an all around fabulous character. Oh and she's more than just a baker, she's a Matchbaker. She can match you with the kind of food you want to eat. She also loves Sherlock. (Yay, me, too)
I loved this book so much I've already pre-ordered book 2 Vangie Vale and the Corpseless Custard, and I don't often do that.
This book was smartly written and by that I mean, Vangie isn't one who falls into trouble, though she does manage to get herself knee...nah neck deep in it several times. She's a wonderfully kind woman, especially when it comes to some rather unkind people, especially Henry's agent, Scarlet, who really doesn't deserve any kindness. (She became a little more easy to handle as the story went on)
I particularly liked the primary murder suspect, Henry. (Somehow I kept picturing looking like Ioan Gruffudd, though I'm not sure why because he's not blonde) He was a man with secrets, but he was really a lovable guy.
It is through these two people that Vangie gets drawn into the murder of a former citizen of Saint Agnes who has lots of secrets of her own.
There are so many twists and turns in the plot that it really keeps you on your toes guessing who the killer was, all the while hoping that Vangie doesn't get into trouble thus resulting her losing her job as pastor. She had some past issues that resulted in her being assigned to this small Montana town. (I wish her back story was more developed, so we really knew why her job was on the line.)
This is a great start to a new series.
I loved this book so much I've already pre-ordered book 2 Vangie Vale and the Corpseless Custard, and I don't often do that.
This book was smartly written and by that I mean, Vangie isn't one who falls into trouble, though she does manage to get herself knee...nah neck deep in it several times. She's a wonderfully kind woman, especially when it comes to some rather unkind people, especially Henry's agent, Scarlet, who really doesn't deserve any kindness. (She became a little more easy to handle as the story went on)
I particularly liked the primary murder suspect, Henry. (Somehow I kept picturing looking like Ioan Gruffudd, though I'm not sure why because he's not blonde) He was a man with secrets, but he was really a lovable guy.
It is through these two people that Vangie gets drawn into the murder of a former citizen of Saint Agnes who has lots of secrets of her own.
There are so many twists and turns in the plot that it really keeps you on your toes guessing who the killer was, all the while hoping that Vangie doesn't get into trouble thus resulting her losing her job as pastor. She had some past issues that resulted in her being assigned to this small Montana town. (I wish her back story was more developed, so we really knew why her job was on the line.)
This is a great start to a new series.
September 29, 2017
I was so surprised when I received the email that said that I had won a copy of this book because something about the title intrigued me...maybe it was Macaron's.
When it came in the mail ... I COULD NOT WAIT TO DIVE IN... and that I did too! One word comes to mind- COZY. I seriously sat down, bundled in my warm electric blanket and immediately connected with the not so average Vangie. She is complex, looking for a do-over in the picturesque setting of Montana. Her baked goods are something that gets that town talking, right away! Imagine having food that matches your personality? But, beyond this bakery, which to me as a reader sounds like a dream come true...she is also a pastor and her background goes even beyond. She is a lot like me, goal setter and a person with compassion but one who does not want the credit. This plays a factor in the next character introduced, a famous actor, which really doesn't fluff Vangie's feathers...like some would.
It was here that I was hooked! The story started to twist...to turn... secrets began emerging, bodies showed up....blackmail began. The best part was...and I read A LOT and usually figure a story out way before the end...I COULD NOT FIGURE OUT WHO the killer was. I thought I knew but then, another thing would happen, leaving me discarding that character and thinking of another. This kept happening. Throughout the book. That in and of itself if REFRESHING!
I was so excited at the end, thinking that this is book 1 and how many others could follow. (I am a N.R. fan...so bring on the trilogies please!)
When it came in the mail ... I COULD NOT WAIT TO DIVE IN... and that I did too! One word comes to mind- COZY. I seriously sat down, bundled in my warm electric blanket and immediately connected with the not so average Vangie. She is complex, looking for a do-over in the picturesque setting of Montana. Her baked goods are something that gets that town talking, right away! Imagine having food that matches your personality? But, beyond this bakery, which to me as a reader sounds like a dream come true...she is also a pastor and her background goes even beyond. She is a lot like me, goal setter and a person with compassion but one who does not want the credit. This plays a factor in the next character introduced, a famous actor, which really doesn't fluff Vangie's feathers...like some would.
It was here that I was hooked! The story started to twist...to turn... secrets began emerging, bodies showed up....blackmail began. The best part was...and I read A LOT and usually figure a story out way before the end...I COULD NOT FIGURE OUT WHO the killer was. I thought I knew but then, another thing would happen, leaving me discarding that character and thinking of another. This kept happening. Throughout the book. That in and of itself if REFRESHING!
I was so excited at the end, thinking that this is book 1 and how many others could follow. (I am a N.R. fan...so bring on the trilogies please!)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews