What do you think?
Rate this book


224 pages, Paperback
First published May 8, 2018
Story: She'll Become A Woman Later
Author: Arisleyda Dilone
Mini Review: Arisleyda Dilone is an intersex Dominican woman who came to the U.S. Because she was raised as a woman, she came to identify herself (and her gender identity) as a woman.
But she never got her period and neither did her breasts grow in, which are often two identifying factors society likes to use to tell someone, "You're a woman now."
I think something good about reading this story is that we read about the experiences of an intersex person who was raised as a woman and was even expected to experience life as a woman. When she finds out that she has male chromosomes, this engages conversations about understanding intersex issues, gender identity, and the culture of shame surrounding (an absence of) period towards intersex individuals. It also touches very briefly on genital mutilation, which is unfortunately still a common practice around the globe--and very dangerous.
Something I'm curious to know from this story is if Arisleyda's family ever learned that she's intersex or if they somehow already knew? At least for me, this part seemed unclear and was never really expanded on.
Story: Periods and Friendship
Author: Anne Friedman and Aminatou Sow
Mini Review: There's something relieving about having someone who understands and knows what you're going through in any aspect, and just having them be there for you can help with the situation. The same can also go for periods.
This story features an ongoing dialogue--during the course of a single cycle--between two women: Anne Friedman and Aminatou Sow. Of course, their experiences with period and having it associated with shame is included in this story, as well as the different aspects of misogyny involved in shaming those who experience periods, even if it's an issue that affects others besides women. The conversations people hold often focuses solely on people who are AFAB instead of all who have period, including trans and non-binary folks; this story challenges that. Furthermore, this story also talks about how important it is to educate about period due to the lack of knowledge there is surrounding period.
Several books are recommended between the two in this dialogue, but it could also be taken as personal recommendations for people to better understand how bodies function, how each body functions differently, and so on.
This story encourages dialogue regarding period and shows how addressing this issue is empowering. Period is part of the biology of a human being, and it's acknowledged that period shouldn't be used as an ultra-political tool or as a so-called source of power. It is a biological cycle and a reality for many people. It's as simple as that. However, I felt that this focused more on dialogue than on resolution. (I thought of another critique of this story, but because I'm sick--and therefore forgetful--, I'll have to bring it up when I'm able to remember it.)
Story: Going with the Flow: Blood and Sisterhood at the London Marathon
Author: Madame Gandhi
Mini Review: If there's one thing that those of us who experience period know is that we have no control over it nor over when it comes. This piece is proof of that.
Madame Gandhi chooses to freebleed (in case you don't know what that means, it basically means you choose to not wear a tampon, sanitary pad, or any sort of material for your period once it hits) in order to raise awareness for those without access to resources for menstruation. In a sense, I think that this also made her more aware, by giving her a small glimpse through a single event, of what it's like for those who do not have resources or have inadequate resources. I think that can be an eye-opening event for any woman to experience, and is important to consider when spreading education and awareness.
I do feel like this story could have been longer. It felt pretty short for an important topic such as this one. I do want to know more about what Madame Gandhi thought with this experience, and how it has changed both her perspective and her contributions towards changing things.
Story: I Can't Walk but I Can Bleed
Author: Santina Muha
Mini Review: Those of us who have period know what it's like to have PMS, the pain that comes with menstruation, etc. But what about the experiences of someone who is in a wheelchair and experiences menstruation?
This kind of scenario wasn't something I had given much thought to before this story, but reading this story, I can get a small glimpse into what this kind of thing is like. While there are pros--like if you get period unexpectedly and a stain forms on the back of your pants--, there are also cons. It affects Santina's decision to choose to wear pads over tampons (because tampons are a small risk for TSS, but given her experiences, she is worried it'll debilitate her further and so she chooses not to wear them after a while). It affects how Santina reacts through PMS.
This story also briefly approaches how birth control can be extremely important for those who experience debilitating symptoms of period. This is also important knowledge because there are many women who will need birth control in order to help with irregular periods and other symptoms.
I did feel like sometimes Santina focuses more on able-bodied or non-paraplegic/quadriplegic experiences, so I'm curious: What advice would Santina Muha give for those who share and relate more to her own experiences with period?
Story: There's a First for Everything
Author: Ingrid Nilsen
Mini Review: A lot of us probably remember our first period and what that was like. Even if we had been educated about it, we may have felt frightened regardless about getting that first one and may even feel shame about it.
This is where Ingrid Nilsen comes in with her story. But she not only addresses how her first period was like, but also her experiences with breaking out of the shame surrounding period. First, through the comfort of her mother; second, through a roommate who is understanding about period and ignores the blood; third, through a guy she dates who--instead of acting grossed out--immediately helps out. These are important experiences that seem to have also helped her out of the shame of having been abused, the shame society gives towards lesbians (including closeted lesbians like herself), and so on.
This story also kinda made me think of something, which may not be important for some but I feel is important to bring up. So here's what it's made me think about:
Planned Parenthood is an organization that supports women's health. I have never personally been inside one of their organizations or even to one of the events centralizing them, but I have been aroundis a minor issue that Planned Parenthood is more willing to hand out a free condom instead of free pads (the first, you can just avoid sex and never need products for sex, but period is unavoidable for many until they hit menopause). This is just based on my personal observations. If anyone has an experience that shows otherwise, I think it's important to contribute that to the conversation as well.
To conclude, I kinda felt that her coming out is brushed aside a little, but I wonder if she could have expanded more on how shame leaked out of her life through these experiences and whether or not they influenced how she came out and how she addresses period issues for all--including lesbians and lesbian couples--today.
Story: My Period and Me: A Trans Guy's Guide to Menstruation
Author: Wiley Reading
Mini Review: Menstruation is often used as a signifier in society for womanhood, even though this has been debunked many times. This story expands on how menstruation is not a signifier for womanhood.
Wiley Reading talks about his experiences with period and having to learn to separate bodily functions from how society defines womanhood, and understanding that gender identity and sex identity isn't as binary as we'd like to think. Instead of allowing this biological experience to negate his manhood, he gives a list of ways he copes by reminding himself that he is a man and associating with a community of trans guys who will better understand where is he coming from.
I think it is important to expand on this part as well. I'm curious to hear what advice Wiley Reading has to offer on this topic of gender identity to not just trans guys, but also trans girls and non-binary folks and how separating period from identity doesn't negate gender identity.
(Note: I had a better review for this story set up earlier, but my computer malfunctioned. Had to fix it and, as a result, I had to recreate this review as best as I could.)
Story: Black Blood
Author: Ashley Reese
Mini Review: Hitting puberty is a kind of milestone before receiving period, and Ashley Reese expands on how this affects Blacks specifically.
Ashley Reese expands on how breasts start growing early for almost a quarter of all Black girls (23%). This is in comparison to 15% of Latinas, 10% of White girls, and 2% of Asian girls. The oversexualization of Black girls also makes Black girls targets for sexual abuse. Appropriate educate about periods and the innocence of these young girls who experience puberty earlier than most demographics is absolutely necessary, and Ashley Reese expands on this through her work. It is important to keep these statistics in mind because of how society tends to view marginalized women, particularly focusing on Black girls in this piece, and strive to eliminate racist ideas even in these areas.
Something I would've liked to learn more about in this piece (and may learn more about through more research) is what is happening that Black girls are experiencing puberty and periods earlier. I think learning more about this would be incredibly helpful so that we can better work towards decreasing this incredibly high percentage.
Story: The Homeless Period: It Doesn't Bear Thinking about and That's the Problem
Author: Kylyssa Shay
Mini Review: When us women think about period, we think of its arrival, how it affects us, and of the resources we can utilize to help us with our periods. But what happens if our access to these products is cut off?
Kylyssa Shay addresses how homeless people are affected by period, especially focusing on how the lack of appropriate resources makes it difficult to take care of period. Additionally, Kylyssa Shay lists ways in which we can support others who are homeless and affected by periods. This kind of resolution is crucial, so that we better know how to take care of the issue.
Something I'd want to hear more about is what does she draw from her experiences and how they've affected her personally?
Story: Bad Blood
Author: Emma Straub
Mini Review: Although so many of us experience periods, there are also those whose experiences take on a whole new level.
Emma Straub expands on her own experiences with period, where she was losing incredibly high amounts of blood, was anemic as a result of losing such a significant amount of blood, and was constantly using the bathroom because of the excess blood. This affected her throughout her youth and into her adult years, until she found the reason for this excess loss of blood: fibroids.
She tells her story so that others may be aware of how severe periods can be an indication of a more serious issue. Through raising awareness through her story, she gives others the ability to identify whether or not there's a problem with their period and to also seek treatment.
I wonder what advice she would give to others who are experiencing the same (or even similar) problems, beyond seeking professional help. Are there any tips she'd give while the person is awaiting treatment?
Story: The Politics of Periods
Author: Jennifer Weiss-Wolf
Mini Review: Of course, in order to address periods appropriately, we need to understand the current politics of periods, how it is currently being addressed, and all current issues surrounding it. This is what Jennifer Weiss-Wolf expands on.
Weiss-Wolf addresses where we are in the fight for menstrual equity and how much farther we still need to go. Examples of how much farther we need to go includes eliminating the tampon tax (which sees period as a luxury as opposed to viewing it as a natural biological function) and consideration of providing tampons free or inexpensive for all.
We are still a long way from the end of the fight for menstrual equity, and this emphasizes the politics behind it. I do wonder, after having read this piece, what led Jennifer Weiss-Wolf towards delving more into the politics of periods and what her own individual story involving this is.
Story: Periods, According to Pop Culture
Author: Elizabeth Yuko
Mini Review: Periods aren't limited to just politics and our own personal stories. They can also expand into fictional areas. This is what Elizabeth Yuko expands on.
Elizabeth Yuko gives us further insight into how periods are addressed in media, including in helpful ways. But she also talks about any myths that circulate in the media. She brings up a wide range of resources as examples of how periods are made out to be bad (i.e. men try to avoid women during certain times of the month), and when they also perpetuate myths (i.e. women always experience sync up their periods). Elizabeth Yuko also addresses the period paradox, which is basically that women are told to "suck up" the pain and discomfort of period while also being told that this pain and discomfort is so debilitating that women are incapable of holding a position of power. I found this to be an interesting point, one that I've often thought about as well, and I'm glad that Yuko addressed it here.
I did notice that, based on the media mentioned here, there seem to be very limited fictional resources that openly discuss periods. Although not all literature and films will mention period, obviously, it seems like it's not addressed as often as it truly should be. I also wonder, based on this, what advice Elizabeth Yuko would give to addressing periods better in media, particularly in fiction?
Menstruation stigma is a global human rights issue. When people who menstruate don’t have the means to safely manage their periods, when they don’t have access to supplies, or to bathrooms where they feel safe, they miss out on education and the opportunities it leads to. All societies suffer when half their populations have their educational and economic potential cut short.
Periods happen to lots and lots of people. Many of them are women and girls, but those of us who are something else should have a context for our experience and a way of talking about it without being misgendered.
It’s not unreasonable to provide free menstrual products everywhere[…] We have free toilet paper, so wanting the same for menstrual products is not extreme. This is a normal human function.
By establishing an expectation of period shaming, many modern societies prevent the opportunity to actually bond over an experience that half of the world’s population will likely have in their life.