憂国のモリアーティ 2 [Yūkoku no Moriarty 2]

憂国のモリアーティ [Yūkoku no Moriarty] #2

by Ryōsuke Takeuchi (writer), 竹内良輔, Hikaru Miyoshi (illustrator)

死こそが人の心を動かす──
陸軍内で、麻薬組織掃討の気運が高まる中、極秘の特務機関創設の情報を得たアルバート。直後、ロンドンを訪れたウィリアムが何者かに攫われて──!? 国に巣くう歪みを正すため、モリアーティが仕立てる鮮烈な“犯罪劇"がついに始まる!!

Genres: Manga, Mystery, Historical Fiction, Historical, Graphic Novels, Fiction, Crime

204 pages, Paperback

First published March 3, 2017

About the author

Ryōsuke TAKEUCHI (竹内良輔, Chinese: 竹內良輔) is a Japanese author.

Reviews

[Josu Diamond · Rating 4 out of 5]

Empieza lo bueno.

Este segundo volumen de Mortiarty, el patriotra nos presenta nuevos personajes... ¡SHERLOCK Y WATSON! Estoy chillando porque pensaba que la historia se iba a centrar más en Moriarty y en su misión por concederle a la sociedad la igualdad de clases, pero obviamente uno no puede existir sin el otro. La aparición del dúo dinámico y némesis de Moriarty le suma puntos a la historia, porque ya sabemos que son mentes demasiado brillantes para coexistir en paz.

Las cosas que me fallaron en la primera entrega se subsanan un poco aquí. Este volumen contiene 4 capítulos: uno que funciona como independiente, un segundo y tercero que forman parte de un mismo arco, y por el último el capítulo final, que es la primera parte de otro arco. El primer capítulo, cuya trama tiene que ver con la trama general del manga, me pareció bastante horrible. Demasiado sencillo y con un planteamiento básico que se pinta como algo increíblemente bien pensado y sorprendente.



Los capítulos que hablan sobre el barco, que son la mitad de esta entrega, me parecieron brutales. No solo por el ritmo y los personajes, sino porque en este caso el plan está bien ejecutado y todo es bastante coherente. Aquí ya aparece Sherlock y en el siguiente capítulo conocemos más de este "nuevo" personaje, Watson y la Señora Hudson (que me encanta en esta versión, por cierto).

En definitiva... Sí, me ha gustado bastante. Mucho más entretenido que el primero y con más cohesión en conjunto, formando poco a poco una historia un poco más grande que entremezcla personajes, motivos ocultos, misterio y la meta: cambiar la sociedad victoriana de clases. Continuaré sin duda, ¡porque menudo final!

[b. ♡]

*holmes introduced* - oh no he’s hot!
*watson introduced* - oh no he’s hot!
*lestrade introduced* - oh no he’s hot!

[beep ☀︎ · Rating 5 out of 5]

why is sherlock holmes hot

[Geoff · Rating 4 out of 5]

It will eventually get old seeing Moriarty be so much smarter than those he goes up against, but we're not quite at that point yet. And the potential solution to that issue, Sherlock Holmes, is introduced in this volume. This Sherlock is more flamboyant, assured, and socially adept than some portrayals, but he's still manipulative and single minded when it comes to deduction. Watson makes an appearance too, and h's a pretty standard Watson (and endearing for that as well) It's fun to see his and Moriarty's first meetings and sparring. The general theme of "secret history" and Moriarty masterminding criminal acts in the name of overturning an unfair social caste system of corrupt nobles is still compelling. I'm interested to see where this is going.

**Thanks to the artist, publisher, and NetGalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review.

[Shawna Finnigan · Rating 4 out of 5]

TW// murder, suicide

Note: I didn’t read the bonus chapter as it’s not on the ShonenJump app.

Volume two was even better than volume one! The stakes are higher and the story got a lot more interesting with Sherlock joining the mix. I’m also loving the interactions between some of the side characters, especially Moran/Albert and Mrs. Hudson/John. I can’t wait to keep reading to see what happens next.

[zara · Rating 5 out of 5]

noahtic act should be commemorated as a historical moment for the lgbtq people because that's when sherlock and william, the genius super gay individuals, meet for the first time

[Vikki · Rating 4 out of 5]

Move over Cumberbatch there is a new gay Sherlock in town

[Gem (The Creepy Geek) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved the Noahtic arc! Very dark and we got an introduction to Sherlock!

Also the introduction of Watson and Miss Hudson was perfect!

[Rod Brown · Rating 2 out of 5]

I was hoping this volume would smooth out some of the awkwardness in the script and art of the first volume, but instead the faults are magnified in the opening chapters with extremely dumb plots peopled with characters I can barely tell apart. First Moriarty gets kidnapped by some drug traffickers. Then he takes an ocean cruise to bring justice to a British lord who has been getting away with murder. Both of these cases involve overly-elaborate ruses and a lot of speechifying about the evils of nobility and the corrupt class system.

The final chapter kicks off a retelling of A Study in Scarlet with Moriarty monitoring the actions of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson in the case. It's continued in the next volume, which I have on hand and will read, but I'm pretty sure it will be my last venture with this series.


FOR REFERENCE:

Contents: Chapter 4. The Case of the Noble Kidnapping -- Chapter 5. The Noatich, Act 1 -- Chapter 6. The Noatich, Act 2 -- Chapter 7. A Study in S, Act 1 -- Bonus Manga. Louis the Depressed, Part 2

[Cindee · Rating 5 out of 5]

This volume was even better than the first I really liked how Sherlock was introduced I am really looking forward to where the story goes from here. I am still loving the characters especially William I just love how well he plans things out I like his personality in general I also really liked Sherlock he was well introduced a really interesting character. I am really liking the plot William is doing more to try to cause some kind of change and doing things his own way to change the corrupt system. I really liked how Sherlock and his lot were introduced since they are the complete opposite of William and his people so things should play out differently. I just really like this story it is really good will continue it soon.

[eli. · Rating 5 out of 5]

this is definitely fruity

[Zainab · Rating 4 out of 5]

the entirety of every scene that had sherlock and liam had me in such a chokehold

[Nilo0 · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5/5
جلد دوم رو بیشتر دوست داشتم و خشونت و انتقام‌گیری‌های منصفانه‌تری داشت و شخصیت شرلوک هولمز جالبی هم داشت.
داستان نیمه موند که باید ادامه داد و جلدهای بعدی. و هم خوند.
این بار آلبرت موریارتی می‌شه مسئول تشکیل ام‌آی‌سیکس انگلیس و اختیاراتی پیدا می‌کنه برای اجرای ماموریت‌هایی برای انتقام‌گیری از اشراف‌زاده‌های فاسد به کمک ویلیام برادرش.
دوست دارم ادامه بدم ببینم چی می‌شه.

[Danny_reads · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5⭐

I have to say, I think I enjoyed the Anime's version of the Noahtic Arc a lot more... I love seeing the differences between the Anime and the Manga, but I definitely enjoyed the previous volume more!

[Stay Alive · Rating 5 out of 5]

This series is bloody brilliant!

[TheReadingNest · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5 ⭐️

New obsession unlocked 😍

[Anna Quilter · Rating 3 out of 5]

And enter Sherlock Holmes and Watson and Mrs.Hudson...

[Slinkysnake · Rating 3 out of 5]

Louis my shining star, don't you realise that all your good deeds are working for a bad man?

[Adibah Atiqa (persephtiyareads) · Rating 4 out of 5]

In Chapter 4, I wish the plan of how Liam able to figure out on the kidnapping will be much detailed. Me being a dumb and brainless creature need more sort of like extension so I can full in awe with that brain of yours, Liam 👀

In Chapter 5 & 6 (The Noathic arc), we finally met the full fledged bad and rotten noble who thirsted for the blood he called commoner, “animal”. Gosh, the moment he got the punishment he deserved, I FEEL GOLDEN NGL.

Here, we witnessed how Moriarty’s status acts as weapon or metaphorically, knife that stabbed behind your back. The noble really didn’t see it coming.

And hello, SIR SHERLOCK WHY ARE YOU JUST- so hot!! Okay, enough of that but his introduction with his deduction, that’s it..that’s the very Sherlock’s significance.

We also been clarified from the perspective of Moriarty’s side that their scheme acts as a trigger/catalyst of change in the unequal system when lives hanging on a thread of death.

In Chapter 7 (A Study in Scarlet, Act I), the familiar case!! I couldn’t wait to know more of it. I love the introduction of both Miss Hudson and Dr. Watson.

But let me get this line a spotlight, shall we?

“And that detective will be the protagonist of our play. We’ll see if he has that potential with this audition”

[Shae · Rating 4 out of 5]

I wasn't sure how I was going to feel about this series, but I continue to be surprised. In this volume, we finally get some interaction with Holmes and Watson. We also spend a significant amount of time with them. Though I enjoyed that, I found myself missing the Moriarty brothers, and wondering what mischief they were up to. Looking forward to the next volume for sure.

[LittleMockingbird · Rating 3 out of 5]

What a silly clown man
Also we don't have enough evidence to deny that Sherly was trying to flirt when he talked about the stairs
3.5 stars bc I like the anime version more

[Adam M · Rating 4 out of 5]

As an exceptionally young professor, William James Moriarty has started to make a reputation for himself. He and his brothers have turned their sights on London and they are slowly trying to create more chaos for the aristocracy. Their circle of conspirators grows a little wider, we are introduced to MI-6 and the role it might play in their future. The biggest surprise here was the addition of Sherlock Holmes. I was only surprised because it's only volume two and I sort of figured we would need more time before he showed up and changed their plans. The rivalry hasn't begun here, but the seeds are planted.

Again, plot/pacing/art were all great and kept me reading at a clip. Looking forward to picking up the next installment and seeing how serious it gets.

[⋆˚࿔Ana · Rating 3 out of 5]

Estoy enamorada de todos

[Claudia · Rating 4 out of 5]

Holmesssss!!

[Rin ⭐️ · Rating 4 out of 5]

حلو، شخصيتي المفضله طلعت أكثر سوو💞💖💗👍🏻😭

[waterlilly · Rating 5 out of 5]

grrrrrr j'aime trop

[ifrahaha · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was so much more fun than the first one. Loved the dynamics between Watson, Sherlock and Hudson.

[Yub Yub Commander · Rating 2 out of 5]

I think my biggest issue with the story is that it became trite. I'll be honest, I was more interested in Moriarty from the start. Sherlock has gotten his fair share of retellings and remakes, so having a story from Moriarty's POV was refreshing.

The first chapter of the book jumped around so much that by the end of it, I still didn't know what was going on and I was shocked to find out that it was more like a poorly written one-shot.

The characters are still difficult to distinguish from one another, something I had difficulty with in the first book and had hoped would be better by this one, but I spent the majority of the book wondering who several characters were only to realize they were unimportant. All of the young men have the exact same facial structure and have two hair styles to choose from to distinguish them.

Mild spoiler: Sherlock's POV dominates the entire second half of the story, and the story is yet another retelling of some classic cases. Yes there are new twists to it, but honestly I could care less about Sherlock as a character in this. I find him very flat. Having been introduced to Moriarty first, Sherlock seems like a cheap copy of him with too many cliches and "quirks" to make him unique or interesting.

I found the plot interesting up until the final chapter. Learning more about Moriarty's schemes was interesting, and I wanted to see more of what insane stuff he and his brothers did before Sherlock came onto the scene, because obviously Moriarty has to have had criminal connections and his hands in a lot of stuff well before Sherlock ever met him. I feel like bringing Sherlock in was rushed just for the shock factor of "Oh look, it's Moriarty's enemy." Same with many other well-known Sherlock characters.

[yona!! · Rating 5 out of 5]

J’aime j’aime j’aime j’aime
L’anime est super bien adapté d’ailleurs !! Les épisodes correspondant aux mangas sont très fidèles 🕺🏻Bref. Je suis très fan
(Avis première lecture 17-18 août 2021)

2e lecture le 14/11/2025

[⛅ Sunny (sunnysidereviews) ⛅ · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars

This was really interesting, but some of the ideas didn't make sense to me. Overall amazing story though!