2018 CARNEGIE LONGLIST BOOK 17/20
3.75
This had all the warmth and wit of Katherine Rundell’s previous books. I adored Rooftoppers, and I liked this one too. Perhaps not as much, though - this one didn’t feel quite as effortlessly funny and unique. However, that being said, my overall experience of reading this book was pure enjoyment, and I think it is a book that lots of young readers will really love. I would say that this is a children’s book written with children in mind.
I think Rundell’s biggest talent is her lush, quirky writing. Immediately present from the first pages, the writing is a beautiful compliment to the story, and perfect for readers of all ages. The charming humour is woven into the prose with a lot of skill, and it brought back memories of reading Rooftoppers, which was a completely different story but had a similar story. Rundell’s writing is easy to spot - it is bright and bold and colourful and fun. I also think that this book as effective with the fast paced story line. It is a relatively long book, but the story is swooping and really makes it a quick read. This is something that you can just sit down and get all the way through. I also think it would make a perfect read out loud story. Although I can definitely see the story is aimed at younger kids, as there never really seems to be that much of a threat, and the dangers of the jungle are never really present. This is a light positive read that will make you smile.
I do think that in places it was trying a little too hard to be bold and bright. Some of the scenes and funny moments felt a little unnatural. And sometimes they were overcrowded, which I think was an attempt to try and make the book as quirky as possible. Paired with extremely bold setting, this was just a bit too much for me, though I know some readers will adore that kind of stuff. I wasn’t 100% impressed with the characters either. The whole thing is told from Fred’s POV, which can get a little tiring when you realise that you are stuck with a book that is just a brave, heroic, stereotype. The two girls didn’t really step outside of their allocated boxes much either - though I did like Con. And Max grew a little grating after reading about the same irrating things that he did over 300 pages.
All in all, I thought this was fun ride. Not as good as Rooftoppers, but still a book I think that many people will love. Rundell’s lovely writing is all there, and though this was maybe trying a bit too hard, I think some readers won’t mind that. I liked this book, and left it feeling pretty satisfied.