What do you think?
Rate this book


288 pages, Hardcover
First published April 17, 2018
What I was trying to explain: the final page of any novel is a destination, the creation of form offering the illusion of inevitability, the denial of chaos. We don't love novels because they are like life, but because they are unlike it - deftly organized, filled with the satisfaction of shape. This shapeliness isn't "closure," a modern comfort word too airlessly psychological for the deep gratifications storytelling provides. The great carapace of the novel puts a bridle on the stampede of detail.
And yet the great unsorted pile of detail - that's what a life is. Not the organization of details into shape (that's the novel), but the recognition of the welter of life - notetaking, James's ineluctable consequence of one's greatest inward energy...to take them...as natural as to look, to think, to feel, to recognize, to remember.
You understood - I think you did - that I didn't think of notetaking as material, bricks for the great architecture of a boo, even if Henry James did. I was taking them for themselves. Life is not a story, a settled version. It's an unsorted heap of images we keep going through, the familiar snaps taken up and regarded, then tossed back until, unbidden, they rise again, images that float to the surface of the mind, rise, fall, drift - and return only to drift away again in shadow. They never quite die, and they never achieve form. They are the makings of a life, not of a narrative. Not art, but life training its poignant desire for art. Call them vignettes, these things we finger and drop again into their shoebox.
We all have these snippets rolling around, not stories we tell, just photos that refuse to fade entirely away. These are the framed moments that decide a life and are lost to art because they aren't complete, have no resolution. They're nothing much. Essais, vignettes, memoirs - the French words our stalwart form-seeking Anglophone mind must borrow to articulate our formlessness.
(p99-100)
"Each day was exactingly scheduled, hours given to study (languages especially: Italian, Spanish), transcription of admired texts, drawing and sketching, long walks, correspondence, reading, reading, reading in several languages — both silently and, at night, aloud to one another amid the glow of candles, an alarming expense of nine pounds per annum, but a requirement of the romantic reading life."Is there a sign-up sheet for that lifestyle somewhere?