Eoin Dempsey is a young Irish writer from Ireland who now lives in the United States. Currently he is a teacher in Philadelphia. His first novel, “Finding Rebecca”, is an incredible achievement for a first novel. "The Bogside Boys" is his second work of historical fiction. He obviously did extensive research on the Troubles in Northern Ireland. He met the son of one of the men killed in the Bloody Sunday massacre and an IRA man who had spent 12 years in jail for his activities. He can write very well, but there is an awkwardness at times that is missing from his first novel.
The location, except for a brief stay for the Irish brothers and their mother in Paris, is County Derry. Londonderry is the name preferred by the Protestants. The Irish Catholics live in the Bogside, a cordoned off area outside of town that the Irish call their own. The Protestants live in another area of town and are supported by British soldiers. Two different cultures clash.
Mick and Pat Doherty, twin Irish brothers, live in Bogside with their parents. Using the Westside Story theme, the author writes that Mick is in love with Melissa, a Protestant from the Protestant section of town. Melissa is not a rounded character initially; she lacks depth, plays games and does not seem very interesting a person. Mick, on the other hand, has depth, is honest and direct, is very unselfish and has a wonderful heart. What does he see in Melissa except her looks? The juxtaposition of events with Melissa and events with Mick seem somewhat forced and not fluid for most of the book. However, that improves as the book progresses, and Melissa is a more filled-out character towards the end of the novel.
Their love affair has been a carefully kept secret for 6 months, but Mick decides to introduce her to his family on the day of a peaceful Civil Rights march. Melissa joins the boys and their father for what is supposed to be a peaceful and safe march. However, some of the young Irish lads from another section of the march throw stones and gas canisters at the British soldiers who are trying to keep order. Carried away with enforcement, some soldiers fire on the unarmed, peaceful marchers and kill Mick and Patrick’s father. A few of the boys’ friends who had been throwing stones are killed as well.
Mick and Pat’s mother decides to go to Paris to live with the maternal grandparents. Melissa is to join them soon. However, official investigation of the killings exonerates the soldiers. The Irish marchers are said to be terrorists and the British soldiers acted in self-defense. After hearing the official report, Pat yearns to revenge his father and wants to return to Derry. Mick goes to support him. Trained by the IRA, the boys go on their first mission. Three IRA women meet three British soldiers at a bar and entice them to their car with a story that they are all going to a party. Mick, Pat and a man named, McClean follow them in their car. When the IRA women stop at the side to the road in a deserted area, Mick and his group are told to kill the soldiers. Mick is unable to kill a soldier; he hadn’t known they would be murdering innocent men. He said they should ransom them instead. However, McClean kills one soldier, and Pat kills two of them, including the one that Mick was to kill. Unfortunately, Melissa was in the bar and saw Mick and talked to him.. Maggie, the main IRA woman operative, gets permission to kill Melissa, so that there are no witnesses to link them to the murders.
In order to protect his brother and Melissa, Mick goes to the police and confesses to all the killings.
After serving 15.5 years in prison, Mick gets out of prison with the goal of joining the IRA again in order to sabotage their operations. The main IRA has been making peaceful overtures. Mick joins an IRA radical splinter group that wants to use very violent acts to ignite the Protestants to respond in kind and bring Southern Ireland into the war. The reader has to suspend belief at this point. It does not seem believable to me that Mick would do this after serving all that time in prison.
In any case, in the novel, Mick foils an IRA attempt to blow up dozens of innocent Protestant marchers in Memorial Hall, headquarters of the Apprentice Boys of Derry. Found out for his treachery, Mick is tortured and then rescued by Pat and Mick’s friend, Sean.
All ends well for Mick. He marries Melissa, has a daughter as well as the son he found he had after he got out of prison. We learn the family lives in Dublin, although they have come back to Derry to visit his father’s grave.
The romance was the weakest part of the novel. It was rather awkwardly portrayed. It would have been a better book without the romance. This just does not measure up to Westside Story; it is not done nearly as well. The idea of Mick joining an IRA splinter group in order to sabotage it after his release from prison was not very believable to me either. There were a few other sections that did not make sense, as well. For example, it was not realistic that the brothers would have an intelligent philosophical discussion in the car after Mick was rescued from his torturers. How could Mick even talk at all after being tortured so badly? However, the author did research the situation in Northern Ireland extensively, and there is quite a lot of information to learn in this historical novel. The factual basis is solidly there.