This was a favorite read when I was a teenager, so I decided to revisit it to see if it still holds up.
And surprisingly, it did. It was really interesting to see how many of my favorite tropes were present in this book(and love of them probably sparked by it) - Girl disguised as a boy: check. Historical recreation: check. Romance: check. Family saga: check.
Some frustrations this time around were rough dialogue, and the scope of the book feeling too broad. The narrative/descriptive writing was decent, but the way characters spoke to each other was stilted, cheesy or both. As for the scope, there was a LOT going on here, and while I enjoyed each segment, it lent itself to making the book feel less cohesive, and ultimately dissatisfying because it shifted gears and moved on to a different focus without being a whole thing. I think it would have been better to cut out some of the early history of Daniel and Lyna (that name is another frustration - how the heck do you say it?!) and “zoom in” on their adult lives. Or maybe the opposite - spend time with them as young people in their formative years, then save the adult life for another book.
Overall, however, it was a quick fun read that took me right back to being a voracious reader nerd in a small church. I felt the historical aspect was quite well done, as well as representing both sides of the conflict (here, the American Revolution). If I don’t continue the series, it’s because there are literally thousands of other books on my list that I want to read, and I’ve already read this series at least three times.