This book is extremely adorable, which was it’s main selling point for me. I love the graphics. This is my very first Dolly book I’ve read, so I was a bit disappointed to find out this book is essentially the author’s interpretation of what she thinks Dolly would do, or advice she would give. The author draws from many random quotes, interviews, songs, etc. of Dolly’s since her stardom, and throws it all together to ride the current Dolly hype. I did learn a decent bit of things about Dolly, especially her childhood, so I did enjoy that. The book was very respectfully written about her, so the author’s admiration for Dolly is evident. But it just feels like a rip off. I felt I could probably learn just as much about Dolly, if not more, from other books.
My biggest complaint is that the author can’t seem to make up her mind who her target audience is. Is it preteens/teens? Young adults? Suitable for all ages? A lot of the book and advice is very juvenile, but then occasional adult topics or themes will be present in the book.
I put down the book for 2 months when I got to chapter four. The section about dieting really pissed me off, as I imagine many readers of this book will be young girls. Marino writes, “And apparently sometimes Dolly, and a lot of other celebrities who have to be extremely weight conscious, will chew their food and then spit it out. Not throwing it up, mind you. Just never swallowing it to begin with. It sounds a little gross and borderline eating disorder, but I guess if you’re not spitting your food out in front of anyone and carry a spittoon with you- and I’m not saying that Dolly does- this could work. It’s one way to have your cake and not eat it too” (p. 77).
Why on earth would you ever write that? I can’t recommend buying this for your daughter or nieces. That was wild information to include in a book a lot of impressionable minds will read. It fails at being suitable for a young audience, and it fails at being mature enough for adults to fully enjoy.