I like to review books based on their own context and whether they reach their own goals. So, that said, this prequel story to a sequel film to a prequel film for the original Alien film is not one that I began reading with expectations for classic level literature. But I liked it for what it was.
Alan Dean Foster wrote the best screenplay novelization that I have ever read with his novelization of the original Aliens screenplay. Since he wrote that book before the film was complete, he had not seen any of H.R. Giger's creature and set design, which ended up dramatically influencing the finished product of the film. So, in that first book, we get to see Foster giving us his own vision of the screenplay. It puts on display just how good the story writing was on that first film, even before the impressive visuals.
However, Foster's treatment for Alien: Covenant was not so agreeable to me. Since I know this writer can make something of a good script, I tend to blame the failure of that novelization on the script, not on Foster. The only value that book has is to see how much an improvement Ridley Scott was able to make from the script he had, if Foster's book reflects the original script more closely.
But here, it seems that Alan Dean Foster was probably given greater range to write his own book. I expect he was given some kind of plot to follow. But this is not a novelization of a screenplay. This is a new story that takes place between the prequel films Prometheus and Alien: Covenant. It takes place on earth, and no Xenomorphs make an appearance. But there aren't technically any Xenomorphs in Foster's original Alien novel, either. So that should be fine. Still, many readers may find themselves disappointed to read a novel with the name "Alien", claiming to be part of the franchise, and with an image of a Xenomorph on the cover, without the creatures being included. I'd understand the complaint.
My complaint is less with the lack of aliens, and more with some of the choices in the plot and premise. Most of the story surrounds the launching of the Covenant colony ship, and a group of religious terrorists that wish to stop it. Though I enjoyed the book enough as it is, I was disappointed by the emphasis placed on the terrorist's willingness to lose their own lives for their cause, without adequately providing them with a justification for such actions. True extremists aren't just willing to die for a cause for reasons of extremism alone. Without some belief that their sacrifice will be rewarded, either with something left behind for their family, some sort of measurable glory, or a spiritual consequence in a life to come, they don't just willingly commit suicide. In not providing this, the book's premise is weakened considerably, and these villains become paper thin caricatures instead of a real threat.
Secondly, the perspective of the book places these terrorists in the role of villains for wanting to stop the colony ship from launching, because of a prophet's visions of demonic creatures from beyond. This puts Weyland-Yutani Corporation in the role of victim. But any reader familiar with the Alien franchise will know that these kooky religious folks are actually right. For this colony ship to leave, the earth and everyone on the ship will be put in grave danger by demonic looking creatures. In fact, if they were to succeed, they would actually save the lives of everyone on board. Furthermore, the Weyland-Yutani Corporation has consistently been villainous toward the protagonists of nearly every story ever written in the Alien canon (and outside the canon). It seems to be a lost opportunity that this book was not instead written with the terrorists as the protagonists, and the corporation as the villain. That could have made for some very interesting reading.
Instead we have a somewhat bland, but competently entertaining thriller. Though some of the big pieces don't entirely fit, Foster is still adept at character description and science fiction action, enough to keep this die-hard fan happy through to the last page.
The very best part of my copy of this book is the inscription on the inside cover. It is written by my seven-year-old, who gave it to me for Christmas. He also drew a picture in black pen of he and I watching an Alien movie together, something we have yet to do. But, one day...
Recommended only to very dedicated fans of the Alien franchise, who enjoy supermarket paperback thrillers.
☠
Mass Market Paperback
Titan Books, 2017
Three Stars
December 25, 2017 - January 1, 2018
☠