Although Summer of the Midnight Sun doesn’t break into my favorites list, I did enjoy the story and found a lot of good aspects therein. I think one of the things I most enjoyed about it was the setting. Alaska can be harsh and unforgiving even today, but in those days, before all of the modern conveniences available to those living in a cold climate now, it was downright brutal. I love how the land was almost its own characters and entity. I thought the little details and nuances of their daily life, the supplies they use, their mode of travel grabbed my attention and added a lot to the story.
The characters were intriguing, although I can’t say that I always connected strongly with them. At times they came across as a bit bland. Leah and Jacob Barringer had a really strong sibling relationship, and I liked their interactions together. It took me a while to warm up to her; at times I felt that she was kind of naïve for being a thirty-year-old. Helaina’s character was intriguing, though I’m not sure how realistic it is that a lady was a part of the Pinkerton Agency. I was glad to see some internal struggles with her spirituality, as well as some external struggles in her search for Jayce Kincaid, a long-time friend of Jacob & a man that turned Leah down years before. I think for me there was a lack of urgency in general for the characters; I didn’t feel their panic, fear, sorrow or joy. Sometimes the dialogue felt forced and didn’t seem to flow naturally. There was definitely more telling than showing, and it often felt like watching a movie – I was entertained, but not always moved.
I appreciated how there wasn’t a real villain in the story – there comes to be one, but he is a shadowy, distant figure that mostly just causes problem from afar. The real antagonist in the story was really the setting itself. As I mentioned above, the land came to be its own entity for me and really propelled the plot.
As for the spiritual aspect, it was just alright for me. It was a little on the nose at times and didn’t always weave into the story realistically, though I did like Helaina’s struggles throughout the story, and later Jayce’s toward the end of the story.
The ending is basically a cliff-hanger, but since I didn’t really fall in love with any of these characters, I’m not going to rush out and seek the next book. I would be interested in continuing the series eventually, just perhaps when I’m in the mood for the author’s style and setting.