THE CATHOLIC PRIESTHOOD. Part I. 7 The Great Dignity of the Priesthood.-Vocation to it. Chapter I. Jesus Christ the Eternal Priest 7 Chapter II. Dignity of the Priest.-His Power over Christ's Sacred Body 25 Chapter III. Dignity of the Priest.-His Power over Christ's Mystic Body.-Over the Faithful 38 Chapter IV. Dignity of the Priest.-His Power of Preaching the Word of God 48 Chapter V. God the Author of Vocations 59 Chapter VI. Who are Called to the Priesthood 68 Chapter VII. Motives for Following the Divine Calling to a State of Perfection 75 Chapter VIII. How the Ecclesiastical Student should preserve the Grace of Vocation 85 Chapter IX. Marks of Non-vocation to the Priesthood 103 Chapter X. The Sin of those who Become Priests Without a Divine Vocation 120 Chapter XI. States of Life. -The Third Order of St. Francis 133 Chapter XII. The Desire of a Secular Priest to Embrace the Religious State 151
Father Michael Mueller, C.SS.R., was born in 1825 in Germany. He later joined the Congregation of the Most Holy Redeemer, and was one of eleven clerics sent to the United States by the American Redemptorist Provincial. Upon completion of his theology studies in Maryland, he was ordained in 1853 by John Nepomucene Neumann. He served the Redemptorist communities in the U.S. as Consulter to the Provincial, as well as Superior and Novice Master. Father Mueller is the author of The Blessed Eucharist, Prayer: The Key to Salvation, Triumph of the Blessed Sacrament, The Prodigal Son, and God the Teacher of Mankind. He died in 1899.
Father Müller and I certainly agree about the dignity and the sublimity of the priesthood. How he set about proving his theses is my point of contention with his writing.
This was an extremely uneven book. He frequently wanted to put forth a Pope Leo the Great or some other mighty saint and use that as a proof for priests, bishops, and popes everywhere. It was sloppy and it was unconvincing.
Sometimes, he would name drop and it would work, such as when a long list of popes condemned secret societies in perfect concord.
Other times, he would list the people who had stood up for the sanctity of marriage and boldly assert that Rome was always the champion of keeping the powerful from their selfish annulments. I kept thinking how St. Jane of Valois would certainly like a word with him on that one.
Father Müller also used St. Charles Borromeo’s experience in Milan of a terrible plague as a proof that priests are always ready, willing, and able to die horrible deaths for their people. Putting aside the cowardice on display in modern times, I actually listened to the audiobook of St. Charles Borromeo’s heroic efforts during that time. One of his sacred duties as leader had been to call back priests who had fled in fear. Father Müller’s efforts to make every priest a paragon of virtue simply by the act of his being ordained fool no one.
All the same, there are beautiful passages in this little work. When he talks about the priesthood as an office, or when he talks about an individual priest’s merits without trying to extrapolate it onto every priest who has ever been, it works quite well.
In other places, it is tone deaf and heavy handed.