What do you think?
Rate this book
The Guardians Trilogy #3
Island of Glass
As the hunt for the Star of Ice leads the six guardians to Ireland, Doyle, the immortal, must face his tragic past. Three centuries ago, he closed off his heart, yet his warrior spirit is still drawn to the wild. And there’s no one more familiar with the wild than Riley—and the wolf within her…
An archaeologist, Riley is no stranger to the coast of Clare, but now she finds herself on unsure footing, targeted by the dark goddess who wants more than the stars, more than the blood of the guardians. While searching through Irish history for clues that will lead them to the final star and the mysterious Island of Glass, Riley must fight her practical nature and admit her sudden attraction to Doyle is more than just a fling. For it is his strength that will sustain her and give her the power to run towards love—and save them all…
An archaeologist, Riley is no stranger to the coast of Clare, but now she finds herself on unsure footing, targeted by the dark goddess who wants more than the stars, more than the blood of the guardians. While searching through Irish history for clues that will lead them to the final star and the mysterious Island of Glass, Riley must fight her practical nature and admit her sudden attraction to Doyle is more than just a fling. For it is his strength that will sustain her and give her the power to run towards love—and save them all…
342 pages, Paperback
First published December 6, 2016
3051 people are currently reading
10768 people want to read
About the author
Nora Roberts
1,225 books60.3k followersNora Roberts is the #1 New York Times bestselling author of more than 200 novels, including Hideaway, Under Currents, Come Sundown, The Awakening, Legacy, and coming in November 2021 -- The Becoming -- the second book in The Dragon Heart Legacy. She is also the author of the futuristic suspense In Death series written under the pen name J.D. Robb. There are more than 500 million copies of her books in print.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,596 reviews
February 9, 2017
I have loved this series from the very first book and even though I have loved them and all its characters, Riley and Doyle's story, was the one I have been most looking forward to and I can say with absolute honesty, that it did not disappoint. It was worth every single moment of waiting to finally be able to get their story and inside their heads.
Like I mentioned before, I've loved all the characters so far, it is almost impossible not to but I knew that these two rough and tough, slightly jaded and calloused characters were going to be the real heart of the story and I wasn't wrong. I absolutely loved finally getting, not only, their backstories and history, but what they were really thinking and feeling about their mission, their role in it, and of course, each other. Plus as an extra bonus, we still got all the characters that we've already fallen in love with and this just made me love them even more as well.
This was such a great conclusion to the series, full of twists and turn and surprises and tender moments as well as lots of the action we love, this very well might be one of my most favorite ones by Roberts yet. It is definitely one that will stick with me and I won't soon be forgetting.
*ARC copy provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
Like I mentioned before, I've loved all the characters so far, it is almost impossible not to but I knew that these two rough and tough, slightly jaded and calloused characters were going to be the real heart of the story and I wasn't wrong. I absolutely loved finally getting, not only, their backstories and history, but what they were really thinking and feeling about their mission, their role in it, and of course, each other. Plus as an extra bonus, we still got all the characters that we've already fallen in love with and this just made me love them even more as well.
This was such a great conclusion to the series, full of twists and turn and surprises and tender moments as well as lots of the action we love, this very well might be one of my most favorite ones by Roberts yet. It is definitely one that will stick with me and I won't soon be forgetting.
*ARC copy provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
December 29, 2023
5 incredibly subjective “It’s Nora Roberts and I just love her” stars. (This rating is for the trilogy in its entirety.)
I’ve been reading a lot of epic fantasy lately. And I love it. But fantasy tends to be the steak of my literary diet. (Vegetarian friends, please forgive me for this extended meat metaphor.) Steak provides protein and iron, and is obviously delicious, but when it your diet consists of all red meat all the time, you risk getting gout. Fantasy keeps me on the edge of my seat and makes me think, but too much of a good thing can lead to burnout. Sometimes, you just need to break up your diet. Which is what Nora Roberts’ books do for me. Her books are my popcorn, and the change was wonderful.
Something you need to know about Nora’s books. They’re predictable. Like, Nora-has-a-formula-that-she-applies-to-all-of-her-books predictable. When I pick up one of her books, I know that good is going to win out, that love will conquer all, and that all of the main characters will not only live, but live happily ever after. And that’s exactly why I love them. Sometimes I need a story that is safe and comfortable and, well, predictable. Like popcorn! And Nora is the best in the business at delivering comfort brain-food.
Onto this series specifically. This is soft fantasy, the story of a group of six radically different individuals, drawn together to find three fallen stars and save the world from an insane goddess. All six individuals are mythical in some sense, and the three women each fall in love with one of the three men over the course of their own book. Like I said, predictable. But so much fun. My favorite character in the trilogy was Annika. She was gorgeous and kind and funny and so incredibly different. Her story, Bay of Sighs, was my favorite in the trilogy. But this was a very nice, cosy ending. Everyone lived happily ever after, just as I knew they would. Which was just exactly what I needed. *contented sigh*
For more of reviews, as well as my own fiction and thoughts on life, check out my blog, Celestial Musings
I’ve been reading a lot of epic fantasy lately. And I love it. But fantasy tends to be the steak of my literary diet. (Vegetarian friends, please forgive me for this extended meat metaphor.) Steak provides protein and iron, and is obviously delicious, but when it your diet consists of all red meat all the time, you risk getting gout. Fantasy keeps me on the edge of my seat and makes me think, but too much of a good thing can lead to burnout. Sometimes, you just need to break up your diet. Which is what Nora Roberts’ books do for me. Her books are my popcorn, and the change was wonderful.
Something you need to know about Nora’s books. They’re predictable. Like, Nora-has-a-formula-that-she-applies-to-all-of-her-books predictable. When I pick up one of her books, I know that good is going to win out, that love will conquer all, and that all of the main characters will not only live, but live happily ever after. And that’s exactly why I love them. Sometimes I need a story that is safe and comfortable and, well, predictable. Like popcorn! And Nora is the best in the business at delivering comfort brain-food.
Onto this series specifically. This is soft fantasy, the story of a group of six radically different individuals, drawn together to find three fallen stars and save the world from an insane goddess. All six individuals are mythical in some sense, and the three women each fall in love with one of the three men over the course of their own book. Like I said, predictable. But so much fun. My favorite character in the trilogy was Annika. She was gorgeous and kind and funny and so incredibly different. Her story, Bay of Sighs, was my favorite in the trilogy. But this was a very nice, cosy ending. Everyone lived happily ever after, just as I knew they would. Which was just exactly what I needed. *contented sigh*
For more of reviews, as well as my own fiction and thoughts on life, check out my blog, Celestial Musings
August 20, 2017
This ends the Trilogy. This book is more plot driven than character driven. The magic, the goddesses, the stars were all very cool. But the relationship between the two main characters felt a bit forced. I felt like he actually wanted the mermaid then settled on the genius archeologist.
Still an excellent book by a master storyteller.
Still an excellent book by a master storyteller.
February 6, 2017
The mythological parts feel like an info dump, this was unexpected & shocking. Usually this is where Nora Roberts draws you in deeper, its integral to her worldbuilding and plot.
"Nobody says we all live happily ever after. Nobody says we’re fated to kill the dark god and do a victory dance.”
Going for realistic, sound cynical.
I'm convinced they will be disappointed if they make it.
Mad God with a mad monster.
Vain, obsessed but doesn't induce fear, shivers, dread, anything. Nerezza was a pale villain. At times it feels as if she is trying too hard and has poor planning abilities.
Malmon could have fared much better, the potential was there.
Doyle's story packs a punch and was quite moving.
The boy longed for adventure, the man is weary of them. Adventures, war, death and grief.
Twist....please make it count.
Cool, calculated and cruel. Mixed feelings at this point...
34% and the chemistry feels forced. Their love burned too fast and too bright to convince me. Sigh.
Emotionally disconnected. No sense of urgency when they fight, no panic when one of them is attacked.
Riley dismisses his feelings, his pain at times. Doyle gels better with Sasha but I don't see her walking away from the Amazing Bran. Ever.
I like Riley and Doyle as individuals, I'm alarmed when I think of them as partners.
But they could definitely make it as close friends.
“A lycan president.”
“We could do a hell of a lot worse.”
“And a Secret Service code name ‘Furry’ lacks dignity.”
You made a joke.”
There was no banter or build up to their relationship, suddenly there is need and intense attraction. How is it so quick? Where was the spark during the last 2 books? Was it in hibernation mode?
“Don’t tell me you care about me. That’s cheap. That’s beneath us both.”
“You suit so well.”
Riley gaped at Sasha. “What?”
You and me both.
Various versions of this are repeated to convince you that they are soulmates. There's a remix, an unlplugged version, a ballad....I don't think even Nora Roberts was convinced about this pair.
The End.
Tell me that wasn't anti climatic!!!
This book gets 3 stars because :
1 The Amazing Sorcerer Bran
Gorgeous, Irish, Wicked and Brilliant. Did I mention funny?
I don't have a crush. You're the one with the massive crush.
2 Doyle's Issues
Doyle is an immortal, has lived for more than 3 centuries. Died or severely injured often. Think of a twisted version of the bigger they are, the harder they fall - Doyle has lived longer, lost and grieved, his memories weigh on him. He is closed off emotionally as a coping mechanism.
Ireland is the place where he was broken, dead and reborn. Going back was definitely not a picnic, but he never mopes. Classy brooder. True warrior.
It was satisfying to see him come to terms with his issues.
3 Description
The delicious meals and Bran's house painted an enchanting picture.
The book loses 2 stars because :
1 Mismatched romantic couple
I didn't believe in them, at any point. Let's fire a cannon at this ship.
2 The End?
This bothered me on 2 levels.
The actual ending and the fact that this was the last book in the series should have been explosive. If I had to use just one word : Underwhelming
"Nobody says we all live happily ever after. Nobody says we’re fated to kill the dark god and do a victory dance.”
Going for realistic, sound cynical.
I'm convinced they will be disappointed if they make it.
Mad God with a mad monster.
Vain, obsessed but doesn't induce fear, shivers, dread, anything. Nerezza was a pale villain. At times it feels as if she is trying too hard and has poor planning abilities.
Malmon could have fared much better, the potential was there.
Doyle's story packs a punch and was quite moving.
The boy longed for adventure, the man is weary of them. Adventures, war, death and grief.
Twist....please make it count.
Cool, calculated and cruel. Mixed feelings at this point...
34% and the chemistry feels forced. Their love burned too fast and too bright to convince me. Sigh.
Emotionally disconnected. No sense of urgency when they fight, no panic when one of them is attacked.
Riley dismisses his feelings, his pain at times. Doyle gels better with Sasha but I don't see her walking away from the Amazing Bran. Ever.
I like Riley and Doyle as individuals, I'm alarmed when I think of them as partners.
But they could definitely make it as close friends.
“A lycan president.”
“We could do a hell of a lot worse.”
“And a Secret Service code name ‘Furry’ lacks dignity.”
You made a joke.”
There was no banter or build up to their relationship, suddenly there is need and intense attraction. How is it so quick? Where was the spark during the last 2 books? Was it in hibernation mode?
“Don’t tell me you care about me. That’s cheap. That’s beneath us both.”
“You suit so well.”
Riley gaped at Sasha. “What?”
You and me both.
Various versions of this are repeated to convince you that they are soulmates. There's a remix, an unlplugged version, a ballad....I don't think even Nora Roberts was convinced about this pair.
The End.
Tell me that wasn't anti climatic!!!
This book gets 3 stars because :
1 The Amazing Sorcerer Bran
Gorgeous, Irish, Wicked and Brilliant. Did I mention funny?
I don't have a crush. You're the one with the massive crush.
2 Doyle's Issues
Doyle is an immortal, has lived for more than 3 centuries. Died or severely injured often. Think of a twisted version of the bigger they are, the harder they fall - Doyle has lived longer, lost and grieved, his memories weigh on him. He is closed off emotionally as a coping mechanism.
Ireland is the place where he was broken, dead and reborn. Going back was definitely not a picnic, but he never mopes. Classy brooder. True warrior.
It was satisfying to see him come to terms with his issues.
3 Description
The delicious meals and Bran's house painted an enchanting picture.
The book loses 2 stars because :
1 Mismatched romantic couple
I didn't believe in them, at any point. Let's fire a cannon at this ship.
2 The End?
This bothered me on 2 levels.
The actual ending and the fact that this was the last book in the series should have been explosive. If I had to use just one word : Underwhelming
December 8, 2016
This book, and the whole trilogy, is about hunt for the infamous Star of Ice and the six guardians who are tied so closely together. With amazing characters that are fierce and highly gifted in their own way, each of them bring not only a paranormal strength to the team, but also beautiful love and romance as they find each other.
When you sit down to read a Nora Roberts book, you don’t realize how effortlessly the words seem to flow. But don’t let that fool you. This book is highly detailed, with an amazing plot that twists and turns, along with intense character development that keeps you engaged from page one.
There is a reason why Nora Roberts is America’s favorite author and when you pick up this book and read the series as a whole, you will see that reason. Intense, amusing, breath holding, and an amazing ending that leaves you wishing for more. Never a dull moment!
full review - http://amidlifewife.com/island-of-gla...
When you sit down to read a Nora Roberts book, you don’t realize how effortlessly the words seem to flow. But don’t let that fool you. This book is highly detailed, with an amazing plot that twists and turns, along with intense character development that keeps you engaged from page one.
There is a reason why Nora Roberts is America’s favorite author and when you pick up this book and read the series as a whole, you will see that reason. Intense, amusing, breath holding, and an amazing ending that leaves you wishing for more. Never a dull moment!
full review - http://amidlifewife.com/island-of-gla...
December 16, 2016
A winner NR, after eons! Praise be!!!
January 2, 2017
Right from the start when I was reading the first book in the series, I knew Doyle and Riley's romance would be the less convincing one and I wasn't wrong. If we take all the action and sceneries out of the last book, we end up with very little.
September 25, 2019
Well this one was slightly better than the second one but I still struggled with it as it seemed to take forever to get to the point of the story.
I think I’ll leave it awhile before I read more of Nora Roberts books but, I will probably read more at a later date.
I think I’ll leave it awhile before I read more of Nora Roberts books but, I will probably read more at a later date.
March 28, 2017
What a fantastic conclusion to another of Nora Roberts' impressive trilogies. We all love a satisfying ending and Nora never disappoints her readers. In her stories, good always triumphs over evil. It is not easy and never quick. It takes a considerable amount of time, courage, intellect; tons of hard work and persistence and of course some magic and luck, but towards the end evil is vanquished and justice is served.
This is not a standalone novel. "Island of Glass" is the final book in the Guardians Trilogy and should be read in order, following "Stars of Fortune" and "Bay of Sighs". The story revolves around six individuals and their quest for finding three magical stars. In this book, they travel to the charming County Clare in Western Ireland to acquire the third and final star. With their unique strength and flaws these six characters have come a long way from being complete strangers to becoming as close-knit as family. Together they have fought fiercely, loved passionately and now must embark upon this final journey to secure the last star.
There are backstories that provide answers to remaining questions and uncover mysteries, enough action to keep the excitement alive and also a fair amount of romance that adds an appeal to the tale. Altogether this was a story filled with magic and love, friendship and trust and most importantly the victory of light over dark. A satisfying and enjoyable read.
This is not a standalone novel. "Island of Glass" is the final book in the Guardians Trilogy and should be read in order, following "Stars of Fortune" and "Bay of Sighs". The story revolves around six individuals and their quest for finding three magical stars. In this book, they travel to the charming County Clare in Western Ireland to acquire the third and final star. With their unique strength and flaws these six characters have come a long way from being complete strangers to becoming as close-knit as family. Together they have fought fiercely, loved passionately and now must embark upon this final journey to secure the last star.
There are backstories that provide answers to remaining questions and uncover mysteries, enough action to keep the excitement alive and also a fair amount of romance that adds an appeal to the tale. Altogether this was a story filled with magic and love, friendship and trust and most importantly the victory of light over dark. A satisfying and enjoyable read.
December 29, 2018
3.5 stars
Our six-Bran, Sasha, Annika, Sawyer, Doyle, and Riley are finally in Ireland on Bran's estate seeking the Ice Star. Of course, Nerezza is quite infuriated by these meddlesome characters and swears she's going to end the shenanigans once and for all. The plot was rich and much was revealed about the mystical connections between the six characters. However, it was not so strong on the romance between Doyle and Riley. It felt as if NR needed to put them together but their chemistry was a bit weak and their sex scenes a bit boring. All in all, I felt it a satisfying conclusion to an enjoyable trilogy.
Our six-Bran, Sasha, Annika, Sawyer, Doyle, and Riley are finally in Ireland on Bran's estate seeking the Ice Star. Of course, Nerezza is quite infuriated by these meddlesome characters and swears she's going to end the shenanigans once and for all. The plot was rich and much was revealed about the mystical connections between the six characters. However, it was not so strong on the romance between Doyle and Riley. It felt as if NR needed to put them together but their chemistry was a bit weak and their sex scenes a bit boring. All in all, I felt it a satisfying conclusion to an enjoyable trilogy.
December 10, 2016
4.5 Stars! Lovely conclusion to the whole series!! Doyle and Riley might just be my most favourite pairing of all;)
December 11, 2016
The biggest problem I had with this book is that there was no build up to the central romance. Riley and Doyle have been fighting back to back and in each other's constant company in two previous books and yet the two of them barely looked at each other in those previous two books.
Yet suddenly in this one, Riley starts noticing Doyle's shoulders and thinking she hasn't had sex in months and pow -- suddenly they are lusting after each other, having sex and then saying I love you before the book is even 60% done. It was really rather soulless. It felt like 'Eh, these are the two that are left, lets get 'em hooked up now.' Sasha and Bran got three whole books to be a couple and Sawyer and Annika got two. So yeah, Doyle and Riley felt a bit shortchanged. I would have preferred it if they had at least been able to show attraction earlier.
The drama didn't need to come from their romance, in fact it was totally back burner to killing off a vengeful Goddess and saving the world. I also liked that Doyle was the primary focus, with him confronting his past and finally putting his family to rest.
But overall as a conclusion to what a a pretty interesting trilogy, this felt kinda flat. I did like the ending, it was neat and tied everything in a nice Happily Ever After bow, but I think I've been spoiled by urban fantasies where multiple romances can get juggled over multiple books. I think I wouldn't have felt so 'meh' about Riley and Doyle if they had started their romantic dance in the earlier books.
Yet suddenly in this one, Riley starts noticing Doyle's shoulders and thinking she hasn't had sex in months and pow -- suddenly they are lusting after each other, having sex and then saying I love you before the book is even 60% done. It was really rather soulless. It felt like 'Eh, these are the two that are left, lets get 'em hooked up now.' Sasha and Bran got three whole books to be a couple and Sawyer and Annika got two. So yeah, Doyle and Riley felt a bit shortchanged. I would have preferred it if they had at least been able to show attraction earlier.
The drama didn't need to come from their romance, in fact it was totally back burner to killing off a vengeful Goddess and saving the world. I also liked that Doyle was the primary focus, with him confronting his past and finally putting his family to rest.
But overall as a conclusion to what a a pretty interesting trilogy, this felt kinda flat. I did like the ending, it was neat and tied everything in a nice Happily Ever After bow, but I think I've been spoiled by urban fantasies where multiple romances can get juggled over multiple books. I think I wouldn't have felt so 'meh' about Riley and Doyle if they had started their romantic dance in the earlier books.
December 13, 2016
Annika - a mermaid
Sawyer - time traveler with a magic compass
Riley - an archaeologist werewolf
Doyle - an immortal warrior
Bran - an Irish sorcerer
Sasha - an artist and seer
This group of gifted strangers, called together by the three moon goddesses, has seen battle and have had success. They are no longer strangers on individual quests, but guardians on the final quest. They have fought fiercely and loved passionately. Well, Sasha, Bran, Sawyer and Annika have, loved passionately - that is. This final quest to find and secure the Ice Star will be a supreme test for Riley, the archaeologist werewolf and Doyle, the immortal warrior.
The final star is on the Island of Clare in Ireland. The guardians are making their home base in the manor that Bran built on the ruins, at the end of a lane, high on the cliffs above the sea. Bran was drawn there, but it's Doyle to whom this place holds so many memories. A place Doyle hoped never to see again. A place where, not far away, Doyle lost his young brother to the black magick and his own life was changed forever.
I have got to say that I'm not a fan of the "pre-ordained" romance that these trilogies use as their basis. Doyle and Riley are the last two "unpaired" people so.... it is a given that they get together and live happily ever after. Nothing very romantic about this. And.... this trilogy is so formula driven that I don't even need to finish the book know the ending. But, if I had wanted to read something original, I would have chosen another book.
Sawyer - time traveler with a magic compass
Riley - an archaeologist werewolf
Doyle - an immortal warrior
Bran - an Irish sorcerer
Sasha - an artist and seer
This group of gifted strangers, called together by the three moon goddesses, has seen battle and have had success. They are no longer strangers on individual quests, but guardians on the final quest. They have fought fiercely and loved passionately. Well, Sasha, Bran, Sawyer and Annika have, loved passionately - that is. This final quest to find and secure the Ice Star will be a supreme test for Riley, the archaeologist werewolf and Doyle, the immortal warrior.
The final star is on the Island of Clare in Ireland. The guardians are making their home base in the manor that Bran built on the ruins, at the end of a lane, high on the cliffs above the sea. Bran was drawn there, but it's Doyle to whom this place holds so many memories. A place Doyle hoped never to see again. A place where, not far away, Doyle lost his young brother to the black magick and his own life was changed forever.
I have got to say that I'm not a fan of the "pre-ordained" romance that these trilogies use as their basis. Doyle and Riley are the last two "unpaired" people so.... it is a given that they get together and live happily ever after. Nothing very romantic about this. And.... this trilogy is so formula driven that I don't even need to finish the book know the ending. But, if I had wanted to read something original, I would have chosen another book.
June 19, 2018
This is a very good close-up for this series.
The third book is definitely better than the second one that I found boring a bit. I think it's thanks to the MC - Riley and Doyle who are much more distinct and interesting than Annika and Sawyer (don't get me wrong, I like them too, but I find Riley and Doyle more fascinating).
The plot is a bit tendentious but that's the case of the whole series which is not the best by Nora Roberts and is pretty similar to some of her other trilogies. But there is enough action to keep me reading. Also I like the interactions between the characters, especially Riley and Doyle. The ending is quite predictable but... well... the whole series is predictable as well, so I can't really complain about it.
This is a fun read and a very nice close for this series.
The third book is definitely better than the second one that I found boring a bit. I think it's thanks to the MC - Riley and Doyle who are much more distinct and interesting than Annika and Sawyer (don't get me wrong, I like them too, but I find Riley and Doyle more fascinating).
The plot is a bit tendentious but that's the case of the whole series which is not the best by Nora Roberts and is pretty similar to some of her other trilogies. But there is enough action to keep me reading. Also I like the interactions between the characters, especially Riley and Doyle. The ending is quite predictable but... well... the whole series is predictable as well, so I can't really complain about it.
This is a fun read and a very nice close for this series.
December 18, 2017
4 stars for this book story and I add 1 star for the series epilogue!
Review later, when this awful cold go away!🤧😫
Review later, when this awful cold go away!🤧😫
March 20, 2017
Better than the 2nd of the trilogy, not as good as the first. A decent ending saves this finally. 5 of 10 stars
May 31, 2022
3.5 ⭐
Es el mejor libro de la saga pero se me ha hecho pesada la parte final. La historia dd Doyle y Riley muy floja, y me han faltado buenas batallaa
Es el mejor libro de la saga pero se me ha hecho pesada la parte final. La historia dd Doyle y Riley muy floja, y me han faltado buenas batallaa
January 17, 2018
I admit, this is the one I was waiting for the most. Riley intrigued me - being an archaeologist, my own passion, probably helped with that. And Doyle. Well, he had that gruff, kind-of-asshole-but-not-really thing going on. I like that, especially when it ends in a true romance. So I was eager to read their story.
And I was right. I enjoyed the romance the most. Probably, at least in part, because Riley and Doyle had two whole books to get to know one another, to interact with each other, and to learn about themselves both separately and together. So when they come together in this book, in a clash of need and desire, it's eminently satisfying. Though I wonder a little that it didn't happen sooner with the obvious desire on both their parts.
I love that they start their relationship with no strings. There's just need, mutual appreciation, care, and enjoying each other. I love, too, that Riley tells Doyle when that changes for her - with, again, no strings or expectations attached to it. She takes responsibility for her feelings, and doesn't expect anyone else to have to accommodate them. That's hard to do in real life, and pretty rare in the Romance genre.
For the relationship, I probably would give this book 4 stars. What brought it back down to a 3-star read for me was the resolution and the entire Island of Glass thing. It felt abrupt. Here they've been fighting, winning by the skin of their teeth, for nearly three months. But suddenly it's all over in a matter of a couple of thrusts of the sword. It was the quickest climactic fight I think I've ever read. And the Malmon thing? Just weird and seemed extraneous.
Then there was the entirety of the deus-ex-machina that solved all their problems at the end. I mean, don't get me wrong, I wanted them all together and happy. But if you're just going to wipe aside the problems, like that, then why present them as problems in the first place?
This isn't likely to be a series I'll re-read, but I don't count it as time wasted either. I enjoyed reading the adventures of Bran, Sasha, Annika, Sawyer, Riley, and Doyle.
Read more at The Alliterates
And I was right. I enjoyed the romance the most. Probably, at least in part, because Riley and Doyle had two whole books to get to know one another, to interact with each other, and to learn about themselves both separately and together. So when they come together in this book, in a clash of need and desire, it's eminently satisfying. Though I wonder a little that it didn't happen sooner with the obvious desire on both their parts.
I love that they start their relationship with no strings. There's just need, mutual appreciation, care, and enjoying each other. I love, too, that Riley tells Doyle when that changes for her - with, again, no strings or expectations attached to it. She takes responsibility for her feelings, and doesn't expect anyone else to have to accommodate them. That's hard to do in real life, and pretty rare in the Romance genre.
For the relationship, I probably would give this book 4 stars. What brought it back down to a 3-star read for me was the resolution and the entire Island of Glass thing. It felt abrupt. Here they've been fighting, winning by the skin of their teeth, for nearly three months. But suddenly it's all over in a matter of a couple of thrusts of the sword. It was the quickest climactic fight I think I've ever read. And the Malmon thing? Just weird and seemed extraneous.
Then there was the entirety of the deus-ex-machina that solved all their problems at the end. I mean, don't get me wrong, I wanted them all together and happy. But if you're just going to wipe aside the problems, like that, then why present them as problems in the first place?
This isn't likely to be a series I'll re-read, but I don't count it as time wasted either. I enjoyed reading the adventures of Bran, Sasha, Annika, Sawyer, Riley, and Doyle.
Read more at The Alliterates
August 1, 2017
I think my 2 status updates summarize my feelings on this book pretty well:
"There is no realism to these characters. Yeah, yeah - this is a fantasy series, but seriously, reality just isn't so perfect!"
"I really need to stop reading NR because her characters are just too perfect, too sweet, too kind, too caring, too smart, too rich, too lucky, have parents that are too good to be true. The list goes on and on. Her earlier books had some grit to them. The newest ones *sigh* just don't."
Overall it was fine, the plot (as far fetched as it was) flowed well and the heroes won, the bad witch killed, and they all lived Happily Ever After. 3 stars
Also, there were errors in this book that again should not exist for an author of this caliber (this isn't the first NR ebook that I've read with problems; never noticed this with physical books). I know NR isn't doing the final proof read (and she shouldn't) so whoever IS should either be reassigned or told to actually READ the book!
Anywho, I know myself too well to say this will be my last NR book, but I WILL be more discriminant in my readings from now on. :)
"There is no realism to these characters. Yeah, yeah - this is a fantasy series, but seriously, reality just isn't so perfect!"
"I really need to stop reading NR because her characters are just too perfect, too sweet, too kind, too caring, too smart, too rich, too lucky, have parents that are too good to be true. The list goes on and on. Her earlier books had some grit to them. The newest ones *sigh* just don't."
Overall it was fine, the plot (as far fetched as it was) flowed well and the heroes won, the bad witch killed, and they all lived Happily Ever After. 3 stars
Also, there were errors in this book that again should not exist for an author of this caliber (this isn't the first NR ebook that I've read with problems; never noticed this with physical books). I know NR isn't doing the final proof read (and she shouldn't) so whoever IS should either be reassigned or told to actually READ the book!
Anywho, I know myself too well to say this will be my last NR book, but I WILL be more discriminant in my readings from now on. :)
December 10, 2016
Sooo so sad for this to be ending (a trilogy). I REALLY enjoyed all three books - a lot!
July 22, 2018
In Island of Glass, our story continues with our six guardians, who travel to Doyle’s and Bran’s home in Ireland. Doyle has some bittersweet moments that he has to face of his past, of losing his brother and losing everyone he has ever loved over the years. This is where they are on the final leg of their journey and their battle again the evil goddess.
This is Doyle and Riley’s book, and I admit I wasn’t sure how I would feel about it. These two aren’t my favorite characters of the six, and I hadn’t really felt much of their chemistry in the previous two books so I was curious to see how this book would play out their romance. And it wasn’t what I was wanting, I did feel like it was a bit lacking at times, but they did have some stunning moments that I loved though. Doyle and Riley have more alpha like characteristics. They are both fights, leaders and are badass. So they have many personality traits in common. Riley is our shifter of the group, but she is more open to love than Doyle is. She views Doyle as her potential mate, but she also knows that Doyle isn’t wanting anything serious.
However weary he might be of life after three centuries of it, he was more weary of witnessing death.
Doyle has closed off his heart completely. He has been alone for a long time and has watched everyone he has loved die over the years, so it makes sense he wouldn’t want to lose Riley either. But I did feel like their relationship had some disjointed moments at times but I will say they create fireworks in the bedroom. Probably the hottest sex scenes in the trilogy is in this book. Which makes sense in some ways, since these two are the strongest and no gentle loving when having sex. But I did want more from their story, more emotional intimacy that I found lacking at times.
The plot of the story was simply just as wonderful as the previous two books. There is adventure, suspense, trickery of the mind, and an evil goddess that is to be defeated and boy what a ENDING!! It was so satisfying and fulfilled me in every way. I just love seeing good win over evil and this one packed a punch.
Overall I had a blast with this trilogy, in seeing the growth and unity of these six individuals and seeing a intriguing and intense story play out which some great adventures, captivating characters and a stunning story I won’t soon forget!!
This is Doyle and Riley’s book, and I admit I wasn’t sure how I would feel about it. These two aren’t my favorite characters of the six, and I hadn’t really felt much of their chemistry in the previous two books so I was curious to see how this book would play out their romance. And it wasn’t what I was wanting, I did feel like it was a bit lacking at times, but they did have some stunning moments that I loved though. Doyle and Riley have more alpha like characteristics. They are both fights, leaders and are badass. So they have many personality traits in common. Riley is our shifter of the group, but she is more open to love than Doyle is. She views Doyle as her potential mate, but she also knows that Doyle isn’t wanting anything serious.
However weary he might be of life after three centuries of it, he was more weary of witnessing death.
Doyle has closed off his heart completely. He has been alone for a long time and has watched everyone he has loved die over the years, so it makes sense he wouldn’t want to lose Riley either. But I did feel like their relationship had some disjointed moments at times but I will say they create fireworks in the bedroom. Probably the hottest sex scenes in the trilogy is in this book. Which makes sense in some ways, since these two are the strongest and no gentle loving when having sex. But I did want more from their story, more emotional intimacy that I found lacking at times.
The plot of the story was simply just as wonderful as the previous two books. There is adventure, suspense, trickery of the mind, and an evil goddess that is to be defeated and boy what a ENDING!! It was so satisfying and fulfilled me in every way. I just love seeing good win over evil and this one packed a punch.
Overall I had a blast with this trilogy, in seeing the growth and unity of these six individuals and seeing a intriguing and intense story play out which some great adventures, captivating characters and a stunning story I won’t soon forget!!
December 7, 2016
I have a few mixed feelings on this book. I love how Nora Roberts is slowly moving out of her comfort zone in regards to her trilogies, while at the same time keeping a few things similar. I know that sounds odd that I like the similarities, but it's sort of a comfort to see those pairings of lovers and friends; and the idea of strangers creating bonds to fight a common enemy.
Although this book starts off right where it left off in the previous book, I felt a bit of a disconnect as the tone seemed different to me. Normally, that's a good thing (and to be expected when moving onto a different part of the series or story), but in this case it took awhile to really get back into the story. I felt as if the descriptions were a bit too wordy and Bran's speech had gotten even more "flowery" and stereotypical of what one might imagine of an Irish aristocrat. Which is a shame because he came off way more grounded in the first book. It did calm down later on in the book, but it definitely threw me off more so.
There were still a few parts that lost me throughout the book, but once I got past the first few chapters I became more settled and invested in the story and characters once again.
********Spoiler Alert***********
Although this book starts off right where it left off in the previous book, I felt a bit of a disconnect as the tone seemed different to me. Normally, that's a good thing (and to be expected when moving onto a different part of the series or story), but in this case it took awhile to really get back into the story. I felt as if the descriptions were a bit too wordy and Bran's speech had gotten even more "flowery" and stereotypical of what one might imagine of an Irish aristocrat. Which is a shame because he came off way more grounded in the first book. It did calm down later on in the book, but it definitely threw me off more so.
There were still a few parts that lost me throughout the book, but once I got past the first few chapters I became more settled and invested in the story and characters once again.
********Spoiler Alert***********
March 25, 2018
Read: March 2018
Rating: 4/5 stars
The couple: Riley & Doyle
There were parts of Island of Glass that were beautifully written - the descriptions of Ireland, the Island of Glass itself and the displays of friendship and love between all of the characters - but the romance between Riley and Doyle was weak. They did not have a lot of chemistry. Doyle seemed more interested in Annika (who had the best book of the trilogy; her relationship with Sawyer is the most authentic of all the couples) and Riley didn't seem to be on his radar at all until the plot forced them together.
I did enjoy the quest to find the final star and the ending scenes on the Island of Glass
*edited for typos 25.03.18*
Rating: 4/5 stars
The couple: Riley & Doyle
There were parts of Island of Glass that were beautifully written - the descriptions of Ireland, the Island of Glass itself and the displays of friendship and love between all of the characters - but the romance between Riley and Doyle was weak. They did not have a lot of chemistry. Doyle seemed more interested in Annika (who had the best book of the trilogy; her relationship with Sawyer is the most authentic of all the couples) and Riley didn't seem to be on his radar at all until the plot forced them together.
I did enjoy the quest to find the final star and the ending scenes on the Island of Glass
*edited for typos 25.03.18*
June 15, 2017
Inkvotary
It was beautiful though the end was a bit kitschy. But I enjoyed it. The author gave some great answers to many questions that had remained after reading and finishing book two of this trilogy. And it was a different tone in this novel, because Riley and Doyle are more rough and straight forward than the others. But I kind of liked that. And the fact, that the way how they were searching for the third star was different this time and not the end to the story, gave this book a nice turn and some very hilarious dialogues and scenes. Good, it might not be the best book by Nora Roberts, but a wonderful read for a sunny, relaxing afternoon. And for a Nora Roberts fan, a good choice.
September 8, 2018
This book was very interesting after I got into it and I'm happy that I get done with this book.
December 18, 2016
I'm just a sucker for fantasy. Why not, if a book takes you away, it might as well be total fantasy. Love the story, the characters and everything else about this trilogy.
June 11, 2022
Island of Glass
4 Stars
Series note: This is the final book in the trilogy and completes the ongoing story arc.
The Guardians arrive in Country Clare, Ireland for the last stage of their quest. Doyle McLeary, the medieval warrior cursed with immortality, and Riley Quinn, the Lycan archeologist, must wade together through Irish history and lore to locate the Ice Star as well as the mysterious Island of Glass. A lifetime of loss has led to Doyle avoiding emotional entanglements yet he struggles with his attraction to the wildness of Riley's strength, determination and heart. Will these two unlikely lovers put aside their differences to overcome the threats posed by Nerezza and her minions?
Once again, much of the beginning is focused on establishing the guardians' headquarters in Ireland and the search for the final star. However, the action soon ratchets up both in terms of the romance and the battle against Nerezza.
Doyle and Riley are a strong couple whose relationship requires patience, trust and love. It takes time for their romance to get going, but it is fantastic once it does. There is an intensity to the slow-burn development of their emotional bond that goes beyond the sweet yet subdued connection between Sasha and Bran and the insta-lust of Sawyer and Annika.
The conclusion to the story arc is satisfying, especially the allusions to and . That said, there are some overly saccharine moments - , and the resolution of the various obstacles is far too Deus Ex Machina for my tastes.
Although this has been an entertaining series overall, Nora has several more intense and gripping paranormal trilogies, such as The Sign of Seven and The Circle Trilogy.
4 Stars
Series note: This is the final book in the trilogy and completes the ongoing story arc.
The Guardians arrive in Country Clare, Ireland for the last stage of their quest. Doyle McLeary, the medieval warrior cursed with immortality, and Riley Quinn, the Lycan archeologist, must wade together through Irish history and lore to locate the Ice Star as well as the mysterious Island of Glass. A lifetime of loss has led to Doyle avoiding emotional entanglements yet he struggles with his attraction to the wildness of Riley's strength, determination and heart. Will these two unlikely lovers put aside their differences to overcome the threats posed by Nerezza and her minions?
Once again, much of the beginning is focused on establishing the guardians' headquarters in Ireland and the search for the final star. However, the action soon ratchets up both in terms of the romance and the battle against Nerezza.
Doyle and Riley are a strong couple whose relationship requires patience, trust and love. It takes time for their romance to get going, but it is fantastic once it does. There is an intensity to the slow-burn development of their emotional bond that goes beyond the sweet yet subdued connection between Sasha and Bran and the insta-lust of Sawyer and Annika.
The conclusion to the story arc is satisfying, especially the allusions to and . That said, there are some overly saccharine moments - , and the resolution of the various obstacles is far too Deus Ex Machina for my tastes.
Although this has been an entertaining series overall, Nora has several more intense and gripping paranormal trilogies, such as The Sign of Seven and The Circle Trilogy.
November 25, 2025
The ending wasn’t a surprise at all, but I didn’t care. I quite enjoyed this trilogy, the underlying story of found family was heartwarming and lovely.
December 23, 2016
One of Nora Roberts weaker trilogies, which I usually enjoy as a calorie laden confection after a heavier book. That being said, the final book was the best of this trilogy, simply because I liked the couple that it focused on best: Riley, the lycan and Doyle, the immortal. I am not sure if the mythology in the book is based on any actual mythology, but the quest, to me, lacked a sense of urgency. There was no consequence really offered as to what would happen if the quest was not completed (or why they were even on it to begin with), and furthermore, the battles between the Guardians and Nerezza lacked a sense of edginess, since no one outside of the Guardians was effected by anything going on except the Guardians themselves. The mermaid character of Annika lacked a connection to the other characters, and I found her idiosyncrosies distracting and irritating, rather than charming. In fact, Riley's relationship with Annika's "mate," Sawyer, was far more believable than Annika's relationship with him. Not an unpleasant read, just not as engrossing ---or believable---as some of her other reads. Roberts has effectively wove magic into many of her books but in this trilogy, the magic felt forced and lacking in believability.
August 22, 2018
A solid ending to a fantastic series.
My only complaint is that I didn’t feel the connection between Doyle and Reilly as I did with the others.
When declarations of love were made neither had any or many romantic thoughts (internal or external) about the other outside of fulfilling carnal needs. So the words fell flat. I didn’t feel the love and it spoiled that relationship for me.
I also felt the final battle was way too easy and almost rushed like NR was just done. But that can’t take away from the overall. I’ll miss these characters a lot.
My only complaint is that I didn’t feel the connection between Doyle and Reilly as I did with the others.
When declarations of love were made neither had any or many romantic thoughts (internal or external) about the other outside of fulfilling carnal needs. So the words fell flat. I didn’t feel the love and it spoiled that relationship for me.
I also felt the final battle was way too easy and almost rushed like NR was just done. But that can’t take away from the overall. I’ll miss these characters a lot.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,596 reviews