YA fiction can be exceptional, transcending age and appealing to readers of many generations. This book is not that. First, it is unclear who the audience is for this book. The writing feels not only as if it was intended for middle school girls, but actually reads as if it was written by a middle school girl. Yet, at the same time, the subject matter and some themes and language are inappropriate for a 13-year-old.
The story is clunky at best, often not making a great deal of sense and lacking closure of important themes. It is made even worse by the poorly-crafted prose, which is probably a polite description. It reminded me quite a bit of a story I wrote at age 14 on notebook paper and stuck in a folder to be found years later alongside old yearbooks. I get a kick out of reading that now, with its attempt to sound precocious falling fall short of the mark. Yet, this comparable mess was published. And, even more astonishingly - there are sequels! Plus, there was an added “bonus” of numerous errors that got through the shoddy editing process.
I can’t recommend this to anyone - adult readers will not appreciate the horrible writing quality and Swiss cheese plot, and the latter half of the book is largely inappropriate for pre-teens.