I waffled pretty hard between the Goodreads 3 star "liked it" and the 4 star "really liked it" on this one. Maybe a 3.5 would be truer? I really liked it as a coming of age, I definitely believed the parts about Seth growing up and dealing with his grief, but I personally wish I'd seen more of Malcolm and Seth together for the romance portion (my "liked it" rating). I felt like that took a backseat to the other portions of Seth's story, and that made it hard for me to believe in their HEA without assumptions of werewolf-mate-instalove-instinct to carry them over from what I saw of them together, which didn't feel like it was much of the page time at all, comparatively. I don't think I learned anything new about Mal in this book; with him and Seth having such similar tragedies in their pasts, I expected something about that, at least, but they weren't on page together much, it felt like. There was as much Deputy Malcolm dealing with Seth the troubled townsperson as Mal with Seth his friend. I loved the time with Caleb and Jacob and the kids, but I felt like I was missing something in the development from Seth thinking Mal is cute one day to an implied HEA at the end. The blurb made it seem like this was about their romance, but that doesn't get developed. It almost seems perfunctory when they get together.
It's a good read, though, with an almost totally clean edit, and part of a good series with great world-building and solid character development. I mostly enjoyed it, except for one (other) problem that honestly may be a personal niggle but one that is huge enough I doubt I'll be able to reread this one like I do the first two books in the series. It's a small detail, in some ways, but... it's also major, at the same time. It decided me on rounding down to a three, rather than up to a four, because I find it so difficult to fathom and so distracting from the story, personally.
Mild spoilers, with some history first:
If you've read the first two books, you know we're in a world in which the American Civil War is still very much the recent past; one lead, Caleb, in fact, was a decorated Union soldier who still has nightmares. Serious nightmares/terrors that feature in each of the three books, among other issues.
Americans may remember one of the main names for the people fighting on the other side of that war was "rebel" or "reb" and that "Johnny Reb" or "Johnny Rebel" was a common term considered now to be, depending on your perspective, the national personification of the Confederate soldier or a slang term for the same. The "rebel yell" was even a thing. It's still called the "rebel flag." So if we're in a time period 15ish years or so from the Civil War, "rebel" or "reb" is going to be a pretty charged terminology in the U.S. If you follow the author's social media, you'll probably also know that in this book, Ephraim gets a dog.
He names it Rebel.
I assume this is intentional in spite of the historical concerns, and we just don't know why he does this because he's not a POV character, but I could not understand why he'd want to name his pet for the Confederacy or how it would be allowed to happen that in a house where Caleb lives. I spent ages distracted wondering how there'd be a pet named Rebel at the homestead without even a gentle attempt from Jacob or SOME adult to point out maybe naming your dog after the Confederacy isn't a good idea. I can't even figure out why he'd WANT to name his dog Rebel, because his one real link to that name should be thoughts of the Confederacy and the Confederate soldier, in this time period. (We're also in a town where, later, it's pointed out that it could be dangerous for a character if other townspeople knew he was a former Confederate soldier, so it isn't like Ephraim should be getting positive ideas about those rebels around town, either.)
Naming your pet Rebel is, in fact, still a popular thing to do in parts of the American South as a reference to this past, especially in the places where they still fly Confederate flags and talk about "culture and heritage" and "states' rights." Song lyrics refer to the "rebel flag" (even in singles released in the late 2000s). People print "rebel" on the Confederate flag to create logos and truck stickers. Every single time I come across this dog's name on my Kindle, I cringe, because I cannot imagine the name "Rebel" getting yelled across the homestead like this, day in and day out for more than another decade while Caleb continues having PTSD-induced nightmares of a war in which that term would have featured heavily and prominently as a word for the enemy forces. It seems unnecessarily cruel. I grew up in the south in the 1990s and I can't read it without reacting in this kind of context; I don't see how an actual Union soldier struggling with PTSD is supposed to be cool with hearing it bandied about his house constantly without feeling triggered 24 hours a day.
Every time I see the dog appear in a scene, my enjoyment in cute pet instead ends up a total cringing, distracted, attention-span death-spiral because of the name. It throws me completely out of the text and the story.