Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Brimstone Witch Mystery #5

The Silent Banshee

Rate this book
Cassia Winter is a witch. With the help of her cat, Stanley, she investigates crimes in the magical town of Brimstone. This story sees them dealing with the death of a banshee called Dana Murphy.

On the morning of her death, Dana Murphy’s dying scream produces a huge amount of energy that rushes through the town of Brimstone. The energy makes its way to Cassia’s world and sends her flying off her feet. Upon entering Brimstone, Cassia is told that as the town banshee, Dana predicted many deaths - but apparently not her own.

Cassia and Stanley investigate Dana’s death and are confronted with the grim reality of how she died. They discover that more than one resident in Brimstone had a reason to put an end to Dana’s special talent.

As well as dealing with the murder investigation, Cassia is confronted with help from an unlikely source. Stanley immediately feels uneasy, and that unease grows as they delve further into Dana’s murder.

192 pages, Kindle Edition

First published August 30, 2017

104 people are currently reading
169 people want to read

About the author

April Fernsby

46 books78 followers
Sign up to April's newsletter to get her new releases when they are free: www.aprilfernsby.com

April Fernsby lives in the north of England in a county called Yorkshire. Yorkshire has its fair share of hauntings and supernatural events, including a witch called Mary Bateman, aka The Yorkshire Witch, whose skeleton now hangs in a local museum.

April loves all things supernatural and mysterious. Her favourite book as a child was ‘The Faraway Tree’ as it took the reader into a different world where unusual creatures lived. April looked for a similar tree near her house but never found it.

Her Brimstone Witch series involves the main character, Cassia Winter, going through a cellar door and into another world where magical creatures live, and mysteries abound.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
139 (46%)
4 stars
103 (34%)
3 stars
47 (15%)
2 stars
11 (3%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
Profile Image for Montzalee Wittmann.
5,212 reviews2,339 followers
September 9, 2017
Another paranormal mystery solved

This one was the least favorite of the books so far but still good. I am just getting too tired of the evil Astrid thing. I think she has been a thorn in the book for one book too long. Good mystery.
Profile Image for Christine Scotney.
210 reviews7 followers
June 21, 2018
This is the best Brimstone Witch Mystery I’ve read so far,that’s why it has 5 stars. We go on another adventure with Cassia and Stanley, and there is something big brewing in Brimstone. With Luca not around to help with the investigation, Avril is helping Cassia and as we know from previous books, Avril detests Cassia and has caused nothing but trouble for her and Stanley, even going so far as to shape shift into Cassia (Avril is a shape shifter and guardian) and cause havoc and mistrust towards Cassia from the inhabitants of Brimstone, so why is she offering her help now, all smiles and politeness. Cassia has to accept her help, Blythe, the witch that rules Brimstone has asked Avril to help with Luca gone. Cassia is finding it hard to trust Avril, she’s just too damn nice to her and everyone. And I still didn’t get the who, and the why of the murderer. April, the author does a very good job at keeping you guessing, until it’s revealed. This is the 5 th book in the series, and they just keep getting better. Thoroughly enjoyed it, I’m reading them back to back. Great.
Profile Image for Lizzy.
202 reviews
June 24, 2025
The game is afoot.

Cassia and Stanley have now solved a few murders. They've been in and out of Brimstone, met most of the neighbors, and made some new friends. But it would seem she has made an enemy, a very evil person who has it out for our dynamic duo. The death of the Banshee has brought them back, but evil will have a hand in it. Cassia's getting stonewalled from the out set. No one wants to tell her the whole story when she asks, and it takes her too long to get to the bottom of the mystery. By the time she figures out what's going on, the whole of Brimstone is at risk. She can't even go to Blythe or her Gran because they have been tricked into leaving town to confront Blythe's cousins. With Cassia learning, someone is keeping a secret from her while questioning a suspect. But who is it and what is it? The final chapters will keep you in suspense. The finale does not leave you wanting. Please make sure you read this. It's phenomenal. On to the next wonderfully written story!
Profile Image for Krystyna.
5,134 reviews54 followers
June 13, 2018
A trojan horse or a real offer of friendship

An enjoyable read that ends on a cliffhanger. A blast, a dead banshee and an overture of friendship. Who would want the death of the banshee? Is the old saying true that the motive must be sex, love or money? Is the professed friendship offer real? A good read but really didn't like the fact that it ended on a cliffhanger. Prefer my stories to be complete in themselves even if in a series. Must admit I do love her cat.
Profile Image for Lilith's.
204 reviews1 follower
June 9, 2023
I'm starting to understand less and less the mystery. This was called "The Silent Banshee" but it didn't have much information about the Banshee itself. The build up of the mystery is hard to believe. I mean, I get it, but I don't know... it feels like something is missing. There also a couple of typos, but nothing hideous. Now, as a Brimstone mystery, I'll say it's alright. A great continuity to the saga and I do want to keep reading, so points for that.
725 reviews8 followers
September 18, 2017
Coming together

For a set of cozy mysteries and the rather simple writing style, the backstory sure has gotten complex. A number of small threads have come together to make a thick rope of a plot. It makes me wish our author would write more complex fiction since it's obvious that she has the talent.
Profile Image for Beverly.
302 reviews20 followers
April 1, 2018
Another enjoyable cozy

This episode of the Brimstone Witch Mysteries kept me guessing throughout the book. I never did figure out who the murderer was. This book ended with a cliffhanger on top of it. I love April Fernsby's imagination! I have already purchased the next installment of the series. I can't wait to see what happens next.
929 reviews2 followers
April 5, 2021
So good.

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. Things look grim for the residents of Brimstone as the body of a banshee is found in a wheat field. The justice witch has her work cut out for her. The story and characters were intriguing and engaging. I look forward to reading more about these characters and their further adventures. This book is definitely worth reading.
9 reviews2 followers
October 9, 2017
ENJOY OPEN YOUR MIND AND ENTER NEVER NEVER LAND

I often read take me away books, take me away from my every day world to forget my troubles whilst I forget everything and enjoy Make Me Happy Books.ENJOY NEVER NEVER LAND
Profile Image for Amanda.
911 reviews
April 4, 2018
A fast and fun enough read. The writing style is very annoying, leaning more to the "tell everything instead of showing anything" side. Book ends on a cliff-hanger, and I hate when books can't stand on their own. I haven't read the other books in the series, and I most likely won't.
Profile Image for Terri.
286 reviews9 followers
June 13, 2018
A much loved Banshee!?

There are many lovely retirement homes in Brimstone! At the Caterpillar Retirement Home we meet some of the residents that know when they're going to die! A fast paced mystery!
Profile Image for suzanne wharton.
39 reviews
March 4, 2020
April Fernsby

I have read from book 1 to book 5 this is a very enjoyable series with lots of twists and turns. Some of the books about witches are very similar in story lines but this witch goes between the two worlds. Well worth reading
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
1,166 reviews
April 2, 2020
I loved it! So much goes down in this one. We learn so much about Astrid. Evil person that she is. I hope things work out like Cassie said. This is a must read series! I can’t wait for the next book!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Laurel .
1,346 reviews5 followers
September 11, 2022
This was a fun paranormal mystery. Characters were well defined. While attempting to solve a murder, a dragon with a memory disorder appears. Nothing is as it seems. One mystery is solved. Was not happy with the ending. Exit evil, stage right.
Profile Image for Lynda Bowles.
98 reviews
September 4, 2017
Great book

Wonderful story love the characters, but I want more. Anxiously waiting for the next one in the series. Keep up the great work
Profile Image for Lynn.
691 reviews13 followers
December 20, 2017
Totally different who done it.. Liked it
29 reviews
December 28, 2017
Another great read

I wish these books were longer but filler is not always better. The story ended too quickly. Onto the next mystery.
Profile Image for Zoë.
475 reviews4 followers
October 18, 2018
Its still a strange style of writing but oh the story line is getting so good now x
1,273 reviews
May 23, 2019
Another murder in Brimstone and the justice witch is on the job. A humorous series
Profile Image for Maria.
122 reviews1 follower
September 27, 2021
With every book the series gets better and better.
Profile Image for Beth Helm.
1,056 reviews1 follower
September 3, 2022
I loved this book. April Fernsby has written another wonderful book. Trying to figure out the killer was hard, the characters were great and kept you wondering what will happen.
Profile Image for Amk256 King.
920 reviews1 follower
August 8, 2023
Didn’t enjoy this one …. What’s happened to the actual story?

Was quite frankly rubbish but onwards with the next one we go cause it’s how I roll. If I start it then it has to be finished!
Profile Image for Lariza.
368 reviews75 followers
December 21, 2024
Loving Cassia’s adventures a good continuation to the series
Profile Image for Bonnie Dale Keck.
4,677 reviews58 followers
February 12, 2018
Kindle Unlimited, had 4 of the 4 already plus The Leprechaun's Last Trick (A Brimstone Witch Mystery (A Brimstone Witch Mystery 1.5 basically) from freebie days and had already reviewed all of those, then found had gotten book 5 even on freebie day so had to come back in. Still seeing typos/missing words here and there, and some areas that are either confusing or whatever, minus that still a 4-ish.

Cassia Winter is a witch. With the help of her cat, Stanley, she investigates crimes in the magical town of Brimstone. This story sees them dealing with the death of a banshee called Dana Murphy.On the morning of her death, Dana Murphy’s dying scream produces a huge amount of energy that rushes through the town of Brimstone. The energy makes its way to Cassia’s world and sends her flying off her feet. Upon entering Brimstone, Cassia is told that as the town banshee, Dana predicted many deaths - but apparently not her own.Cassia and Stanley investigate Dana’s death and are confronted with the grim reality of how she died. They discover that more than one resident in Brimstone had a reason to put an end to Dana’s special talent.As well as dealing with the murder investigation, Cassia is confronted with help from an unlikely source. Stanley immediately feels uneasy, and that unease grows as they delve further into Dana’s murder.


NOTE: the 3 sets START with #2 book, might try to find time to re-read them, there is something 'off' so only a 4 but want to pinpoint reason.


Murder Of A Werewolf (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 1)
The Leprechaun's Last Trick (A Brimstone Witch Mystery 1.5 basically)

As Dead As A Vampire (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 2)
The Centaur's Last Breath (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 3)
The Sleeping Goblin (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 4)
Brimstone Witch Mysteries - Box Set 1 {Does NOT include #1 NOR 1.5}
As Dead As A Vampire/The Centaur's Last Breath/The Sleeping Goblin

The Silent Banshee (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 5)
The Murdered Mermaid (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 6)
The End Of The Yeti (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 7)
Brimstone Witch Mysteries - Box Set 2
The Silent Banshee/The Murdered Mermaid/The End Of The Yeti

Death Of A Rainbow Nymph (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 8)
The Witch Is Dead (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 9)
A Deal With The Grim Reaper (A Brimstone Witch Mystery Book 10)
Brimstone Witch Mysteries - Box Set 3
Death Of A Rainbow Nymph/The Witch Is Dead/A Deal With The Grim Reaper

The Leprechaun's Last Trick (A Brimstone Witch Mystery)
It is a bridge between the first book (Murder of a Werewolf) and the second As Dead as a Vampire so listed it once here and once in order.
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.