4.5 Stars: I have been seeing great reviews for this series over the last year, but when I read the synopsis, I thought this really is not my cup of tea, but those positive comments kept coming. I finally decided to take the plunge. This story was totally unexpected and thoroughly enjoyed. It is a cozy mystery but has aspects of a Harry Potter type story. We have a witch that had no idea she was a witch, a magical land (an island off the coast of France), fantastical creatures, talking flames and more. When the murder occurs, our main character, Imogene is a suspect mainly because she is an outsider who had a misunderstanding with the victim. Throw in a cooking contest, a couple of handsome men, a best friend and you have a great story. It was excellently written, humorous, wonderfully descriptive, fantastic characters and the contained all the qualities of a great cozy mystery. With all my trepidation, I wished I had picked this one up earlier as I now have a lot to catch up on. If you like cozy mysteries, especially if they are different, and can suspend reality and enjoy a fantasy world, then I recommend you pick this book up and get to know Imogene, Maple, Hank and the others.