What do you think?
Rate this book
An Amish Fairytale #2
Ella: An Amish Retelling of Cinderella
In Sarah Price’s heartwarming Amish version of this best-loved fairytale, a hardworking, overlooked young woman is rewarded in unexpected ways . . .
“Be kind and have faith.” Ella Troyer strives to abide by her mother’s final words, although life in the small Amish town of Echo Creek isn’t always easy. Her new stepmother, Linda, treats her coldly, and her two stepsisters, Drusilla and Anna, delight in gossip and laziness. After her father’s death, Ella’s stepsisters are free to attend youth singings while Ella stays at home to manage the household chores, rarely seeing another soul. Until one day, while running an errand, she has a chance meeting with a young Amish man from a nearby town.
Drusilla and Anna are full of admiration for charming, affluent newcomer Johannes Wagler, and Linda hopes to ensnare him as a husband for one of her girls—while keeping Ella out of the way. As for Hannes, he longs to catch another glimpse of the mysterious young woman who can sing so sweetly and bake the most delicious pie he’s ever sampled. Now, with a little help from some unlikely sources, Ella dares to hope she might find her heart’s dearest wishes—for love, family, and a home of her own—coming true at last . . .
“Be kind and have faith.” Ella Troyer strives to abide by her mother’s final words, although life in the small Amish town of Echo Creek isn’t always easy. Her new stepmother, Linda, treats her coldly, and her two stepsisters, Drusilla and Anna, delight in gossip and laziness. After her father’s death, Ella’s stepsisters are free to attend youth singings while Ella stays at home to manage the household chores, rarely seeing another soul. Until one day, while running an errand, she has a chance meeting with a young Amish man from a nearby town.
Drusilla and Anna are full of admiration for charming, affluent newcomer Johannes Wagler, and Linda hopes to ensnare him as a husband for one of her girls—while keeping Ella out of the way. As for Hannes, he longs to catch another glimpse of the mysterious young woman who can sing so sweetly and bake the most delicious pie he’s ever sampled. Now, with a little help from some unlikely sources, Ella dares to hope she might find her heart’s dearest wishes—for love, family, and a home of her own—coming true at last . . .
259 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 1, 2018
120 people are currently reading
370 people want to read
About the author
Sarah Price
135 books648 followersECPA Christian Fiction Bestseller (June 2014, July 2014)
Amazon Top 100 Author for Books & eBooks (January 2016, September 2013, August 2013, May 2013, April 2013, February 2013, January 2013, December 2012)
-------------------------
The author of over 30 novels, Sarah Price publishes with Realms, an imprint of Charisma House and Waterfall, an imprint of Brilliance Audio.
Her book, An Empty Cup, was #3 on Amazon Top 100 eBooks in January 2016.
Follow her on social media:
Blog:http://www.sarahpriceauthor.com.
Facebook: http://facebook.com/fansofsarahprice.
Instagram: @SarahPriceAuthor
Twitter: @SarahPriceAuthr
Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/SarahPrice
FAMILY HERITAGE
During the early 1700s, the Preiss family arrived in America aboard an old sailing vessel called the Patience. The family left Europe, escaping Catholic persecution for their Anabaptist beliefs. Sarah Price comes from a long line of devout Mennonites, including numerous church leaders and ministers throughout the years.
In 1969, Sarah Price was born in Pennsylvania and lived on the land of her ancestors, Johannes Preiss and "King Tammany", otherwise known as Tamanend, a chief of the Lenni Lenape nation in the Delaware Valley.
In the early 1970s, her family moved to Morristown, New Jersey where she still resides with her husband, two children, and assortment of animals.
Ms. Price has advanced degrees in Communication (MA), Marketing (MBA), and Educational Leadership (PhD).
Ms. Price was a former full-time college professor. After being diagnosed with breast cancer in 2013, she now writes full-time.
Amazon Top 100 Author for Books & eBooks (January 2016, September 2013, August 2013, May 2013, April 2013, February 2013, January 2013, December 2012)
-------------------------
The author of over 30 novels, Sarah Price publishes with Realms, an imprint of Charisma House and Waterfall, an imprint of Brilliance Audio.
Her book, An Empty Cup, was #3 on Amazon Top 100 eBooks in January 2016.
Follow her on social media:
Blog:http://www.sarahpriceauthor.com.
Facebook: http://facebook.com/fansofsarahprice.
Instagram: @SarahPriceAuthor
Twitter: @SarahPriceAuthr
Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/SarahPrice
FAMILY HERITAGE
During the early 1700s, the Preiss family arrived in America aboard an old sailing vessel called the Patience. The family left Europe, escaping Catholic persecution for their Anabaptist beliefs. Sarah Price comes from a long line of devout Mennonites, including numerous church leaders and ministers throughout the years.
In 1969, Sarah Price was born in Pennsylvania and lived on the land of her ancestors, Johannes Preiss and "King Tammany", otherwise known as Tamanend, a chief of the Lenni Lenape nation in the Delaware Valley.
In the early 1970s, her family moved to Morristown, New Jersey where she still resides with her husband, two children, and assortment of animals.
Ms. Price has advanced degrees in Communication (MA), Marketing (MBA), and Educational Leadership (PhD).
Ms. Price was a former full-time college professor. After being diagnosed with breast cancer in 2013, she now writes full-time.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews
May 29, 2018
This is the second book in the Amish Fairytale series. I've read and enjoyed both a lot. This is such a fun read. Amish book readers will get a kick out of how this story mirrors the fairytale Cinderella. Ella is a young woman still unmarried and living at home with her father. Her mother has passed away and her father wants the companionship of a new wife. Just like in the Cinderella story it's a disaster from the start but gets so much worse after her father's death. Evil stepmother and wicked stepsisters is what Ella has to put up with day in and day out. Even though they run her ragged by telling her to do all the farm work,inside chores,baking,cooking,sewing,etc Ella still treats her stepsisters and stepmother with kindness and respect as her mother told her to treat people. It's never reciprocated of course. Her stepsisters couldn't bake a pie if their life depended on it. An Amish woman is taught how to run a household and all that goes with it at an early age so who knows how the stepsisters will ever find a husband. When a handsome young man shows an interest in Ella the evil ones do all they can in their power to turn his eye toward them instead of her. The mother is no better as she claims something Ella did was done by her daughters. Unknown to the stepmother and stepdaughters the handsome young man sees through them and knows what they are really like. I loved the ending but no spoilers here. Let's just say they got what they deserved. Kindness pays off and deceit will do nothing but make you look bad and untrustworthy.
Pub Date 29 May 2018
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books through NetGalley. Thank you. All opinions expressed are my own.
Pub Date 29 May 2018
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books through NetGalley. Thank you. All opinions expressed are my own.
July 8, 2019
A clean and realistic retelling of Cinderella set in an Amish farming community, devoid of magic, fairy godmothers and the supernatural. The romance plotline is nothing extraordinary, but what I liked best was to see how the author dealt with having to match the tale's magical elements with non-magical equivalents, and I loved how she replaced the grand royal ball with a rumspringa party and the glass slippers to identify the mystery girl with a delicious apple pie auction in which, naturally, the star pie is the heroine's. Really lovely.
August 7, 2022
I wasn't sure what I was getting into with this series - Amish fairytales - the author's attempt to retell popular fairytales within an Amish setting. I was pleasantly surprised, although there may have been a slight stretch or two to make the setting fit the narrative.
Ella's father remarried after her mother died. He runs the general store in Echo Creek, and Ella has always been his helper. But when he becomes lonely and brings home a new bride who has two daughters, things change. At first, not so much - Ella doesn't work at the store anymore; she is confined to the home and given all of the cooking, housekeeping, gardening, and animal care to do, while her stepsisters spend their time "helping" at the store and gadding about town, certainly not very Amish behavior. But when Ella's father dies, the changes become even more pronounced. Now her stepmother Linda is running the store, and running it into the ground! Taxes are unpaid, merchandise is not moving, and Linda is making enemies of vendors with her unusual ideas of how to display merchandise. Finally Linda confesses that she is going to have to either sell the store or take on a partner. Ella is horrified, but there is little she can do.
However, the young Amish man from another town who comes to look over the store with the intent to become a partner is entranced with Ella. He makes time to spend with her, which makes her stepsisters very jealous. And her stepmother is eyeing the young man as future marriage material for one of her daughters, so she is intent on keeping Ella from ever seeing Hannes.
I love how the author wove this familiar tale into the Amish setting. It is quite believable and even hilarious how the tables are turned in the end. And the wonderful "moral" of this tale comes from Ella's mother's dying words to her daughter: "Be kind and good, no matter what happens, for God has a plan for you." Many times when her life was very difficult, Ella was tempted to give up or to give un-Christian responses to those who were being mean to her. But her mother's words, her strong faith, and her active prayer life helped Ella remain sweet and faithful under pressure.
Ella's father remarried after her mother died. He runs the general store in Echo Creek, and Ella has always been his helper. But when he becomes lonely and brings home a new bride who has two daughters, things change. At first, not so much - Ella doesn't work at the store anymore; she is confined to the home and given all of the cooking, housekeeping, gardening, and animal care to do, while her stepsisters spend their time "helping" at the store and gadding about town, certainly not very Amish behavior. But when Ella's father dies, the changes become even more pronounced. Now her stepmother Linda is running the store, and running it into the ground! Taxes are unpaid, merchandise is not moving, and Linda is making enemies of vendors with her unusual ideas of how to display merchandise. Finally Linda confesses that she is going to have to either sell the store or take on a partner. Ella is horrified, but there is little she can do.
However, the young Amish man from another town who comes to look over the store with the intent to become a partner is entranced with Ella. He makes time to spend with her, which makes her stepsisters very jealous. And her stepmother is eyeing the young man as future marriage material for one of her daughters, so she is intent on keeping Ella from ever seeing Hannes.
I love how the author wove this familiar tale into the Amish setting. It is quite believable and even hilarious how the tables are turned in the end. And the wonderful "moral" of this tale comes from Ella's mother's dying words to her daughter: "Be kind and good, no matter what happens, for God has a plan for you." Many times when her life was very difficult, Ella was tempted to give up or to give un-Christian responses to those who were being mean to her. But her mother's words, her strong faith, and her active prayer life helped Ella remain sweet and faithful under pressure.
April 14, 2018
This is the second book of the Amish Fairytale series by Sarah price and I have to say that enjoyed just as much as Belle, the first book in the series if not more. We got see Ella's life and the sweet romance she got to have with a young Amish businessman while dealing with her awful step-mother and step-sisters. They are truly horrible people and they deserved what they got at the end of the book. We also got to hear a little bit more about Sadie Whitaker from the first book and I can't wait to read her story.
I recommend this book to anybody who enjoys a good Amish romance. It is truly a great and fast read.
*I received an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
I recommend this book to anybody who enjoys a good Amish romance. It is truly a great and fast read.
*I received an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
April 18, 2018
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Another modern day Cinderella tale with an Amish twist.
Sarah Price is one author that I'm going to read more of. For a person who usually stays away from anything resembling Amish, I find myself captivated by Price's writing. It is in no way boring.
This was a charming little tale of Ella, a girl who lives with her two stepsister and cruel stepmother and forced to do all the chores. But one day she meets her prince charming in the form of a businessman just as charming as he is handsome....with a cunning edge to him.
I'm sure you'll be as enchanted as I was of this book. I highly recommend it for everyone.
Another modern day Cinderella tale with an Amish twist.
Sarah Price is one author that I'm going to read more of. For a person who usually stays away from anything resembling Amish, I find myself captivated by Price's writing. It is in no way boring.
This was a charming little tale of Ella, a girl who lives with her two stepsister and cruel stepmother and forced to do all the chores. But one day she meets her prince charming in the form of a businessman just as charming as he is handsome....with a cunning edge to him.
I'm sure you'll be as enchanted as I was of this book. I highly recommend it for everyone.
August 30, 2018
This was really good. I was hesitant to read another retelling of Cinderella but the author did it justice and it was wonderful!
November 30, 2018
I loved this book!! Great story!! Love this author's books!! Book reminded me of Cinderella!! The stepmother and step sisters were so mean!!
August 10, 2018
But the words seemed to repeat themselves, over and over again. Be kind. And good. God has a plan.
These are the words Ella lived by since her mother's death when she was young. Now that her father is ready to remarry, the words become a test to her faith and the promise she made to her mother. Ella strongly believes that breaking a promise is paramount to lying. Linda her new step mother along with Linda's daughter's Drusilla and Anna, is testing her faith. Life is manageable while her father is the head of the house, however, when he dies and leaves all that he has, his Amish store and house to his wife, Ella is at the mercy of her step mother and sisters. However, with them there is no mercy. Ella receives her strength from knowing God does have a plan.
With the store in crisis since Linda has taken over, a young man Amish is in town that has taken notice of Ella. He is a mystery with a secret. Ella welcomes his kindness and begins to hope again for a future.
So what does an Amish Cinderella look like? There are mice and pumpkins, foolish step mother and self-centered step sisters. Instead of a ball, a pie contest and instead of fairy god mother a pastor's wife that sees the truth. Bring these all together, you have a picture of God's goodness in all circumstances. One biblical application that I appreciated was one of the father and son. The father sent his son to do his business, but they did not accept the son. It was a subtle picture of what God does thru his son Jesus and how we without knowing it reject the son.
Loved every minute of it.
A Special Thank You to Kensington Books and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
These are the words Ella lived by since her mother's death when she was young. Now that her father is ready to remarry, the words become a test to her faith and the promise she made to her mother. Ella strongly believes that breaking a promise is paramount to lying. Linda her new step mother along with Linda's daughter's Drusilla and Anna, is testing her faith. Life is manageable while her father is the head of the house, however, when he dies and leaves all that he has, his Amish store and house to his wife, Ella is at the mercy of her step mother and sisters. However, with them there is no mercy. Ella receives her strength from knowing God does have a plan.
With the store in crisis since Linda has taken over, a young man Amish is in town that has taken notice of Ella. He is a mystery with a secret. Ella welcomes his kindness and begins to hope again for a future.
So what does an Amish Cinderella look like? There are mice and pumpkins, foolish step mother and self-centered step sisters. Instead of a ball, a pie contest and instead of fairy god mother a pastor's wife that sees the truth. Bring these all together, you have a picture of God's goodness in all circumstances. One biblical application that I appreciated was one of the father and son. The father sent his son to do his business, but they did not accept the son. It was a subtle picture of what God does thru his son Jesus and how we without knowing it reject the son.
Loved every minute of it.
A Special Thank You to Kensington Books and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
April 13, 2018
When I read the last Amish retelling of a fairy tale by this author I knew I had to read all the books in the series. When Ella: An Amish Retelling of Cinderella became available on Netgalley I immediately requested. I was able to read in two sessions and stayed up after midnight finishing this book. The author did an excellent job of converting the classic tale of Cinderella into an Amish novel. She did an excellent job of portraying the step-mother and step-sisters as abusive. The step-mother made Ella do all the work, never let her socialize and put her daughters before Ella. Ella was way too kind and were never say a word against them. They did everything they could to sabotage the friendship of Hannes and Ella. Linda the step-mother wanted her daughters to capture the attention of Hannes. Then there is the kindly Marian. She plays the part of the fairy godmother. I don't want to give too much of the storyline away but I guarantee you will enjoy it even if you don't enjoy Amish fiction. There is even a twist toward the end. The comeuppance that the step-family received was priceless.
I received this ebook thanks to Kensington Books and Netgalley. The opinions are all my own and I received no compensation for reviewing this book. This book is due to be released on May 29, 2018.
I received this ebook thanks to Kensington Books and Netgalley. The opinions are all my own and I received no compensation for reviewing this book. This book is due to be released on May 29, 2018.
May 2, 2018
If I were to use only one word to describe this book, it would be sweet. While I’m still pretty new to the Amish fiction genre, I love fairytale retellings, so when I heard about this book, it really jumped out at me. This novel did not disappoint me. I was impressed with how the author used Amish customs in place of certain instances in the original fairytale in ways I would have never thought of. Price was able to take those traditions and work them into her novel in ways that clearly followed the original storyline while giving a fresh take on a beloved story. The book was full of characters with both good and bad traits that fit in seamlessly with the Cinderella story. Readers will love Ella and Hannes and root for them as they read the story.
Overall, Ella: An Amish Retelling of Cinderella is a sweet retelling of a beloved classic. Fans of Amish fiction will love the book and readers that love fairytale retellings will also want to give this one a try.
I give this book 4 out of 5 stars.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Zebra Publishing through NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Overall, Ella: An Amish Retelling of Cinderella is a sweet retelling of a beloved classic. Fans of Amish fiction will love the book and readers that love fairytale retellings will also want to give this one a try.
I give this book 4 out of 5 stars.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Zebra Publishing through NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
July 11, 2018
Sheer brilliance! I get giddy just thinking about this Amish fairy tale series. We've had Beauty and the Beast and now Cinderella and Snow White coming out in the fall. I truly hope that this series is as endless as the number of fairy tales out there! It's so much fun to spot the similarities to the original tales while marveling at the unique Amish twist Price brings to each story.
"Be kind and good, no matter what happens, for God has a plan for you." Ella has lived by the wise counsel of her dying mother in the midst of the most trying times. Clearly I am not as sweet natured as our plucky heroine, because I seethed in fury at the odious Linda's horrid behavior and loudly encouraged Ella to be anything but kind and good. Ha! I love getting riled at the villains in a fairy tale -- especially since I know justice will be served in the end. :-) And the way this familiar tale plays out is pure magic. This author is beyond clever and I want to say so much more but you really need to discover all the delightful nuances yourself. A truly sublime read that will make you happy.
"Be kind and good, no matter what happens, for God has a plan for you." Ella has lived by the wise counsel of her dying mother in the midst of the most trying times. Clearly I am not as sweet natured as our plucky heroine, because I seethed in fury at the odious Linda's horrid behavior and loudly encouraged Ella to be anything but kind and good. Ha! I love getting riled at the villains in a fairy tale -- especially since I know justice will be served in the end. :-) And the way this familiar tale plays out is pure magic. This author is beyond clever and I want to say so much more but you really need to discover all the delightful nuances yourself. A truly sublime read that will make you happy.
April 26, 2018
This is the first book I have read of Sarah Price I enjoyed this book. I love fairy tales in general but I enjoyed her Amish writing of this classic. The story between Hannes and Ella was super exciting I enjoyed the twist through out the book. The way Elle loved the Lord and kept her promise to her mother amazed me. She definitely was more forgiving to her family then most would be.
April 25, 2018
So cute, so well written, a fantasy, a reality and more. This was a great read it was warm, and ful filling. Very true to the Amish life and culture as told. The main characters were well developed and sincere.
July 29, 2018
Please remember how downtrodden the original Cinderella was as this Ella is a doormat too! Sweet Amish retelling though
April 20, 2019
*thank you to Kensington Books and Netgalley for granting me this book in exchange for an honest review*
The story of Cinderella is one we all know and could probably tell without problem. It’s the Amish element of this one that makes it interesting.
Ella Troyer lives with her stepmom and 2 stepsisters where she is treated like a maid moreso than a member of the family. Just like in the Rodgers & Hammerstein or Disney versions, Ella is made to clean and cook and wash while her stepsisters do nothing. Being that Ella is Amish and one of their highest beliefs is to respect one’s parents; Ella takes this abuse (which sometimes can be verbal) without rebuttal because to rebut would be to disrespect her stepmother.
A handsome stranger has come to town and has turned the heads of all the single girls, all except Ella, whom the stranger takes an immediate interest in.
A few long talks and a carefully planned scheme later, all is well! Ella’s married a wonderful man, her stepfamily has gotten what they deserve and life is grand.
I enjoyed the author’s take on this classic fairytale. By making it an Amish retelling, there were certain elements that had to be changed (the savior wasn’t a handsome prince, just a goodly man) but it worked out nonetheless. I also like how the author linked her upcoming story to the current one. I feel each of the stories could be read as a stand-alone but that little bit of background from the previous one is quite nice.
The story of Cinderella is one we all know and could probably tell without problem. It’s the Amish element of this one that makes it interesting.
Ella Troyer lives with her stepmom and 2 stepsisters where she is treated like a maid moreso than a member of the family. Just like in the Rodgers & Hammerstein or Disney versions, Ella is made to clean and cook and wash while her stepsisters do nothing. Being that Ella is Amish and one of their highest beliefs is to respect one’s parents; Ella takes this abuse (which sometimes can be verbal) without rebuttal because to rebut would be to disrespect her stepmother.
A handsome stranger has come to town and has turned the heads of all the single girls, all except Ella, whom the stranger takes an immediate interest in.
A few long talks and a carefully planned scheme later, all is well! Ella’s married a wonderful man, her stepfamily has gotten what they deserve and life is grand.
I enjoyed the author’s take on this classic fairytale. By making it an Amish retelling, there were certain elements that had to be changed (the savior wasn’t a handsome prince, just a goodly man) but it worked out nonetheless. I also like how the author linked her upcoming story to the current one. I feel each of the stories could be read as a stand-alone but that little bit of background from the previous one is quite nice.
August 24, 2019
I thoroughly enjoyed this retelling of Cinderella! I will read this novel again I am sure. A beautiful way to thread in the blessings God has for those with a servants heart & those who are abused for their goodness.
May 29, 2018
I don’t usually read Amish romances, but I love fairy tale retellings and I loved the Ellie’s People books when I was a kid, so I decided to try this one out. I’m glad I did! While it’s somewhat simplistic, it’s also very sweet and fairy tale-like. Like most Amish romances, it’s also very Christian, so if that’s a deal-breaker for you, you probably won’t like it. While this is the second in a series, I read it as a standalone.
After her father died suddenly, Ella’s stepmother inherited the general store he founded and ran for years. Unfortunately, she’s proved to be not very good at it, and Ella’s stepsisters will basically do anything to get out of doing chores, preferring to go gossip with their friends.
Like I said previously, it’s a bit simplistic, especially characterization-wise. The bad people – like the stepmother and stepsisters – are very, very bad. The stepsisters, especially, abuse Ella’s tendency to put others’ needs ahead of her own to get out of doing pretty much anything so they can go gossip with friends. I didn’t like that immediately the step-sisters were described as overweight and “large boned” as a shorthand way of showing they’re the bad guys. That kind of fat shaming, in my opinion, has no place in such an unabashedly Christian book. Hannes, on the other hand, is the epitome of perfect Amish husband material – “prudent with his words and even-tempered with his speech.” The story’s version of the fairy godmother is, also, a vision of perfect Amish womanhood. I was delighted to see what the Amish equivalent to a prince was, and there were other little references to the fairy tale that were cute.
My main issue with the book was that I disliked that Ella was such a doormat. Like I mentioned previously, she had a habit of volunteering to do the stepsisters’ chores so they’d stop arguing over who would do them. Her step-family is ridiculously cruel to her, basically using her a servant and running the store into the ground, but she never attempts to bring the issues up with a church authority. While Ella is, eventually, gently reproached by a church elder for being so good and kind at her own expense, it felt a bit like too much too late. I think being good and kind in the face of trying circumstances (and people!) is a certainly a good thing, but Ella took it to an extreme. In some ways, being so self-sacrificial just worsened her step-sisters’ and stepmother’s tendency towards relying on her, meaning that they never felt the effects of their wrongdoing until Ella’s “fairy godmother” stepped in. Basically, rather than allowing them the chance to correct their “sin,” she aided them in continuing it. I’m pretty sure that this is a place where general mainstream Protestantism differs with the Amish, though, so I won’t mark the book down for it.
Overall, though, I think it was a very enjoyable read, and I’m giving it four stars. If you love both Amish romances and fairy tale retellings, I’m sure you’d love this book!
I received this book for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
“[S]he kept repeating the words her mother had told her just before she died: Be kind and good, no matter what happens, for God has a plan for you.”
After her father died suddenly, Ella’s stepmother inherited the general store he founded and ran for years. Unfortunately, she’s proved to be not very good at it, and Ella’s stepsisters will basically do anything to get out of doing chores, preferring to go gossip with their friends.
Like I said previously, it’s a bit simplistic, especially characterization-wise. The bad people – like the stepmother and stepsisters – are very, very bad. The stepsisters, especially, abuse Ella’s tendency to put others’ needs ahead of her own to get out of doing pretty much anything so they can go gossip with friends. I didn’t like that immediately the step-sisters were described as overweight and “large boned” as a shorthand way of showing they’re the bad guys. That kind of fat shaming, in my opinion, has no place in such an unabashedly Christian book. Hannes, on the other hand, is the epitome of perfect Amish husband material – “prudent with his words and even-tempered with his speech.” The story’s version of the fairy godmother is, also, a vision of perfect Amish womanhood. I was delighted to see what the Amish equivalent to a prince was, and there were other little references to the fairy tale that were cute.
“I try to make good choices, to follow God’s Word, and to be fair to others.” With a quick glance over his shoulder, he took a deep breath and sighed. “It’s hard to watch other people who do not walk the same path.”
[…] She replied slowly, echoing his serious tone, “The choices we make, Hannes, are the one thing we truly own. If some people choose poorly, we can only pray for them, ja? We cannot be responsible for others’ poor decisions.”
My main issue with the book was that I disliked that Ella was such a doormat. Like I mentioned previously, she had a habit of volunteering to do the stepsisters’ chores so they’d stop arguing over who would do them. Her step-family is ridiculously cruel to her, basically using her a servant and running the store into the ground, but she never attempts to bring the issues up with a church authority. While Ella is, eventually, gently reproached by a church elder for being so good and kind at her own expense, it felt a bit like too much too late. I think being good and kind in the face of trying circumstances (and people!) is a certainly a good thing, but Ella took it to an extreme. In some ways, being so self-sacrificial just worsened her step-sisters’ and stepmother’s tendency towards relying on her, meaning that they never felt the effects of their wrongdoing until Ella’s “fairy godmother” stepped in. Basically, rather than allowing them the chance to correct their “sin,” she aided them in continuing it. I’m pretty sure that this is a place where general mainstream Protestantism differs with the Amish, though, so I won’t mark the book down for it.
Overall, though, I think it was a very enjoyable read, and I’m giving it four stars. If you love both Amish romances and fairy tale retellings, I’m sure you’d love this book!
I received this book for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
June 1, 2018
Ella is a fun, quick read that transports the reader into an Amish tale that incorporates all of the expected components and characters of the Cinderella fairytale, though not always in an expected way. Her stepmother is appropriately capriciously cruel and her step-sisters vain and lazy, and there just happen to be some mice in the cellar.
Ella herself is a lovely version of Cinderella, putting up with the demands of her stepmother and step-sisters as she keeps in mind her mother's dying words, that she be good and kind to all and that God has a plan for her. Though her wish to be helpful and kind is taken advantage of, she has her small rebellions (see mention of mice above) but remains respectful and hard working, which doesn't go unnoticed by a a select few members of her community. And the introduction of Hannes, the "handsome prince" role of the piece, as a potential business partner for Ella's stepmother and object of her step-sisters' marital machinations, is quite fun. As he attempts to get to know Ella and assures her that everything is not always what it seems, Hannes is quite, well, charming.
But what, you might think, about the ball? I'll just say that I loved how the author turned this aspect, as well as how Ella gets to the event, into a believable and pivotal part of the story. I do think the discovery of a trunk was a missed opportunity, though there is no telling whether it will play into a future story. I was hopeful that a will would be discovered inside, but that would have moved the story in another direction and I quite like how everything worked together to give a satisfying ending in keeping with the fairytale.
I was unsure of what an Amish retelling of Cinderella would be like, but I was quickly pulled in to the story and I found myself happily reading it in one sitting. This is a delightful fairytale retelling that will lend itself to rereads, and the mentions of Ella's friends Belle (Beauty) and Sadie (Snow White) have me wanting to read the previous and upcoming books in this Amish Fairytale series.
Recommended for those who enjoy Amish novels, fairytale retellings with a faith element, or just a fun and enchanting read. 3.5 stars.
This review refers to an e-galley copy read courtesy of the publisher, through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Ella herself is a lovely version of Cinderella, putting up with the demands of her stepmother and step-sisters as she keeps in mind her mother's dying words, that she be good and kind to all and that God has a plan for her. Though her wish to be helpful and kind is taken advantage of, she has her small rebellions (see mention of mice above) but remains respectful and hard working, which doesn't go unnoticed by a a select few members of her community. And the introduction of Hannes, the "handsome prince" role of the piece, as a potential business partner for Ella's stepmother and object of her step-sisters' marital machinations, is quite fun. As he attempts to get to know Ella and assures her that everything is not always what it seems, Hannes is quite, well, charming.
But what, you might think, about the ball? I'll just say that I loved how the author turned this aspect, as well as how Ella gets to the event, into a believable and pivotal part of the story. I do think the discovery of a trunk was a missed opportunity, though there is no telling whether it will play into a future story. I was hopeful that a will would be discovered inside, but that would have moved the story in another direction and I quite like how everything worked together to give a satisfying ending in keeping with the fairytale.
I was unsure of what an Amish retelling of Cinderella would be like, but I was quickly pulled in to the story and I found myself happily reading it in one sitting. This is a delightful fairytale retelling that will lend itself to rereads, and the mentions of Ella's friends Belle (Beauty) and Sadie (Snow White) have me wanting to read the previous and upcoming books in this Amish Fairytale series.
Recommended for those who enjoy Amish novels, fairytale retellings with a faith element, or just a fun and enchanting read. 3.5 stars.
This review refers to an e-galley copy read courtesy of the publisher, through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
May 20, 2018
Fairytale retellings are a bit addicting for me - the minute I see the word "fairytale," I immediately pick up the book and start reading. And if it's an Amish retelling? Now my interest is peaked! Cinderella is a classic, and it's a fairly simple tale to mold into whatever subgenre you're focused on, whether it's contemporary, paranormal, Christian, etc. I loved how Sarah Price took the story and made it so original in an Amish setting, really drawing me in and keeping things surprising, which is hard to do with a retelling. Usually things are super predictable, but not in this book!
Ella Troyer's father passed a year ago, and now that she's alone with her stepmother and stepsisters, things have become unbearable. Forced to do all of the household chores and miss community activities, she feels trapped and is beginning to think she may never know anything else. When a handsome man comes to town, all the young women in her community see him as a catch, but he only has eyes for Ella. But his reason for being there is closely connected to Ella's family, and that connection inevitably leads to conflict. When her stepsisters decide they want him for themselves, it will take a large helping of faith to carry Ella through to a happily ever after.
Hannes and Ella were just about perfect for each other, and I loved how their relationship grew over time! It wasn't your typical love-at-first-sight fairytale, but instead it built over time with sweet meetings by the river and quiet conversations out of sight of Ella's family. Ella was basically a saint, which fits with the Cinderella story but became somewhat irritating as time went on. She let her family walk all over her for so long, and while she stood up for herself later in the story, I wanted her to get some gumption a little sooner. Hannes was a great contrast to her, as he had no problem standing up to her family and helping Ella see how strong she could be.
There were several plot twists that helped keep this retelling unique and exciting, and I am eager to read the next story in the series! That one will be a retelling of Snow White, I imagine, as seven male Amish brothers living in solitude were mentioned.
**I received a free copy via NetGalley and this is my honest review.**
Ella Troyer's father passed a year ago, and now that she's alone with her stepmother and stepsisters, things have become unbearable. Forced to do all of the household chores and miss community activities, she feels trapped and is beginning to think she may never know anything else. When a handsome man comes to town, all the young women in her community see him as a catch, but he only has eyes for Ella. But his reason for being there is closely connected to Ella's family, and that connection inevitably leads to conflict. When her stepsisters decide they want him for themselves, it will take a large helping of faith to carry Ella through to a happily ever after.
Hannes and Ella were just about perfect for each other, and I loved how their relationship grew over time! It wasn't your typical love-at-first-sight fairytale, but instead it built over time with sweet meetings by the river and quiet conversations out of sight of Ella's family. Ella was basically a saint, which fits with the Cinderella story but became somewhat irritating as time went on. She let her family walk all over her for so long, and while she stood up for herself later in the story, I wanted her to get some gumption a little sooner. Hannes was a great contrast to her, as he had no problem standing up to her family and helping Ella see how strong she could be.
There were several plot twists that helped keep this retelling unique and exciting, and I am eager to read the next story in the series! That one will be a retelling of Snow White, I imagine, as seven male Amish brothers living in solitude were mentioned.
**I received a free copy via NetGalley and this is my honest review.**
April 16, 2018
What an adorable tale! Cinderella is one of my favorite fairytales, with Ever After being my favorite version (although it's movie form and not a book), because Without the magical pumpkins and mice turned into horses, it was made to appear possible. I love this retelling for the same reason. It was able to stay true to the Cinderella tale without straying from the realm of possibility.
I loved how well the characters were developed. In the classic Cinderella story, she was forced to be the maid in her home and was really never permitted to leave. This story adds a bit of a twist in that since the family is Amish, they all attend church services together and there are other occasions where Ella leaves the home and is a part of society. Although prevented from having her own social life, she's not completely absent from the community. She is called upon to help at church events as well. Everywhere she goes Ella is a humble helper.
I won't do any spoiling, but considering the story takes place in an Amish community, I think it's safe to say that there is no royal ball in this story. There isn't even a glass slipper. The event that takes it's place manages to reflect Ella's character in a deeper way than a piece of clothing ever could. The author weaves everything together to fit in a truly heartwarming way.
This was such a lighthearted and enjoyable read. I highly recommend this tale especially to fans of Cinderella. It's one a mother and daughter could enjoy together as well. Everyone loves a good fairytale every now and then :)
*I received a complimentary copy of the book from NetGalley and the author in hopes of an honest review. I am under no obligation for a positive review. Thoughts and opinions expressed are mine alone.
I loved how well the characters were developed. In the classic Cinderella story, she was forced to be the maid in her home and was really never permitted to leave. This story adds a bit of a twist in that since the family is Amish, they all attend church services together and there are other occasions where Ella leaves the home and is a part of society. Although prevented from having her own social life, she's not completely absent from the community. She is called upon to help at church events as well. Everywhere she goes Ella is a humble helper.
I won't do any spoiling, but considering the story takes place in an Amish community, I think it's safe to say that there is no royal ball in this story. There isn't even a glass slipper. The event that takes it's place manages to reflect Ella's character in a deeper way than a piece of clothing ever could. The author weaves everything together to fit in a truly heartwarming way.
This was such a lighthearted and enjoyable read. I highly recommend this tale especially to fans of Cinderella. It's one a mother and daughter could enjoy together as well. Everyone loves a good fairytale every now and then :)
*I received a complimentary copy of the book from NetGalley and the author in hopes of an honest review. I am under no obligation for a positive review. Thoughts and opinions expressed are mine alone.
July 21, 2024
Ella: An Amish Retelling of Cinderella by Sarah Price
Amish Fairytale #2
288-page Kindle Ebook [Location Only] 3250
Genre: Retellings, Amish Romance, Christian Fiction
Featuring: Spoiler Preview, Links, Orphan, Motherless Girls, Girlfriends, Stepsisters, Stepmother, General Store, Garden, Economic Abuse, Kindhearted Vs Mean-spirited Trope, Amidst Book 1, Manipulation, Gossip, Church, Mice, Domestic Activities, Debt, Marry The Owner Of Trope, Missing Person, Recipes, Excerpt of Sadie: An Amish Retelling of Snow White
Rating as a movie: PG for adult situations
Songs for the soundtrack: “Das Loblieb”
Books and Authors mentioned: The Story of the Beauty and the Beast by Gabrielle-Suzanne de Villeneuve translation by James Planché, Cendrillon/Cinderella by Charles Perrault, Snow White by The Brothers Grimm
My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½🥧
My thoughts: 🔖42% Location 1374 of 3250 Chapter Twelve - This is great, you definitely have to read in order as this story starts in the middle of the previous story and some of the events overlap but since we only have Ella's POV the spoilers for book 1 aren't beyond the blurb. We get more insight into Sadie's story. I'm beginning to understand why this series only has 3 books, especially if they are all told simultaneously. I loved that the stepmother's behavior is more realistic but just as cruel.
This story was very good; at one point, I was wondering if the mice would talk. I love how the stories overlap and occur simultaneously. Between Belle and Ella's books, I have lots of suspense built up for Sadie's story. I'm starting it right away.
Recommend to others: Yes. This is a good series that feels equally authentic and romanticized.
Amish Fairytale
1. Belle (2017)
2. Ella (2018)
3. Sadie (2018)
Amish Fairytale #2
288-page Kindle Ebook [Location Only] 3250
Genre: Retellings, Amish Romance, Christian Fiction
Featuring: Spoiler Preview, Links, Orphan, Motherless Girls, Girlfriends, Stepsisters, Stepmother, General Store, Garden, Economic Abuse, Kindhearted Vs Mean-spirited Trope, Amidst Book 1, Manipulation, Gossip, Church, Mice, Domestic Activities, Debt, Marry The Owner Of Trope, Missing Person, Recipes, Excerpt of Sadie: An Amish Retelling of Snow White
Rating as a movie: PG for adult situations
Songs for the soundtrack: “Das Loblieb”
Books and Authors mentioned: The Story of the Beauty and the Beast by Gabrielle-Suzanne de Villeneuve translation by James Planché, Cendrillon/Cinderella by Charles Perrault, Snow White by The Brothers Grimm
My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½🥧
My thoughts: 🔖42% Location 1374 of 3250 Chapter Twelve - This is great, you definitely have to read in order as this story starts in the middle of the previous story and some of the events overlap but since we only have Ella's POV the spoilers for book 1 aren't beyond the blurb. We get more insight into Sadie's story. I'm beginning to understand why this series only has 3 books, especially if they are all told simultaneously. I loved that the stepmother's behavior is more realistic but just as cruel.
This story was very good; at one point, I was wondering if the mice would talk. I love how the stories overlap and occur simultaneously. Between Belle and Ella's books, I have lots of suspense built up for Sadie's story. I'm starting it right away.
Recommend to others: Yes. This is a good series that feels equally authentic and romanticized.
Amish Fairytale
1. Belle (2017)
2. Ella (2018)
3. Sadie (2018)
March 26, 2019
This one took me two days to read (Belle I read on one day!) I'm usually not a fan of Cinderella stories (aside from the amazing Lunar Chronicles) but this one had me hooked from the start of chapter 3!
An Amish Cinderella who is a really hard worker and who doesn't speak against her step-mother because of her deeply instilled faith and cultural values. Now THAT makes sense. (I've always had issue with Cinderella not standing up for herself)
Amish step-sisters who are lazy, and that's a bigger problem since laziness goes against all Amish teachings and beliefs- as well as pride and envy, etc. I literally laughed out loud when I realized how much an Amish man would NOT want to marry one of these step-sisters if they couldn't even cook or clean or any of the other things that Amish women are valued for! A lovely twist on the usual lazy step-sister characters.
The "prince" had me guessing at for a while. WHO he was wasn't hard to guess, but HOW he could be considereda prince and how exactly the traditional Cinderella plot-line would play out was a source of constant interuptions to my husband as I laid down my book and made another guess. It was much fun indeed.
This was truly a gem and I love Sarah Price's writing as she takes a classic story we all know and seamlessly places it into an Amish community.
Only two questions remain: what's in the wooden chest? And what happened to the pink dress?!
An Amish Cinderella who is a really hard worker and who doesn't speak against her step-mother because of her deeply instilled faith and cultural values. Now THAT makes sense. (I've always had issue with Cinderella not standing up for herself)
Amish step-sisters who are lazy, and that's a bigger problem since laziness goes against all Amish teachings and beliefs- as well as pride and envy, etc. I literally laughed out loud when I realized how much an Amish man would NOT want to marry one of these step-sisters if they couldn't even cook or clean or any of the other things that Amish women are valued for! A lovely twist on the usual lazy step-sister characters.
The "prince" had me guessing at for a while. WHO he was wasn't hard to guess, but HOW he could be considereda prince and how exactly the traditional Cinderella plot-line would play out was a source of constant interuptions to my husband as I laid down my book and made another guess. It was much fun indeed.
This was truly a gem and I love Sarah Price's writing as she takes a classic story we all know and seamlessly places it into an Amish community.
Only two questions remain: what's in the wooden chest? And what happened to the pink dress?!
April 27, 2018
Ella, is the second book in Sarah Prices’ new series where she retails fairy tales in an everyday Amish setting. As an avid reader of novels that retail fairy tales, I can honestly say that this version is in my top two books, I just can’t decide which one I like better, so maybe it’s actually tied for first.
We find Ella, an orphaned young woman, living in her childhood home with her step-mother and two lazy step-sisters. Ella is responsible for all the chores and baking and often helps in her father’s, now step-mother’s, store in town. The only thing that continues to keep her going is the promise she made to her mother.
When Henry comes to town in hopes of helping out with the struggling store, Ella is not prepared for the friendship that develops. With her step-mother pushing him into marriage with of her own daughters, Ella is left to wonder does Henry really care about her like she does for him.
The author does a wonderful job on the characters and it was easy to picture the town and characters in real time as the story played out. I highly recommend this book for anyone who loves a good fairy tale or just a good Amish story.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from netgalley.com and Kensington Books in return for my honest opinion. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
We find Ella, an orphaned young woman, living in her childhood home with her step-mother and two lazy step-sisters. Ella is responsible for all the chores and baking and often helps in her father’s, now step-mother’s, store in town. The only thing that continues to keep her going is the promise she made to her mother.
When Henry comes to town in hopes of helping out with the struggling store, Ella is not prepared for the friendship that develops. With her step-mother pushing him into marriage with of her own daughters, Ella is left to wonder does Henry really care about her like she does for him.
The author does a wonderful job on the characters and it was easy to picture the town and characters in real time as the story played out. I highly recommend this book for anyone who loves a good fairy tale or just a good Amish story.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from netgalley.com and Kensington Books in return for my honest opinion. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 5, 2018
I love a good fairy tale, and “Cinderella” has always been my favorite. But I have to admit that I think this may now be my very favorite version of that tale. Sarah Price has done an excellent job of placing this story in an Amish setting. I loved everything about this book. I laughed and sighed my way through the ending of the story when Ella finally gets her happily-ever-after with Hannes.
Ella is a perfect Cinderella. She’s a likeable, kind-hearted, and faithful young lady who trusts God through all her struggles. Although Hanes is not a “Prince”, he fits his role very well. They fit together perfectly and are believable as a couple.
Miriam, the deacon’s wife, takes her turn as a sprirted—and sneaky—fairy godmother. Linda is the standard cruel step-mother and there is not one likeable thing about her. And oh, those clueless, cruel, and prideful step-sisters! I’d love to tell you how this story ends, and what takes the place of the “glass slipper”, but that would be ruining your fun. I’ll give you a hint: It’s the perfect ending to an Amish fairytale. Sarah Price has another version of an Amish fairytale coming soon. If it’s as sweet as this one was, I don’t want to miss it.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to give a positive review. This is my honest opinion about this book.
Ella is a perfect Cinderella. She’s a likeable, kind-hearted, and faithful young lady who trusts God through all her struggles. Although Hanes is not a “Prince”, he fits his role very well. They fit together perfectly and are believable as a couple.
Miriam, the deacon’s wife, takes her turn as a sprirted—and sneaky—fairy godmother. Linda is the standard cruel step-mother and there is not one likeable thing about her. And oh, those clueless, cruel, and prideful step-sisters! I’d love to tell you how this story ends, and what takes the place of the “glass slipper”, but that would be ruining your fun. I’ll give you a hint: It’s the perfect ending to an Amish fairytale. Sarah Price has another version of an Amish fairytale coming soon. If it’s as sweet as this one was, I don’t want to miss it.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to give a positive review. This is my honest opinion about this book.
June 6, 2018
Ella has not had it easy since her father died unexpectedly and left her alone with her stepmother and two stepsisters. She has had to do whatever her stepsisters did not want to do which is everything from cooking, cleaning and working in the family store. Her stepmother lets the girls get away with everything while making Ella look and feel as if she is worthless. An unfortunate event has plagued the family and something must be done to save the family store. When a young man starts visiting Echo Creek for his father another store owner life gets interesting for all. Will this be Ella's chance to shine?
Sarah Price has done a wonderful job in the retelling of Cinderella through an Amish perspective. It makes it very fun and interesting. My favorite line in the story is Ella's mother's final words, “Be kind and have faith.” What a powerful line. I have found myself repeating that many times since I have finished the book.
This book is great for teenage readers (and adults) who want to read a clean romance without the crude sex scenes and unneeded obscene language that is finding its way into young adult books.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books through NetGalley. Any and all opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Sarah Price has done a wonderful job in the retelling of Cinderella through an Amish perspective. It makes it very fun and interesting. My favorite line in the story is Ella's mother's final words, “Be kind and have faith.” What a powerful line. I have found myself repeating that many times since I have finished the book.
This book is great for teenage readers (and adults) who want to read a clean romance without the crude sex scenes and unneeded obscene language that is finding its way into young adult books.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books through NetGalley. Any and all opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
June 7, 2018
What a delightful story! After the death of Ella's mother, her father brought home a woman and her two daughters telling Ella he had decided to remarry. As is Cinderella, the stepmother and stepsisters were unkind to Ella. This increased tremendously after her father's passing. Ella, remembering her mother's final words to her to 'be good and kind, for the Lord has a plan for your life.' This is how Ella coped with her life. Ella is not allowed to have a social life, for she must complete her daily list of chores given to her by her stepmother, Linda, while her stepsisters, Drusilla and Anna, are allowed to be lazy and have lots of fun.
Then, one Sunday, there is a stranger at Church. A good looking young adult man, Hannes. He noticed Ella and her lovely singing to God and hoped to see her again.
A nice little twist to the story brought to my remembrance a plaque in my granny's house, that said, 'Cooking is the way to a man's heart.' You will have to read the book to know what I mean by that! Highly recommend this book!
Wonderful 'fairy tale' ending!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher, Kensington through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Then, one Sunday, there is a stranger at Church. A good looking young adult man, Hannes. He noticed Ella and her lovely singing to God and hoped to see her again.
A nice little twist to the story brought to my remembrance a plaque in my granny's house, that said, 'Cooking is the way to a man's heart.' You will have to read the book to know what I mean by that! Highly recommend this book!
Wonderful 'fairy tale' ending!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher, Kensington through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
June 14, 2018
I absolutely loved Ella! This is the second book in Price's, An Amish Fairytale series and both books have been so good. Price takes the well known Fairy tale, Cinderella, and remakes it into an Amish book, and she does it so well.
Ella tells the story of Ella Troyer. Her father, a store owner, has died and Ella resides with her stepmother and her stepsisters. Ella ends up doing all of the chores. She is not treated kindly at all. She sits back and watches her stepsisters get to enjoy youth singings and other events, while she is at home. She has not had the opportunity to be courted because she is never out in the community. Ella's stepmother is also doing a terrible job of running the family store and now the family finds themselves in financial trouble. The answer to the family's financial trouble may be to partner with another Amish business owner. When an Amish man mysteriously appears and is immediately drawn to Ella, he begins to show her kindness that she has not known since her father. The more the two spend time together, the more they realize they have deep feelings for one another. But God is working behind the scenes in this story and things are not always what they appear.
The book is so good and the ending is just perfect.
Ella tells the story of Ella Troyer. Her father, a store owner, has died and Ella resides with her stepmother and her stepsisters. Ella ends up doing all of the chores. She is not treated kindly at all. She sits back and watches her stepsisters get to enjoy youth singings and other events, while she is at home. She has not had the opportunity to be courted because she is never out in the community. Ella's stepmother is also doing a terrible job of running the family store and now the family finds themselves in financial trouble. The answer to the family's financial trouble may be to partner with another Amish business owner. When an Amish man mysteriously appears and is immediately drawn to Ella, he begins to show her kindness that she has not known since her father. The more the two spend time together, the more they realize they have deep feelings for one another. But God is working behind the scenes in this story and things are not always what they appear.
The book is so good and the ending is just perfect.
May 17, 2018
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books and Netgalley. I was under no obligation to post a review and have given my honest opinion
Ella Troyer is faced with losing her mom gaining a new family and then losing her dad. She is reminded of her mother's memory to always be kind and nice. As she faces helping her stepmom and siblings with everything, she catches a suitors eye can she do it all or will something have to give?
Every time I get my hands on Sarah’s book I just can’t put it down most nights reading late into the night and this was once again one of those books. I wanted to know what happened. I have read Sarah’s other book Belle and now this one and for whatever reason these books make me feel like I’m coming home. They are so good it makes you feel like your catching up with friends and the author has that way of just reaching through the pages to keep you interested and going from beginning to end. Seriously this book was amazing. I loved everything about it. The author kept it light but also with a lesson to be learned while reading this wonderful story. The author leaves you hungry both physically and spiritually.
Ella Troyer is faced with losing her mom gaining a new family and then losing her dad. She is reminded of her mother's memory to always be kind and nice. As she faces helping her stepmom and siblings with everything, she catches a suitors eye can she do it all or will something have to give?
Every time I get my hands on Sarah’s book I just can’t put it down most nights reading late into the night and this was once again one of those books. I wanted to know what happened. I have read Sarah’s other book Belle and now this one and for whatever reason these books make me feel like I’m coming home. They are so good it makes you feel like your catching up with friends and the author has that way of just reaching through the pages to keep you interested and going from beginning to end. Seriously this book was amazing. I loved everything about it. The author kept it light but also with a lesson to be learned while reading this wonderful story. The author leaves you hungry both physically and spiritually.
April 29, 2018
Sarah Price brings us another book that is an Amish retelling of fairy tales. The does a great job following the Cinderella fairy tale, however, I read it with mixed emotions.
I understand the Amish concept of forgiveness to others for their actions, however, I felt that Ella was too much of a “doormat” and perhaps should have been at least a little vocal towards her “wicked” stepmother and stepsisters’ abuse toward her. To me, she came across as “too holy (perfect)” of a person. I found myself almost to the point of not wanting to finish the book because of the abusive treatment to Ella and her lack of defending herself.
I did want to finish, however, to see how the “Prince Charming” would handle the situation and was very happy and satisfied with the final actions of the book.
I do still recommend it for those who enjoy Sarah Price’s books.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books and Netgalley. I was under no obligation to post a review and have given my honest opinion
I understand the Amish concept of forgiveness to others for their actions, however, I felt that Ella was too much of a “doormat” and perhaps should have been at least a little vocal towards her “wicked” stepmother and stepsisters’ abuse toward her. To me, she came across as “too holy (perfect)” of a person. I found myself almost to the point of not wanting to finish the book because of the abusive treatment to Ella and her lack of defending herself.
I did want to finish, however, to see how the “Prince Charming” would handle the situation and was very happy and satisfied with the final actions of the book.
I do still recommend it for those who enjoy Sarah Price’s books.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kensington Books and Netgalley. I was under no obligation to post a review and have given my honest opinion
May 29, 2018
Cinderella has always been one of my favorite fairytales. The thought of how people can treat others so bad and with little disregard makes me sad and angry. In this tale, Ella is unmarried and lives at home with her parents. When her mother passes, her father seeks the companionship of another wife. However, this just brings disaster and despair for Ella. After her father's death, things within the home become unbearable. Ella however, shows more compassion than most would because she remembers her mother saying to treat others kindly. Who will get a husband in the end? Will her two evil stepsisters or will Ella be the one? You must read to find out.
I love how the characters were fleshed out in this book. Readers will be amazed at how the story so mirrors Cinderella. I cannot wait to read more with this series. I received a copy through Netgalley. This review was not required.
I love how the characters were fleshed out in this book. Readers will be amazed at how the story so mirrors Cinderella. I cannot wait to read more with this series. I received a copy through Netgalley. This review was not required.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews