Summary:
3 1/2 stars. Not a 4-star book but definitely better written than most 3-star books, which is why I'm rounding up... as well, of course, on the strength of the first book, which still has me aglow. 'Return', however, falls far short of the sheer thrills of the first installment and I wasn't surprised that the author mentions some hesitancy to having 'come back' at all after the stand-alone thrills of the first tome. This book paints humanity in some really REALLY nasty ways, so you've been warned!
Review:
While still a very well written and exciting book - this are the sum total of the positive aspects - 'Return to Q Island' falls far short of the original Q Island story in several ways. Gone are all the 'cool' and one-of-a-kind introductions to how the virus started and/or spreads, gone are a host of sympathetic characters (not all of whom met their demises in various poetically un-/just ways either), gone really was the joyous uniqueness that made 'Q Island' one of my top reads of the year. 'Return' unfortunately falls into the same trap that several zombie serials do, namely, it just focuses on how when the chips are down, humans essentially turn into total complete a-holes and self-serving scumbags. Doesn't matter if you're a drug dealer, a thug or even a preacher: chances are, you're a total jerk!
Which I guess is another way of saying there are very few characters in this book to root for if any at all. Again, something the author wrote in his epilogue surprised me in that he found the first book lacked heroes. I completely disagree as the sheer courage most of that cast showed was extremely poignant. Heck, even in the process of saving his family (well, at least those he didn't kill), I found Patrick's seemingly abrupt changes to be disappointingly brutal rather than inspiring. Yes, I know he had a few bad days but geez! In addition, bringing the new aspect of 'eusocial' characteristics into the mix was at best a bit of a yawner in terms of the paleo development or evolution if you will. And definitely not something I'd be asking a ditzy biology major to teach me...
Finally, even though I didn't really expect a 'cure' per se to materialize, I would have liked to have seen more of the external effort at play, that is, beyond just essentially turning millions of Americans into displaced war refugees. Geez, I know the current administration hates anyone not listed in Forbes Top 500, but my optimism remains intact enough to think we might rise above something like this - not only as a nation, but hopefully as a species!?! Probably not is the message here...
Oh well, we can always look back and say 'should have stopped while we were ahead'. But then again, hindsight is 20/20.