What do you think?
Rate this book
A Justifiable Madness
Can you really tell the difference between madness and sanity?
Mark Randall goes to great lengths to get himself admitted to an acute psychiatric ward and, despite being mute, convinces professionals that he is psychotic. But who is he and why is he so keen to spend time in a psychiatric hospital?
When Mark is admitted, silent and naked, the staff are suspicious about his motives.
Dealing with this, as well as the patients on the ward, Mark’s troubles really begin once he is Sectioned under the Mental Health Act. When decisions about his future are handed to Consultant Psychiatrist, Dr Giles Sharman, Mark’s life goes from bad to worse.
Drugged, abused and in danger, Mark looks for a way out of this nightmare. But he’s about to learn, proving that you are sane might not be easy as it sounds…
244 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 10, 2017
119 people are currently reading
119 people want to read
About the author
A.B. Morgan
12 books43 followersAlison Morgan lives in Bedfordshire where she was born and brought up. She worked in the county for nearly thirty years for the NHS mostly at the front line of mental health services.
Alison retired earlier than anticipated because of an unexpected health challenge which redirected her to write in order to save her own sanity. Her crime thrillers pull on many years of experience within psychiatry.
Other than that: family, friends, rugby, live music, real cider, lively conversation, laughter and more recently motorbikes (mid-life crisis).
Alison retired earlier than anticipated because of an unexpected health challenge which redirected her to write in order to save her own sanity. Her crime thrillers pull on many years of experience within psychiatry.
Other than that: family, friends, rugby, live music, real cider, lively conversation, laughter and more recently motorbikes (mid-life crisis).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
September 22, 2017
I don’t think it’s possible to read the above blurb and not be intrigued by this novel – what would possess a man to go to great lengths to get himself admitted to a psychiatric hospital and convince everyone he’s psychotic!?! I’m not going to reveal the reason why, you have to read the book to find that out for yourself but what I will say is, A Justifiable Madness is a truly entertaining read! And Morgan is clever about it, she fully pulls you into this story, has you burning to know why Mark had himself admitted, you start going through all the different scenarios in your head before she reveals the reason.
Narrated by Mark, the patient, and Monica, a nurse on the ward, A Justifiable Madness is sure to entertain. Mark, or should I say Jesus Trainman [again, you have to read it for yourself to find out what that’s all about], finds himself in much deeper water than he intended when he gets himself admitted to Pargiter Ward, where he’s placed under the care of Dr Giles Sharman. And if there’s one place you don’t want to be, it’s under the care of Dr Sharman – he’s a power hungry psychiatric consultant who abuses his power in the most shocking way! The race is on for Mark to get out of the hospital, where he has been placed under legal section, whilst still fulfilling his “mission.”
One thing we look for in crime thrillers are the characters we love to hate – those filled with pure evil, enter Dr Sharman. A Justifiable Madness also has some wonderful characters too, enter the patients, namely Welsh Phil, who becomes an ally of sorts to Mark. Mark, himself, is a very likeable character, and that reader anticipation kicks in as you begin to fear for his well-being. And Monica may just be the best nurse ever!
I believe it was the authors intention to entertain so when you read phrases such as “Hotel Bonkers” and “Nutters”, don’t take offence please – it’s all in light-hearted jest. Morgan worked in mental health services for nearly thirty years, so I’m sure she has no intention to cause offence, she just has a fun sense of humour and that humour shines through in this novel. I’m a student Mental Health Nurse and when I finished this book, I thought, phew – I’m glad this is a work of fiction, I’d hate to work under such a horrid consultant, only to read the Acknowledgements at the end of this book to see this novel was inspired by true events!
The events move at a fast-pace in this thriller, making it a quick and enjoyable read. If you love to be entertained, read A Justifiable Madness. As a debut novel, I have been thoroughly impressed and I’m looking forward to reading more from this author as she had me completely entertained by this fun and fast-paced read!
*My thanks to Bloodhound Books for providing me with a digital copy of this book*
Narrated by Mark, the patient, and Monica, a nurse on the ward, A Justifiable Madness is sure to entertain. Mark, or should I say Jesus Trainman [again, you have to read it for yourself to find out what that’s all about], finds himself in much deeper water than he intended when he gets himself admitted to Pargiter Ward, where he’s placed under the care of Dr Giles Sharman. And if there’s one place you don’t want to be, it’s under the care of Dr Sharman – he’s a power hungry psychiatric consultant who abuses his power in the most shocking way! The race is on for Mark to get out of the hospital, where he has been placed under legal section, whilst still fulfilling his “mission.”
One thing we look for in crime thrillers are the characters we love to hate – those filled with pure evil, enter Dr Sharman. A Justifiable Madness also has some wonderful characters too, enter the patients, namely Welsh Phil, who becomes an ally of sorts to Mark. Mark, himself, is a very likeable character, and that reader anticipation kicks in as you begin to fear for his well-being. And Monica may just be the best nurse ever!
I believe it was the authors intention to entertain so when you read phrases such as “Hotel Bonkers” and “Nutters”, don’t take offence please – it’s all in light-hearted jest. Morgan worked in mental health services for nearly thirty years, so I’m sure she has no intention to cause offence, she just has a fun sense of humour and that humour shines through in this novel. I’m a student Mental Health Nurse and when I finished this book, I thought, phew – I’m glad this is a work of fiction, I’d hate to work under such a horrid consultant, only to read the Acknowledgements at the end of this book to see this novel was inspired by true events!
The events move at a fast-pace in this thriller, making it a quick and enjoyable read. If you love to be entertained, read A Justifiable Madness. As a debut novel, I have been thoroughly impressed and I’m looking forward to reading more from this author as she had me completely entertained by this fun and fast-paced read!
*My thanks to Bloodhound Books for providing me with a digital copy of this book*
September 24, 2017
I finished this book very quickly as it's an interesting and engrossing read. An excellent debut from Alison Morgan.
Focusing on mental health, being sectioned and medical malpractice, you wouldn't think there'd be much humour involved, but dark humour (my favourite kind,) is used well and appears natural in the situations it's used in.
I have to give special mention to two of the main characters, for very different reasons. Dr Sharman, I'm sure, will be universally hated by readers of this book. I hope his kind of bed-side manner is the minority, and that nurses like Monica are the majority - people who actually care for and respect the patients on their wards.
I found this a thought provoking read. How many doctors care more for the payments they receive from the big pharmaceuticals then they do their patients? How many nurses would stand up for patients rights?
If you like a book that keeps you thinking about it after you've finished it, I recommend you read this one.
Focusing on mental health, being sectioned and medical malpractice, you wouldn't think there'd be much humour involved, but dark humour (my favourite kind,) is used well and appears natural in the situations it's used in.
I have to give special mention to two of the main characters, for very different reasons. Dr Sharman, I'm sure, will be universally hated by readers of this book. I hope his kind of bed-side manner is the minority, and that nurses like Monica are the majority - people who actually care for and respect the patients on their wards.
I found this a thought provoking read. How many doctors care more for the payments they receive from the big pharmaceuticals then they do their patients? How many nurses would stand up for patients rights?
If you like a book that keeps you thinking about it after you've finished it, I recommend you read this one.
September 23, 2017
i absolutely loved the description for this book and couldn’t wait to get round to actually reading it. I have to admit I’m not quite sure what I was expecting from the description but what I read was very different to what I had envisioned but believe me this was no bad thing.
Its hard to say to much about this story without giving the storyline away which I think will ruin it for others so I’m not going to go into it to much.
The reason why Mark is in there is something that won’t disappoint believe me. I have to admit it took me by surprise when I realised where the story was going and I enjoyed the journey the author took me on and the extremely satisfying ending that she delivers to us.
A Justifiable Madness is a book that will take readers by surprise and keep them hooked until the very last page. Very different from other books in its genre of which will make it stand out from the crowd. Highly recommended.
Its hard to say to much about this story without giving the storyline away which I think will ruin it for others so I’m not going to go into it to much.
The reason why Mark is in there is something that won’t disappoint believe me. I have to admit it took me by surprise when I realised where the story was going and I enjoyed the journey the author took me on and the extremely satisfying ending that she delivers to us.
A Justifiable Madness is a book that will take readers by surprise and keep them hooked until the very last page. Very different from other books in its genre of which will make it stand out from the crowd. Highly recommended.
September 22, 2017
There is even criteria to meet before you are admitted into a psychiatric hospital and for some people they have to wait months and months before they can get help. So when Mark Randall gave an outstanding performance of Jesus, while completely naked and on the busy early morning train station platform, he was soon arrested. In fact he was a dead ringer for Robert Powell when he played the part, if anyone could mange to lift theirs eyes and look him in the face. Yep The criteria had been meet, a quick fast track ticket into the nearest local establishment to help the mentally disturbed. The thing is can the part of a sane man be played as easily in order to get out?
My first thought was there some sort of initiation going on, I mean it was September and the universities would be starting back up soon, or was it a dare or prank? Only time would tell. Mark was very sane and knew exactly what he was doing and now he played mute so perhaps I thought a bet to see which ‘idiot’, using the term loosely here, could survive the longest before been detected? Due to his now mute behaviour the staff gave him a name, he was known as Jesus Trainman.
I was in my element here it was like One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest. I didn’t know which were in need of locking up the most the patients or the staff! The inmates were much wiser than the doctors where Jesus Trainman was concerned just like the old saying goes, “It takes one to know one.” This story really gave me food for thought as it is very dark and disturbing, especially with the more vulnerable members of society that don’t have a voice.
This is the debut novel of Alison Morgan and I thoroughly enjoyed it. It is a psychological thriller mixed in with some real events and gives a refreshing read from an unusual place, as it is mainly acted out behind closed, locked and bolted doors. There is an insight into the running of the place and the voice of the staff and patients. What drowns them all though is Dr. Giles Sharman.
There is some wicked humour in this book, with descriptions of Mark’s friends while the over all story really played with my mind and gave me a lot to think about. Very different and extremely well told.
My first thought was there some sort of initiation going on, I mean it was September and the universities would be starting back up soon, or was it a dare or prank? Only time would tell. Mark was very sane and knew exactly what he was doing and now he played mute so perhaps I thought a bet to see which ‘idiot’, using the term loosely here, could survive the longest before been detected? Due to his now mute behaviour the staff gave him a name, he was known as Jesus Trainman.
I was in my element here it was like One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest. I didn’t know which were in need of locking up the most the patients or the staff! The inmates were much wiser than the doctors where Jesus Trainman was concerned just like the old saying goes, “It takes one to know one.” This story really gave me food for thought as it is very dark and disturbing, especially with the more vulnerable members of society that don’t have a voice.
This is the debut novel of Alison Morgan and I thoroughly enjoyed it. It is a psychological thriller mixed in with some real events and gives a refreshing read from an unusual place, as it is mainly acted out behind closed, locked and bolted doors. There is an insight into the running of the place and the voice of the staff and patients. What drowns them all though is Dr. Giles Sharman.
There is some wicked humour in this book, with descriptions of Mark’s friends while the over all story really played with my mind and gave me a lot to think about. Very different and extremely well told.
September 23, 2017
It is 1994, a man resembling Jesus has just stepped off a train, he is naked, apart from a pair of sandals! Hours later he is admitted to a psychiatric ward and will not speak. He has achieved the first part of his plan and is exactly where he wants to be. From here on in the story weaves it,s way around the ward, the other patients and the staff.
The story is told from the viewpoint of Staff Nurse Monica and the man referred to as Jesus Trainman (he looks like Jesus, he is a man, he came off a train, it makes perfect sense). It is not until you start to get mid-way through this story that you are told the reason for his incarceration, up until this point the scene is being set, other characters are introduced and the dynamis within the ward is described. But do not for a moment think that this is a slow burner just ambling along, it isn’t, there are various things afoot in the hospital and the plot has more than warmed up by the time you start to realise what the point of the story from Jesus’s perspective is. When he is sectioned his time on the ward takes a very severe turn, and to make matters worse those in charge will not or are unable to listen to or help him, they have already made up their minds about him.
There are quite a few characters in this book, and for a little while it took me a moment to remember who was who, but it didn’t take too long for them to sink in. The characters tell of their experiences in hospital as well as how differrent members of staff are perceived by patients and other staff. Not all staff are liked.
This book seems to play on some of our worst fears, While under the care of professionals the vulnerable are supposed to be safe, in this story that is not the case, to make matters worse, some members of staff are completely powerless to have their concerns listened to. As I said at the beginning, this book is thought-provoking, and makes for a great discussion, as I found when talking to a colleague at work about the story. I had to keep reminding myself that it is set in the 1990’s and the Mental Health Act has changed a lot since then. But I am also aware that not all institutions follow protocols set as the media inform us, this adds to the a chilling aspect to the story
This is definitely a book that will appeal to readers who like Institutionalised Psychological Thriller/ Crime genres. I think it would be a great book for Reading Groups to discuss as there are various interesting concepts and themes. I was sent this book for my honest and unbiased thoughts.
The story is told from the viewpoint of Staff Nurse Monica and the man referred to as Jesus Trainman (he looks like Jesus, he is a man, he came off a train, it makes perfect sense). It is not until you start to get mid-way through this story that you are told the reason for his incarceration, up until this point the scene is being set, other characters are introduced and the dynamis within the ward is described. But do not for a moment think that this is a slow burner just ambling along, it isn’t, there are various things afoot in the hospital and the plot has more than warmed up by the time you start to realise what the point of the story from Jesus’s perspective is. When he is sectioned his time on the ward takes a very severe turn, and to make matters worse those in charge will not or are unable to listen to or help him, they have already made up their minds about him.
There are quite a few characters in this book, and for a little while it took me a moment to remember who was who, but it didn’t take too long for them to sink in. The characters tell of their experiences in hospital as well as how differrent members of staff are perceived by patients and other staff. Not all staff are liked.
This book seems to play on some of our worst fears, While under the care of professionals the vulnerable are supposed to be safe, in this story that is not the case, to make matters worse, some members of staff are completely powerless to have their concerns listened to. As I said at the beginning, this book is thought-provoking, and makes for a great discussion, as I found when talking to a colleague at work about the story. I had to keep reminding myself that it is set in the 1990’s and the Mental Health Act has changed a lot since then. But I am also aware that not all institutions follow protocols set as the media inform us, this adds to the a chilling aspect to the story
This is definitely a book that will appeal to readers who like Institutionalised Psychological Thriller/ Crime genres. I think it would be a great book for Reading Groups to discuss as there are various interesting concepts and themes. I was sent this book for my honest and unbiased thoughts.
September 21, 2017
An ordinary morning at a train station turns into some something completely different when a man appears on the platform and says he is Jesus. He looks the part too except ….. he is naked!
| Introduction |
A warm September morning sees “a sea of commuters” boarding trains to the city. Travellers, seemingly anonymous, only interested in getting to their work. When a stark-naked man steps onto the platform, the other travellers barely notice it, until he addresses a passenger and starts shouting incantations. Before the public know it, the man, Mark, is lying down on the platform and no one has a clue as to what to do. The two British Transport policemen, who happen to be present, have no other choice but to apprehend Mark (they do not know his name but we do!) and bring him to the nearest hospital where he is admitted to the psychiatric ward.
| Storyline |
It is already clear to the reader that something is seriously amiss with Mark and, on his admission to hospital, we find he has a predetermined plan. Who in their right mind would scheme to be admitted to a hospital’s psychiatric ward? We follow Mark or Jesus as the nurses call him as he looks and acts like Jesus – at least, the Jesus as portrayed by Robert Powell. The air of mystery, hanging around Mark, also arouses suspicion with the medical staff, especially Staff Nurse Monica Morris. Part of Mark’s plan is that he is to stay mute and that is not as easy as he had thought it would be because he enjoys the banter around him about his appearance. Still, we have no clue what is going on but Mark is happy to have been admitted to the psychiatric ward. Part one of his plan has succeeded. As Mark still remains mute and has not identified himself, the nurses name him ‘Jesus Trainman.’
When he finds out how living on the inside is, confined in the ward, Mark feels sad. But he will not let his ‘plan’ go to pieces. He learns to know the other patients and they seem to take a liking to him, regard him as different. Nurse Monica has a gut feeling that Mark is no ordinary patient – there is something underneath. But why does he, Jesus, not speak whereas he is able to hear perfectly, and understands what he is told? He, on the other hand, scrutinises everything, the organisation of the ward, the medication, the casual dress code of the nursing staff, in short, how such a psychiatric ward functions. Then Dr Sharman, the hospital’s Consulting Psychiatrist, diagnoses Mark and from that moment on, his luck runs out. Big time. A turning point in everything Mark wanted to achieve, even if we do not perceive what Mark’s goal is, we do know that the situation is getting dangerous.
| My Thoughts |
This is a fascinating and insightful thriller about psychiatric treatment and diagnosis. The outset of this psychological novel is based upon true events (if you want to know more, check out the review on my website and read the very last paragraph, where I have put some information – however it might give the plot away, hence the position at the bottom of the review). I was totally drawn in and took sides before I knew it! I loved the character Monica whose perceptions and opinions we learn, seeing what occurs through her eyes. It is good that the author shows us a caring nurse – as the outcome of the novel might induce discussions about the NHS which would distract from the topic of this novel.
The novel is well-written and keeps you intrigued as you have to know how this will end although I must say the last paragraph felt detracting and uncharacteristic of the book. Mark is a likeable protagonist (as are his looks!) who somehow gets trapped into his own scheme. I did feel a pang of regret that this book, as a work of fiction, does not address the outset of the true events (sorry, I have to phrase carefully) but instead, comes up with a horrible bully as Psychiatrist. It would have been interesting to read what happens if the Consulting Psychiatrist was a caring professional but then again, it was fascinating to see how the system allows them to go unchallenged. In the end, that is the author’s prerogative and I found this psychological thriller enjoyable and entertaining.
Read the review (including the very last paragraph beneath the blog tour poster, which gives important information as to the true events the book's plotline is based upon) on my website: https://www.bitsaboutbooks.net/justif...
| Introduction |
A warm September morning sees “a sea of commuters” boarding trains to the city. Travellers, seemingly anonymous, only interested in getting to their work. When a stark-naked man steps onto the platform, the other travellers barely notice it, until he addresses a passenger and starts shouting incantations. Before the public know it, the man, Mark, is lying down on the platform and no one has a clue as to what to do. The two British Transport policemen, who happen to be present, have no other choice but to apprehend Mark (they do not know his name but we do!) and bring him to the nearest hospital where he is admitted to the psychiatric ward.
| Storyline |
It is already clear to the reader that something is seriously amiss with Mark and, on his admission to hospital, we find he has a predetermined plan. Who in their right mind would scheme to be admitted to a hospital’s psychiatric ward? We follow Mark or Jesus as the nurses call him as he looks and acts like Jesus – at least, the Jesus as portrayed by Robert Powell. The air of mystery, hanging around Mark, also arouses suspicion with the medical staff, especially Staff Nurse Monica Morris. Part of Mark’s plan is that he is to stay mute and that is not as easy as he had thought it would be because he enjoys the banter around him about his appearance. Still, we have no clue what is going on but Mark is happy to have been admitted to the psychiatric ward. Part one of his plan has succeeded. As Mark still remains mute and has not identified himself, the nurses name him ‘Jesus Trainman.’
When he finds out how living on the inside is, confined in the ward, Mark feels sad. But he will not let his ‘plan’ go to pieces. He learns to know the other patients and they seem to take a liking to him, regard him as different. Nurse Monica has a gut feeling that Mark is no ordinary patient – there is something underneath. But why does he, Jesus, not speak whereas he is able to hear perfectly, and understands what he is told? He, on the other hand, scrutinises everything, the organisation of the ward, the medication, the casual dress code of the nursing staff, in short, how such a psychiatric ward functions. Then Dr Sharman, the hospital’s Consulting Psychiatrist, diagnoses Mark and from that moment on, his luck runs out. Big time. A turning point in everything Mark wanted to achieve, even if we do not perceive what Mark’s goal is, we do know that the situation is getting dangerous.
| My Thoughts |
This is a fascinating and insightful thriller about psychiatric treatment and diagnosis. The outset of this psychological novel is based upon true events (if you want to know more, check out the review on my website and read the very last paragraph, where I have put some information – however it might give the plot away, hence the position at the bottom of the review). I was totally drawn in and took sides before I knew it! I loved the character Monica whose perceptions and opinions we learn, seeing what occurs through her eyes. It is good that the author shows us a caring nurse – as the outcome of the novel might induce discussions about the NHS which would distract from the topic of this novel.
The novel is well-written and keeps you intrigued as you have to know how this will end although I must say the last paragraph felt detracting and uncharacteristic of the book. Mark is a likeable protagonist (as are his looks!) who somehow gets trapped into his own scheme. I did feel a pang of regret that this book, as a work of fiction, does not address the outset of the true events (sorry, I have to phrase carefully) but instead, comes up with a horrible bully as Psychiatrist. It would have been interesting to read what happens if the Consulting Psychiatrist was a caring professional but then again, it was fascinating to see how the system allows them to go unchallenged. In the end, that is the author’s prerogative and I found this psychological thriller enjoyable and entertaining.
Read the review (including the very last paragraph beneath the blog tour poster, which gives important information as to the true events the book's plotline is based upon) on my website: https://www.bitsaboutbooks.net/justif...
September 18, 2017
A JUSTIFIABLE MADNESS By B Morgan.
Proving you're sane is not as easy as it sounds.
Mark Randall goes to great lengths to get himself admitted to a psychiatric ward. But who is he and why is he so keen to spend time in a hospital?
A fantastic read with brilliant characters. Couldn't put it down. 5*. Bloodhound books.
Proving you're sane is not as easy as it sounds.
Mark Randall goes to great lengths to get himself admitted to a psychiatric ward. But who is he and why is he so keen to spend time in a hospital?
A fantastic read with brilliant characters. Couldn't put it down. 5*. Bloodhound books.
September 24, 2017
Review to follow soon but a very impressive debut novel
September 23, 2017
Firstly this is a very intriguing blurb. As soon as I read the blurb I couldn’t wait to read this story and I wasn’t disappointed. With the amount of books I read the blurb has to catch my attention and this certainly grabbed my attention.
When Mark, Jesus Trainman, is found naked at a train station he ends up in a psychiatric hospital after being sectioned. While reading u kept asking myself who is Mark and why did he want to be sectioned.
This is a really well written and unique storyline. As an avid blogger I crave unique storylines and I applaud the author on such a brilliant debut novel. The author gave us a great insight into what can happen in a psychiatric hospital. I certainly recommend this dark and twisted story. I’m looking forward to reading more from this author.
When Mark, Jesus Trainman, is found naked at a train station he ends up in a psychiatric hospital after being sectioned. While reading u kept asking myself who is Mark and why did he want to be sectioned.
This is a really well written and unique storyline. As an avid blogger I crave unique storylines and I applaud the author on such a brilliant debut novel. The author gave us a great insight into what can happen in a psychiatric hospital. I certainly recommend this dark and twisted story. I’m looking forward to reading more from this author.
January 15, 2018
Mentally hospitals scary
Mark, almost lost everything to get this story. Real mn are scary pts over medicated.this story was perfected. Characters were strong.scared. but did what they felt needed to be done. Great read, beginning to end.excited.
Mark, almost lost everything to get this story. Real mn are scary pts over medicated.this story was perfected. Characters were strong.scared. but did what they felt needed to be done. Great read, beginning to end.excited.
September 21, 2017
A B Morgan has written one of the best opening scenes to a book I have ever read. It drew me in and kept my curious mind needing to read on.
Mark was such a conundrum to work out, but a genuinely likeable character.
An extremely interesting insight in to the possibilities of power being in the wrong hands.
Having worked a short stint in one of my previous careers in a Hospital I found the descriptive nature of writing transporting me back there.
I found Emma and Monica's working relationship and friendship brought so much personality and credibility to the story.
With such a powerful storyline and being filled with dread for Mark, A.B.Morgan peppered it with humour making this a fantastic read, especially if like me you love "people watching" and trying to work out the human mind.
An extremely well crafted debut novel, with a storyline that I found original and powerful. With atinge of what if and sadness, I thoroughly enjoyed this read for various reasons and impressed with the style of A B Morgan's debut novel.
Mark was such a conundrum to work out, but a genuinely likeable character.
An extremely interesting insight in to the possibilities of power being in the wrong hands.
Having worked a short stint in one of my previous careers in a Hospital I found the descriptive nature of writing transporting me back there.
I found Emma and Monica's working relationship and friendship brought so much personality and credibility to the story.
With such a powerful storyline and being filled with dread for Mark, A.B.Morgan peppered it with humour making this a fantastic read, especially if like me you love "people watching" and trying to work out the human mind.
An extremely well crafted debut novel, with a storyline that I found original and powerful. With atinge of what if and sadness, I thoroughly enjoyed this read for various reasons and impressed with the style of A B Morgan's debut novel.
September 22, 2017
This is a very interesting read. A mute man naked on a railway station platform sets in motion a series of events that results in Mark being admitted to a psychiatric hospital and sectioned under the Mental Health Act. He soon finds that he has bitten off more than he can chew as he finds out it is easier to convince people you are insane than it is to prove you are sane.
This book is a very unique interpretation of the issues that surround Mental Health and the abuse that patients endure in the name of ‘treatment’. Unfortunately it is probably a pretty accurate view of what goes on in Psychiatric wards and the treatment some patients are subjected to.
I felt the characters could have had a bit more depth and while I found the book realistic in some ways there were a few parts that I am still unsure about. However, it is fiction and a very good read.
Thank you to Bloodhound Books for the advance copy.
This book is a very unique interpretation of the issues that surround Mental Health and the abuse that patients endure in the name of ‘treatment’. Unfortunately it is probably a pretty accurate view of what goes on in Psychiatric wards and the treatment some patients are subjected to.
I felt the characters could have had a bit more depth and while I found the book realistic in some ways there were a few parts that I am still unsure about. However, it is fiction and a very good read.
Thank you to Bloodhound Books for the advance copy.
September 25, 2017
A Justifiable Madness
This was different, set in a mental hospital, Jesus is admitted, and the story gets crazier. I certainly enjoyed this book, the characters were realistic, the staff were caring. Many twists and an ending that will be a total surprise. This was a fun read for a mystery. I was thoroughly entertained.
This was different, set in a mental hospital, Jesus is admitted, and the story gets crazier. I certainly enjoyed this book, the characters were realistic, the staff were caring. Many twists and an ending that will be a total surprise. This was a fun read for a mystery. I was thoroughly entertained.
February 20, 2018
OMG!
Reading the reviews on this book had me hooked and then reading about the authors background made it that more interesting. This was one of those books that really grabs your attention for all the wrong reasons, especially when there was some truth in it. This was a cleverly and well written plot about a young man, who gets admitted to a psychiatric ward with the question being how insane do you have to be to get admitted and then Sectioned. With a dedicated nurse and a pompous consultant this makes for a very harrowing and beautifully written story that makes it hard to put the book down.
Reading the reviews on this book had me hooked and then reading about the authors background made it that more interesting. This was one of those books that really grabs your attention for all the wrong reasons, especially when there was some truth in it. This was a cleverly and well written plot about a young man, who gets admitted to a psychiatric ward with the question being how insane do you have to be to get admitted and then Sectioned. With a dedicated nurse and a pompous consultant this makes for a very harrowing and beautifully written story that makes it hard to put the book down.
September 25, 2017
The description for A Justifiable Madness well and truly captured my attention, I had so many questions going into the story. With obviously the main one being - Why would anyone try to get themselves admitted into a psychiatric hospital? I have to admit to being completely curious as to where the story was going to go. To be honest it felt quite refreshing to not really have any clues as to the storyline to begin with. It meant that I could just completely wrap myself in the story from meeting Mark and his antics then being arrested and admitted to the hospital.
I enjoyed reading the story from the different perspectives, with Monica you can see she is trying to do her job and also how she can't quite figure Mark out. The conversations between Monica and Emma are lively and they added a lightness to their environment and working life. Then you have Mark and I loved his inner dialogue as he begins his time on the ward mute so you get to hear his true thoughts. He is a determined character that I couldn't help but like.
Then we are introduced to Dr Sharman and that is when events really unravel I would hate to ruin the story so no spoilers from me. I found the story subtle as in that there was tension but it was more underlying and not full on. I actually liked this pace it fit in really well with the storyline even though it isn't a highly tension filled story the pacing was brilliant and in no time at all I had reached the end. I enjoyed the clever plot and it definitely made me think about the whole subject of psychiatry from diagnosis through to the treatment. A Justifiable Madness is part thriller, drama and suspense all rolled into one making a fantastic combination.
An intriguing and different story!
With thanks to Bloodhound Books for my copy. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
I enjoyed reading the story from the different perspectives, with Monica you can see she is trying to do her job and also how she can't quite figure Mark out. The conversations between Monica and Emma are lively and they added a lightness to their environment and working life. Then you have Mark and I loved his inner dialogue as he begins his time on the ward mute so you get to hear his true thoughts. He is a determined character that I couldn't help but like.
Then we are introduced to Dr Sharman and that is when events really unravel I would hate to ruin the story so no spoilers from me. I found the story subtle as in that there was tension but it was more underlying and not full on. I actually liked this pace it fit in really well with the storyline even though it isn't a highly tension filled story the pacing was brilliant and in no time at all I had reached the end. I enjoyed the clever plot and it definitely made me think about the whole subject of psychiatry from diagnosis through to the treatment. A Justifiable Madness is part thriller, drama and suspense all rolled into one making a fantastic combination.
An intriguing and different story!
With thanks to Bloodhound Books for my copy. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
October 9, 2019
In 'A Justifiable Madness', Mark Randall is hellbent on getting admitted into a psychiatric ward as evidenced by his walking around naked in a train station. His prolonged wait pays off but he gets more than he bargained for when he is evaluated by the notorious Dr Sharman. Will he be able to escape before he loses his mind for real?
This book started off intriguing and suspenseful as there was the burning question regarding Mark's purpose. He was careful not to engage in any conversation no matter what was said to him. His admission, along with the staff's observations were interesting since it would only be a matter of time before someone figured out he was faking a mental illness.
The truth behind why he was there was well-thought-out. However, the revelation came a little too soon for my liking. It was heavy-handed due to the info dump. Furthermore, many challenges were overcome easily with little to no consequences. As a result, there was no emotional impact - no fear or worry about whether certain characters would get away with their actions.
It would have been far better if the characters had been more fleshed out instead of being flat, with their traits being told and not shown. Besides that, the writing would have benefited from fastidious editing to eliminate repetition such as Anna Brown's "beige and square" appearance. The ending was unsatisfactory, forcefully dragged out to include several unimportant characters and how .
Overall, 'A Justifiable Madness' provided an eye-opening insight into the terrors that come from abuse of power and greed in the world of psychiatry. That being said, it suffered greatly from lack of three-dimensional characters and a series of conveniences.
This book started off intriguing and suspenseful as there was the burning question regarding Mark's purpose. He was careful not to engage in any conversation no matter what was said to him. His admission, along with the staff's observations were interesting since it would only be a matter of time before someone figured out he was faking a mental illness.
The truth behind why he was there was well-thought-out. However, the revelation came a little too soon for my liking. It was heavy-handed due to the info dump. Furthermore, many challenges were overcome easily with little to no consequences. As a result, there was no emotional impact - no fear or worry about whether certain characters would get away with their actions.
It would have been far better if the characters had been more fleshed out instead of being flat, with their traits being told and not shown. Besides that, the writing would have benefited from fastidious editing to eliminate repetition such as Anna Brown's "beige and square" appearance. The ending was unsatisfactory, forcefully dragged out to include several unimportant characters and how .
Overall, 'A Justifiable Madness' provided an eye-opening insight into the terrors that come from abuse of power and greed in the world of psychiatry. That being said, it suffered greatly from lack of three-dimensional characters and a series of conveniences.
September 21, 2017
A naked man, Mark, is at a train station handing out prayers in a strange language. Of course his is going to get noticed and subsequently hauled away to the local psychiatric ward. There he refused to speak but appears to be “normal”. He understand commands and conversations around him but can’t/won’t speak. Mark has a plan and he is delighted to have been sent to the ward and things progress well. Until he is sent to the Consult Psychiatrist, Giles Sharman. Sharman is a bully and not really liked amount the staff. This is where Mark’s plan goes haywire when Sharman thinks he knows him and exactly how to “cure” him.
For a first book, Alison Morgan has written an amazing story. Jesus Trainman, aka Mark, is taken to the local psych ward and doesn’t really fit in. He seems like he has some issues yet there is something about him that leaves at least one nurse questioning him. But his plan is quickly derailed when Dr. Sharman decides to follow his own rules and treat Mark like other patients. The question is if Mark is sane or not and if he can prove it.
When I first read the description of this book I thought about Nellie Bly, I won’t spoil it but definitely read her story. So, when it was clear that Mark was up to something I had a hunch what it was about. Although it was not exactly what I was thinking, it was still really good.
This is a great story and one that I strongly recommend checking out. I will be keeping my eyes open for other books from Alison Morgan.
I received A Justifiable Madness from Bloodhound Books for free. This has in no way influenced my opinion of this book.
For a first book, Alison Morgan has written an amazing story. Jesus Trainman, aka Mark, is taken to the local psych ward and doesn’t really fit in. He seems like he has some issues yet there is something about him that leaves at least one nurse questioning him. But his plan is quickly derailed when Dr. Sharman decides to follow his own rules and treat Mark like other patients. The question is if Mark is sane or not and if he can prove it.
When I first read the description of this book I thought about Nellie Bly, I won’t spoil it but definitely read her story. So, when it was clear that Mark was up to something I had a hunch what it was about. Although it was not exactly what I was thinking, it was still really good.
This is a great story and one that I strongly recommend checking out. I will be keeping my eyes open for other books from Alison Morgan.
I received A Justifiable Madness from Bloodhound Books for free. This has in no way influenced my opinion of this book.
April 18, 2019
“Just one more chapter” type of book
Mark is at a train station, and behaving very oddly. He is taken to a psychiatric unit – just as he hoped he would be. He is obviously acting, but why does he want to be admitted to a hospital?
Told from the perspective of Mark and Nurse Monica Morris this is a thought provoking, very involving story. Why did Mark want to get into a psychiatric unit? How will the doctors treat him once he is there. How is he going to get himself out again? Although containing some very witty moments, this is a strong psychological thriller. As the book cover says “Who decides if you’re insane?”
5*s from me for this “just one more chapter before I stop reading” novel, with a plot that seems scarily plausible (indeed it was inspired by real events of the 1970s), and made me pause for thought on many occasions. Very few main characters, with plenty of action that keeps going at a good pace. Lots of “what will happen next” suspense for the reader, and writer by an author who (I understand) was previously a mental health nurse.
Perfect for Book Clubs – plenty of lively discussion material in here!
This is the second thriller I have read by this great author, the first being The Camera Lies; also rated 5*s by me.
Mark is at a train station, and behaving very oddly. He is taken to a psychiatric unit – just as he hoped he would be. He is obviously acting, but why does he want to be admitted to a hospital?
Told from the perspective of Mark and Nurse Monica Morris this is a thought provoking, very involving story. Why did Mark want to get into a psychiatric unit? How will the doctors treat him once he is there. How is he going to get himself out again? Although containing some very witty moments, this is a strong psychological thriller. As the book cover says “Who decides if you’re insane?”
5*s from me for this “just one more chapter before I stop reading” novel, with a plot that seems scarily plausible (indeed it was inspired by real events of the 1970s), and made me pause for thought on many occasions. Very few main characters, with plenty of action that keeps going at a good pace. Lots of “what will happen next” suspense for the reader, and writer by an author who (I understand) was previously a mental health nurse.
Perfect for Book Clubs – plenty of lively discussion material in here!
This is the second thriller I have read by this great author, the first being The Camera Lies; also rated 5*s by me.
September 17, 2017
A man is found at a railway station naked handing out prayers to the commuters in an unknown language. He is soon taken to the local psychiatric ward where he is sectioned and detained whilst appearing mute. One of the nurses thinks there is something more about him but can’t quite put her finger on what. One of the consultants , Dr Sharman , says he has seen the man before but won’t say anything more. The consultant is a bully to the staff and generally unliked by everyone he comes into contact with and is called “Charming Sharman” tongue in cheek. A very different story, a very unusual plot. Characters, especially Mark and Monica who come to life through the pages and you are willing for the right thing to happen. This is sensitively written in dealing with psychological issues whilst maintaining enough “what if’s” to keep the reader compelled. A very interesting premise and a highly enjoyable read.
I voluntarily chose to read this ARC and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased
I voluntarily chose to read this ARC and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased
September 22, 2017
A Dark clever twister of a read....
A busy morning at a train station ,commuters rushing about their business, families off on their travels and there on one of the platforms is a man who seems to be completely mad ..Naked, dancing about ,speaking in tongues... When he is spotted he is immediately taken to the hospital to be assessed...but he is mute ..Upon seeing the Consulting Psychiatric doctor Dr.Giles Sharman he is sectioned under the Mental health act...but is this man mad ? Only when he is in the system his nightmare begins ..drugged ..helpless and alone where can he turn to for help...There is one though a nurse Monica...who in her own way stands up and knows the difference between what is right and wrong..When the patient passes her a note one day ....one will have a secret to keep and one will have a story that will shock the world entirely.. This story will make you wander who is the madman and what goes on within the system...A dark little twister of a read...
A busy morning at a train station ,commuters rushing about their business, families off on their travels and there on one of the platforms is a man who seems to be completely mad ..Naked, dancing about ,speaking in tongues... When he is spotted he is immediately taken to the hospital to be assessed...but he is mute ..Upon seeing the Consulting Psychiatric doctor Dr.Giles Sharman he is sectioned under the Mental health act...but is this man mad ? Only when he is in the system his nightmare begins ..drugged ..helpless and alone where can he turn to for help...There is one though a nurse Monica...who in her own way stands up and knows the difference between what is right and wrong..When the patient passes her a note one day ....one will have a secret to keep and one will have a story that will shock the world entirely.. This story will make you wander who is the madman and what goes on within the system...A dark little twister of a read...
March 10, 2021
A.B.Morgan, worked for nearly thirty years for the NHS,mostly at the front line of mental health services. And what she writes has the immediacy of felt experience.
“A Justifiable Madness” is a commentary on the arbitrary decisions taken by doctors and other professionals in the mental health service.
Mark Randall succeeds in getting himself admitted to an acute psychiatric ward, although he is perfectly alright. He remains mute, and quietly observes the happenings around him. But he is in deeper than he realises, and before he realises it, he is under the care of the narcissistic Dr. Giles Sharman.
What happens next?
The book reads very well, the writing style very light, with no lags at any point.
Which is why it’s disappointing to have a dragged out ending. Psychologists say that the last statement, or image remain in one’s mind more strongly than anything that precedes it.
This was a 4 Star book, but that drawn-out conclusion pulls it down to 3.5 Stars.
“A Justifiable Madness” is a commentary on the arbitrary decisions taken by doctors and other professionals in the mental health service.
Mark Randall succeeds in getting himself admitted to an acute psychiatric ward, although he is perfectly alright. He remains mute, and quietly observes the happenings around him. But he is in deeper than he realises, and before he realises it, he is under the care of the narcissistic Dr. Giles Sharman.
What happens next?
The book reads very well, the writing style very light, with no lags at any point.
Which is why it’s disappointing to have a dragged out ending. Psychologists say that the last statement, or image remain in one’s mind more strongly than anything that precedes it.
This was a 4 Star book, but that drawn-out conclusion pulls it down to 3.5 Stars.
September 25, 2017
A very unusual concept, which is extremely well executed. The idea of how much power one consultant can have over an individual's life is very different and, as demonstrated very cleverly and capably in this book, far too easily done. The story was believable, very believable and that gave it an extra layer of fear. The plot moves along at a brisk pace and the characters are appropriately likeable, hateful or pity inducing. This is an excellent book, which everyone should read, especially those working in mental health services. Bravo AB Morgan
September 18, 2017
When I read the blurb for this book I wondered if I'd like it as it seemed a strange concept - someone getting themselves admitted to a psychiatric ward on purpose....
It doesn't take long for the reason to be explained and then you're on the edge of your seat wondering how he's going to get out of this situation.
This is a great book that will keep you gripped throughout.
Thanks to Bloodhound Books for sending me an advance copy.
It doesn't take long for the reason to be explained and then you're on the edge of your seat wondering how he's going to get out of this situation.
This is a great book that will keep you gripped throughout.
Thanks to Bloodhound Books for sending me an advance copy.
January 20, 2018
I'd had this one sitting on my kindle for ages and bumped it up the pile after another one of this author's books was recommended. Set in psychiatric ward I found the theme of the book a refreshing change. Who is the man who looks like Jesus and what is he doing in here? Is this really a reflection of what goes on in our hospitals for those with mental health issues? . Good story, well written and a satisfactory ending too.
January 27, 2018
A thoroughly good read, if you have read and enjoyed Nellie Bly's "Ten days in the Mad House" then this should appeal, my only criticism, without giving away the plot is that Monica's knowledge of the 1983 MHA appears to be lacking especially as she works in an acute setting where it would be used most, if not every day, that said it didn't detract from the gripping storyline which as several others have said keeps the reader guessing until the end.
September 24, 2017
Gripping
I read this book quite quickly and it was shocking. The characters in this book are so believable. I would encourage people to give it a go
I read this book quite quickly and it was shocking. The characters in this book are so believable. I would encourage people to give it a go
October 18, 2017
Enjoyable
This was a good book, the characters were relatable and although a bit predictable, I found it interesting and wanted to read more.
This was a good book, the characters were relatable and although a bit predictable, I found it interesting and wanted to read more.
November 18, 2017
Oh, please. Don’t bother.
November 26, 2023
This book had a really intriguing plot. I have to admit there were times when I wasn’t sure where this book was going to go. But it kept me reading, and it got really interesting, really quickly.
Read
September 24, 2017Review to follow.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews