What do you think?
Rate this book
Cowboys of Colorado #2
A Touch of Flame
USA Today bestselling author Jo Goodman returns to the gunslinging outlands of A Touch of Frost with a sizzling new romance where the new town doctor learns there's nothing she likes better than a run-in with the law.
Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse is like no physician Ben Madison has ever met—she's a woman. As the newly elected sheriff of Frost Falls, Colorado, Ben is tasked with welcoming Ridley to the community. But while Ben might be tempted by the new doc's charms, getting the town to accept a big-city, female doctor is no easy feat. To earn their trust she'll have to prove herself and Ben determines to help her...even if she's the most stubborn woman he's ever met.
When the husband of one of Ridley's patients threatens her, forbidding Ridley from treating his wife or children, all of Ben's protective instincts kick in. Ridley has come to rely on Ben's steady presence and the delicious tension that simmers just below the surface of their easy friendship—but as much as she trusts that his warnings to steer clear of Jeremiah Salt are sincere, she's never been one to back down from a challenge and she refuses to abandon her patient.
But sticking to your guns can earn you trouble in the rough terrain of the Wild West, and danger threatens Ridley from unexpected places, forcing Ben to confront his deepest fear in order to save the woman he loves.
Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse is like no physician Ben Madison has ever met—she's a woman. As the newly elected sheriff of Frost Falls, Colorado, Ben is tasked with welcoming Ridley to the community. But while Ben might be tempted by the new doc's charms, getting the town to accept a big-city, female doctor is no easy feat. To earn their trust she'll have to prove herself and Ben determines to help her...even if she's the most stubborn woman he's ever met.
When the husband of one of Ridley's patients threatens her, forbidding Ridley from treating his wife or children, all of Ben's protective instincts kick in. Ridley has come to rely on Ben's steady presence and the delicious tension that simmers just below the surface of their easy friendship—but as much as she trusts that his warnings to steer clear of Jeremiah Salt are sincere, she's never been one to back down from a challenge and she refuses to abandon her patient.
But sticking to your guns can earn you trouble in the rough terrain of the Wild West, and danger threatens Ridley from unexpected places, forcing Ben to confront his deepest fear in order to save the woman he loves.
416 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published June 5, 2018
78 people are currently reading
877 people want to read
About the author
Jo Goodman
64 books480 followersTo find characters to illustrate my first family saga, I cut out models from the Sears catalogue. I was in fourth grade, but it was a start. In seventh grade I wrote a melodrama about two orphan sisters, one of whom was pregnant. There was also a story about a runaway girl with the unlikely name of Strawberry and one about mistaken identities and an evil blind date. My supportive, but vaguely concerned parents, sighed with relief when I announced I was going to write children's books. They bought me an electric typewriter and crossed their fingers, but somehow PASSION'S BRIDE came out. No one was really surprised.
I graduated from Indiana University of Pennsylvania with a major in biology and a minor in chemistry and some notion that I would do marine research. Years of competitive swimming didn't help me anticipate seasickness. A career change seemed in order. I began working with adolescents and families, first as a childcare worker and later, after graduating from West Virginia University with a master's degree in counseling, as a therapist. I am currently the executive director of a child caring/mental health agency and find my work and my writing often compliment each other. One grounds me in reality and the other offers a break from it.
I graduated from Indiana University of Pennsylvania with a major in biology and a minor in chemistry and some notion that I would do marine research. Years of competitive swimming didn't help me anticipate seasickness. A career change seemed in order. I began working with adolescents and families, first as a childcare worker and later, after graduating from West Virginia University with a master's degree in counseling, as a therapist. I am currently the executive director of a child caring/mental health agency and find my work and my writing often compliment each other. One grounds me in reality and the other offers a break from it.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 94 reviews
January 15, 2023
A Touch of Flame is a 19-century western romance featuring a new-to-town female doctor and the new town sheriff. They are attracted to each other from the start and the romance progresses smoothly as they both face numerous problems in the community related to their professions. A few dangerous situations arise, and themes of domestic abuse and women’s plight occur; however, the descriptions remain on the tamer side of violence. I most enjoyed the snappy banter the couple swapped as the story unfolded. While the setting is historical, the steam factor is open door. The audio narrated by Laurel Lefkow was an ideal way to experience the book.
July 5, 2018
The fact that E. Ridley Woodhouse, the young doctor that’s come to replace old Dr. Dunlop, is a woman stirs up some gossip, and the town is a little slow accepting a female can be a proper doctor. Fortunately, Dr. Dunlop enlisted the town’s sheriff, Ben Madison to help Ridley in the transition. He’s well respected, and knows everyone in town, even if he’s completely frustrating at times. Like relentlessly trying to find out what exactly the “E.” in E. Ridley Woodhouse stands for, lol. And no, it’s not Eureka!
Ben didn’t know Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse was a woman, and he has no issues with that. His mother raised him to respect an intelligent woman, but boy, Ridley gets under his skin from the minute she steps off the train! In the best possible way, of course. The romance was playfully antagonistic. The teasing between them cute and funny, enough to put a smile on my face.
There’s some prejudice over having a woman doctor especially in view of the time in history, but Ridley proves herself capable and compassionate. However, treating Lily Salt leads to some trouble with Lily’s husband, Jeremiah Salt. I hated that awful man! Ridley proved herself tough and resourceful, but still, the sheer physical size difference and the fact that he was a mean bully just looking for an opportunity to get his pound of flesh set me on edge. Thankfully, Ridley has quite a few allies when it comes to this difficult and dangerous situation, Ben being the most important.
I thoroughly enjoyed the previous book, A Touch of Frost, and so I was eager to pick up the new installment. Getting a glimpse of what life what like in the late 1800’s is interesting. A life without most modern conveniences like indoor plumbing (chamber pots, eeek!) and where the only source of water is a pump in the kitchen sounds a little daunting!
A Touch of Flame is basically a stand-alone story, some of the events in the last book are recounted because Ben is first introduced there, and his history is important to his character now. But it’s not necessary to read the previous book to enjoy A Touch of Flame. I was pleased to “see” Phoebe and Remington (the couple from the previous book) again, and their cute little son, Colt here. The romance between Ben and Ridley is the heart of the story, but it a little danger and suspense makes this a story you don’t want to put down.
A copy was kindly provided by Berkley in exchange for an honest review.
This review is also posted at The Readers Den.
Ben didn’t know Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse was a woman, and he has no issues with that. His mother raised him to respect an intelligent woman, but boy, Ridley gets under his skin from the minute she steps off the train! In the best possible way, of course. The romance was playfully antagonistic. The teasing between them cute and funny, enough to put a smile on my face.
There’s some prejudice over having a woman doctor especially in view of the time in history, but Ridley proves herself capable and compassionate. However, treating Lily Salt leads to some trouble with Lily’s husband, Jeremiah Salt. I hated that awful man! Ridley proved herself tough and resourceful, but still, the sheer physical size difference and the fact that he was a mean bully just looking for an opportunity to get his pound of flesh set me on edge. Thankfully, Ridley has quite a few allies when it comes to this difficult and dangerous situation, Ben being the most important.
I thoroughly enjoyed the previous book, A Touch of Frost, and so I was eager to pick up the new installment. Getting a glimpse of what life what like in the late 1800’s is interesting. A life without most modern conveniences like indoor plumbing (chamber pots, eeek!) and where the only source of water is a pump in the kitchen sounds a little daunting!
A Touch of Flame is basically a stand-alone story, some of the events in the last book are recounted because Ben is first introduced there, and his history is important to his character now. But it’s not necessary to read the previous book to enjoy A Touch of Flame. I was pleased to “see” Phoebe and Remington (the couple from the previous book) again, and their cute little son, Colt here. The romance between Ben and Ridley is the heart of the story, but it a little danger and suspense makes this a story you don’t want to put down.
A copy was kindly provided by Berkley in exchange for an honest review.
This review is also posted at The Readers Den.
December 9, 2024
An enjoyable romance about Ridley, a female doctor, who struggles to be accepted by the community of the small town she settles in, due to her gender as a doctor. From the first time Ridley meets the sanguine and likeable red-headed Ben, the sheriff, there is a genuine attraction. These two really like each other, as well as feeling a sexual attraction. The banter between them is funny, well-written and enjoyable to read.
Although there is a strong secondary plot about Lily Salt and her family difficulties, it doesn't detract from Ben and Ridley's story. I like that their romance proceeds without any silly miscommunication or other clumsy plot devices. They simply slowly fall in love with each other and end up with a lovely HEA.
There are some dramatic events that occur in the book, and a few unpleasant characters, but overall it's a warm and affectionate depiction of life in a small Western town in the late nineteenth century. Ben in particular is an appealing hero. Nicely done, and an enjoyable read.
Lily Salt's happy-ever-after is told in the sequel to this book, A Touch of Forever. Unfortunately for me, without realising it, I read that one first. IMO it is better to read this book before A Touch of Forever, as there some spoilers. Oh well. I still enjoyed both books.
This book was my September 2022 Romance Across The Ages challenge read - 'Americana'.
Reread for December 2024 Historical Romance Book Club BOTM - 'Americana'
Although there is a strong secondary plot about Lily Salt and her family difficulties, it doesn't detract from Ben and Ridley's story. I like that their romance proceeds without any silly miscommunication or other clumsy plot devices. They simply slowly fall in love with each other and end up with a lovely HEA.
There are some dramatic events that occur in the book, and a few unpleasant characters, but overall it's a warm and affectionate depiction of life in a small Western town in the late nineteenth century. Ben in particular is an appealing hero. Nicely done, and an enjoyable read.
Lily Salt's happy-ever-after is told in the sequel to this book, A Touch of Forever. Unfortunately for me, without realising it, I read that one first. IMO it is better to read this book before A Touch of Forever, as there some spoilers. Oh well. I still enjoyed both books.
This book was my September 2022 Romance Across The Ages challenge read - 'Americana'.
Reread for December 2024 Historical Romance Book Club BOTM - 'Americana'
June 15, 2018
I don't know how historically accurate this story is, but I loved it all the same!
The love story was unexpectedly simple: there's no courting, no angst!
What I found less believable was the fact that they had sex before actually haing fallen in love! It was a reaction to a powerful attraction! Very modern IMHO!
Still the story is lovely and I loved their banter! They say the most surprising things to each other!
Worth reading!
The love story was unexpectedly simple: there's no courting, no angst!
What I found less believable was the fact that they had sex before actually haing fallen in love! It was a reaction to a powerful attraction! Very modern IMHO!
Still the story is lovely and I loved their banter! They say the most surprising things to each other!
Worth reading!
September 27, 2025
4/5; 4 stars; A-
I really enjoy Jo Goodman's wry humour for her characters as well as the way she depicts life in a small town in the wild west. Ben was a character who showed up in the first book in the series and it was interesting to get to know him better. The doctor was a surprise to him and the town but she wormed her way into the fabric of their lives made a place for herself.
The pacing of the book is like her other ones, no heart pounding action, just a bit of mystery, a light touch of angst, a smidge of danger, and a happy ending.
I really enjoy Jo Goodman's wry humour for her characters as well as the way she depicts life in a small town in the wild west. Ben was a character who showed up in the first book in the series and it was interesting to get to know him better. The doctor was a surprise to him and the town but she wormed her way into the fabric of their lives made a place for herself.
The pacing of the book is like her other ones, no heart pounding action, just a bit of mystery, a light touch of angst, a smidge of danger, and a happy ending.
July 15, 2018
Despite a charming hero in Ben the Sheriff and a quirky town full of intriguing health issues with a skilled doctor ready to address them all, I found this book pretty slow and uninspiring. The romance, especially the early stages of it, lacked spark, and until Ridley and Ben suddenly decide to kiss half way through the book, I would have been hard pressed to label this book a romance at all.
I think in this book Goodman's predilection for dialogue-heavy writing proved to be a problem for the romance itself. The banter takes off immediately as Ridley and Ben meet at the local train station when she arrives as the new town doctor. I quickly found the banter tiring. We learn so little from it except that these two wordsmiths are handy with zingers. Also of note, the couple's banter style is appropriated by all of the other characters in the book, leaving me to think that this town is full of linguistic artists ready to wield similar rapid-fire dialogue full of irony and sarcasm. I wondered at times if an audio recording of the book could help differentiate the cacophony of voices here competing in put downs and comebacks. There is also a complete absence of internal thoughts for either Ridley or Ben during the first half, leaving me searching for clues that a romance was afoot at all. I did think it was interesting that both characters decide to hop into bed just because they wanted to, and there is a much-delayed discussion of things like commitment or love. In this respect the romance feels very modern, and though I don't mind that aspect of it per se, I'm not entirely sure it feels very authentic in this particular historical setting. The sex is protection-free too, which is a bit of a headscratcher, especially given the fact that the heroine is a physician. Surely if there is a female character fully aware of the consequences of unprotected sex, it's Ridley.
Ridley is a woman doctor at a time when women's access to higher education, especially medical school, was extremely restricted. I like the way Goodman handles this issue and unlike the romance, there is much more development of Ridley's negotiation of sexism from her patients. She has to earn everyone's respect for her intelligence and training and skills and overcome negative perspectives, and she does a fine job here. I enjoyed the look into small town life and the realistic ailments people encounter in their daily lives. This part of the story is slow moving but entertaining in its own way. There is also a dangerous villain in the book who is a bit more prosaic than past Goodman villains. That actually works well in this book though which really centers on daily life in a small town, and the town wife-beater is a realistic threat to his family's life as well as to the harmony of town life. It has a curious resolution that felt very Goodman-esque.
The second half of the book picks up and there are some funny moments between Ridley and Ben as they move toward a committed relationship. But the romance is not a memorable one and I'm unlikely to recall much about this book in the long run, except that it took me far too long to read the dang thing.
I think in this book Goodman's predilection for dialogue-heavy writing proved to be a problem for the romance itself. The banter takes off immediately as Ridley and Ben meet at the local train station when she arrives as the new town doctor. I quickly found the banter tiring. We learn so little from it except that these two wordsmiths are handy with zingers. Also of note, the couple's banter style is appropriated by all of the other characters in the book, leaving me to think that this town is full of linguistic artists ready to wield similar rapid-fire dialogue full of irony and sarcasm. I wondered at times if an audio recording of the book could help differentiate the cacophony of voices here competing in put downs and comebacks. There is also a complete absence of internal thoughts for either Ridley or Ben during the first half, leaving me searching for clues that a romance was afoot at all. I did think it was interesting that both characters decide to hop into bed just because they wanted to, and there is a much-delayed discussion of things like commitment or love. In this respect the romance feels very modern, and though I don't mind that aspect of it per se, I'm not entirely sure it feels very authentic in this particular historical setting. The sex is protection-free too, which is a bit of a headscratcher, especially given the fact that the heroine is a physician. Surely if there is a female character fully aware of the consequences of unprotected sex, it's Ridley.
Ridley is a woman doctor at a time when women's access to higher education, especially medical school, was extremely restricted. I like the way Goodman handles this issue and unlike the romance, there is much more development of Ridley's negotiation of sexism from her patients. She has to earn everyone's respect for her intelligence and training and skills and overcome negative perspectives, and she does a fine job here. I enjoyed the look into small town life and the realistic ailments people encounter in their daily lives. This part of the story is slow moving but entertaining in its own way. There is also a dangerous villain in the book who is a bit more prosaic than past Goodman villains. That actually works well in this book though which really centers on daily life in a small town, and the town wife-beater is a realistic threat to his family's life as well as to the harmony of town life. It has a curious resolution that felt very Goodman-esque.
The second half of the book picks up and there are some funny moments between Ridley and Ben as they move toward a committed relationship. But the romance is not a memorable one and I'm unlikely to recall much about this book in the long run, except that it took me far too long to read the dang thing.
May 23, 2020
A new doctor is in town and the townsfolk are not going to like it. Ridley Woodhouse has a mammoth challenge ahead of her, taking over from a beloved male physician and dealing with the prejudices against her gender as well as being a newcomer. Sheriff Ben Madison has been assigned by the old doc to ease Ridley's introduction to the community. As usual, he approaches the task like he approaches most everything else - unhurried and with good humour. However, Ridley soon realises that his jovial nature masks a thoughtful and steely man not to be messed with.
Jo Goodman writes with such a deft touch, that this book is like a balm after the chafing discomforts of enduring the inferior, incongruous stories of others. Her characters are so complete; each arch of the brow, each strand of hair, each minute gesture, each word uttered have their place in the story. The coherence and consistency is so impressive that few can equal her. Unfortunately, she often has a problem with the pacing of the plot. Like in so many of her other books, the protagonists get together half way through after which the spotlight turns to solving the subplot crisis involving other townsfolk (the heroine of the next book). The bantering between the lead is cute. Goodman writes excellent dialogues but there's very little romantic tension in this book. She does tackle domestic violence admirably and realistically, documenting the difficulties for women in the pre-suffrage era, before it occurred to many women that they do have a voice let along rights. Goodman's language gives effortless impression of being historically authentic and so are the wonderful details of the setting. Medical conditions and treatments were well researched but I was bothered a bit by Ridley's failure to adhere to patient confidentiality. All in all solid and entertaining reading, and the next book promises more heart and perhaps some angst.
“You are being deliberately obtuse.”
“You’re giving me too much credit. There’s folks who will tell you I can be obtuse without even trying.”
He simply grinned at her in that maddening way of his and rolled over her objections by never addressing them at all. He never really argued so he never lost an argument. It was frustrating and just a little unnerving.
The fact that he suspected she was lonely made her feel vulnerable and vaguely out of sorts with him. She did not appreciate the way he sifted through her thoughts as though he were panning for gold, and she especially did not appreciate when he showed her a nugget.
Jo Goodman writes with such a deft touch, that this book is like a balm after the chafing discomforts of enduring the inferior, incongruous stories of others. Her characters are so complete; each arch of the brow, each strand of hair, each minute gesture, each word uttered have their place in the story. The coherence and consistency is so impressive that few can equal her. Unfortunately, she often has a problem with the pacing of the plot. Like in so many of her other books, the protagonists get together half way through after which the spotlight turns to solving the subplot crisis involving other townsfolk (the heroine of the next book). The bantering between the lead is cute. Goodman writes excellent dialogues but there's very little romantic tension in this book. She does tackle domestic violence admirably and realistically, documenting the difficulties for women in the pre-suffrage era, before it occurred to many women that they do have a voice let along rights. Goodman's language gives effortless impression of being historically authentic and so are the wonderful details of the setting. Medical conditions and treatments were well researched but I was bothered a bit by Ridley's failure to adhere to patient confidentiality. All in all solid and entertaining reading, and the next book promises more heart and perhaps some angst.
“You are being deliberately obtuse.”
“You’re giving me too much credit. There’s folks who will tell you I can be obtuse without even trying.”
He simply grinned at her in that maddening way of his and rolled over her objections by never addressing them at all. He never really argued so he never lost an argument. It was frustrating and just a little unnerving.
The fact that he suspected she was lonely made her feel vulnerable and vaguely out of sorts with him. She did not appreciate the way he sifted through her thoughts as though he were panning for gold, and she especially did not appreciate when he showed her a nugget.
December 11, 2023
4.5 stars. A bit slow to start with, but Ms Goodman sure knows how to write characters you can root for. Ben is simply the bee's knee, and Ridley complements him. The side characters are well drawn too.
June 4, 2018
I loved this book. It's not the fastest paced, or the sexiest but it completely worked for me. Our hero is Ben Madison, who is the newly elected sheriff of Frost Falls, Colorado. Taking place in 1898, Ben is the most easy-going, never-to-get-riled hero I've read. That doesn't mean he is stupid or doesn't care, he just likes to observe and play along real nice with the folks, to keep everyone peaceful and happy. He puts the bad guys in jail and truly cares about his townspeople. He check in on the elderly and those who are ailing. He has a very dry wit about him - so when he says something, you never know if he is being serious. I absolutely adored him.
Our heroine is the brand new doctor in town. After her godfather went back to Boston to retire, she takes over and the town isn't really on board with a female doctor. Ben takes it upon himself to show Ridley around town, and to show his public support of her, in hopes to ease the transition to a female doctor. I liked Ridley a lot too. Very mature, doesn't go into her new job with grand expectations, since she knows being a woman is never easy in a professional field. She is patient and kind and gets so frustrated with Ben and his easy-going nature. Ben lives right next door to Ridley, and they form a friendship and a close bond before any romance occurs. Like I mentioned, this isn't the sexiest book, but their romance unfolded at just the right pace for me.
We meet a lot of the townsfolk, as we learn their different ailments and their feelings about Ridley. There is one prominent story line that involves spousal abuse. The town's blacksmith, Jeremiah, beats his wife, Lily, after he drinks too much. Ben knows this, Ridley learns of this, and pretty much the whole town knows, but what can be done? Ben will put Jeremiah in jail for a few nights, so Lily has a day or two to heal, but she won't leave so Ben can't do much more. This is definitely a darker story line and takes up a lot of pages. I think it's handled with a lot of care and done really well.
Grade: B+
Our heroine is the brand new doctor in town. After her godfather went back to Boston to retire, she takes over and the town isn't really on board with a female doctor. Ben takes it upon himself to show Ridley around town, and to show his public support of her, in hopes to ease the transition to a female doctor. I liked Ridley a lot too. Very mature, doesn't go into her new job with grand expectations, since she knows being a woman is never easy in a professional field. She is patient and kind and gets so frustrated with Ben and his easy-going nature. Ben lives right next door to Ridley, and they form a friendship and a close bond before any romance occurs. Like I mentioned, this isn't the sexiest book, but their romance unfolded at just the right pace for me.
We meet a lot of the townsfolk, as we learn their different ailments and their feelings about Ridley. There is one prominent story line that involves spousal abuse. The town's blacksmith, Jeremiah, beats his wife, Lily, after he drinks too much. Ben knows this, Ridley learns of this, and pretty much the whole town knows, but what can be done? Ben will put Jeremiah in jail for a few nights, so Lily has a day or two to heal, but she won't leave so Ben can't do much more. This is definitely a darker story line and takes up a lot of pages. I think it's handled with a lot of care and done really well.
Grade: B+
May 22, 2018
3.5 stars
Ben and Ridley’s relationship seemed doomed from the start. Both testing waters and pushing buttons made the chemistry spark from the moment she stepped off the train. Both being guarded about personal history they become quickly push differences aside to help a friend. Ben and Ridley relationship never started on the path that so many did in historical romances; they became lovers before they ever really courted. Ben and Ridley always carried a hope for marriage and a settled future. The secondary characters added the hope for a change in laws, anger at the abuse taking place, laughter at Ellies antics with Ben and joy for Phoebe and Remington. I did enjoy reading A Touch of Flame, it made me smile and hope throughout the novel that each character would receive their happily-ever-after. I’ve read Ms. Goodmans work before and enjoyed it all, A Touch of Flame is probably the one that I didn’t feel sucked into as much as others, but I still felt the pull to finish it and see what happened between Ben and Ridley.
April 24, 2022
Romance in the old west…
It didn’t take long for E. Ridley Woodhouse and Ben Madison to begin their romantic dance. I read this series a bit out of order. That was okay though. This is the second in the series, and while knowing Ben’s back story would have added to the story, it worked well as a standalone.
Ridley was the new doctor and no one was more surprised that she was a woman, than Ben. There was resistance from the town, providing much of the drama that followed, but Ben was there to support her, tease her, and fall in love… Ridley was up for any and all challenges and was a modern woman who knew her own mind. Pushing the era’s social norms, I loved how they interacted with each other, and their family and neighbours. This was not a typical love story – are they ever? – and was even better for it…
This author always provides a host of characters and situations that liven things up. Once again, she put it all together in a sweet, and sometimes forward thinking, love story. Don’t be put off by the slow-ish start, you will be glad you hung on! ~Diane, 4 stars
It didn’t take long for E. Ridley Woodhouse and Ben Madison to begin their romantic dance. I read this series a bit out of order. That was okay though. This is the second in the series, and while knowing Ben’s back story would have added to the story, it worked well as a standalone.
Ridley was the new doctor and no one was more surprised that she was a woman, than Ben. There was resistance from the town, providing much of the drama that followed, but Ben was there to support her, tease her, and fall in love… Ridley was up for any and all challenges and was a modern woman who knew her own mind. Pushing the era’s social norms, I loved how they interacted with each other, and their family and neighbours. This was not a typical love story – are they ever? – and was even better for it…
This author always provides a host of characters and situations that liven things up. Once again, she put it all together in a sweet, and sometimes forward thinking, love story. Don’t be put off by the slow-ish start, you will be glad you hung on! ~Diane, 4 stars
abandoned
September 2, 2018Blah, it's always hit and miss with Goodman. I got so bored I forgot it was on my kindle until the library told me they took it back.
September 24, 2019
This wasn't as good as her last read, a bit too slow but I still enjoyed it. The heroine is a doctor, and the hero is the town good guy.
August 6, 2018
I was bored out of my mind! I had forgotten everything from the first book where Ben's mom Ellie was the villain, but when Phoebe and Remington showed up it all came back to me. And I thought this set of characters was a little incredulous. The book was just awful, I found the villain to be so cliche, it seems there is always a drunken wife beater in westerns and the end of that plot line was predictable and has been done a thousand times. I didn't buy the romance and the idea of a female doctor in that era and environment would have had a lot more opposition than the author portrayed. Jo Goodman has written some incredible characters in difficult situations with tremendous compassion and creativity, but this isn't one of them.
May 7, 2018
Anyone that reads a particular genre is likely aware how similar novels can become; that familiarity is a big draw in genre fiction because the reader knows what to expect. I read A LOT of historical romances - they're fun, character-driven, and I love the historical setting. What I like about Jo Goodman's western historicals is that they often come across as something unique in a genre that is characterized by specific tropes. Those same tropes are evident in Goodman's novels, but her writing is subtle and often relies on the reader to puzzle certain things out. I love the fact that Goodman doesn't spell everything out to her readers, and A Touch of Flame is no different.
A Touch of Flame is set in 1898, Colorado. E. Ridley Woodhouse is the new doctor in the town of Frost Falls. Ben Madison is the newly elected sheriff who has been charged to take Dr. Woodhouse under his wing. Ben does not count on this doctor being a woman. For her part, Ridley very much counts on Ben and their entire population of Frost Falls having some doubt of her medical ability - this is something that she is used to. Luckily, Ben is kind of an unusual character and throws all of Ridley's expectations right out the window.
This is the second historical romance that I've read in the last couple of months to feature a enterprising female doctor, and there is no doubt that A Touch of Flame offers a compelling story of a young woman facing adversity in her chosen profession. What I liked about Ridley's character here, is that the author didn't have to tell readers' all about Ridley's background and her commitment to the profession. Instead Goodman shows readers this information in her characterization of Ridley. The choice to communicate information to readers in subtle ways, like Ridley's competence and knowledge, is a great deal more effective than simply being told that Ridley is a smart and capable doctor. This inclination to show through actions in the narrative rather than to state information to the reader is what appeals to me so much in Goodman's writing. And personally, I thought A Touch of Flame to be the best Goodman novel that I have read to date. The characters of Ben and Ridley were so compelling and their considered and slow-progressing romance was more realistic than many of the developing relationships that populate romanclandia.
The plot to A Touch of Flame is mostly derived from the internal conflict on the part of Ridley and Ben. While there are other aspects that direct Ridley and Ben's attention outside of their relationship, those elements ultimately are subdued and drive the romance between these two characters whether it be in developing their individual characters or the pair of them as a couple.
And lastly, I also have to admit to having also appreciated the fact that A Touch of Flame was lighter than the most recent books by the author. That's not to say that the character's don't face the reality of life, but I did feel that the characters and their backstories were lighter and less tragic than the characters, most specifically the heroines, of the previous books by Goodman. The less traumatic backstory for Ridley, and to a lesser extent, Ben, was also helped by the unusual courtship between these two. Ben's bizarre sense of humour was fantastic and, as always, I appreciated that Goodman creates a romance lead that's not dominating and overpowering.
An excellent historical romance by Goodman. Those who read Mary Balogh's historicals will very much appreciate Goodman's subtle style of writing.
*Review copy provided by the publisher via NetGalley.
A Touch of Flame is set in 1898, Colorado. E. Ridley Woodhouse is the new doctor in the town of Frost Falls. Ben Madison is the newly elected sheriff who has been charged to take Dr. Woodhouse under his wing. Ben does not count on this doctor being a woman. For her part, Ridley very much counts on Ben and their entire population of Frost Falls having some doubt of her medical ability - this is something that she is used to. Luckily, Ben is kind of an unusual character and throws all of Ridley's expectations right out the window.
This is the second historical romance that I've read in the last couple of months to feature a enterprising female doctor, and there is no doubt that A Touch of Flame offers a compelling story of a young woman facing adversity in her chosen profession. What I liked about Ridley's character here, is that the author didn't have to tell readers' all about Ridley's background and her commitment to the profession. Instead Goodman shows readers this information in her characterization of Ridley. The choice to communicate information to readers in subtle ways, like Ridley's competence and knowledge, is a great deal more effective than simply being told that Ridley is a smart and capable doctor. This inclination to show through actions in the narrative rather than to state information to the reader is what appeals to me so much in Goodman's writing. And personally, I thought A Touch of Flame to be the best Goodman novel that I have read to date. The characters of Ben and Ridley were so compelling and their considered and slow-progressing romance was more realistic than many of the developing relationships that populate romanclandia.
The plot to A Touch of Flame is mostly derived from the internal conflict on the part of Ridley and Ben. While there are other aspects that direct Ridley and Ben's attention outside of their relationship, those elements ultimately are subdued and drive the romance between these two characters whether it be in developing their individual characters or the pair of them as a couple.
And lastly, I also have to admit to having also appreciated the fact that A Touch of Flame was lighter than the most recent books by the author. That's not to say that the character's don't face the reality of life, but I did feel that the characters and their backstories were lighter and less tragic than the characters, most specifically the heroines, of the previous books by Goodman. The less traumatic backstory for Ridley, and to a lesser extent, Ben, was also helped by the unusual courtship between these two. Ben's bizarre sense of humour was fantastic and, as always, I appreciated that Goodman creates a romance lead that's not dominating and overpowering.
An excellent historical romance by Goodman. Those who read Mary Balogh's historicals will very much appreciate Goodman's subtle style of writing.
*Review copy provided by the publisher via NetGalley.
June 11, 2018
Loved Ben and E. as a couple and there were a lot of funny moments, but a true reflection of how a women's right to speak out against a husband's abuse. Although this can be read as a stand alone, I would read Remington's story just so you can get the background of Ellie (Ben's mom).
September 26, 2019
Jo Goodman never disappoints. This series is one of my favorites and Ben's story was one of her best. Goodman delivers a romance that is, at times, toe curling and at the same time tackles some issues that arise to this day. You can read it for the fabulous romantic tale or look at those deeper issues.
June 11, 2018
Not as good as JG's other books. Just meh.
March 31, 2021
Enjoyable read about a small town sheriff and the new female doctor.
I appreciated the dark edge to the story, the realistic portrayal of domestic violence and the family who survive it.
I appreciated the dark edge to the story, the realistic portrayal of domestic violence and the family who survive it.
September 18, 2019
Really good. I like the atmospheric setting, the concentration on world-building and character development outside the romance plot. Goodman's novels are more subtle than many, and that's something I appreciate.
June 13, 2018
It’s been a very long time since I read a Western romance and Jo Goodman was a new author for me, but I’d heard good things and so...
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Ben’s sly humor and Ridley’s slow realization of it really made this book. It’s right there from the very first scene and never lets up. The banter never feels forced or overdone but is perfectly appropriate to their characters and oh so dry.
The competence displayed by both of them as they go about their business is another highlight. They do their jobs well without being flashy about it and that’s just perfect for the time and place. The 1890s were a time when women were moving into professional careers and the story treats it seriously but not sensationally.
This is as much a story about a community as a relationship and I’m glad this book was a little longer than the norm for the genre and took the time to let all the relationships and events breathe. It’s the second in a series and there’s some carry over from the first book but it’s not necessary to have read it to enjoy this one.
I’m gonna go read it right now though.
And I’ll be coming back to Jo Goodman.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Ben’s sly humor and Ridley’s slow realization of it really made this book. It’s right there from the very first scene and never lets up. The banter never feels forced or overdone but is perfectly appropriate to their characters and oh so dry.
The competence displayed by both of them as they go about their business is another highlight. They do their jobs well without being flashy about it and that’s just perfect for the time and place. The 1890s were a time when women were moving into professional careers and the story treats it seriously but not sensationally.
This is as much a story about a community as a relationship and I’m glad this book was a little longer than the norm for the genre and took the time to let all the relationships and events breathe. It’s the second in a series and there’s some carry over from the first book but it’s not necessary to have read it to enjoy this one.
I’m gonna go read it right now though.
And I’ll be coming back to Jo Goodman.
July 16, 2019
Much of the romantic tension in Harlequin romances of the 1970s and 80s stems from the fact that readers are allowed access into the minds of only one of their books' two romantic leads. Authors show us what their female protagonists think, feel, and desire, but the thoughts, feelings, and desires of their male leads remain hidden, a mystery. Readers, like the heroine herself, are put into a state of suspense, looking for clues about the hero's goals and motivations but never really certain of them until the story's climax, when the hero declares his love. Only after the hero had given voice to previously private, secret feelings can readers, and the heroine, be certain they really know what is inside his head and heart.
Much contemporary romance fiction takes a different tack...
See full review at:
http://romancenovelsforfeminists.blog...
Much contemporary romance fiction takes a different tack...
See full review at:
http://romancenovelsforfeminists.blog...
May 19, 2024
A wonderful story with a small town setting, Colorado, 1898, and a great cast of characters. A newly arrived female doctor, Ridley has come to Frost and is met by the sheriff, Ben when she arrives. It takes awhile for folks to get used to having a woman for their doctor as Ben paves the way for her.
The story is a slow burn romance but at times it’s overshadowed by what’s going on in town… who’s getting jailed, local saloon happenings, ladies gossip, the alcoholic blacksmith who abuses his wife etc. The banter between Ridley and Ben is really good… zingers fly frequently. However, there’s not a lot of their internal thoughts and the passion for the most part feels lukewarm. At last there’s a nice warm and fuzzy HEA.
The story is a slow burn romance but at times it’s overshadowed by what’s going on in town… who’s getting jailed, local saloon happenings, ladies gossip, the alcoholic blacksmith who abuses his wife etc. The banter between Ridley and Ben is really good… zingers fly frequently. However, there’s not a lot of their internal thoughts and the passion for the most part feels lukewarm. At last there’s a nice warm and fuzzy HEA.
November 28, 2022
Ben is the sheriff of this Western town. Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse is the town's new doctor, and to most peoples' consternation, she's a woman. Ben is determined to help her despite her not wanting his aid, especially since she tends to ruffle feathers.
The romance is stronger in this story than in the first book of the series, but the story is interesting too.
The romance is stronger in this story than in the first book of the series, but the story is interesting too.
July 6, 2018
See the full review at HarlequinJunkie.com
A Touch of Flame had all of the rapid fire dialogue, lovable characters, and rich details that I’ve come to expect out of Jo Goodman’s wonderful writing. Set in the small community of Frost Falls, Colorado, I adored the unlikely romance between their new female physician and the town’s mischievous sheriff.
Over the past few years, Jo Goodman has become one of my go-to authors for Western historical romances. There’s just SO much to love about her work. From the carefully crafted characters to the lively conversations and the plots that include a bit of mystery and/or action, I know I’m pretty much guaranteed a great time. I will admit that I was concerned when I started this book, though, after reading about our hero Ben in book one. He didn’t quite handle things too well. Read More
A Touch of Flame had all of the rapid fire dialogue, lovable characters, and rich details that I’ve come to expect out of Jo Goodman’s wonderful writing. Set in the small community of Frost Falls, Colorado, I adored the unlikely romance between their new female physician and the town’s mischievous sheriff.
Over the past few years, Jo Goodman has become one of my go-to authors for Western historical romances. There’s just SO much to love about her work. From the carefully crafted characters to the lively conversations and the plots that include a bit of mystery and/or action, I know I’m pretty much guaranteed a great time. I will admit that I was concerned when I started this book, though, after reading about our hero Ben in book one. He didn’t quite handle things too well. Read More
May 10, 2019
Jo Goodman’s Touch of Flame is a entertaining read. This novel is actually second in a series but the author does a good job of making it a standalone. Excellent character and plot development. Goodman also gives a glimpse of early attitudes toward women in the medical field. I will read more from this author. I was chosen to read an advance copy of this book as part of Penguin's First to Read program. However, the opinions expressed in this review are 100% mine and mine alone.
July 22, 2018
Exactly what I expect from Jo Goodman, which is a good thing.
September 19, 2020
https://openbooksociety.com/article/a...
A Touch Of Flame
The Cowboys of Colorado, Book #2
By Jo Goodman
ISBN13: 9780399584299
Author Website: jogoodman(.)com
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer jerjen
Synopsis:
USA Today bestselling author Jo Goodman returns to the gunslinging outlands of A Touch of Frost with a sizzling new romance where the new town doctor learns there’s nothing she likes better than a run-in with the law.
Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse is like no physician Ben Madison has ever met—she’s a woman. As the newly elected sheriff of Frost Falls, Colorado, Ben is tasked with welcoming Ridley to the community. But while Ben might be tempted by the new doc’s charms, getting the town to accept a big-city, female doctor is no easy feat. To earn their trust she’ll have to prove herself and Ben determines to help her…even if she’s the most stubborn woman he’s ever met.
When the husband of one of Ridley’s patients threatens her, forbidding Ridley from treating his wife or children, all of Ben’s protective instincts kick in. Ridley has come to rely on Ben’s steady presence and the delicious tension that simmers just below the surface of their easy friendship—but as much as she trusts that his warnings to steer clear of Jeremiah Salt are sincere, she’s never been one to back down from a challenge and she refuses to abandon her patient.
But sticking to your guns can earn you trouble in the rough terrain of the Wild West, and danger threatens Ridley from unexpected places, forcing Ben to confront his deepest fear in order to save the woman he loves. (Goodreads)
Review:
When Ben agrees to help get the new doctor get settled in, he figures it will be easy, a piece of cake. That is until he meets the doctor and finds out that the he is a she. He does know how the fine folks of Frost Falls, Colorado, will react, but he is pretty sure will not be all sunshine and roses. But he will do the best he can to make the transition as easy as possible.
Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse is definitely a woman, and she accepted the position of being the new doctor for Frost Falls. She knows it will not be easy, but she feels she is up to the challenge. She does not know what to make of Ben, he appears to be in her corner but he cannot make people accept her. She not only has to be a good doctor, she also has to figure out a way to be accepted. That is a tall order.
The characters are well rounded and well developed. I really enjoyed getting to know Ridley and Ben. They are both great people and want to help others. I really liked the way they bickered, that was quite funny. I enjoyed getting to know Ben’s mother and Mr. Butterworth, they added a lot to add to the story. Ridley and Ben had a lot of work to do to keep the people of Frost Falls safe and healthy and they did a great job.
I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a well crafted women’s contemporary book. I have to read the first book in this series.
*OBS would like to thank the publisher for supplying a free copy of this title in exchange for an honest review*
A Touch Of Flame
The Cowboys of Colorado, Book #2
By Jo Goodman
ISBN13: 9780399584299
Author Website: jogoodman(.)com
Brought to you by OBS Reviewer jerjen
Synopsis:
USA Today bestselling author Jo Goodman returns to the gunslinging outlands of A Touch of Frost with a sizzling new romance where the new town doctor learns there’s nothing she likes better than a run-in with the law.
Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse is like no physician Ben Madison has ever met—she’s a woman. As the newly elected sheriff of Frost Falls, Colorado, Ben is tasked with welcoming Ridley to the community. But while Ben might be tempted by the new doc’s charms, getting the town to accept a big-city, female doctor is no easy feat. To earn their trust she’ll have to prove herself and Ben determines to help her…even if she’s the most stubborn woman he’s ever met.
When the husband of one of Ridley’s patients threatens her, forbidding Ridley from treating his wife or children, all of Ben’s protective instincts kick in. Ridley has come to rely on Ben’s steady presence and the delicious tension that simmers just below the surface of their easy friendship—but as much as she trusts that his warnings to steer clear of Jeremiah Salt are sincere, she’s never been one to back down from a challenge and she refuses to abandon her patient.
But sticking to your guns can earn you trouble in the rough terrain of the Wild West, and danger threatens Ridley from unexpected places, forcing Ben to confront his deepest fear in order to save the woman he loves. (Goodreads)
Review:
When Ben agrees to help get the new doctor get settled in, he figures it will be easy, a piece of cake. That is until he meets the doctor and finds out that the he is a she. He does know how the fine folks of Frost Falls, Colorado, will react, but he is pretty sure will not be all sunshine and roses. But he will do the best he can to make the transition as easy as possible.
Dr. E. Ridley Woodhouse is definitely a woman, and she accepted the position of being the new doctor for Frost Falls. She knows it will not be easy, but she feels she is up to the challenge. She does not know what to make of Ben, he appears to be in her corner but he cannot make people accept her. She not only has to be a good doctor, she also has to figure out a way to be accepted. That is a tall order.
The characters are well rounded and well developed. I really enjoyed getting to know Ridley and Ben. They are both great people and want to help others. I really liked the way they bickered, that was quite funny. I enjoyed getting to know Ben’s mother and Mr. Butterworth, they added a lot to add to the story. Ridley and Ben had a lot of work to do to keep the people of Frost Falls safe and healthy and they did a great job.
I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a well crafted women’s contemporary book. I have to read the first book in this series.
*OBS would like to thank the publisher for supplying a free copy of this title in exchange for an honest review*
June 7, 2018
A Touch of Flame by Jo Goodman is the 2nd book in her Cowboys of Colorado series. This is a western historical romance that I really enjoyed, especially with the couple being so likable
Dr. Ridley Woodhouse, our heroine, arrives in Frost Falls, Colorado to take over as the new doctor in town. When Ben Madison, our hero and the town Sheriff, meets Ridley at the train station, he is surprised that the new doctor is a woman. Ben is also very aware that the town will not accept Ridley easily, and that she had her work cut out to prove herself.
At first Ridley was somewhat cold to Ben, but in time that will change. Ridley pushes herself to help those in need, proving to them that she can do the job, with word of mouth slowly alerting people that she is very capable. The long road ahead will find Ridley also in the middle of a family suffering abuse by the drunken husband, with Ben having to step in to protect Ridley.
What follows is a sweet slow build romance between Ben, who quickly begins to fall for Ridley, which also starts warming her up from the strict cold start. They were so great together, as the romance was fun, humorous and their chemistry was sensual. It was also enjoyable to get to know many of the town’s people, and how Ridley besides doctoring them, quietly manages to help some of them with their own personal issues. The main focus beside Ben and Ridley, and the town residents, was the abusive drunk, who would beat his wife, with the scared children going to Ben or Ridley for help. He was becoming too dangerous, and Ben would not let Ridley go to their house alone. This did create a lot of tension and danger into the mix of this wonderful romance, and town. It was nice to see Phoebe and Remington (first book heroes) again, and after Ridley helps Phoebe deliver her baby, the woman in town begin to open their arms to accept Ridley.
I did love Ridley, who was a strong & independent young lady, and in time, as her romance with Ben heated up, was a fun heroine. I also adored the handsome Ben, who a wonderful hero, great sheriff and perfect for Ridley & Frost Falls. There also was two major things that happened in the town that brought about danger and sadness, which touched on our heart.
Jo Goodman did an excellent job in creating a wonderful couple in Ben and Ridley, and a story which had a lot of humorous banter, tragedy and an enjoyable romance. If you enjoy romance, a western and historical background, with a fun sexy couple, then you should read A Touch of Flame.
Barb
The Reading Cafe
Dr. Ridley Woodhouse, our heroine, arrives in Frost Falls, Colorado to take over as the new doctor in town. When Ben Madison, our hero and the town Sheriff, meets Ridley at the train station, he is surprised that the new doctor is a woman. Ben is also very aware that the town will not accept Ridley easily, and that she had her work cut out to prove herself.
At first Ridley was somewhat cold to Ben, but in time that will change. Ridley pushes herself to help those in need, proving to them that she can do the job, with word of mouth slowly alerting people that she is very capable. The long road ahead will find Ridley also in the middle of a family suffering abuse by the drunken husband, with Ben having to step in to protect Ridley.
What follows is a sweet slow build romance between Ben, who quickly begins to fall for Ridley, which also starts warming her up from the strict cold start. They were so great together, as the romance was fun, humorous and their chemistry was sensual. It was also enjoyable to get to know many of the town’s people, and how Ridley besides doctoring them, quietly manages to help some of them with their own personal issues. The main focus beside Ben and Ridley, and the town residents, was the abusive drunk, who would beat his wife, with the scared children going to Ben or Ridley for help. He was becoming too dangerous, and Ben would not let Ridley go to their house alone. This did create a lot of tension and danger into the mix of this wonderful romance, and town. It was nice to see Phoebe and Remington (first book heroes) again, and after Ridley helps Phoebe deliver her baby, the woman in town begin to open their arms to accept Ridley.
I did love Ridley, who was a strong & independent young lady, and in time, as her romance with Ben heated up, was a fun heroine. I also adored the handsome Ben, who a wonderful hero, great sheriff and perfect for Ridley & Frost Falls. There also was two major things that happened in the town that brought about danger and sadness, which touched on our heart.
Jo Goodman did an excellent job in creating a wonderful couple in Ben and Ridley, and a story which had a lot of humorous banter, tragedy and an enjoyable romance. If you enjoy romance, a western and historical background, with a fun sexy couple, then you should read A Touch of Flame.
Barb
The Reading Cafe
January 20, 2019
I really enjoyed this book. It makes me want to go back and re-read more Jo Goodmans, and I’ve already been on a bit of a glom of hers in the last few months.
Ridley is the new doctor in town and sheriff Ben is helping her get settled and introduced to the townspeople. Their romance was quite gentle and realistic, we watch them become friends through working together in the town of Frost Falls. Ben is liked by everyone and Ridley is a little stiff and has a more difficult time getting to know people and appreciates his help working her way into the life of the town. I appreciated Ben’s sense of humor and how he protected and cared for all of the people in the town. Ridley’s competence and struggles as the new female doctor were described well. In contrast to a few other reviewers, I enjoyed the plotting in this book, a wife beater is the type of evil one might have regularly come in contact with at the time as opposed to some cartoon bad guy, so I found that refreshing.
I will agree with a few others that the first few amorous encounters begin kind of abruptly- I was convinced by that point that they were attracted to each other (even though neither said or thought it much prior to that we’re told about) however, the way they began was a bit odd.
And I also questioned how anyone is engaging in all of this pre-wedding intercourse with little thought of pregnancy, especially a doctor (or how they could do it that often without protection and not conceive, I mean, sure, it’s possible, but not likely).
Based on her history of not paying attention to men or considering marriage you could tell that just the fact that Ridley wanted to marry Ben was proof of her love. Ben doesn’t have that kind of background, and I would’ve appreciated a few more of his thoughts to get a sense of his love for Ridley. He jokes a lot and really doesn’t ever say too much about his love, but his actions did show it.
Yet despite these quibbles I really enjoyed the friends to lovers romance between these two. And I did like that Ben was a joker. I think my favorite part was that this was a rare book where the hero and heroine were not at odds for most of the book and we get to observe them as a couple working together (even though they’re not an official couple for much of it). I am firmly convinced of their HEA and I like that.
Ridley is the new doctor in town and sheriff Ben is helping her get settled and introduced to the townspeople. Their romance was quite gentle and realistic, we watch them become friends through working together in the town of Frost Falls. Ben is liked by everyone and Ridley is a little stiff and has a more difficult time getting to know people and appreciates his help working her way into the life of the town. I appreciated Ben’s sense of humor and how he protected and cared for all of the people in the town. Ridley’s competence and struggles as the new female doctor were described well. In contrast to a few other reviewers, I enjoyed the plotting in this book, a wife beater is the type of evil one might have regularly come in contact with at the time as opposed to some cartoon bad guy, so I found that refreshing.
I will agree with a few others that the first few amorous encounters begin kind of abruptly- I was convinced by that point that they were attracted to each other (even though neither said or thought it much prior to that we’re told about) however, the way they began was a bit odd.
And I also questioned how anyone is engaging in all of this pre-wedding intercourse with little thought of pregnancy, especially a doctor (or how they could do it that often without protection and not conceive, I mean, sure, it’s possible, but not likely).
Based on her history of not paying attention to men or considering marriage you could tell that just the fact that Ridley wanted to marry Ben was proof of her love. Ben doesn’t have that kind of background, and I would’ve appreciated a few more of his thoughts to get a sense of his love for Ridley. He jokes a lot and really doesn’t ever say too much about his love, but his actions did show it.
Yet despite these quibbles I really enjoyed the friends to lovers romance between these two. And I did like that Ben was a joker. I think my favorite part was that this was a rare book where the hero and heroine were not at odds for most of the book and we get to observe them as a couple working together (even though they’re not an official couple for much of it). I am firmly convinced of their HEA and I like that.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 94 reviews