Although I have certainly found the general concept of Alison Walsh’s A Literary Tea Party: Blends and Treats for Alice, Bilbo, Dorothy, Jo, and Book Lovers Everywhere appealing and also rather nicely literature based (with ample direct quotes from the novels on which the author’s recipes are based), as to the actual tea party recipes themselves, truth be told, but I have personally not at all been impressed. For while many of them do appear visually tempting as to the end products (and that I do appreciate the inclusion of photographs for the vast majority of Walsh’s recipes), considering that MOST of the novels featured in A Literary Tea Party: Blends and Treats for Alice, Bilbo, Dorothy, Jo, and Book Lovers Everywhere are children’s books, are novels written and conceptualised for younger readers, that far far too many of Alison Walsh’s included recipes involve both complicated lists of ingredients and equally thus instructions, well, I for one do think that this kind of makes A Literary Tea Party: Blends and Treats for Alice, Bilbo, Dorothy, Jo, and Book Lovers Everywhere not really all that suitable for having children try their hands at cooking (or even helping out) and indeed, even adult cooks, especially if not so confident in the kitchen, could or perhaps even would find many of Alison Walsh’s recipes complicated and as such likely also frustrating to reproduce.
And yes, this is also the main reason why I am only going to be rating A Literary Tea Party: Blends and Treats for Alice, Bilbo, Dorothy, Jo, and Book Lovers Everywhere with but two stars (since truthfully, except for perhaps the raspberry cordial recipe based on L.M. Montgomery’ Anne of Green Gables most of the other featured recipes look either not all that appealing taste wise to and for me or like I need to be a master chef in order to even attempt them).
EDITED TO ADD: But after just checking on the raspberry cordial recipe, Alison Walsh actually and to my dismay and anger claims that Anne of Gables was written not by Lucy Maud Montgomery but by Frances Hodgson Burnett (who penned The Secret Garden). And NO INDEED, I cannot and will not accept that kind of a literary mistake and have therefore just lowered (and with no feelings of guilt whatsoever at that) my star ranking for A Literary Tea Party: Blends and Treats for Alice, Bilbo, Jo, and Book Lovers Everywhere from two to only one star (as no, these kinds of errors really should not happen, and honestly, where was the editor to not have caught this, especially since in the bibliography, Anne of Green Gables is in fact listed with the correct author, as having been written by L.M. Montgomery, so indeed and from where I stand, that mistake should really have been noticed and changed).