What do you think?
Rate this book
A Witch P.I. Mystery #23
Witch Is Why Promises Were Broken
There’s no time like… It’s at times like this that you find out who your friends are. If Jill is to prevail, she will need all her friends and a big helping of luck. …custard cream time.
248 pages, Kindle Edition
First published December 1, 2017
1467 people are currently reading
376 people want to read
About the author
Adele Abbott
74 books591 followersAdele Abbott's world is full of mystery, magic and a whole lot of crazy. Come join in the fun.
Web site: http://www.AdeleAbbott.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AdeleAbbottA...
Web site: http://www.AdeleAbbott.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AdeleAbbottA...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews
January 21, 2020
An extraordinarily entertaining supernatural cozy mystery series
Entertaining supernatural cozy mystery series. Outstanding cast of characters with a very entertaining storyline. Young woman who is a private investigator train by her adopted father takes over the business with her father passes away. Soon after she find her biological mother and meet her as she is dying in the hospital. Something happens between them and the next thing she knows she finds out she is actually a witch. She soon finds out that she also has family in the supernatural world a grandmother and aunt into cousins. They live in a supernatural town that can only be visited by people who are of supernatural persuasion. She soon starts to straddle both worlds visiting her family there as well as her adoptive sister and her family in the human world. She continues on in her private investigation service in the real world while beginning to take on cases in the supernatural world as well. Follow along as she solves multiple cases in each book. On occasion she will also interact with the reader with a snarky quip or comment. Extraordinarily entertaining and a fun read. Check it out
Entertaining supernatural cozy mystery series. Outstanding cast of characters with a very entertaining storyline. Young woman who is a private investigator train by her adopted father takes over the business with her father passes away. Soon after she find her biological mother and meet her as she is dying in the hospital. Something happens between them and the next thing she knows she finds out she is actually a witch. She soon finds out that she also has family in the supernatural world a grandmother and aunt into cousins. They live in a supernatural town that can only be visited by people who are of supernatural persuasion. She soon starts to straddle both worlds visiting her family there as well as her adoptive sister and her family in the human world. She continues on in her private investigation service in the real world while beginning to take on cases in the supernatural world as well. Follow along as she solves multiple cases in each book. On occasion she will also interact with the reader with a snarky quip or comment. Extraordinarily entertaining and a fun read. Check it out
June 12, 2022
Another murder and a guy has disappeared. One of the people in the local police force is out. There's a ballroom competition and Winky is involved in gambling. A new local police person comes in and seems to hate Jill right off.
A friend moves away, a troll needs help, there's some gargoyles, a couple of witchfinders, another murder and two pregnancies. Her grandmother cheats yet again.
It's obvious that Jill has a lot to deal with. What Winky is doing seems to be pretty unrealistic (actually, almost anything he does is pretty unrealistic.) Her grandmother yet again demonstrates her lack of ethics. As is said, with great power comes great responsibility and, at least in my opinion, part of that responsibility involves being ethical, understanding and helpful. None of those traits fit her grandmother.
A friend moves away, a troll needs help, there's some gargoyles, a couple of witchfinders, another murder and two pregnancies. Her grandmother cheats yet again.
It's obvious that Jill has a lot to deal with. What Winky is doing seems to be pretty unrealistic (actually, almost anything he does is pretty unrealistic.) Her grandmother yet again demonstrates her lack of ethics. As is said, with great power comes great responsibility and, at least in my opinion, part of that responsibility involves being ethical, understanding and helpful. None of those traits fit her grandmother.
May 7, 2018
Two minds.
The books are still well written and the last couple have gotten interesting again, but I am in two minds as to wether I actually LIKE Jill Gooder. Her lying constantly is ridiculous, her treatment of her sister and Jack is abysmal (although, maybe she takes after her father in that regard). The way the entire mess of cases comes together each time however is magical. While all the plains in the series are interesting it is Ghost Town that truly terrifies me. What if the afterlife is truly just another work to survive(?) existence with no way out?
The books are still well written and the last couple have gotten interesting again, but I am in two minds as to wether I actually LIKE Jill Gooder. Her lying constantly is ridiculous, her treatment of her sister and Jack is abysmal (although, maybe she takes after her father in that regard). The way the entire mess of cases comes together each time however is magical. While all the plains in the series are interesting it is Ghost Town that truly terrifies me. What if the afterlife is truly just another work to survive(?) existence with no way out?
December 11, 2017
Witch is Why Promises Were Broken (Book 23) Review
Well Adele, another entertaining story! Your imagination is very good and unique. I have enjoyed reading your stories very much and look forward to the next book in the series. I highly recommend reading Adele's stories to anyone interested in reading cleverly written funny and stories. Thanks for the entertainment!
Well Adele, another entertaining story! Your imagination is very good and unique. I have enjoyed reading your stories very much and look forward to the next book in the series. I highly recommend reading Adele's stories to anyone interested in reading cleverly written funny and stories. Thanks for the entertainment!
December 2, 2017
A busy Jill
I definitely like these better since Jill has been busier--she usually has several cases and a little work to put in on one of the backstories. At any rate a fun romp with Jill was just what the doctor ordered.
I definitely like these better since Jill has been busier--she usually has several cases and a little work to put in on one of the backstories. At any rate a fun romp with Jill was just what the doctor ordered.
December 4, 2017
Good short read
It's a good short read but since it's book 24 guess you would say I'm hooked. It's like a serial and short so you can finish in a few hrs. Would be best to start with the first book it is a continuing story.
It's a good short read but since it's book 24 guess you would say I'm hooked. It's like a serial and short so you can finish in a few hrs. Would be best to start with the first book it is a continuing story.
December 4, 2017
Everettes R Us
Grandma is a cheat, but we already knew that. Jill is in trouble, but we knew that too. They now have a pretty sloth, but Jack doesn't know. And I definitely don't trust the new neighbors! None of them!
Grandma is a cheat, but we already knew that. Jill is in trouble, but we knew that too. They now have a pretty sloth, but Jack doesn't know. And I definitely don't trust the new neighbors! None of them!
August 13, 2019
Very entertaining
I love the ending. It made me laugh. Sorry, no cliffhanger this time. A very good book, though. Lots of development in Jill’s life. I really enjoyed reading about some of the things she faces personally. Plus, all the antics of the rest of the characters.
I love the ending. It made me laugh. Sorry, no cliffhanger this time. A very good book, though. Lots of development in Jill’s life. I really enjoyed reading about some of the things she faces personally. Plus, all the antics of the rest of the characters.
March 1, 2020
Witch Is Why Promises Were Broken (A Witch P.I.Mystery Book 23)
This was a good book how ever I do wish the author had done more to make it more interesting.I look forward to reading more of this author's work.
This was a good book how ever I do wish the author had done more to make it more interesting.I look forward to reading more of this author's work.
July 11, 2020
Wonderful read!
Absolutely wonderful characters that interact with each other beautiful! Fabulous plot twists and turns that will keep you on the edge of your seat. I highly recommend this series.
Absolutely wonderful characters that interact with each other beautiful! Fabulous plot twists and turns that will keep you on the edge of your seat. I highly recommend this series.
June 22, 2021
Another fun read.
Don't know how she does it, but Jill has the knack of solving almost every mystery that comes her way. I say almost because there are still some that she has yet to solve. Add her family and pets, there is never a dull moment.
Don't know how she does it, but Jill has the knack of solving almost every mystery that comes her way. I say almost because there are still some that she has yet to solve. Add her family and pets, there is never a dull moment.
June 10, 2022
Loads of Fun to Read
This book is a light read filled with fun and mystery. Very enjoyable as Jill continues her search for the people in the locket, Gargoyles, and Winky’s captor.
This book is a light read filled with fun and mystery. Very enjoyable as Jill continues her search for the people in the locket, Gargoyles, and Winky’s captor.
December 11, 2017
Potato chip book - don't bother thinking, but it's amusing. Lots of puns, plot points are seriously transparent, and you don't even have to guess what's going to happen.
December 26, 2017
I've read the entire Witch PI series so far. I find them to be a quick read, and very amusing. I'll keep reading until Ms. Abbott decides the story is finished!
December 22, 2017
Fun Seriesa
Once again, Jill solves the case. Looking forward to the next book in the series. What will Grandma come up with next?
Once again, Jill solves the case. Looking forward to the next book in the series. What will Grandma come up with next?
December 30, 2017
Another entertaining read
These are really excellent for the distracted mom who needs entertainment. I’ve read all of them so far and plan to keep reading this author.
These are really excellent for the distracted mom who needs entertainment. I’ve read all of them so far and plan to keep reading this author.
February 9, 2018
Promises were broken.
Promises were broken had a lot of mysteries for our PI witch to solve. She did a great job of making it fun. Can't wait for the next one to come out.
Promises were broken had a lot of mysteries for our PI witch to solve. She did a great job of making it fun. Can't wait for the next one to come out.
March 14, 2018
Winky and Kathy are assholes.
April 4, 2018
Dancing with the Devil
Another busy time for Jill, with cases in GT, Candlefield and the human world. Plus, Winky is gambling and new information comes to light.
Another busy time for Jill, with cases in GT, Candlefield and the human world. Plus, Winky is gambling and new information comes to light.
June 9, 2018
Just love Jill
I love the interactions with Jill and Jack, along with her sister Kathy. Really enjoy the ghostly parents still reach out to her.
I love the interactions with Jill and Jack, along with her sister Kathy. Really enjoy the ghostly parents still reach out to her.
December 16, 2018
Loved it.
January 6, 2019
The ending shocked me and made me emotional which I did not expect as usually these are funny light reads
January 20, 2019
I love Adele Abbott’s books. Easy and relaxing reads, comfortable characters, very imaginative and fun!
October 29, 2019
The secrets are getting even more intriguing. Love this series and can't wait for the final one in the Witch is Why and get to the Witch is How final group of 12? May be more, but we will see.
February 18, 2020
Fun read. Enjoying the series!
March 8, 2020
Who is Jill really?
Murder. Mayhem and gambling....... Jill has her hands full with new neighbors dead red heads and three deaths on a train
Murder. Mayhem and gambling....... Jill has her hands full with new neighbors dead red heads and three deaths on a train
April 23, 2020
Suspense and humor
I find Jill Holders sense of humor refreshingly childlike. She handles situations professionally and with little magic. She balances her world's with finess.
I find Jill Holders sense of humor refreshingly childlike. She handles situations professionally and with little magic. She balances her world's with finess.
July 14, 2020
Another one done
August 25, 2020
A witchy story!
Great story! Lots of fun!! One of my favorite authors! Always look forward to the next story by the author!!
Great story! Lots of fun!! One of my favorite authors! Always look forward to the next story by the author!!
February 6, 2021
Pedro bowley
Another good read and they are getting better everytime I read each story she writes good 👍 for you adele
Another good read and they are getting better everytime I read each story she writes good 👍 for you adele
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews