Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Atlas Catesby #2

Murder in Bloomsbury

Rate this book
Acclaimed author D. M. Quincy is back with a second captivating mystery as adventurer Atlas Catesby must put aside his own feelings for Lady Lilliana as they work together to get justice for someone she holds dear.Aristocratic adventurer Atlas Catesby has spent the last year trying to forget Lady Lilliana Warwick, but when she reappears in his life imploring him to help her solve a murder, Atlas feels compelled to say yes.The ner’re-do-well brother of Lilliana’s maid died of arsenic poisoning. Authorities are ruling his death an accident, but his sister suspects he was murdered. As Atlas and Lilliana investigate, they discover that the victim had a mysterious lover—a high-born lady he threatened with scandal after she spurned him. When they finally uncover her shocking true identity, the case blows wide open and it turns out there is a whole string of women who had reason to kill the handsome charmer. Now, as Atlas fights his growing feelings for Lilliana, they must work together to catch the assassin before the killer gets to them first.Perfect for fans of Charles Finch and C. S. Harris, Murder in Bloomsbury is the magnificent second Atlas Catesby mystery.

304 pages, Kindle Edition

First published February 13, 2018

119 people are currently reading
953 people want to read

About the author

D.M. Quincy

3 books253 followers
D.M. Quincy is an award-winning television journalist who has covered dozens of crimes, including violent unsolved murders that stayed with her for years afterwards.

She’s pretty sure that had something to do with her decision to write her own stories in which a brilliant amateur detective always gets the bad guy (or girl), thus making sure that justice is always served.

As a US Foreign Service brat, D.M. spent most of her childhood roaming the world, which is probably why the protagonist in her Atlas Catesby mystery series travels to far-flung places as often as he can.

When she isn’t hunched over her laptop researching ways for her villains to kill people, D.M. reads, spends time with her family, devours foreign television mystery series on Netflix, and plots her next travel adventure.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
350 (32%)
4 stars
494 (46%)
3 stars
207 (19%)
2 stars
15 (1%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews
Profile Image for Phrynne.
4,035 reviews2,725 followers
July 20, 2020
A Regency mystery which combines two of my favourite genres. Three if you count it as a Cosy as well! Obviously this book was written with readers like me in mind.

I enjoyed book two every bit as much as I did book one. Atlas Catesby is an excellent character and more of a gentleman than most of his so called superiors. His relationship with Lilliana is fun, on again, off again and finishing the book with a great finale!

I was very slow guessing the solution to the mystery. Maybe I spent too much time cheering on the almost lovers and not enough looking for clues. I enjoyed the historical facts too and learned quite a bit about arsenic and its many supposed uses at the time.

A series I will certainly apply myself to reading. I really want to know what happens next!
Profile Image for Empress Reece (Hooked on Books).
915 reviews82 followers
October 9, 2019
Just as good as the first! I figured out the mystery again but I still thoroughly enjoyed the story. I've grown attached to the characters already. I loved the ending- I've been waiting two books for that ending. lol ... Men are oblivious sometimes-sorry guys : )

Profile Image for ❀⊱RoryReads⊰❀.
815 reviews182 followers
December 6, 2024
3 Stars

Adventurer Atlas Catesby is, in his own words, barely a gentleman. The year before this story takes place he was involved in solving a murder and the lady he assisted then, Lady Lilliana, has once again requested his help. The brother of Lady Lilliana's maid has been poisoned and although the authorities have declared it to be an accidental death, the dead man's sister is convinced he was murdered. Atlas doesn't really want to get involved, but he's madly in love with Lady Lilliana and the chance to spend time with her again is too tempting.

The late Georgina/Regency period of British history is my favorite and this book is smack dab in the middle of it. The thwarted romance between Atlas and Lilliana adds interest to this mystery, which, to be honest, was easy to figure out well before the book was over. I've read dozens and dozens of Regency romances and historical fiction novels and this one stands out because the quality of the writing. The author knows how to construct a sentence and set a scene, making reading a pleasure. For me, the characters and writing are what keep me coming back to a mystery series and D.M. Quincy does a great job with both.
Profile Image for Barbara Rogers.
1,754 reviews207 followers
February 12, 2018
Series: Atlas Catesby #2
Publication Date: 2/13/18

Excellent! What a great read. Well written, well plotted, interesting and well developed main characters – and a very believable plot. Actually, the plot is based on a very real case that took place in Scotland in about the same time period. I’m loving this series and highly recommend that you read the first book in the series before this one. You don’t have to, you can begin with this one, but the first one is great and shows the development of the relationships between many of the main characters. I read this book from beginning to end – in one sitting. I just couldn’t put it down. I say that as I sit here bleary-eyed – with toothpicks holding my eyes open. One thing I do have to say though – for some reason, this book (and the first) often made me think of the Victorian era rather than the Regency.

Atlas Catesby is, by his own description and thinking, not quite a gentleman. That isn’t meant to describe his behavior – because, in that, he is every inch a gentleman – even a bit of a prig. No, it means that he is more on the edge of society – the fourth child of a baron – no title and only a modest fortune. Imagine his dismay when he found himself very much in love with the sister of a very powerful duke in the last book. He knew nothing could come of the relationship, so being the traveler and adventurer he is, he left on a voyage. This book begins nine months after the last book ended and Atlas has just returned from Jamaica.

Atlas is rudely awakened by his valet, Jamie, after a night where he’d gotten very, very drunk. That is something he just doesn’t do – but it was a night filled with things he just doesn’t do. The valet excitedly tells him that there is a liveried servant with an urgent message. Atlas groans, but when Jamie tells him that the livery is black and gold, he quickly goes on alert because he recognizes it as the Duke of Somerville’s livery – Lilliana’s brother. Panic – something must have happened to Lilliana.

Thus began an intriguing mystery. It turns out that Lilliana’s maid, Tracy, doesn’t believe her brother died naturally. She’s convinced that he was murdered and is very distraught. The authorities have ruled it an accident, but the maid is sure that isn’t the case. Atlas can’t pass up any puzzle – and he also can’t pass up the opportunity to spend more time with Lilliana, so he takes on the task of investigating.

As Atlas and Lilliana discover more and more about the deceased, they can definitely believe that he might have been murdered – and there are suspects aplenty. What a nasty, nasty man he was. He ruined so many young lives and tried to keep ruining them even after death. What an interesting case filled with twists and turns and some nasty people. The solution isn’t as simple as it appears to be and Atlas is puzzled almost to the very end.

While the investigation is continuing, Atlas is struggling with his feelings for Lilliana. He has long known that he loves her and was even going to offer for her until he found she was the sister of a Duke (book 1). He left after that because he knew he wasn’t good enough for her – she deserved better than him – someone of title and fortune. Now, she’s being courted by a Marquess. Can Atlas walk away a second time? Will Atlas turn away and find another love? You won’t know until the last page.

The returning characters are great and I thoroughly enjoyed getting to visit with them again – Jamie, of course, because it is great to see how he’s changed and grown. Then, the Earl of Charlton is always a delightful character. Watching his infatuation with Atlas’ sister, Thea, is endearing and funny – and her reactions to him are priceless. Then, there is a new character, Atlas’ nephew, who makes an appearance and it will be interesting to watch and see what happens with him. You just know there is going to be quite a story there!

Just one question her though -- why do authors sometimes get hung up on characters with similar names? I hate to try to keep them straight. In this book, we have Lavinia and Lilliana. Why couldn't Lavinia be Barbara (a perfectly acceptable Regency name) or Mary or . . . Well -- just something else.

I highly recommend the book, the author, and the series!

Please check out my reviews at:
Blog: https://flippinpages.blog/
Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/flippinpages...
Twitter: https://twitter.com/FlippinPagesRev
Twitter: https://twitter.com/BarbBookReview

"I requested and received this e-book at no cost to me and volunteered to read it; my review is my honest opinion and given without any influence by the author or publisher."
Profile Image for Merry.
881 reviews291 followers
March 25, 2021
I devoured this book. I enjoy the characters and the twists and turns of the characters. Since this is the 2nd book of the series the characters were already familiar to me and I enjoyed that its not insta love. The book is more mystery than romance but loves true course is moving along. I already have book 3 ready to read.
Profile Image for Lorraine.
1,161 reviews87 followers
June 3, 2022
Georgian England. Nine months later (after the Murder in Mayfair). D. M. Quincy’s Murder in Bloomsbury (Atlas Catesby, #2) continues Atlas Catesby’s role of investigator. Atlas returns to London after spending nine months adventuring and attempting to totally forget Lilliana when he is awaken by Jamie, his valet, who explains that Atlas has a note that has been delivered by someone in ‘black and gold’ livery. Atlas is now AWAKE! The Duke of Somerville! His sister - Lady Roslyn Lilliana Sterling! So much for forgetting Lilliana! So starts Atlas’ second investigation with Lilliana/Lady Roslyn Lilliana Sterling. Lilliana’s lady’s maid is trying to comprehend the accidental death of her brother. Tacy, Lilliana’s lady’s maid, believes that her brother was murdered. Lilliana asks Atlas if he will investigate with her. Here we go again! Characters from the previous investigation are charmingly back, and new ones appear. All are trying to discover if the arsenic found in Tracy’s brother’s stomach was truly self-administered accidentally. Atlas interviews and observes many. Intriguing and cleverly written. (I definitely have a crush on Atlas.) “Witty dialogue”. Loved it! 5 stars.
Profile Image for Bev.
3,270 reviews348 followers
December 2, 2023
Please know that while this review will not contain spoilers about the mystery itself, those who have not read the first of the Atlas Catesby series will have part of the overarching story spoiled if they view the spoiler section. There is some mystery surrounding both Atlas and the woman he rescues in the first book. We don't learn until the end who she is. This review assumes you have already found this out.

********************



As the investigation proceeds, they find that Gordon Davis was not as charming as Lillianna's maid believed. He has left a trail of broken hearts, irate fathers, and jealous lovers behind him as well as men he maneuvered into the clutches of gaming dens. There's no shortage of people who might have wanted the handsome wastrel dead--but who had access to arsenic as well as the opportunity to give it to Davis? And can they find out in time to prevent another death?

This second novel is even better than the first (and I enjoyed that a great deal). Atlas and the recurring cast are terrific and it is interesting to watch the relationships grow. I enjoyed the parts that Lillianna and Atlas's friend Charlton played in the investigation. If Charlton's not careful, he's going to let his brains outshine his dandy persona. Each of them play a vital role in uncovering clues to what really happened in the poisoning of Davis. There has also been a slight movement in the mystery surrounding Atlas's earlier life and I anticipate that book three will see more development in that area. Hopefully, with his growing abilities as an investigator, he will be able to lay that mystery to rest--with a happy result.

The murder itself is loosely based on a famous poisoning case and those familiar with true crime of the era may recognize the trappings--but be warned Quincy puts her own spin on the story with good result. Another good historical mystery for those who appreciate the Regency period as well as good plotting.

First posted on my blog My Reader's Block.
Profile Image for Kris.
977 reviews12 followers
January 12, 2018
I had so much fun with this book. This is a well written murder mystery set in regency London with compelling characters and a slowburning romance. That is a lot of my boxes ticked.

I found both Atlas Catesby and Lady Lilliana very likeable and I enjoyed all the other characters that appeared involved in the murder case. I also loved Lord Charlton and Atlas’ sister Thea and their interactions.

Although I have not yet read the first book Murder in Mayfair, after reading this one I fully intend to. Murder in Bloomsbury does work as a standalone, even if background information, such as the history between Catesby and Lilliana, is only hinted at. It only served to make me more curious to read the first book.

The resolution of the murder case may not have been surprising, but I thought it was very well done. The writing kept me interested at all times and I would love to read more by this author, who brought the time period alive so vividly.

If you like historical fiction and murder mysteries, do yourself a favour and pick this book up.

On a sidenote, I am not that fond of the front cover...

*I read an ARC for this book in exchange for a review - this by no means influences my opinion*
Profile Image for Kiesha ~ Gwenllian ferch Gruffydd .
422 reviews16 followers
February 27, 2019
Wow, what a 360 from the first book in the series. The characters were much more engaging to me as the personality of characters were more fleshed out. The mystery was really good too. I'm loving the developing romance between Atlas and Lilliana. Secondary characters were great too. I'm looking forward to the 3rd book in this series

4.5 story, 5 narration.
Profile Image for Rebecca.
2,951 reviews39 followers
July 2, 2020
3.5 STARS

Even though the beginning wanted to make me stop, I am glad I didn't. I enjoyed the mystery aspect more than the first book, but I wanted more interaction between Lilliana and Atlas. I loved the ending and look forward to the next installment.
Profile Image for Kathy Martin.
4,157 reviews115 followers
January 13, 2018
The second Atlas Catesby historical mystery begins when the woman he's been trying to forget asks him to solve the mystery of the death of her maid's brother. Atlas is very good at puzzles and is intrigued by this mystery. He is also the fourth son of a newly minted baron - aristocratic but on the lowest end of the scale. Lady Roslyn Sterling is the sister of a duke and way above him in wealth and the ranking of society. Atlas feels that he can not have any sort of relationship with her despite the fact the he loves her. She is not convinced and is determined to show them how well they would suit, in her subtle and ladylike way.

As Atlas investigates Gordon Davis he uncovers more and more people who would have wanted him dead. Davis was an attractive and charming man from the lower class who wanted to raise his social status by marrying up. He carried on affairs with and aristocratic lady and a wealthy businessman's daughter. While he was a footman, he also accompanied two young aristocratic ladies on their shopping expedition for "naughty" books which gave him blackmail material to use with their fathers. One of the fathers is the wealthy peer who is courting Lady Roslyn and who asks that Atlas back off to allow him to court her.

Davis was poisoned with arsenic which was a relatively common chemical of the day. It was used in industry including the dye factory where Davis worked after losing his position as a footman. It was also sometimes used medicinally for clearing complexions and to increase vigor. Atlas and is new valet Jamie need to check the poison books of the pharmacies near the suspects to find out who bought the arsenic and who poisoned Davis.

I enjoyed the setting of this story. I also enjoyed Atlas Catesby who is an honorable man and a great puzzle solver. I have hopes for the relationship of Lilliana and Atlas and look forward to more books in the series to see how it progresses.
Profile Image for Moriah.
465 reviews5 followers
October 23, 2017
I received a copy of this title from the publisher for an honest review. Murder in Bloomsbury was a 4 1/4 star read for me. The second title in DM Quincy's Atlas Catesby series, it can be read as a stand alone, but since the first one is so good, go out and read it first so you can enjoy this one even more. This book takes place approximately nine months after the events of Murder in Mayfair; Atlas is recently back from a visit to Jamaica and finds himself summoned by Lady Lilliana, sister to the Duke of Somerville. Curious despite his attempts to forget her, Atlas obeys the summons and discovers Lilliana needs his help with determining what happened to her maid's brother. Although his death was ruled suicide by overdosing with Arsenic, his sister is sure he wouldn't have killed himself. Unable to refuse Lilliana's request, Atlas quickly discovers that the victim, Gordon Davis, was not as innocent as his sister believed and there is no shortage of suspects. Former lovers, fiances, outraged relatives, and jealous spouses all had reason to want David dead. The mystery in the book was well done with plenty of twists and turns that kept me guessing until about 3/4 of the way through the book when I was able to put all the clues together. There are interesting developments in secondary stories featuring Atlas's friend the Earl of Charlton, his sister, and of course his relationship with Lilliana. Like many historical mysteries featuring a romance, developments between the main characters continue to develop from book to book and that holds true here; I can't wait to see what happens next with Atlas and Lilliana.
Profile Image for Kristin.
1,030 reviews1 follower
May 24, 2018
If you haven’t read the first book in this mystery series, Murder in Mayfair, back up and start with it because it gives you interesting history between the main character Atlas Catsby and and his off-again-on-again love interest, Lady Lilliana.

That said, this book starts off about 1 1/2 year’s later. Atlas is summoned to Lilliana’s brother’s home to interest him in finding out the true facts behind the death of Lilliana’s maid’s brother. Again enlisting the help of Lilliana and his good friend Earl of Charlton along with his butler, Jamie, the plot begins to complicate.

Set in the Georgian period in England, this series explores the mores and customs of the period. The author goes into interesting detail of the characters’ lives confined by the standards of the 1800’s. Descriptive highlights of the dress of the day for both men and women is also included.

This series is delightful, filled with good writing, interesting complex characters, and a plot that will keep you involved all throughout the book. The book is a fast read with humor, intrigue, and an even-paced plot. I am already looking forward to the next installment of this excellent addition to the historical mystery genre.
Profile Image for Waverly Fitzgerald.
Author 17 books44 followers
March 14, 2018
At first I thought I wasn't going to be able to read this book because I thought I spotted a bunch of what I thought were mistakes in the first chapter. Not so. The author is very knowledgeable about Victorian mores and customs and some of the things that threw me off (like the hero doing puzzles--what we would call jigsaw puzzles) are possible. Also loved the way he smoked a nargila or hookah, and has a casual fling with his widowed landlady. Both believable. The plot revolves around arsenic and its many uses in Victorian times: as a medicine, a cosmetic, a dye.
The book reminded me most of Ashley Gardener's series featuring Captain Lacey. Atlas Catesby is also a man of a lower social status then his wealthy friend, the Earl of Charlton, and a flirtatious relationship with a noblewoman who he helped escape from an unsavory husband (in the previous book). One of the things I appreciated about this book was that every time Catesby got some new information about the murder he's trying to solve, he goes directly to question that person. None of that putting it off for another day because of intervening events that is so common in mysteries. I read it straight through in two days and immediately ordered a copy of the first book, Murder in Mayfair.
Profile Image for Joanna Shupe.
Author 34 books2,570 followers
October 25, 2017
The second installment in Quincy's series, this book did not disappoint. I enjoyed the simmering tension between Atlas and Lilliana, and the mystery was fast-paced and interesting. There were several twists and turns I didn't expect. Quincy's writing really gives a flavor of the time period and I enjoyed the small details she wove in throughout. A solid 5-star read from me!
(ARC provided for an honest review.)
Profile Image for Sharyn.
3,143 reviews24 followers
June 19, 2022
I am really enjoying this series. I love all the characters, particularly Atlas. I am fortunate to already have #3 which I am going to start immediately. I picked up this book at a library sale, I had never heard of this author and was quite lucky my library had book 1 and 3! So instead of writing more, I am going to start reading book 3 now, even though it is close to midnight as I need to see what happens.
Profile Image for Claudia.
Author 9 books40 followers
September 1, 2021
Details put you there

Another charming romance starring Atlas Catesby and his Lady Roslyn. The romance simmers below the surface, the mystery-puzzle is revealed in steps, but it’s the effortless reading (the result of meticulous writing effort and skill—so smooth as to be invisible) and the spectacular period details that make this series so delightful.
Looking forward to the next one.
Profile Image for Teresa.
1,048 reviews39 followers
February 10, 2020
3.5 stars. Another enjoyable book in this series.
Profile Image for Eileen Lynx.
925 reviews13 followers
March 19, 2020
Fun audio book. Good narrator. I really like regency mysteries but not regency romance. So I’m glad there’s another regency mystery series.
Profile Image for QSTCMomma.
272 reviews1 follower
February 18, 2022
Not quite 3 - 2 1/2


Not a great sequel but not a terrible one either. Again, for being so clever, Atlas is clearly slow on the uptake.

The writing is not extraordinary but decent. I was pleased with the authors use of antiquated words to fit the time period.

I was disappointed to notice the author using identical phrasing and sentences in both books. Copy and paste is not a friend to an excellent writer.

Additionally, the first book felt like she was writing a murder mystery with a love story. This one felt like she wanted to write a love story with a murder mystery.

Profile Image for Meg Griffin.
10 reviews
February 13, 2019
Damnit, Ms. Quincy! Your cliffhangers are worthy of Thomas Hardy, himself! This may be book #2, but no less excellent than the first! I have a tiny plot-hole problem, but like the rest of the story, by the time I had a chance to contemplate such a thing, something huge and outlandish happened! Every twist and turn makes me (figuratively) gasp, and every time I hit the end of my rope with frustration, something gives and pleases me immensely. This review covers both the first two books, I must say. These books are the most fantastic rollercoaster I’ve been on in a while and I desperately await the next. Damn you, madam; you have me truly addicted! 5 stars; no question.
Profile Image for Lynn Put.
428 reviews1 follower
May 29, 2019
4 1/2 stars. I’ve really enjoyed reading the two books in this historical mystery series and love not only the two main characters but also the supporting characters. Atlas Catesby’s character is written as an intelligent, caring gentleman who loves solving puzzles and therefore finds himself in the middle of his second investigation involving a man who has believed to have been poisoned. The investigation also brings him closer to Lilliana as the two of them work together to solve the crime.
808 reviews13 followers
August 7, 2018
A good read

The pacing in this second Atlas Catesby mystery is a bit slower and as such took me a bit longer to get into. Once invested however, the story took hold with its twists and turns leading to a satisfying ending. I also like the deepening relationship between Atlas and Liliana and hope to se more of them in future novels.
Profile Image for Annette.
1,768 reviews10 followers
January 16, 2018
Atlas Catesby is the son of a famous poet. At times, that name allows him entrance to places. Atlas is also a traveler. He has just returned from Jamaica and his next destination is to be India.

But, he has been summoned to the home of the Duke of Sommerville. He is being asked to investigate a death. Lady Lilliana Warwick, the Duke's sister, is asking for Atlas' help.

They have a history. He helped her when she was the suspect in her husband's murder. Atlas and Lilliana also have a very close friendship. That would be normal between two people who survived such an intense time in their lives. Of course, nothing came come of their relationship. She is the sister of a duke and he is the poor son of a poet.

The dead man was a footman. He was also a man who used his good looks and charm to take advantage of women. He intended to use his personal qualities to raise his standard of living by marrying a woman of a higher social standing. All in all, he was the kind of man who deserved to be murdered. He used women in a cruel manner.

Atlas and Lilliana are determined to find out the truth about his death. Lilliana's lady's maid was Gordan Davis' sister and they want to help her deal with the loss of her brother.

As the investigation progresses, facts begin to come quickly. There is a long list of people who are viable suspects. Gordan was not a nice man.

As the investigation progresses, Atlas also finds that Lilliana has a wealthy suitor. Atlas is not certain why, but that fact makes him unhappy.

This is a very well done story. The plot moves forward at a good pace. The clues are well placed and create a good trail to the ultimate conclusion.

The characters are terrific. Atlas and Lilliana are well rounded people. Both of them are intelligent and they learn from the clues equally well. There is not a person nor a fact which is not examined carefully.

The secondary characters add a great deal to the story. Each of the suspects appear to be viable suspects as well as interesting human beings. All in all, this is a well done mystery.

Ms Quincy is a new to me author who has provided a sparkling mystery with a romance chaser.

I received this book from the publisher through NetGalley. I am voluntarily writing this review and all opinions are my own.
1,224 reviews30 followers
February 11, 2018


I would like to thank Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for making this book available in exchange for an honest review. Following Murder in Mayfair, Atlas Catesby returns to apply his ability to solve puzzles to inv stigate the death of Gordon Davis in Murder in Bloomsbury. Davis was a factory clerk who frequently took arsenic. When the coroner notes a large amount of arsenic in his system it is ruled as an accidental death. Davis’ sister is the personal maid to Lilliana, who requests Atlas’ assistance when the ruling is questioned. As he investigates, he discovers that Davis was having an affair with the wife of a count, was courting the daughter of his employer and enjoying a flirtation with the wife of another resident in his boarding house. The list of those who might want him dead is considerable.

Lilliana and Atlas are an impressive team. As the sister of a powerful duke, she has access to members of society. Atlas explores the gaming hells and areas where it would not be appropriate for Lilliana to be seen. There is an attraction between them that Atlas continuously fights. She is being courted by a lord who can provide her with security, while Atlas is not in her social class. It is a dilemma that he struggles with throughout the story.

D.M. Quincy provides a fascinating look at the use of arsenic for reasons of health. From increasing energy to improving one’s complexion, arsenic was available to the general public for a number of applications. This is also a look at the social structure in England in the 18th century. While most young girls looked to marry well, Quincy provides strong female characters in Lilliana and Atlas’ sister Thea, a mathematician.

Although this is the second book in the series, Quincy provides a brief look at the events that originally brought Atlas and Lilliana together. It will leave you hoping to see how this relationship progresses in the future. Fans of Deanna Raybourn or historical mysteries will also enjoy Quincy’s mysteries.
Profile Image for Leslie.
879 reviews47 followers
March 4, 2024
I want to start on a positive note so I did enjoy this one (particularly the characters, including Jamie, the well-meaning but not entirely competent valet who also has valuable detecting talents), and will probably read more in the series, but I had a couple of quibbles. The first is hopefully for this book alone, but the second has continued through both that I've read.

1) Although I know it was set up so it ended the way it did, Atlas' constant obsession with being "too far down the social scale" and his determination to decide Lilliana's future for her, "for her own good," drove me up the wall. I also wish the ending had been a bit less abrupt. Incidentally, I'm not an expert on the intricacies of the British social system, but I found the claim that he never even would have encountered her in the normal course of things to be a bit odd when his best friend is an earl (only two ranks below her brother), which I'm assuming would have given him entrée into those circles.

2) This also annoyed me exceedingly in the first book. The endless rhapsodizing about Lilliana's beauty and aristocratic bearing was enough to make me wonder if I were reading a romance novel rather than a mystery and drove my rating from a 3.5 down to a 3. And if I had to read one more time about her "off-kilter smile," apparently her only flaw, presumably so she doesn't seem too perfect...

I got the following from only a few chapters:
"Delicate chin"
"Eyes dark certainly but touched with a rich jewel tone that reminded him of leaves in the fall"
"Fine-boned loveliness"
"One elegant shoulder" (the other one, not so much?)
"Crystalline gaze"
"Beautiful eyes"
"Lovely lines of her face"
"Aristocratic profile and lithe figure"
"Ivory complexion"
Profile Image for Annie (is so far behind &#x1f62c;).
413 reviews10 followers
April 1, 2018
I give this a 3.5 stars out of 5, mostly because I would need to go back to the first in the series to fully understand the relationships of Atlas, lilliane, Charlton, James, etc. Although well done enough to follow, there were little intricacies that were missing and that left me wondering how they were all connected. I also wish the author had found a different name than 'Elizabeth' to be the mysterious 'L'. It was a bit disappointing that I immediately guessed she would be 'Libby' or 'Lizzie' and therefore the lady in question.

Outside of that, however, after a bit of a slow start, I managed to get through this all in one afternoon. It was a good read, enjoyable and the mystery well done. I thought Lilliane could have played a larger part in the investigation but appreciate that there were huge constraints on a lady's access to places and discussions that took place around her so to be fair, it could be quite limiting. I liked that Atlas loved her for her mind and her curiosity and intelligence at a time when women were discouraged and not expected to gain an education.

The period was well done, although I kept feeling it was in the Victorian era rather than the Regency (I must have missed that part), and some of the language seemed a little too modern (would they have said 'jilted' in the Regency era? That sounds a bit 1920's America to me.

Again, just little niggles in an otherwise engaging and enjoyable read.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
2,102 reviews38 followers
November 20, 2020
Gordon Davis, a clerk residing in Bloomsbury, had always harboured aspirations beyond his station. Blessed with good looks and a good physique, he capitalized on his obvious assets to seduce young ladies of wealth... some of them even participated in their own ruination. Such was Davis' rakish existence albeit unknown to his sister who brought him up after the death of their mother who died crazed from the pox. Though Davis was also found dead at his lodgings (his looks and body markedly changed), his sister did not believe he died because of a stomach ailment and so she asked for her mistress' help. Nothing for Mrs. Roslyn Lilliana Warwick, sister of the wealthy and powerful Duke of Somerville... but to ask her brother to summon Atlas Catesby, youngest son of a baronet... world traveler and adventurer... explorer... lover of puzzles and with a mind for relentless probings for the truth and the solution for a murder... to come to her maid's aid. This touches on selfish hedonistic destructive greed... blackmail and foolish young girls who thought being naughty by breaking sexual taboos and having affairs were quite fun. There are things like STDs... and a little fear of such things is the more correct, proper and healthier option. Oh, not to forget older women who should know better but allowed themselves to be beguiled into inconceivable gullibility and pathetic self~delusion.

P.S. ~ For such a sharp and smart puzzle~solver, Catesby is still hopelessly clueless about women in general, and about Lily in particular... while the Duke of Somerville, despite his sexual proclivities. has been awaiting at an age for him to pay his addresses to his sister and to negotiate settlements with him, as her brother and head of the family.
Profile Image for Critterbee❇.
924 reviews72 followers
February 3, 2018
I like this series; this is book 2, and the second that I have read. It is a bit of a readalike for Charles Finch's Charles Lenox Mysteries. In the first one, I noticed a few atmospheric bits that took me out of the Regency era into the Victorian era, but was not too troubled because the story was unexpected and entertaining.

In this second book, that happened more frequently. And while I am currently reading a surprisingly similar series, I can not stop comparing the two. Both heroes are gentleman recovering from an injury to their foot, and both have been lucky enough to stumble into friendship with a pink of the ton. I use the word lucky, because that allows them to move more freely in society, and society views the friendship as such. Both men consider themselves socially at the lower end of the scale, barely gentleman. Both have a strong sense of honour and protective streak. So far, both seem to have a bit of a forbidden romance with an 'untouchable female'. And both solve mysteries.

Atlas Catesby is summoned to help Lady Roslyn look into the death of her maid's brother. Atlas shows no subtlety, and charges around aggressively questioning newly met people of all social status, which they seem to allow with little reluctance. Shockingly anachronistic behavior is discovered. A wife of a peer talks freely and bluntly about an affair that she is having, to a man she has just met. The plot moppets that were bouncing around book one make a tiny appearance. Atlas's sense of honour suddenly seems mercurial.

This series has inconsistencies. In the characters, in the writing, in the timing. It just is not as good as the first in the series. Things are told, not shown, and told again. And again.

I am not sure whether I will continue with this series, as my tbr is ginormous. And I am reading a very similar yet seemingly superior series, which I prefer. Might check back again later.

*eARC Netgalley*
Profile Image for Homerun2.
2,706 reviews18 followers
February 11, 2018
A strong entry in the Atlas Catesby Regency/mystery series. Atlas Catesby has spent a year trying to forget Lady Roslyn, whom he rescued in the last series debut. They solved a mystery together and felt a strong bond, but given that she is the daughter of an earl and he is without title or significant fortune, he has avoided her.

But she summons him to conduct another investigation: one of her servants has a brother who died under mysterious circumstances. So Atlas and Lady Roslyn are thrown together again in a puzzling case involving illicit liaisons, blackmail and scandal.

The two main characters are strong leads -- layered, principled, and intelligent. The cast of characters including Atlas's sister Thea, his friend Charlton, and his valet Jamie are well-written. The mystery has some surprises at the end. All in all, an entertaining read. Would characters in this time period behave as Atlas and Lady R? No, probably not, but unless you are a stickler for historical accuracy you will be able to overlook that for the sake of the plot.

Thanks to the publisher and to Net Galley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.