This is not a great book if your expectations are set to "historical novel" level. Some people have commented that this is a children's book and in a way that is correct as this was written when Galt was 16. This is apparent in the flow of action and narrative, sometimes rushed and sometimes drawn out overlong. In what is clearly an homage to books like Treasure Island, The Swiss Family Robinson, and the like, the language can sometimes be laborious and overly florid, but you get the gist of Galt trying to capture the old-time flavour of those classic adventure tales. Unfortunately, Galt also captures too many of the antiquated views concerning women and non-Europeans often present in those same tales and this is jarring and offensive to modern sensibilities. However, viewed through the lens of a serial in a pulp magazine (or the weekly action/adventure sword and sorcery comedy-dramas of the 90s, like Hercules: The Legendary Journeys), this can be a fun read. Yes it has a host of faults, but it also has enough merits to make it enjoyable.