What do you think?
Rate this book
St Peter's, Cardross: Birth, Death and Renewal
The ruin of St Peter's College has sat on a wooded hilltop above the village of Cardross for more than three decades. Over that time, with altars crumbling, graffiti snaking across its walls and nature reclaiming its concrete, it has gained a mythical, cult-like status among architects, preservationists and artists.
St Peter's only fulfilled its original role as a seminary for 14 years, from 1966 to 1979. As its uncompromising design gave way to prolonged construction and problematic upkeep, the Catholic Church reassessed the role of seminaries, resolving to embed trainee priests not in seclusion, but in communities. Although briefly repurposed as a drug rehabilitation centre, the building was soon abandoned to decay and vandalism.
Ever since, people have argued and puzzled over the future and importance of St Peter's. It has been called both Scotland's best and worst twentieth century building. In 1992, it was listed category A. One of its architects suggested the idea of 'everything being stripped away except the concrete itself – a purely romantic conception of the building as a beautiful ruin'. And now in 2016, St Peter's is renewed as a cultural space through the work of the arts organisation NVA.
In this landmark book, Diane Watters looks at the history of a structure that emerged out of an innovative phase of post-war Catholic church building. She traces the story of an architectural failure which morphed into a tragic modernist myth: unappreciated architects betrayed by an unloving client, and abandoned by an uncaring society. This is a historian's account of the real story of St Peter's College: an exploration of how one of Scotland's most singular buildings became one of its most troubled – and most celebrated.
St Peter's only fulfilled its original role as a seminary for 14 years, from 1966 to 1979. As its uncompromising design gave way to prolonged construction and problematic upkeep, the Catholic Church reassessed the role of seminaries, resolving to embed trainee priests not in seclusion, but in communities. Although briefly repurposed as a drug rehabilitation centre, the building was soon abandoned to decay and vandalism.
Ever since, people have argued and puzzled over the future and importance of St Peter's. It has been called both Scotland's best and worst twentieth century building. In 1992, it was listed category A. One of its architects suggested the idea of 'everything being stripped away except the concrete itself – a purely romantic conception of the building as a beautiful ruin'. And now in 2016, St Peter's is renewed as a cultural space through the work of the arts organisation NVA.
In this landmark book, Diane Watters looks at the history of a structure that emerged out of an innovative phase of post-war Catholic church building. She traces the story of an architectural failure which morphed into a tragic modernist myth: unappreciated architects betrayed by an unloving client, and abandoned by an uncaring society. This is a historian's account of the real story of St Peter's College: an exploration of how one of Scotland's most singular buildings became one of its most troubled – and most celebrated.
320 pages, Hardcover
Published November 1, 2016
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
April 14, 2026
I became aware of this building through i account of St Peter's in any other book. And although I came for the pictures, I got deeply engrossed in the full story, and the deep dive into the modern architecture movement within church building during the 20th century was highly interesting as well.
Seems to me that this really is the ultimate book on the subject. It could maybe do with an update, since another 10 years have passed and yet more beams will have come down, more graffitis been added, and more attempts at trying to figure out what to do with "it" will have happened.
Seems to me that this really is the ultimate book on the subject. It could maybe do with an update, since another 10 years have passed and yet more beams will have come down, more graffitis been added, and more attempts at trying to figure out what to do with "it" will have happened.
August 9, 2021
Fascinating book with stunning pictures about the rise and fall of St. Peter's in Cardross. Seeing the pictures though don't come close to seeing how the buildings have become overgrown. Nature has taken over this rather incredible site, and it's a bit sad.
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews