“The Crow: Clash By Night” by Chet Williamson had potential, but it ultimately fell short for me. While the premise of Amy Carlisle’s story—seeking justice for the children she cared for—is compelling, the execution left much to be desired.
The portrayal of the antagonists, the Sons of America, felt too familiar, echoing modern extremist behaviors. This could have been an opportunity for a nuanced exploration, but instead, it comes across as shallow and gratuitous.
Amy’s death scene, while pivotal, lacks the emotional depth and resonance that could have made her sacrifice more impactful. The narrative choices often feel like they’re trying to shock rather than genuinely engage. As a transgender woman, I also found it difficult to connect with a story so steeped in masculine perspectives, especially given the lack of female or diverse voices in this series overall.
Ultimately, while Clash By Night had some interesting moments, it didn’t live up to the depth or emotional complexity of other entries in The Crow universe.