“The Longing” is a like participating in an extended intensive therapy session. I feel badly for Sydney’s crappy background, and for Essex’s real life crappy experience with her own parents, but “The Longing” is neither entertaining nor educational…it’s unpleasant.
Unlike most (every other?) of Essex’s books, there are no werewolves, extraterrestrials or true angels from heaven; everyone is human. What is familiar, though, is the instalove 19yo Sydney feels for 45yo Caroline. In fact, Sydney falls in love before she even sees or meets Caroline; she determines that the singing voice she hears is that of an angel. Her determination to let Caroline know she loves her almost escalates to stalker territory as she shares her thoughts of devotion with readers/listeners, but since Caroline is secretly attracted to Sydney, I suppose it all kind of works out acceptably.
Besides being actually human, Caroline is also not the pillar of perfection that Essex’s mere mortals normally swoon over. Caroline is a nice enough sympathetic character, having been dumped a year ago by her long time girlfriend, and she’s targeted for being gay by a wacko neighbor. Other than being attracted to 19yo Sydney physically and admiring her bravery for not denying being gay even in the face of extreme hardship and cruelty, it’s never really clear why 45yo Caroline falls so quickly in love with Sydney.
Being such a very nice person, it’s unrealistic that all of Caroline’s friends, as well as her ex, are complete and utter unpleasant bitches. Why would she be friends with such nasty people?
Well, I hung on through Sydney’s anxiety attacks and wondered how an HEA would be crafted for her and Sydney. Meh - it was just sort of slapped on at the end. The long anticipated sexy fun time for virgin Sydney and experienced Caroline was far too brief and fade-to-black to add any final enjoyment to the book.
The writing, as is usually the case for Essex, is lush and evocative. Unfortunately, both the writing and the narration focus on dark, dreary emotions throughout the book. “Melodramatic” could’ve been my one-word review for “The Longing”. 2.5* rounded down to 2* because it did indeed disappoint me.