What do you think?
Rate this book
The Wishing Thread
For fans of Jennifer Chiaverini and Sarah Addison Allen, The Wishing Thread is an enchanting novel about the bonds between sisters, the indelible pull of the past, and the transformational power of love.
The Van Ripper women have been the talk of Tarrytown, New York, for centuries. Some say they’re angels; some say they’re crooks. In their tumbledown “Stitchery,” not far from the stomping grounds of the legendary Headless Horseman, the Van Ripper sisters—Aubrey, Bitty, and Meggie—are said to knit people’s most ardent wishes into beautiful scarves and mittens, granting them health, success, or even a blossoming romance. But for the magic to work, sacrifices must be made—and no one knows that better than the Van Rippers.
When the Stitchery matriarch, Mariah, dies, she leaves the yarn shop to her three nieces. Aubrey, shy and reliable, has dedicated her life to weaving spells for the community, though her sisters have long stayed away. Bitty, pragmatic and persistent, has always been skeptical of magic and wants her children to have a normal, nonmagical life. Meggie, restless and free-spirited, follows her own set of rules. Now, after Mariah’s death forces a reunion, the sisters must reassess the state of their lives even as they decide the fate of the Stitchery. But their relationships with one another—and their beliefs in magic—are put to the test. Will the threads hold?
Includes an exclusive conversation between Sarah Addison Allen and Lisa Van Allen
Look for special features inside. Join the Random House Reader’s Circle for author chats and more.
From the Trade Paperback edition.
The Van Ripper women have been the talk of Tarrytown, New York, for centuries. Some say they’re angels; some say they’re crooks. In their tumbledown “Stitchery,” not far from the stomping grounds of the legendary Headless Horseman, the Van Ripper sisters—Aubrey, Bitty, and Meggie—are said to knit people’s most ardent wishes into beautiful scarves and mittens, granting them health, success, or even a blossoming romance. But for the magic to work, sacrifices must be made—and no one knows that better than the Van Rippers.
When the Stitchery matriarch, Mariah, dies, she leaves the yarn shop to her three nieces. Aubrey, shy and reliable, has dedicated her life to weaving spells for the community, though her sisters have long stayed away. Bitty, pragmatic and persistent, has always been skeptical of magic and wants her children to have a normal, nonmagical life. Meggie, restless and free-spirited, follows her own set of rules. Now, after Mariah’s death forces a reunion, the sisters must reassess the state of their lives even as they decide the fate of the Stitchery. But their relationships with one another—and their beliefs in magic—are put to the test. Will the threads hold?
Includes an exclusive conversation between Sarah Addison Allen and Lisa Van Allen
Look for special features inside. Join the Random House Reader’s Circle for author chats and more.
From the Trade Paperback edition.
402 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2013
545 people are currently reading
7131 people want to read
About the author
Lisa Van Allen
4 books141 followersLisa Van Allen is the New York Times and USA Today bestselling author of THE WISHING THREAD and THE NIGHT GARDEN. Her work has been translated in six languages and printed in seven countries to date, and her work has appeared multiple times on bestseller lists. When not writing, she can usually be found cleaning up the endless piles of books left around the house by her toddling daughter, trying to entertain a Jack Russel “terror” named Einstein, or prepping for whatever new adventure her husband has up his sleeve (he’s a high-ranking scout for a professional sports team). She is currently working on a new book that promises to be her most emotional story yet. For news about releases and price drop promotions, please join her mailing list at www.WriterLisaVanAllen.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 602 reviews
June 19, 2013
2.5 Stars
The wishing Thread a novel by Lisa Van Allen is and interesting read and tells the story of the Van Ripper Women who have been the talk of Tarrytown, New York for many years. Aubrey, Bitty and Meggie are three sisters who after the death of their aunt meet up again at their childhood home a place called the Stitchery. These ladies when asked a can knit a little magic into folks lives and are somewhat feared and yet held in awe in their small community.
Each chapter is headed by a knitting term, and there are plenty of knitting and magic happening throughout the novel and while I found the writing good I found the plot very bland. The sisters stories are interesting but it just seemed to take to long for anything to happen.
For those who love knitting, a little bit of magic and romance and some family drama you may enjoy this novel but for me there was too much plain and not enough purl .
I would like to thank Net Galley and Radom House Publishing Group - Ballintine for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
The wishing Thread a novel by Lisa Van Allen is and interesting read and tells the story of the Van Ripper Women who have been the talk of Tarrytown, New York for many years. Aubrey, Bitty and Meggie are three sisters who after the death of their aunt meet up again at their childhood home a place called the Stitchery. These ladies when asked a can knit a little magic into folks lives and are somewhat feared and yet held in awe in their small community.
Each chapter is headed by a knitting term, and there are plenty of knitting and magic happening throughout the novel and while I found the writing good I found the plot very bland. The sisters stories are interesting but it just seemed to take to long for anything to happen.
For those who love knitting, a little bit of magic and romance and some family drama you may enjoy this novel but for me there was too much plain and not enough purl .
I would like to thank Net Galley and Radom House Publishing Group - Ballintine for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
October 1, 2013
Review originally published at The Bookwyrm's Hoard.
The Wishing Thread isn't simply, as I expected when I started it, a book about knitting or about magic. It's about the ways we are knit together: as family, as lovers, as community. It's about the past and the present, traditions and beliefs, hope and despair all inextricably woven together to create the fabric of our stories, both individual and collective. And it's about our choices, and what we make of them.
This isn't a fantasy book. If anything, it's magical realism. But as the reader, you decide -- like Aubrey, Bitty, and Meggie -- whether the magic of the Stitchery is true or merely imagined. And it's not high magic in any sense; if it exists, it's an everyday magic, intertwined with the crumbling, broken-edged reality of Tarrytown's decaying neighborhoods, like a strand of silk held and knitted with a rough woolen thread to form a fabric whose tough durability hides a hint of shimmer when it moves.
The characters in the novel are so well depicted, so real, that they practically jump out of the pages. Bitty's determined denial of magic, Aubrey's belief and her insecurities and desires, and Meggie's close-held grief and longing brought each woman to life as I read, until I felt I knew them intimately as family, as though I were an invisible cousin living in their home. Bitty was the hardest to get to know; she held me at bay much as she holds her sisters at bay. Some of the secondary characters are equally well-drawn: Bitty's children, Nessa and Carter; Aubrey's wonderful friend Vic, and even the high society matron, Ruth Ten Eyck.
Tarrytown came alive for me, as well; I found myself wanting to visit the town, to see the lighthouse and mansions and cemetery and clock tower for myself. Alas, while Tarrytown and Sleepy Hollow are real, Tappan Square and the Stitchery exist only within the pages of the book. I would have loved to visit the Stitchery, to climb its sagging stairs and explore its turret and attics.
The Van Ripper family and Tappan Square's struggles to fend off an eminent domain seizure were simultaneously enheartening and heartbreaking. I really didn't see the ending coming, yet somehow it felt so right, as though I'd known subconciously where it was headed all along.
As a knitter, I delighted in the quotes from the Great Book in the Hall that begin each chapter. As a result of reading both those and The Wishing Thread as a whole, I know I'll think about my own knitting differently from now on: about the intention I put into my stitches, about knitting as a creative, almost magical act.
I highly recommend The Wishing Thread for readers who love interesting characters and more than a touch of ambiguity. It would make an excellent book club choice; there is so much to discuss and debate within its pages. I loved the novel, and will be picking up a print copy for my shelves as soon as I can.
FTC disclosure: I received a review copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
The Wishing Thread isn't simply, as I expected when I started it, a book about knitting or about magic. It's about the ways we are knit together: as family, as lovers, as community. It's about the past and the present, traditions and beliefs, hope and despair all inextricably woven together to create the fabric of our stories, both individual and collective. And it's about our choices, and what we make of them.
This isn't a fantasy book. If anything, it's magical realism. But as the reader, you decide -- like Aubrey, Bitty, and Meggie -- whether the magic of the Stitchery is true or merely imagined. And it's not high magic in any sense; if it exists, it's an everyday magic, intertwined with the crumbling, broken-edged reality of Tarrytown's decaying neighborhoods, like a strand of silk held and knitted with a rough woolen thread to form a fabric whose tough durability hides a hint of shimmer when it moves.
The characters in the novel are so well depicted, so real, that they practically jump out of the pages. Bitty's determined denial of magic, Aubrey's belief and her insecurities and desires, and Meggie's close-held grief and longing brought each woman to life as I read, until I felt I knew them intimately as family, as though I were an invisible cousin living in their home. Bitty was the hardest to get to know; she held me at bay much as she holds her sisters at bay. Some of the secondary characters are equally well-drawn: Bitty's children, Nessa and Carter; Aubrey's wonderful friend Vic, and even the high society matron, Ruth Ten Eyck.
Tarrytown came alive for me, as well; I found myself wanting to visit the town, to see the lighthouse and mansions and cemetery and clock tower for myself. Alas, while Tarrytown and Sleepy Hollow are real, Tappan Square and the Stitchery exist only within the pages of the book. I would have loved to visit the Stitchery, to climb its sagging stairs and explore its turret and attics.
The Van Ripper family and Tappan Square's struggles to fend off an eminent domain seizure were simultaneously enheartening and heartbreaking. I really didn't see the ending coming, yet somehow it felt so right, as though I'd known subconciously where it was headed all along.
As a knitter, I delighted in the quotes from the Great Book in the Hall that begin each chapter. As a result of reading both those and The Wishing Thread as a whole, I know I'll think about my own knitting differently from now on: about the intention I put into my stitches, about knitting as a creative, almost magical act.
I highly recommend The Wishing Thread for readers who love interesting characters and more than a touch of ambiguity. It would make an excellent book club choice; there is so much to discuss and debate within its pages. I loved the novel, and will be picking up a print copy for my shelves as soon as I can.
FTC disclosure: I received a review copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
June 20, 2013
I love, love, LOVED this book. In fact, it's the best book I've read all year.
The Wishing Thread is about three unusual sisters who are reunited after their grandmother dies unexpectedly. One of the sisters lives in The Stitchery, an ancient knit-and-yarn shop that is an icon of a rundown, seedy section of Tarrytown. This Stitchery is the kind of place the residents speak of only in soft voices, because everyone knows the sisters can knit powerful spells into the sweaters and scarves they give to those willing to make true sacrifices. But does the magic really work? That's a matter of faith and opinion, and Van Allen exploits these themes with a deft and subtle pen. Atmospheric, brilliantly written, and emotionally compelling, The Wishing Thread is a masterful tale about sisterly relationships and the value of true sacrifice.
The Wishing Thread is about three unusual sisters who are reunited after their grandmother dies unexpectedly. One of the sisters lives in The Stitchery, an ancient knit-and-yarn shop that is an icon of a rundown, seedy section of Tarrytown. This Stitchery is the kind of place the residents speak of only in soft voices, because everyone knows the sisters can knit powerful spells into the sweaters and scarves they give to those willing to make true sacrifices. But does the magic really work? That's a matter of faith and opinion, and Van Allen exploits these themes with a deft and subtle pen. Atmospheric, brilliantly written, and emotionally compelling, The Wishing Thread is a masterful tale about sisterly relationships and the value of true sacrifice.
September 12, 2014
There is, of course, always a question - a question of the difference between what is real and what is true. A thing can be true without being real. You may not grasp this entirely, but don't worry. This is the nature of faith, of magic, of a good life's work.
This was a sweet, easy-reading book about knitting spells and the relationship between sisters. For me it was also about accepting your own destiny, and the different ways people try and avoid doing this. The story started strong, but unravelled towards the end. It felt like some situations where forced to a closure. There were a lot of lose threads at the end of the story. That said, I still enjoyed it. Sometimes you only need a light snack and not a three course meal when reading. The Wishing Thread is perfect beach reading.
The story: The Van Ripper sisters—Aubrey, Bitty, and Meggie—are said to knit people’s most ardent wishes into beautiful scarves and mittens, granting them health, success, or even a blossoming romance. But for the magic to work, sacrifices must be made—and no one knows that better than the Van Rippers.
September 4, 2013
From the moment I read the synopsis for The Wishing Thread, I thought of Alice Hoffman’s Practical Magic (One of my all time favorite reads and Book to Movie adaptations) and Sarah Addison Allen’s Garden Spells (Another of my all time favorite reads) and I knew that I had to read this one. I can’t say that it quite lived up to my expectations, but it came darn close! And they were very high expectations.
The setting of Tarrytown, NY (right next door to Sleepy Hollow) was drawn so absolutely perfectly that this was one of those books that the reader will wish they could simply step inside and live in for a time. I loved The Stitchery and the neighborhood…with a few repairs I certainly could have made that house my own! Lisa Van Allen’s writing style is descriptive and evocative without being long winded and adds perfectly to the feel of this novel. The pacing may feel a bit slow for some, but I love to savor books such as these and find that the slower pace lets me fully appreciate the beauty and wisdom found withing the pages.
Each of the three sisters drew me in immediately and I was able to connect with each of them in a different way. Bitty, the eldest, struggling to hold up appearances and keep herself distant from her past. Meggie, who has been searching for so long that she’s lost track of exactly what she really needs to find. And Aubrey, our heroine, part time librarian and the caretaker of The Stitchery and through extension the community…who finds her own inner strength and learns to redefine the rules and therefore her life. Even the recently passed Aunt Mariah has such a presence! Each of the other secondary characters are also so well fleshed out…that The Wishing Thread just rings so true. Which is key in any great work of Magical Realism.
Lisa Van Allen also manages to deliver a sweet and believable romance – one has to love Vic – as well as several great friendships. Let’s just say that she writes relationships well.
So lets talk about the magic…about the possibility of knitting one’s wishes with intent and positive thoughts into a garment and passing it along. What a gift. And is it really all that hard to believe? We’ve all seen the studies done on the power of optimism and positive thought.
Great men are they who see that spiritual is stronger than any material force – that thoughts rule the world. ~~Ralph Waldo Emerson
And ultimately how important are those threads in pulling back together a fractured family and a splintered community? How beautiful and strong would that knit be if created with all the heart and soul of a trio of sisters and a town united? I left this book feeling lighter and happier, confident that yes…I can choose to make and remake my path as needed. That family and friends and hope and faith may not stop time but can move mountains nonetheless. The Wishing Thread is indeed a magical novel even for those like me who don’t knit.
Additional Note: I actually went and took a knitting class after reading this book…I don’t know how much time I’ll have to practice or if I’ll keep it up…but I loved the power and the beauty of creating something with my own two hands. And why not…I can reknit myself every day should I so choose:)
The setting of Tarrytown, NY (right next door to Sleepy Hollow) was drawn so absolutely perfectly that this was one of those books that the reader will wish they could simply step inside and live in for a time. I loved The Stitchery and the neighborhood…with a few repairs I certainly could have made that house my own! Lisa Van Allen’s writing style is descriptive and evocative without being long winded and adds perfectly to the feel of this novel. The pacing may feel a bit slow for some, but I love to savor books such as these and find that the slower pace lets me fully appreciate the beauty and wisdom found withing the pages.
Each of the three sisters drew me in immediately and I was able to connect with each of them in a different way. Bitty, the eldest, struggling to hold up appearances and keep herself distant from her past. Meggie, who has been searching for so long that she’s lost track of exactly what she really needs to find. And Aubrey, our heroine, part time librarian and the caretaker of The Stitchery and through extension the community…who finds her own inner strength and learns to redefine the rules and therefore her life. Even the recently passed Aunt Mariah has such a presence! Each of the other secondary characters are also so well fleshed out…that The Wishing Thread just rings so true. Which is key in any great work of Magical Realism.
Lisa Van Allen also manages to deliver a sweet and believable romance – one has to love Vic – as well as several great friendships. Let’s just say that she writes relationships well.
So lets talk about the magic…about the possibility of knitting one’s wishes with intent and positive thoughts into a garment and passing it along. What a gift. And is it really all that hard to believe? We’ve all seen the studies done on the power of optimism and positive thought.
Great men are they who see that spiritual is stronger than any material force – that thoughts rule the world. ~~Ralph Waldo Emerson
And ultimately how important are those threads in pulling back together a fractured family and a splintered community? How beautiful and strong would that knit be if created with all the heart and soul of a trio of sisters and a town united? I left this book feeling lighter and happier, confident that yes…I can choose to make and remake my path as needed. That family and friends and hope and faith may not stop time but can move mountains nonetheless. The Wishing Thread is indeed a magical novel even for those like me who don’t knit.
Additional Note: I actually went and took a knitting class after reading this book…I don’t know how much time I’ll have to practice or if I’ll keep it up…but I loved the power and the beauty of creating something with my own two hands. And why not…I can reknit myself every day should I so choose:)
August 30, 2013
Ahhhh I love a good yarn (pun intended), and when this book was likened to the writing of one of my favorite authors Sarah Addison Allen on Netgalley, I knew I had to request a copy.
The Wishing Thread focuses on the lives of the Van Ripper women who reside in Tarrytown, NY. They are accused of being all sorts of things but mostly Aubrey, Bitty, and Meggie have a skill for knitting bespoke items that include the hopes, dreams and wishes of the people they are being produced for into the threads of the garment.
The yarn shop is left to the girls by their aunt Mariah, and it forces all of them to come back together and reassess their relationships with each other and the people around them.
The ebb and flow of this story is excellent, the descriptive narrative really leaves you with a full visual of where you are and what you are seeing. I lost myself in this book, its originality and its unusual storyline pulled me in and kept me company for a few hours. I must admit I did have a few “Practical Magic” flashes, but not in a bad way, the familial feel to the writing, makes you feel like you are almost a part of it, I almost started hunting for my old knitting needles!
Highly recommended. If you are looking for a light, entertaining unusual book then you can’t go wrong with this.
The Wishing Thread focuses on the lives of the Van Ripper women who reside in Tarrytown, NY. They are accused of being all sorts of things but mostly Aubrey, Bitty, and Meggie have a skill for knitting bespoke items that include the hopes, dreams and wishes of the people they are being produced for into the threads of the garment.
The yarn shop is left to the girls by their aunt Mariah, and it forces all of them to come back together and reassess their relationships with each other and the people around them.
The ebb and flow of this story is excellent, the descriptive narrative really leaves you with a full visual of where you are and what you are seeing. I lost myself in this book, its originality and its unusual storyline pulled me in and kept me company for a few hours. I must admit I did have a few “Practical Magic” flashes, but not in a bad way, the familial feel to the writing, makes you feel like you are almost a part of it, I almost started hunting for my old knitting needles!
Highly recommended. If you are looking for a light, entertaining unusual book then you can’t go wrong with this.
July 7, 2013
When you read a lot, it often becomes difficult to find much of anything that truly feels original, especially when it comes to categories as frequently abused as magical realism. This book is different and that made me happy.
The characters are definitely worth reading the book for. Sisters, they share some similarities, but they are also very different. I thought this author did a supreme job of highlighting those differences and making the women in this book work off of one another well.
This is a pretty intensely written story at times. I definitely think it is one of the better books I have read this year and it has a lot of unexpected twists that I didn't foresee.
This is the kind of book that you want to curl up with when there are no other distractions and just enjoy it to the fullest extent. I found it easy to become wrapped up in the lives of the characters and wanted to know what would happen next with each turn of the page.
The dialogue was easy to read and enchanting. I loved getting to know this group of characters and learning about their lives.
I recommend this book to anyone who likes a story that can make them believe magic is real and one life can affect another.
This review is based on a digital ARC from the publisher.
The characters are definitely worth reading the book for. Sisters, they share some similarities, but they are also very different. I thought this author did a supreme job of highlighting those differences and making the women in this book work off of one another well.
This is a pretty intensely written story at times. I definitely think it is one of the better books I have read this year and it has a lot of unexpected twists that I didn't foresee.
This is the kind of book that you want to curl up with when there are no other distractions and just enjoy it to the fullest extent. I found it easy to become wrapped up in the lives of the characters and wanted to know what would happen next with each turn of the page.
The dialogue was easy to read and enchanting. I loved getting to know this group of characters and learning about their lives.
I recommend this book to anyone who likes a story that can make them believe magic is real and one life can affect another.
This review is based on a digital ARC from the publisher.
August 27, 2013
Something was not quite right. Sometimes I blame it on ebooks. And it might be the problem that I had this time. I never felt connected to the characters, or the book itself. Sometimes ebooks just loose the magic that books hold for me. Because the book itself was good, just not for me this time.
The magic, was there magic at all? I like magical realism cos the magic is just embedded in the story. It feels normal or real. Here I never even knew if there was any magic at all and there it lost the magical realism for me.
The book is about 3 sisters and a knitting magic. They knit, people's wishes come true, sometimes. But the sisters have scattered and only lonely Audrey is left. Meggie is the wandered who comes back, and Bitty is the one who married rich but is still unhappy. They all have their problems to deal with and paths to find.
The story is good, save the neighborhood, the house, themselves. There is a hint of romance too.
But in the end, I was on the outside looking in and mostly got stressed cos I had to return the e-reader and the book took 2 weeks to finish.
The magic, was there magic at all? I like magical realism cos the magic is just embedded in the story. It feels normal or real. Here I never even knew if there was any magic at all and there it lost the magical realism for me.
The book is about 3 sisters and a knitting magic. They knit, people's wishes come true, sometimes. But the sisters have scattered and only lonely Audrey is left. Meggie is the wandered who comes back, and Bitty is the one who married rich but is still unhappy. They all have their problems to deal with and paths to find.
The story is good, save the neighborhood, the house, themselves. There is a hint of romance too.
But in the end, I was on the outside looking in and mostly got stressed cos I had to return the e-reader and the book took 2 weeks to finish.
August 27, 2013
Have you ever read a book you just wanted to crawl into the pages and the story, and live there? That is how I felt about The Wishing Thread. If I could magically transport my life into this book, I would.
It's a family tradition for my brother and I to love the story of the Headless Horseman and Sleepy Hollow. We know the Disney cartoon by heart, the songs, the dialogue, even the lines from the cartoon shorts that come before it on the DVD. I loved the Johnny Depp movie version, and I am excited for the upcoming television show, although it involves time travel and that usually turns me off. I sadly have never read the Washington Irving story, but I plan on correcting that in October.
I looked at the blurb for the book, and was a little apprehensive. I have had bad experiences with books that take place or are based on an original story, like this one. Or Scarlett, that sad sequel to Gone with the Wind. So I started reading a little reservedly. It didn't take long for the story and the characters to steal me away into their lives.
Aubrey and her two sisters grew up with their aunt in a house that had been in the family for generations. Their house is known as The Stichery around town, and always had been. The Van Rippen family's heritage is long and winding and magical. They can knit spells, fulfilling the wishes of those who come to them, desperate, hopeful, resigned. The wisher must give up something of great importance to them in order for the deal to be made, and for the spell to work. But this is not a guarantee that the magic will work, just a sign of good faith between the two.
The idea of being able to embed emotions such as dreams and wishes, and curses like anger and despair into creative works is also called sympathetic magic. I have read this as a device in another book, where it was said that women who made quilts while waiting for their loved ones to come back from war sewed those emotions right into the quilts. I find this idea fascinating - I am pretty fanciful, and halfway believe that the transference really could happen.
The sisters grow up, and one by one leave The Stitchery - except Aubrey. She is different. She is the chosen one to stay on and grant the wishes, the sign of the choosing being her bright electric blue eyes. This part confused me, I wasn't sure if it was her whole entire eye that was blue, including the whites, or just the iris. Their beloved aunt dies, and her sisters come home for a visit. At this point, their lives start unraveling, and outside forces are working against them and The Stitchery. It is up to them to come together to change their own fates.
When I finished reading the story, I read the author interview and book club questions in the back. One of the book club questions was what would you would wish for, and what would you give up in the hopes of your wish coming true? You don't have to say, because I am sure your wishes are personal, but I think it is a thought provoking question.
This book is wonderful - magical, hopeful, yet with the real struggles that people actually go through in life, with a touch of Headless Horseman. The book was set during the fall, and it made me wish for autumn, with its crisp breezes, crunchy leaves, and sweaters and jeans, and is my favorite time of the year. And I don't knit, but I think I am going to give it a try this winter!
It's a family tradition for my brother and I to love the story of the Headless Horseman and Sleepy Hollow. We know the Disney cartoon by heart, the songs, the dialogue, even the lines from the cartoon shorts that come before it on the DVD. I loved the Johnny Depp movie version, and I am excited for the upcoming television show, although it involves time travel and that usually turns me off. I sadly have never read the Washington Irving story, but I plan on correcting that in October.
I looked at the blurb for the book, and was a little apprehensive. I have had bad experiences with books that take place or are based on an original story, like this one. Or Scarlett, that sad sequel to Gone with the Wind. So I started reading a little reservedly. It didn't take long for the story and the characters to steal me away into their lives.
Aubrey and her two sisters grew up with their aunt in a house that had been in the family for generations. Their house is known as The Stichery around town, and always had been. The Van Rippen family's heritage is long and winding and magical. They can knit spells, fulfilling the wishes of those who come to them, desperate, hopeful, resigned. The wisher must give up something of great importance to them in order for the deal to be made, and for the spell to work. But this is not a guarantee that the magic will work, just a sign of good faith between the two.
The idea of being able to embed emotions such as dreams and wishes, and curses like anger and despair into creative works is also called sympathetic magic. I have read this as a device in another book, where it was said that women who made quilts while waiting for their loved ones to come back from war sewed those emotions right into the quilts. I find this idea fascinating - I am pretty fanciful, and halfway believe that the transference really could happen.
The sisters grow up, and one by one leave The Stitchery - except Aubrey. She is different. She is the chosen one to stay on and grant the wishes, the sign of the choosing being her bright electric blue eyes. This part confused me, I wasn't sure if it was her whole entire eye that was blue, including the whites, or just the iris. Their beloved aunt dies, and her sisters come home for a visit. At this point, their lives start unraveling, and outside forces are working against them and The Stitchery. It is up to them to come together to change their own fates.
When I finished reading the story, I read the author interview and book club questions in the back. One of the book club questions was what would you would wish for, and what would you give up in the hopes of your wish coming true? You don't have to say, because I am sure your wishes are personal, but I think it is a thought provoking question.
This book is wonderful - magical, hopeful, yet with the real struggles that people actually go through in life, with a touch of Headless Horseman. The book was set during the fall, and it made me wish for autumn, with its crisp breezes, crunchy leaves, and sweaters and jeans, and is my favorite time of the year. And I don't knit, but I think I am going to give it a try this winter!
October 5, 2013
I am a huge fan of Sarah Addison Allen. When I read the synopsis for The Wishing Thread and it stated that it would appeal to fans of hers, I knew I had to read this book.
The Wishing Thread, by Lisa Van Allen, is magical story about the Van Ripper Family. The matriarch, Aunt Mariah, has recently died, and her three nieces have been reunited at her funeral after being estranged for some time. They discover that their Aunt has left her yarn shop, The Stitchery, to all of them, and now they must decide what they want to do with it.
The Van Ripper women are well known in Tarrytown and the surrounding area of Sleepy Hollow NY for fulfilling the hopes, wishes and dreams of the locals by knitting magic into their handcrafted creations. But, there is a catch to the magic they create - for the magic to work, the requester must sacrifice something in return.
This story is highly reminiscent of Garden Spells by Sarah Addison Allen and Practical Magic by Alice Hoffman. The similarities between the three books are many, although where Garden Spells revolves around food, The Wishing Thread centers on knitting. But magic is magic afterall, and this story does have it's share.
I did think that the setting was very fitting for the book. I enjoyed the author's descriptive writing style, and although I am not much into any type of hobby that involves knitting or crocheting, I still found the story to be entertaining. Although some reviewers have found the comparison to be unsatisfactory, I believe that fans of Sarah Allen and Alice Hoffman will find The Wishing Thread to be an equally enjoyable read.
I received this ebook from NetGalley in return for an honest review.
The Wishing Thread, by Lisa Van Allen, is magical story about the Van Ripper Family. The matriarch, Aunt Mariah, has recently died, and her three nieces have been reunited at her funeral after being estranged for some time. They discover that their Aunt has left her yarn shop, The Stitchery, to all of them, and now they must decide what they want to do with it.
The Van Ripper women are well known in Tarrytown and the surrounding area of Sleepy Hollow NY for fulfilling the hopes, wishes and dreams of the locals by knitting magic into their handcrafted creations. But, there is a catch to the magic they create - for the magic to work, the requester must sacrifice something in return.
This story is highly reminiscent of Garden Spells by Sarah Addison Allen and Practical Magic by Alice Hoffman. The similarities between the three books are many, although where Garden Spells revolves around food, The Wishing Thread centers on knitting. But magic is magic afterall, and this story does have it's share.
I did think that the setting was very fitting for the book. I enjoyed the author's descriptive writing style, and although I am not much into any type of hobby that involves knitting or crocheting, I still found the story to be entertaining. Although some reviewers have found the comparison to be unsatisfactory, I believe that fans of Sarah Allen and Alice Hoffman will find The Wishing Thread to be an equally enjoyable read.
I received this ebook from NetGalley in return for an honest review.
October 9, 2018
2.5. I read this book because the setting of Tarrytown/Sleepy Hollow is very familiar to me. By making the setting a character in the story, each small inaccuracy adds up to a problem for me. That is my problem, but in light of the author's note extolling her research and love for the place, it was an issue for me.
Generally the story lines were a meh. The happy ending full of milquetoast. The book was surely out of my wheelhouse. I should go back to my favorite meaty authors.
A note to authors of women's fiction: Unless a mother is an addict, mentally ill or a prostitute, she is not going to lose custody of her small children. I have seen a woman hire a hit man to kill her husband and still retain custody. This is not a good conflict. Please find another.
Generally the story lines were a meh. The happy ending full of milquetoast. The book was surely out of my wheelhouse. I should go back to my favorite meaty authors.
A note to authors of women's fiction: Unless a mother is an addict, mentally ill or a prostitute, she is not going to lose custody of her small children. I have seen a woman hire a hit man to kill her husband and still retain custody. This is not a good conflict. Please find another.
October 17, 2013
Book Review & Giveaway: I love novels about the power that women have, real or fantasy, so when I saw The Wishing Thread by Lisa Van Allen I knew I wanted to read it. It also didn’t hurt that it takes place in Tarrytown, NY, which is well known for its ties to The Legend of Sleepy Hollow.
This is a novel about family, the family history that binds us and the family currently around us – both of which help to shape who we are. It’s also a story about the extended family living where we live and how those things shape us. And then it’s about the gifts we carry within ourselves which we choose to share or not share with the world, and the price that comes from our choices. For those of you who are looking for something a bit mystical for this season but not so gory, this might be just the novel to curl up with. And you could win a copy at http://popcornreads.com/?p=6666.
This is a novel about family, the family history that binds us and the family currently around us – both of which help to shape who we are. It’s also a story about the extended family living where we live and how those things shape us. And then it’s about the gifts we carry within ourselves which we choose to share or not share with the world, and the price that comes from our choices. For those of you who are looking for something a bit mystical for this season but not so gory, this might be just the novel to curl up with. And you could win a copy at http://popcornreads.com/?p=6666.
June 12, 2017
Disappointing. This book never really came together for me, I almost wall banged it several times. The central conflict wasn't really explored and way too much time was spent with banal dialog that didn't advance the story. When it came to the totally predictable sacrifice about 2/3 of the way in, I just rolled my eyes. I didn't see this as a study of sister relationships either. There wasn't as much magic in the story as the synopsis lead me to believe. There are better books to read, and too little reading time to waste on merely OK stories.
October 19, 2014
I really enjoyed this - it was imaginative and fun and sweet and very well-written. I look forward to reading more from her. It did remind me a lot of Sarah Addison Allen, who I love - but in a different and unique way. If you like her books, highly recommended.
September 2, 2014
Different, but too unbelievable ànd fantastic for my tastes. A little neat in the end as well. I rather prefer a book that surprises me.
March 9, 2019
I didn’t want this book to end!! Xx
August 6, 2018
3.5
I enjoyed this book because of the knitting. If I were not a knitter I don't think I would have loved it as much as I did. I think the audience for this book is a fairly narrow one because of that.
However, I also I loved the writing (beautiful and atmospheric) and the characters. The romance was too much for me (as usual).
Also, the knitting is very good. A+ descriptions of knitting.
I enjoyed this book because of the knitting. If I were not a knitter I don't think I would have loved it as much as I did. I think the audience for this book is a fairly narrow one because of that.
However, I also I loved the writing (beautiful and atmospheric) and the characters. The romance was too much for me (as usual).
Also, the knitting is very good. A+ descriptions of knitting.
June 25, 2022
Have I shared that I love magical realism?
Well — if I haven’t, then —
I LOVE MAGICAL REALISM.
Well — if I haven’t, then —
I LOVE MAGICAL REALISM.
July 3, 2018
Reminded me very much of Practical Magic. I loved the cozy Fall in Sleepy Hollow, NY setting and the everyday magic.
October 7, 2013
This book is women's fiction with a touch of magic. This type of fiction isn't my normal choice, but as part of my magic realism challenge I try to read widely and it often pays off, as with this book. I enjoyed this book. It wasn't particularly challenging in subject matter or technically, but it is a good story told well. Just when I thought I knew where the story was heading, there was a unexpected twist towards the end.
Is the magic in this story real? Is it coincidence? Is it wishful thinking? Bitty, the eldest sister, doesn't believe in it. Bitty would have been happy to believe it was real. She would have been the first person to say "sign me up!" But in the end, magic was a false security, a grasping at power that humans didn't have but desperately wished for.
The fact is that the magic of the Stitchery is unreliable. None of the guardians of the Stitchery (including Aubrey and Mariah) is able to guarantee that the spells, which they knit into the garments they create, will work. Nor does there seem to be any logic or explanation about which spells fail, which sometimes happens heartbreakingly. This questioning of the magic runs through the book, not just in the doubts of the characters like Bitty, but also in the narration - Chapter One ends with The magic of the Van Ripper family, they said, was in the knitting. If it was magic at all.
In the end it comes down to whether you are like Aubrey, who sees the magic and some sort of order in the world, or like Bitty.
It is interesting that in this book, as in The Threads of the Heart, the women's magic is based in a traditional woman's craft. In other magic realism books about women the magic is to be found in the preparation of food. I have spoken elsewhere about magic realism as a vehicle for showing women's strength. What does placing the magic in traditional female activity say about women? Speaking for myself knitting doesn't exactly float my boat. It seems a very passive activity to me, but I can see that a lot of readers will enjoy and understand the knitting symbolism more than me.
As the eldest of three sisters, I found the relationship between the three very different Van Ripper girls both interesting and well drawn. Both Bitty and Meggie have for different reasons turned their backs on the Stitchery and now are drawn back by Mariah's death, Aubrey's need for her family and, whilst they do not admit it, their own needs. I would have liked more about their relationships.
This book has been recommended to people who enjoy Alice Hoffman and Sarah Addison Allen. It is light and gentle, with a little but not too much romance. All in all it is an enjoyable read.
I received this book through Netgalley in return for a fair review.
This review first appeared on the Magic Realism Books blog - http://magic-realism-books.blogspot.com.
Is the magic in this story real? Is it coincidence? Is it wishful thinking? Bitty, the eldest sister, doesn't believe in it. Bitty would have been happy to believe it was real. She would have been the first person to say "sign me up!" But in the end, magic was a false security, a grasping at power that humans didn't have but desperately wished for.
The fact is that the magic of the Stitchery is unreliable. None of the guardians of the Stitchery (including Aubrey and Mariah) is able to guarantee that the spells, which they knit into the garments they create, will work. Nor does there seem to be any logic or explanation about which spells fail, which sometimes happens heartbreakingly. This questioning of the magic runs through the book, not just in the doubts of the characters like Bitty, but also in the narration - Chapter One ends with The magic of the Van Ripper family, they said, was in the knitting. If it was magic at all.
In the end it comes down to whether you are like Aubrey, who sees the magic and some sort of order in the world, or like Bitty.
It is interesting that in this book, as in The Threads of the Heart, the women's magic is based in a traditional woman's craft. In other magic realism books about women the magic is to be found in the preparation of food. I have spoken elsewhere about magic realism as a vehicle for showing women's strength. What does placing the magic in traditional female activity say about women? Speaking for myself knitting doesn't exactly float my boat. It seems a very passive activity to me, but I can see that a lot of readers will enjoy and understand the knitting symbolism more than me.
As the eldest of three sisters, I found the relationship between the three very different Van Ripper girls both interesting and well drawn. Both Bitty and Meggie have for different reasons turned their backs on the Stitchery and now are drawn back by Mariah's death, Aubrey's need for her family and, whilst they do not admit it, their own needs. I would have liked more about their relationships.
This book has been recommended to people who enjoy Alice Hoffman and Sarah Addison Allen. It is light and gentle, with a little but not too much romance. All in all it is an enjoyable read.
I received this book through Netgalley in return for a fair review.
This review first appeared on the Magic Realism Books blog - http://magic-realism-books.blogspot.com.
June 15, 2013
The Wishing Thread is a lovely surprise! It follows the story of the Van Ripper sisters, and their late aunt's yarn shop "The Stitchery". What makes the knitting element really interesting is: the Van Rippers are able to knit magic spells into the objects they make.
The Stitchery is not just a regular yarn shop: it's also a place where townsfolk can come, and - in exchange for a sacrifice they determine, something they feel is very meaningful to themselves - ask for a spell. Sometimes the spells work, sometimes they don't. Of the three Van Ripper sisters, only Aubrey (the middle sister) still lives in The Stitchery when the book begins. Her older sister Bitty moved out, got married, and now has two children and problems at home. Bitty left the magical side of knitting behind her at a young age. Her youngest sister, Meggie, ran away and has been wandering the world searching for clues about their mother - who may have died, or may just have disappeared.
Aubrey is the one who still believes in the magic of knitting, and who is destined to take over The Stitchery when the girls' aunt dies. But complications arise when the sisters discover what their aunt wrote in her will, and it seems like they will never be able to agree on the fate of The Stitchery.
There is an easygoing, small-town atmosphere to the book- it really takes you into the town and immerses you in their quiet ways. The book is quite slow-moving, which was enjoyable for this story because it had the same effect as knitting a garter-stitch blanket... it's a quiet and easy read.
A romance also crops up in the story, for added interest.
What I enjoyed most about this book were the knitting references, descriptions of yarns, etc. I love yarn. I least enjoyed the part of the plot based around the town council meetings. Honestly I cared about the characters, but I wasn't all that invested in the whole land battle.
I'd recommend this book to others who love knitting. If you don't care for knitting, you may become slightly bored throughout some parts. Though the book takes place over the span of the various seasons, I felt it had a summery vibe to it. It would be a good story to take on a summer vacation.
Thank you to the publishers who, via NetGalley, provided me with an e-copy for review!
The Stitchery is not just a regular yarn shop: it's also a place where townsfolk can come, and - in exchange for a sacrifice they determine, something they feel is very meaningful to themselves - ask for a spell. Sometimes the spells work, sometimes they don't. Of the three Van Ripper sisters, only Aubrey (the middle sister) still lives in The Stitchery when the book begins. Her older sister Bitty moved out, got married, and now has two children and problems at home. Bitty left the magical side of knitting behind her at a young age. Her youngest sister, Meggie, ran away and has been wandering the world searching for clues about their mother - who may have died, or may just have disappeared.
Aubrey is the one who still believes in the magic of knitting, and who is destined to take over The Stitchery when the girls' aunt dies. But complications arise when the sisters discover what their aunt wrote in her will, and it seems like they will never be able to agree on the fate of The Stitchery.
There is an easygoing, small-town atmosphere to the book- it really takes you into the town and immerses you in their quiet ways. The book is quite slow-moving, which was enjoyable for this story because it had the same effect as knitting a garter-stitch blanket... it's a quiet and easy read.
A romance also crops up in the story, for added interest.
What I enjoyed most about this book were the knitting references, descriptions of yarns, etc. I love yarn. I least enjoyed the part of the plot based around the town council meetings. Honestly I cared about the characters, but I wasn't all that invested in the whole land battle.
I'd recommend this book to others who love knitting. If you don't care for knitting, you may become slightly bored throughout some parts. Though the book takes place over the span of the various seasons, I felt it had a summery vibe to it. It would be a good story to take on a summer vacation.
Thank you to the publishers who, via NetGalley, provided me with an e-copy for review!
April 30, 2017
The Wishing Thread is an interesting book. I must admit I had trouble getting into this story at first. It did not hold my interest. There was something about it that I just didn't like so I put it down and walked away. I'm glad I picked it up again.
The Van Ripper sisters from Tarrytown, New York are together for the first time in several years. The woman who raised them, their Aunt Mariah, has died and they have gathered to remember her and make decisions about their family business, the Stitchery. The Stitchery is a run down shop for the knitting community. A person can buy their supplies if they desire or they can request a custom piece be made for them. The custom pieces are very special and incredibly expensive. You see, they include a magic spell for the person who will be wearing the item, wether it's a scarf or gloves or socks or a sweater or anything that can be knitted!
Meggie, Aubrey and Bitty are trying to come to terms with the death of the woman that raised them and also trying to recognize that their lives are not what they had hoped for when they were young. Bitty is married to a man she can no longer stand but can't leave because he is rich and powerful. Meggie, the youngest sister, has been on a quest to try to find their mother who disappeared when they were small. She, as the youngest, has no memories of her mother and is jealous of her sisters because they knew her. She is coping with the fact that her mother never returned because she died. Aubrey is the quiet one who never left. She has dedicated her life to the Stitchery and her aunt and now she is lost since her aunt's death.
The sisters are reconnecting with each other and remembering why they were so close as youngsters. They are making decisions about their lives and what they will accept and what they will no longer accept. They are becoming the strong unit they were when they were younger.
This is a book about family and relationships and the strength within a family unit. It is a book about second chances and love. This is also a book about magic!
I am glad I picked this book up after putting it aside. I liked the characters and the storyline and, I especially liked the magic!
The Van Ripper sisters from Tarrytown, New York are together for the first time in several years. The woman who raised them, their Aunt Mariah, has died and they have gathered to remember her and make decisions about their family business, the Stitchery. The Stitchery is a run down shop for the knitting community. A person can buy their supplies if they desire or they can request a custom piece be made for them. The custom pieces are very special and incredibly expensive. You see, they include a magic spell for the person who will be wearing the item, wether it's a scarf or gloves or socks or a sweater or anything that can be knitted!
Meggie, Aubrey and Bitty are trying to come to terms with the death of the woman that raised them and also trying to recognize that their lives are not what they had hoped for when they were young. Bitty is married to a man she can no longer stand but can't leave because he is rich and powerful. Meggie, the youngest sister, has been on a quest to try to find their mother who disappeared when they were small. She, as the youngest, has no memories of her mother and is jealous of her sisters because they knew her. She is coping with the fact that her mother never returned because she died. Aubrey is the quiet one who never left. She has dedicated her life to the Stitchery and her aunt and now she is lost since her aunt's death.
The sisters are reconnecting with each other and remembering why they were so close as youngsters. They are making decisions about their lives and what they will accept and what they will no longer accept. They are becoming the strong unit they were when they were younger.
This is a book about family and relationships and the strength within a family unit. It is a book about second chances and love. This is also a book about magic!
I am glad I picked this book up after putting it aside. I liked the characters and the storyline and, I especially liked the magic!
July 20, 2016
The Van Ripper sisters have just inherited The Stitchery, their family-owned yarn & knit shop. It also happens to be the place that women go when they have a wish. Rumor has it that the Van Ripper women are witches and can put answers to those wishes in the things they knit. Aubrey is the chosen, she's the one who her sisters thought would get The Stitchery but Mariah surprises the sisters by giving the shop/home to all three of the sisters. The problem is that the The Stitchery is soon to be torn down to become a shopping mall.
Because of her gift/duty Aubrey thinks she will be single alone serving those women who come asking for help. Bitty has run away from poverty and the magic she doesn't believe in - so she marries someone from a rich family to escape, and she doesn't come back for fear that her children will believe magic like they believed in Santa. And then there's Meggie who believes in magic but still runs away from home. The three sisters haven't talked in a very long time and now it's time to work together.
This was a light, easy read full of possibilities. What will the sisters chose to do - or is it all just fate or magic?
Because of her gift/duty Aubrey thinks she will be single alone serving those women who come asking for help. Bitty has run away from poverty and the magic she doesn't believe in - so she marries someone from a rich family to escape, and she doesn't come back for fear that her children will believe magic like they believed in Santa. And then there's Meggie who believes in magic but still runs away from home. The three sisters haven't talked in a very long time and now it's time to work together.
This was a light, easy read full of possibilities. What will the sisters chose to do - or is it all just fate or magic?
September 13, 2013
The Wishing Thread is a mix of women’s fiction and romance with touches of magical realism. The characters capture the reader’s interest and affections, and the story teases the reader with the question of what is real and what is magic.
From the Great Book in the Hall: There is, of course, always a question—a question of the difference between what is real and what is true. A thing can be true without being real. You may not grasp this entirely, but don’t worry. This is the nature of faith, of magic, of art, of a good life’s work: If you ever understand perfectly what you are doing, you should stop right away.
Van Allen’s use of knitting as real craft, as magic, and as metaphor has particular resonance given the role needlecraft has played in women’s history. Her prose has a lovely lyricism that I found greatly appealing. If you are a fan of writers such as Alice Hoffman and Sarah Addison Allen, I predict you will enjoy this book as much as I did.
See full review at Just Janga:
http://justjanga.blogspot.com/2013/09...
From the Great Book in the Hall: There is, of course, always a question—a question of the difference between what is real and what is true. A thing can be true without being real. You may not grasp this entirely, but don’t worry. This is the nature of faith, of magic, of art, of a good life’s work: If you ever understand perfectly what you are doing, you should stop right away.
Van Allen’s use of knitting as real craft, as magic, and as metaphor has particular resonance given the role needlecraft has played in women’s history. Her prose has a lovely lyricism that I found greatly appealing. If you are a fan of writers such as Alice Hoffman and Sarah Addison Allen, I predict you will enjoy this book as much as I did.
See full review at Just Janga:
http://justjanga.blogspot.com/2013/09...
January 20, 2014
The Van Ripper family has long owned The Stitchery. Sought by some, Aunt Mariah, and now Aubrey, are able to weave spells into their projects. Others believe them to be witches, and avoid them. Each request for magic comes with a price, the one seeking the spell must sacrifice something of great value to them. The town square that grew up around The Stitchery has become derelict and is slated to be brought down by a wealthy developer. Aubrey is distraught and does not know what to do when her beloved Aunt Mariah, who's been fighting the developers, passes away. Aubrey's sisters Meggie and Bitty, with her two children, return to The Stitchery. Along with determining the fate of The Stitchery, the sisters must also reassess their own lives and what is important to each of them. The book offers a bit of fairy tale, a touch of magic and the importance of the bonds that tie us together.
September 19, 2014
I love magical realism. This was a cute book about a magical family trying to save their town. Having grown up in Westchester County I am familiar with Tarrytown and the legends that go along with it. Knitting plays a large part and I have to admit, I don't knit. This book made me wonder if I could.. and there's family issues, love and honor, traditons and duty. A bit fluffier than the magical realism books I've read but it was enjoyable.
September 19, 2013
Thanks to Netgalley.com and the publisher for allowing me to read an advance copy in exchange for a review!
Okay, I have no idea why I waited so long to read this one. I've had it on my kindle app for weeks and weeks because the cover was so evocative and the plot sounded interesting but I just kept getting distracted by other books which weren't nearly as good as this one (some of the books I was distracted by were very good, but most of the ones I've read haven't been). I'm kicking myself for taking so long to get around to this. Van Allen has a real way with words, turning what should otherwise be a common turn-of-phrase or even a simple simile or metaphor into pure poetry. Seriously, I got shivers a couple of times while reading because her language was just so beautiful.
These were characters I could like and root for even when they did things I didn't like (and for the most part the things they were doing that I didn't like I could still understand why they thought they had to do it, which is just good character development). Aubrey with her crazy blue eyes, her outsider status, and her deeply-rooted belief in the Stitchery and its magic. Bitty with her standoffishness and cynicism against magic that slowly melted away as she let herself just be around her family. Meggie with her crazy quest even in the face of the pain her absence causes and her ever-changing look (I wish this was a movie because her character is a costume designer/hair designer's dream). And Mariah, who was barely in this book and yet felt like such a big presence, like someone you really wish you could've gotten to know. And the Stitchery itself sounds wonderful and magical even in its current rundown state.
I must confess that I had never heard of Tarrytown itself and so was a little surprised to find out that it was so closely associated with Sleepy Hollow and all the mythology surrounding that area. I loved that there was more to their town than just Washington Irving's story, that there were more urban legends and myths that could be explored. It was fascinating to learn about even though it wasn't expounded upon that much in the novel itself (it made me want to go visit as well as doing some research into those legends).
I loved all the little descriptions of the knitwear produced or worn throughout the book. It felt so natural given the setting and the occupation of those in the Stichery. For some of the descriptions, I had to wrack my brain to remember what those particular patterns look like but more often than not I had to look it up on the internet to get a clearer picture. Most of all, it made me want to pick up some knitting needles and get to work, but sadly it's been so long since I learned to knit that I've forgotten most of it and would need some refresher courses to help me along (I can still crochet though, so there's that). It made me want to make something for someone and infuse some good thoughts, prayers, and maybe even a little magic into it (maybe a love spell for Benedict Cumberbatch? Too much?).
I've got to say, I wasn't expected the romance that unfolded (well, not at first. Once Vic came on the scene I was wishing with every fiber of my being that he and Audrey would end up together) but boy was it a doozy. It felt natural and beautiful and pretty hot even though it wasn't overtly described (serious kudos to Van Allen for being able to make one kiss a million times steamier than anything in Fifty Shades of Grey or any other romance novel I've read. I think I'll take some notes for my own writing) and yet was as evocative and sensual as any other love scene I've ever read (actually most of her scenes were better than most other scenes I've read. I think it had something to do with that things were only touched upon and not written out in lurid detail. It's sorta like how horror movies are so much scarier if you don't see the monster/ghost/baddie but catch only brief glimpses and the rest is left up to your imagination, but for romance instead). And seriously, I nearly cried at a pivotal point. I was so shocked by almost crying (I didn't let myself cry because I was at work and that could be weird) even though I'd seen the sadness coming; I just hadn't expected to be so heart-broken. Again, kudos to Van Allen for writing characters that seemed so real despite all the magic and mystery that I felt my heart break right along with one of them.
I was smiling as I finished the book, and that's always a good sign for me.
Oh, and Lisa Van Allen, if you happen to read this, I would not be adverse to some kind of sequel revolving around the next generation of the Stitchery. I know it's not really necessary but it could be fun, especially with Nessa's pink hair coming in (and I want to know if Vic and Audrey have babies! Because I bet they'd be adorable). :)
And I didn't even talk about the magic, which I found completely fabulous and unique from other books I've read. It wasn't overblown or crazy or even all that unbelievable. I, like a lot of the characters in the book, found myself drawn in so that I believed in the magic of the Stitchery as well. Even though some bits reminded me slightly of Practical Magic, I think Van Allen handled the magical elements in such a way that they were light and believable (I certainly wish there was someone who could knit me a magical good luck charm).
Okay, I have no idea why I waited so long to read this one. I've had it on my kindle app for weeks and weeks because the cover was so evocative and the plot sounded interesting but I just kept getting distracted by other books which weren't nearly as good as this one (some of the books I was distracted by were very good, but most of the ones I've read haven't been). I'm kicking myself for taking so long to get around to this. Van Allen has a real way with words, turning what should otherwise be a common turn-of-phrase or even a simple simile or metaphor into pure poetry. Seriously, I got shivers a couple of times while reading because her language was just so beautiful.
These were characters I could like and root for even when they did things I didn't like (and for the most part the things they were doing that I didn't like I could still understand why they thought they had to do it, which is just good character development). Aubrey with her crazy blue eyes, her outsider status, and her deeply-rooted belief in the Stitchery and its magic. Bitty with her standoffishness and cynicism against magic that slowly melted away as she let herself just be around her family. Meggie with her crazy quest even in the face of the pain her absence causes and her ever-changing look (I wish this was a movie because her character is a costume designer/hair designer's dream). And Mariah, who was barely in this book and yet felt like such a big presence, like someone you really wish you could've gotten to know. And the Stitchery itself sounds wonderful and magical even in its current rundown state.
I must confess that I had never heard of Tarrytown itself and so was a little surprised to find out that it was so closely associated with Sleepy Hollow and all the mythology surrounding that area. I loved that there was more to their town than just Washington Irving's story, that there were more urban legends and myths that could be explored. It was fascinating to learn about even though it wasn't expounded upon that much in the novel itself (it made me want to go visit as well as doing some research into those legends).
I loved all the little descriptions of the knitwear produced or worn throughout the book. It felt so natural given the setting and the occupation of those in the Stichery. For some of the descriptions, I had to wrack my brain to remember what those particular patterns look like but more often than not I had to look it up on the internet to get a clearer picture. Most of all, it made me want to pick up some knitting needles and get to work, but sadly it's been so long since I learned to knit that I've forgotten most of it and would need some refresher courses to help me along (I can still crochet though, so there's that). It made me want to make something for someone and infuse some good thoughts, prayers, and maybe even a little magic into it (maybe a love spell for Benedict Cumberbatch? Too much?).
I've got to say, I wasn't expected the romance that unfolded (well, not at first. Once Vic came on the scene I was wishing with every fiber of my being that he and Audrey would end up together) but boy was it a doozy. It felt natural and beautiful and pretty hot even though it wasn't overtly described (serious kudos to Van Allen for being able to make one kiss a million times steamier than anything in Fifty Shades of Grey or any other romance novel I've read. I think I'll take some notes for my own writing) and yet was as evocative and sensual as any other love scene I've ever read (actually most of her scenes were better than most other scenes I've read. I think it had something to do with that things were only touched upon and not written out in lurid detail. It's sorta like how horror movies are so much scarier if you don't see the monster/ghost/baddie but catch only brief glimpses and the rest is left up to your imagination, but for romance instead). And seriously, I nearly cried at a pivotal point. I was so shocked by almost crying (I didn't let myself cry because I was at work and that could be weird) even though I'd seen the sadness coming; I just hadn't expected to be so heart-broken. Again, kudos to Van Allen for writing characters that seemed so real despite all the magic and mystery that I felt my heart break right along with one of them.
I was smiling as I finished the book, and that's always a good sign for me.
Oh, and Lisa Van Allen, if you happen to read this, I would not be adverse to some kind of sequel revolving around the next generation of the Stitchery. I know it's not really necessary but it could be fun, especially with Nessa's pink hair coming in (and I want to know if Vic and Audrey have babies! Because I bet they'd be adorable). :)
And I didn't even talk about the magic, which I found completely fabulous and unique from other books I've read. It wasn't overblown or crazy or even all that unbelievable. I, like a lot of the characters in the book, found myself drawn in so that I believed in the magic of the Stitchery as well. Even though some bits reminded me slightly of Practical Magic, I think Van Allen handled the magical elements in such a way that they were light and believable (I certainly wish there was someone who could knit me a magical good luck charm).
October 4, 2018
This is a different kind of book than I normally read. Part of the appeal was the knitting theme since my boyfriend is an avid knitter and the best birthday present he ever gave me was teaching me how to knit. It felt like I was reading a Hallmark movie, especially towards the end. That's not a complaint. The book feels like nostalgia. Like walking into a yarn shop. Like cold mornings and warm sweaters. It is a book about magic that you're never really sure if it's real, or if it's only real in the sense that the characters believe in it so strongly. It's magic for the world we live in. It's not simple, it's not neat, and it doesn't always work, but it's still there, so you're tempted to keep your faith it. It's the magic of putting on a hat that was knitted just for you and feeling the love in it.
November 15, 2017
I liked it but I didn't love it. It was a slow trudge at the beginning. Once things got moving I enjoyed it more but the end was anticlimactic in the worst way. I was really into the yarn bombing on devil's night and then the plot seemed to lose cohesion and petered out. I would have loved to hear more about the previous guardians and the legend about how things got started. I also think the magic was lacking, it either needed to be more subtle or more intrusive. As it stands it occupies an uneven middle ground, and I understand that it is supposed to be uncertain but it felt like maybe the author was also uncertain about what role the magic should play in the grand scheme of things. The whole thing felt loose and not as tightly knit as I would have liked.
January 28, 2018
This is exactly the kind of book I usually love, and I’m struggling to understand why I didn’t.
Premise is wonderful. Writing was very descriptive, I felt like I was in Tarrytown and the Stitchery. It just never really came together. The magical realism was never explored as well as it could have been - show me more irate or happy customers, cmon. If it’s more powerful than Aubrey thought - we never got to see it.
The main conflict was resolved so anticlimactically. It was so dragged out and then they just lose it?!
The characters were very well fleshed out, but also not explored to the max.
Maybe I just wasn’t in the right frame of mind to enjoy it.
Premise is wonderful. Writing was very descriptive, I felt like I was in Tarrytown and the Stitchery. It just never really came together. The magical realism was never explored as well as it could have been - show me more irate or happy customers, cmon. If it’s more powerful than Aubrey thought - we never got to see it.
The main conflict was resolved so anticlimactically. It was so dragged out and then they just lose it?!
The characters were very well fleshed out, but also not explored to the max.
Maybe I just wasn’t in the right frame of mind to enjoy it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 602 reviews