Thoughtful and artful biography of Sarah Vaughan. I have to admit right from the start that Sarah Vaughan is not my favorite "girl singer." (That would be Ella Fitzgerald, of course.) And when Elaine is describing Vaughan's characteristic style: slides, melismas, vibrato, I recognized why. I prefer to see the song clearly through the singer, which is what Ella does; although she embellishes, it's usually in service of the song. Whereas Vaughan in her performances is showcasing her voice, which she learned to use her voice as an instrument, during her early days, when after touring with a few bands, she was hanging out in nightclubs with the early jazz greats who revolutionized jazz. Her gift came from being able to improvise, to collaborate and to re-interpret the music, all the gifts of the jazz greats. Elaine's writing has both qualities. She can imitate the sound of music, like most great music reviewers. For instance, this passage:
Yet she also provides a clear window through which to view her subject. The early chapters where Sarah Vaughan is struggling to make a name for herself engaged me more than the later chapters where she is struggling with record producers to be able to perform the material that interests her (over and over again) and where she is touring relentlessly all around the world (but from a biographer's point of view, it would be impossible to avoid the repetition). The writing is rich with quotes from reviewers and colleagues who Elaine interviewed, all smoothly folded into the writing so it flows.